My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
#1456
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
You may be correct on the visa application, they have her passport so I can't check at the moment, I checked the initial application, which details the outline, it specifically states that she was coming to the UK to be married but I'm fairly sure I did the application as a fiancee, we had to provide all documentation regarding the date of the Marriage, (Is there a difference between a marraige visitor visa and a fiancee visa?) the location and the booking details as well as the receipts for the payments, but regardless, as you correctly pointed out, the application failed on her English ability as well as the incorrect visa, the appeal is in and it's providing us with time to get her to a sufficient level of English to get through the IELTS.
We don't want to ever go back to Brazil, it's too dangerous at the moment, they are suffering huge levels of crime, the corruption is horrendous, we would have to live in a gated community, heavily secured with armed guards to live a half normal life, within a month of returning, I specifically would be targeted as someone of means, a very probable victim of car hijacking minimum, and would need to obtain a firearm for our protection. Brazil is going through a period of huge economic failure, it won't be long before civil unrest engulfs certain parts of the country, we have no desire or need to become victims of that.
We don't mind going to Portugal and enjoying the country for however long it takes, I thought that as soon as she has the IELTS cert, we can apply from Portugal, we don't need her to be in Brazil, just outside the UK, and as I referred to earlier, was long as she gets the IELTS, there should be no more obstacles as long as we apply for the correct visa.
What is annoying, without going into a long rant about the unfairness of the British Immigration system is, that at 65, the Language problem ceases to be a problem under current rules, we are both almost 60, so a little discretion would have been welcome, not to mention the fact that I have less rights in my own country than an EU citizen in similar circumstances who doesn't need to jump through hoops to get into my country or me to get into his, I need to prove more to my government than he does to my government (did I mention not going into a long rant )
Digressing, so, the conclusion is, the SS route may continue through any transition period, but as we will fulfil the Spouse visa option within a year, we will follow the rules and shell out more money than we need to if we had taken the perfectly legal SS route,
I don't want to go through the SS route due to the fact that we have a refusal and of course, it's going to look as if we had used the route to circumnavigate the expensive route, Which in effect could have been true, but only for the reason it's so difficult to actually get through the quagmire of rules to do the right thing.
I'm starting to wish for a Corbyn government
I don't want to go through the SS route due to the fact that we have a refusal and of course, it's going to look as if we had used the route to circumnavigate the expensive route, Which in effect could have been true, but only for the reason it's so difficult to actually get through the quagmire of rules to do the right thing.
I'm starting to wish for a Corbyn government
#1457
Forum Regular
Joined: Apr 2017
Posts: 61
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
Hi was wondering when we go back to the uk with a article 10 card can my husband work or do we have to wait for the residance card
#1458
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
Technically he can but your husband would have difficulty proving his right to work. Better to apply for an EEA Family Permit and use that for the initial six months whilst you wait for his EEA residence card to arrive.
#1459
Forum Regular
Joined: Apr 2017
Posts: 61
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
Hi does anyone know how you go about getting a residance card in the uk for your family member
#1460
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 185
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
We got PR !!!!
Hey there if you're still following this thread, I started this journey on the British Expats Forum almost 6 years ago and it's been a long and sometimes stressful journey but we received our Permanent Residence last week (22nd March).
We applied using EIND Caselaw so I must admit, I was rather nervous as I couldn't find any success stories after the 'Qualified Person' condition came into play and as my circumstances hadn't changed during the SS saga and I am still my daughter's full time carer, I took the risk. Thankfully the application stating N/A under EIND and quoting the EIND caselaw in the cover letter wasn't challenged. In fact, our documentation on the 25th March, unopened so I can only assume that they didn't look at the documentation sent, although I know of someone who received their PR the same day who did receive a call to ask about their employment history. I guess that we either had an experienced, knowledgeable assessor or an extremely lazy one.
Good luck to everyone still to apply.
Angela
Hey there if you're still following this thread, I started this journey on the British Expats Forum almost 6 years ago and it's been a long and sometimes stressful journey but we received our Permanent Residence last week (22nd March).
We applied using EIND Caselaw so I must admit, I was rather nervous as I couldn't find any success stories after the 'Qualified Person' condition came into play and as my circumstances hadn't changed during the SS saga and I am still my daughter's full time carer, I took the risk. Thankfully the application stating N/A under EIND and quoting the EIND caselaw in the cover letter wasn't challenged. In fact, our documentation on the 25th March, unopened so I can only assume that they didn't look at the documentation sent, although I know of someone who received their PR the same day who did receive a call to ask about their employment history. I guess that we either had an experienced, knowledgeable assessor or an extremely lazy one.
Good luck to everyone still to apply.
Angela
#1461
Just Joined
Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 6
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
We got PR !!!!
Hey there if you're still following this thread, I started this journey on the British Expats Forum almost 6 years ago and it's been a long and sometimes stressful journey but we received our Permanent Residence last week (22nd March).
