religion, what think you
#91
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2010
Location: Almonte, ON
Posts: 1,061
Re: religion, what think you
No, that's a fundamental misunderstanding of the difference between belief and skepticism. Believers think because their worldview is based on faith, that therefore the same applies to non-believers (i.e. people who call athiesm a 'belief system'). But the two forms of thinking are quite different. Yours is based on faith in something that can never be proved by science. For many non-believers, including myself, it's not about faith in no god, it's about relying on scientific evidence to help understand the way the world works. I don't have 'faith" in science - science can be bad or bought by corporate entities. I don't have 'faith' that there is no god. Rather, I have a skeptical world view where I remain open-minded until science answers the question with evidence one way or the other. right now there is very little evidence for a God or grand planner and a huge amount of evidence (evolution) etc that is against the idea. I choose to go with the scientific method over "faith" or "belief".
believers like to kid themselves that non-believers are just like them, but we're really not, and to think so shows a misunderstanding of the scientific method. We're thinking in a completely different way to you.
believers like to kid themselves that non-believers are just like them, but we're really not, and to think so shows a misunderstanding of the scientific method. We're thinking in a completely different way to you.
Being open minded would suggest though that you'd consider that there was a god. With you completely discharging this possibility you are very mind set on science and the prove we have thus far.
We are all different and that makes the world colourful, let's leave it at that.
Have a lovely weekend all!
#92
Re: religion, what think you
Was a good idea in the context of the time. Given the split allegiances to the Republic and Rome a reasonable proportion just couldn't be trusted. You still can't really...given their propensity to vote for terrorists and murderers as a general rule.
Last edited by orly; Nov 22nd 2013 at 6:01 pm.
#93
Re: religion, what think you
I worked in science until I had the kids and studied science and strongly believe in science and scientific prove of certain things but also that there is more to the story. A bit like "God made the big bang" I tell my kids about science and want them educated in every way and for me personally that includes faith too.
Being open minded would suggest though that you'd consider that there was a god. With you completely discharging this possibility you are very mind set on science and the prove we have thus far.
We are all different and that makes the world colourful, let's leave it at that.
Have a lovely weekend all!
Being open minded would suggest though that you'd consider that there was a god. With you completely discharging this possibility you are very mind set on science and the prove we have thus far.
We are all different and that makes the world colourful, let's leave it at that.
Have a lovely weekend all!
#94
Banned
Joined: Dec 2010
Location: Durham Region Extension
Posts: 3,342
Re: religion, what think you
We are all different and that makes the world colourful
Why is it that we can't all get along then?
Last edited by ultrarunner; Nov 22nd 2013 at 6:37 pm.
#97
Re: religion, what think you
I am not religious, but I was given a grounding in basic Christianity. I got married in a church 20+ years ago. I'm not sure that I would now.
I do, however, believe in a few of those niggly fundamental principles:
I think it's great not to kill anyone.
I rather like that idea about not stealing stuff.
I definitely have no plans to covet my neighbour's ox, or his wife.
I think adultery is just a shame for all concerned - sort your shit out first.
And I generally think being kind and thoughtful is a good human trait, whichever religion wants to claim that one.
I think schools should give an overview of religions. Not to actually teach or preach religion, but to teach about the various religions. It affects millions of the world's population, so some understanding of how or why people tick is a good skill. My children have barely any knowledge about any kind of religion - which is fine in some ways, but is a woefully inadequate understanding of the world around them, and the history of how it came to be this way.
I do, however, believe in a few of those niggly fundamental principles:
I think it's great not to kill anyone.
I rather like that idea about not stealing stuff.
I definitely have no plans to covet my neighbour's ox, or his wife.
I think adultery is just a shame for all concerned - sort your shit out first.
And I generally think being kind and thoughtful is a good human trait, whichever religion wants to claim that one.
I think schools should give an overview of religions. Not to actually teach or preach religion, but to teach about the various religions. It affects millions of the world's population, so some understanding of how or why people tick is a good skill. My children have barely any knowledge about any kind of religion - which is fine in some ways, but is a woefully inadequate understanding of the world around them, and the history of how it came to be this way.
