School year to start.
#16
Oh dear. Donald Trump is an erudite man holding well thought out policy positions and is a danger to no one. His barber is a talented artist.
Back with the double cohort, I wonder if anyone has studied the long term impact. I would think the students in the older year had a competitive advantage when they arrived at university; that may have persisted or it might be that they were bored, like a bright student in a class of slow kids, and dropped out/got into trouble. If we knew what happened to such a large sample we might be better able to predict what happens to the individual age displaced student.
Back with the double cohort, I wonder if anyone has studied the long term impact. I would think the students in the older year had a competitive advantage when they arrived at university; that may have persisted or it might be that they were bored, like a bright student in a class of slow kids, and dropped out/got into trouble. If we knew what happened to such a large sample we might be better able to predict what happens to the individual age displaced student.
One knock-on effect I certainly noticed was applying for jobs after graduation. Most universities upped the number of students they accepted in the double-cohort year... but companies were not really hiring more students 4 years later. There was definitely more competition in applying for jobs out of university.
In addition, friends of mine who were applying to post-graduate programs also found that there was more competition.
I don't think the OAC students found first year much different or less challenging - at least in my experience, the courses were not really adjusted to accommodate those who didn't know the material. Instead, some (but not all) professors ran separate tutorials with their TAs to cover the extra material that the younger year was behind on. (Just my experience, don't imagine this was done everywhere.)
It also didn't matter in every subject. I did a Commerce degree, and this really was only a problem in Calculus. The other courses didn't have the same gap problem.
#17
BE Forum Addict







Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 2,040
From: Orton, Ontario











Oh dear. Donald Trump is an erudite man holding well thought out policy positions and is a danger to no one. His barber is a talented artist.
Back with the double cohort, I wonder if anyone has studied the long term impact. I would think the students in the older year had a competitive advantage when they arrived at university; that may have persisted or it might be that they were bored, like a bright student in a class of slow kids, and dropped out/got into trouble. If we knew what happened to such a large sample we might be better able to predict what happens to the individual age displaced student.
Back with the double cohort, I wonder if anyone has studied the long term impact. I would think the students in the older year had a competitive advantage when they arrived at university; that may have persisted or it might be that they were bored, like a bright student in a class of slow kids, and dropped out/got into trouble. If we knew what happened to such a large sample we might be better able to predict what happens to the individual age displaced student.
It would make an interesting study purely on the basis of what can happen to individual kids when the authorities mess about with their lives. Not sure about the relevance to individual age displaced students as this would very much depend on when they were displaced. Mine for example has been through the entire Canadian system one year ahead. I don't think he is either advantaged or disadvantaged academically compared to his classmates. He still had an extra year of 'schooling' (if you can count UK reception class) compared to them even though he is younger. It could be more relevant to kids, like the OPs who would have been in the equivalent of Gr 11 in the UK but are moved to Gr 12 here as they are missing the foundation for the Gr 12 courses.
#18
Although I am not sure it counts when it's quite so contrived, I appreciate the effort.
It would make an interesting study purely on the basis of what can happen to individual kids when the authorities mess about with their lives. Not sure about the relevance to individual age displaced students as this would very much depend on when they were displaced. Mine for example has been through the entire Canadian system one year ahead. I don't think he is either advantaged or disadvantaged academically compared to his classmates. He still had an extra year of 'schooling' (if you can count UK reception class) compared to them even though he is younger. It could be more relevant to kids, like the OPs who would have been in the equivalent of Gr 11 in the UK but are moved to Gr 12 here as they are missing the foundation for the Gr 12 courses.
It would make an interesting study purely on the basis of what can happen to individual kids when the authorities mess about with their lives. Not sure about the relevance to individual age displaced students as this would very much depend on when they were displaced. Mine for example has been through the entire Canadian system one year ahead. I don't think he is either advantaged or disadvantaged academically compared to his classmates. He still had an extra year of 'schooling' (if you can count UK reception class) compared to them even though he is younger. It could be more relevant to kids, like the OPs who would have been in the equivalent of Gr 11 in the UK but are moved to Gr 12 here as they are missing the foundation for the Gr 12 courses.
#19
BE user by choice









Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 4,854
From: A Briton, married to a Canadian, now in Fredericton.











#20
Just an update, the school has overridden CBE and is allowing her to start at Gd 11. Thank you everyone for the input.
#21