We applied using EIND Caselaw so I must admit, I was rather nervous as I couldn't find any success stories after the 'Qualified Person' condition came into play and as my circumstances hadn't changed during the SS saga and I am still my daughter's full time carer, I took the risk. Thankfully the application stating N/A under EIND and quoting the EIND caselaw in the cover letter wasn't challenged. In fact, our documentation on the 25th March, unopened so I can only assume that they didn't look at the documentation sent, although I know of someone who received their PR the same day who did receive a call to ask about their employment history. I guess that we either had an experienced, knowledgeable assessor or an extremely lazy one.
Good luck to everyone still to apply.
Angela
Hey there if you're still following this thread, I started this journey on the British Expats Forum almost 6 years ago and it's been a long and sometimes stressful journey but we received our Permanent Residence last week (22nd March).
We applied using EIND Caselaw so I must admit, I was rather nervous as I couldn't find any success stories after the 'Qualified Person' condition came into play and as my circumstances hadn't changed during the SS saga and I am still my daughter's full time carer, I took the risk. Thankfully the application stating N/A under EIND and quoting the EIND caselaw in the cover letter wasn't challenged. In fact, our documentation on the 25th March, unopened so I can only assume that they didn't look at the documentation sent, although I know of someone who received their PR the same day who did receive a call to ask about their employment history. I guess that we either had an experienced, knowledgeable assessor or an extremely lazy one.
Good luck to everyone still to apply.
Angela
Thanks for sharing your experience! So glad that you successfully finished your long jurney now.
My husband and I are going back to England next year through Surinder singh. We know it’s quite late stage and nobody knows what the Brexit will affect. But we will try it anyway as we already live in another EU country and want to go back to England.
I have some questions about it if you don’t mind.
We live in Portugal now and my British husband is self-employed. He recieves his income in Portuguese back account and registered tax number and self employed here. It will be appriciated if you could share the documents you proved to apply for resident card? I serched lots of posting about this and not very sure how detail we have to prepare.. also do we have to translate all the documents that is not in English?
also do we have to apply for EEA family permit first before we go back to England? We apply it in Portugal?
Thanks for your help in advance.
Last edited by Chloe93; Jun 1st 2019 at 3:57 am.
#1462
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
Hi Angela,
Thanks for sharing your experience! So glad that you successfully finished your long jurney now.
My husband and I are going back to England next year through Surinder singh. We know it’s quite late stage and nobody knows what the Brexit will affect. But we will try it anyway as we already live in another EU country and want to go back to England.
I have some questions about it if you don’t mind.
We live in Portugal now and my British husband is self-employed. He recieves his income in Portuguese back account and registered tax number and self employed here. It will be appriciated if you could share the documents you proved to apply for resident card? I serched lots of posting about this and not very sure how detail we have to prepare.. also do we have to translate all the documents that is not in English?
also do we have to apply for EEA family permit first before we go back to England? We apply it in Portugal?
Thanks for your help in advance.
Thanks for sharing your experience! So glad that you successfully finished your long jurney now.
My husband and I are going back to England next year through Surinder singh. We know it’s quite late stage and nobody knows what the Brexit will affect. But we will try it anyway as we already live in another EU country and want to go back to England.
I have some questions about it if you don’t mind.
We live in Portugal now and my British husband is self-employed. He recieves his income in Portuguese back account and registered tax number and self employed here. It will be appriciated if you could share the documents you proved to apply for resident card? I serched lots of posting about this and not very sure how detail we have to prepare.. also do we have to translate all the documents that is not in English?
also do we have to apply for EEA family permit first before we go back to England? We apply it in Portugal?
Thanks for your help in advance.
#1463
Just Joined
Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 6
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
we do have plan B, But we thought it’s worth to try as it’s free of charge and we also would like to go back.
do you know anything about documents for SS?
#1464
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
I do but that’s a broad subject. Do you have any specific questions about the documentation you’ll need to provide?
#1465
Just Joined
Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 6
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
My husband is self-emplyed, He works online and paid through Portugess bank account.
So My husband's work contract, his payslip(6months?), his bank account, registration of taxes
Is that enought to prove that you’ve worked as self employed?
Also,
-our marriage certificate
-my residency cards from Portugal/the prove my husband registered in portugal
-our joint bank account
-our rental agreement for the house
-our internet, water/gas, electricity bills under our names
-my passport and my husband's passport
- our cards showing registration at the local health center
- library cards from local public library
- 10 pictures of us in Portugal with our local friends and friends, England.
Anything more do we have to prepare?
Questions..
1) Do we have to translate all of them into English?
2) for the bills, do they have to be original copy or can I juat print out on the website as I pay online?
3) I believe we can apply for family permit in Portugal and enter to the UK. Once we get the femily permit for 6 months, will we possibly get 5 years resident cards in the UK?
Thank you so much for your help.
#1466
Forum Regular
Joined: Mar 2016
Posts: 214
Re: My experience of going the Surinder Singh route so far
Hi All,
Question for anyone with experience of the Pre/Settled Status form or process -.
Is it likely to be an issue if the non-eu spouse does not have a tax or social security number from the host state (even if the BritCit does)?
Thanks
Question for anyone with experience of the Pre/Settled Status form or process -.
Is it likely to be an issue if the non-eu spouse does not have a tax or social security number from the host state (even if the BritCit does)?
Thanks