Last edited by ann m; Nov 22nd 2013 at 7:12 pm.
#98
Re: religion, what think you
I am not religious, but I was given a grounding in basic Christianity. I got married in a church 20+ years ago. I'm not sure that I would now.
I do, however, believe in a few of those niggly fundamental principles:
I think it's great not to kill anyone.
I rather that idea about not stealing stuff.
I definitely have no plans to covet my neighbour's ox, or his wife.
I think adultery is just a shame for all concerned - sort your shit out first.
And I generally think being kind and thoughtful is a good human trait, whichever religion wants to claim that one.
I think schools should give an overview of religions. Not to actually teach or preach religion, but to teach about the various religions. It affects millions of the world's population, so some understanding of how or why people tick is a good skill. My children have barely any knowledge about any kind of religion - which is fine in some ways, but is a woefully inadequate understanding of the world around them, and the history of how it came to be this way.
I do, however, believe in a few of those niggly fundamental principles:
I think it's great not to kill anyone.
I rather that idea about not stealing stuff.
I definitely have no plans to covet my neighbour's ox, or his wife.
I think adultery is just a shame for all concerned - sort your shit out first.
And I generally think being kind and thoughtful is a good human trait, whichever religion wants to claim that one.
I think schools should give an overview of religions. Not to actually teach or preach religion, but to teach about the various religions. It affects millions of the world's population, so some understanding of how or why people tick is a good skill. My children have barely any knowledge about any kind of religion - which is fine in some ways, but is a woefully inadequate understanding of the world around them, and the history of how it came to be this way.
I believe the UK National Curriculum does teach kids about various religions. I agree that it's important for everyone to know about different belief systems, as it drives our cultures and forms our history.
The fundamental principles you list are not limited to any religion, they are part of human morality. One of religion's big deceptions is to claim ownership of morality and argue that there would be no morality without religion.
#99
Re: religion, what think you
Having said that, if no-one had mentioned to me in my formative years that killing people is not a nice past-time, and I had grown up in a moral vacuum - would I have killed someone by now? I don't think not killing is an human instinct - so conversations have happend for thousands of years based on this principle. Religious or not....
#100
slanderer of the innocent
Joined: Dec 2008
Location: Vancouver, BC
Posts: 6,695
Re: religion, what think you
there is some scientific evidence that a sense of justice is built into our brains.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/ar...d=baby-justice
oh dear, more bad news for religion
http://www.scientificamerican.com/ar...d=baby-justice
oh dear, more bad news for religion
#101
Re: religion, what think you
It's said that Christians trying to convert Pagans to their faith were facing resistance because they still wanted to celebrate the winter solstice. So they gave them a different thing to celebrate to compromise the situation, despite the fact that there's no religious basis for it. But getting the most converts is clearly more important than telling the truth.
#102
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: religion, what think you
They don't. There's no reference to any kind of date of Jesus' birth in the Bible, let alone specifically December 25th. If anything, you can speculate that because of the shepherds that visited the stable were out in the fields tending their sheep before his birth, it was more likely to be fall than winter. Sheep would be kept under shelter in wintertime rather than let out.
It's said that Christians trying to convert Pagans to their faith were facing resistance because they still wanted to celebrate the winter solstice. So they gave them a different thing to celebrate to compromise the situation, despite the fact that there's no religious basis for it. But getting the most converts is clearly more important than telling the truth.
It's said that Christians trying to convert Pagans to their faith were facing resistance because they still wanted to celebrate the winter solstice. So they gave them a different thing to celebrate to compromise the situation, despite the fact that there's no religious basis for it. But getting the most converts is clearly more important than telling the truth.
#103
Re: religion, what think you
My understanding is that he did exist, and was an important spiritual leader and political activist at the time, but it's the subsequent few hundred years when the Bible was put together than he gained his god-like status. (No irony intended.)
#104
slanderer of the innocent
Joined: Dec 2008
Location: Vancouver, BC
Posts: 6,695
Re: religion, what think you
the PBS did an awesome doc on the historical (as opposed to Biblical) Jesus. It was a real eye-opener for me.