Old fashioned, or....?
#16
Of course, but some of the things you mention, such as allowing kids to prioritise external activities over family interaction at dinner, and allowing them to socialise with fictional characters rather than their families for entertainment is one of the reasons young people today have so many difficulties with socialisation. We have spoken about this before on this forum but one thing I have noticed is that young adults of around 20 seem to have the socialisation skills and attitude of when I was about 14, and this is why. It's possible to prepare your kids for the real world without ceding to their every whim, and they don't require a private internet connection to do their homework. I agree with your other points.
I want my son to be tech savvy but not at the expense of social skills and non-tech abilities
It's hard sometimes
#17
Banned








Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 3,300











I agree, and I think Garry is right to raise the ubiquity of tech in the world from now on. Soon, tablets are going to look very clunky and dated as we move to augmented reality via contact lenses, and how you monitor a teenager's use of that, I have no idea.
#18
So parents tend to look at how they were bought up (3 Rs, etc) and replay it onto their children. Yet we wouldn't think that a Victorian family was an ideal model for today (have the nanny bring down the respectful child for half an hour of family time, before being sent back to bed). Things change; and where we currently are the models of only ten years ago are out of date.
Do kids need to be able to socialise? Sure do, and there is nothing more antisocial than a teenager. But they also need to be able to socialise, form and navigate interactions, online, and with wildly different cultures (any job in future is going to have a globalisation aspect). That wasn't something parents were bought up with, and a focus on socialisation meaning 'playgroups' isn't really going going to cut it.
At the same time we are very much in a 'two wage earner' situation - if you can at all manage it. That changes the structure and nature of the household, and the mechanisms need to change with it.
All that is before we get to the other changes coming round the corner - the ones that haven't hit yet, but we know are on the cards.
I'm reminded of the Vernor Vinge novel "Rainbows End" that is basically a thought experiment on kids, schooling and families in a technologically accelerated world. Worth a read if you need to break out of old fashioned thinking : http://web.archive.org/web/200711240...inbowsend.html
#19
It's one of my pet peeves - households, families, schools, etc. They all tend to look backward in terms of method of operation, but need to be forward looking in anticipating and preparing for the future.
So parents tend to look at how they were bought up (3 Rs, etc) and replay it onto their children. Yet we wouldn't think that a Victorian family was an ideal model for today (have the nanny bring down the respectful child for half an hour of family time, before being sent back to bed). Things change; and where we currently are the models of only ten years ago are out of date.
Do kids need to be able to socialise? Sure do, and there is nothing more antisocial than a teenager. But they also need to be able to socialise, form and navigate interactions, online, and with wildly different cultures (any job in future is going to have a globalisation aspect). That wasn't something parents were bought up with, and a focus on socialisation meaning 'playgroups' isn't really going going to cut it.
At the same time we are very much in a 'two wage earner' situation - if you can at all manage it. That changes the structure and nature of the household, and the mechanisms need to change with it.
All that is before we get to the other changes coming round the corner - the ones that haven't hit yet, but we know are on the cards.
I'm reminded of the Vernor Vinge novel "Rainbows End" that is basically a thought experiment on kids, schooling and families in a technologically accelerated world. Worth a read if you need to break out of old fashioned thinking : http://web.archive.org/web/200711240...inbowsend.html
So parents tend to look at how they were bought up (3 Rs, etc) and replay it onto their children. Yet we wouldn't think that a Victorian family was an ideal model for today (have the nanny bring down the respectful child for half an hour of family time, before being sent back to bed). Things change; and where we currently are the models of only ten years ago are out of date.
Do kids need to be able to socialise? Sure do, and there is nothing more antisocial than a teenager. But they also need to be able to socialise, form and navigate interactions, online, and with wildly different cultures (any job in future is going to have a globalisation aspect). That wasn't something parents were bought up with, and a focus on socialisation meaning 'playgroups' isn't really going going to cut it.
At the same time we are very much in a 'two wage earner' situation - if you can at all manage it. That changes the structure and nature of the household, and the mechanisms need to change with it.
All that is before we get to the other changes coming round the corner - the ones that haven't hit yet, but we know are on the cards.
I'm reminded of the Vernor Vinge novel "Rainbows End" that is basically a thought experiment on kids, schooling and families in a technologically accelerated world. Worth a read if you need to break out of old fashioned thinking : http://web.archive.org/web/200711240...inbowsend.html
#20
Who here knows how to pass the port (except me)?
Similarly, who here knows the way to point out something in an asian culture?
#21
No but they don't email them either.....
Yes. Every night.
Yes.
Yes although they have one in their playroom
Yes my kids have always got their nose in a book and normally 1 or 2 others on the go too.
BB
#22
Please, thank you etc - just general good manners - I know how to pass the port but that is not what I meant, as you know.
#25
Forum Regular




Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 276
From: London











Write letters to family/friends (on paper, with pen)?
Have meals round the dining table as a family (whenever possible)?
Insist on children writing "thank you" letters for presents?
Refuse to allow TVs/computers in young children's bedrooms?
Encourage their kids to read - and if possible buy - "real" books?
#28
Ahh, but to give that reply I must understand the phrase, no?
And although there are many more people who know the etiquette that I expected, that's kinda my point. Even manners change over time, and the things you need to know will shift. Is it more important to understand about deploying a 'IMHO' or the Bishop of Norwich?
A 'thanks' at the right time might not have gone out of style in a hundred years, but you try holding a door open for a colleague of the female persuasion today, and in a reasonable percentage of cases you'll get an earful.
And although there are many more people who know the etiquette that I expected, that's kinda my point. Even manners change over time, and the things you need to know will shift. Is it more important to understand about deploying a 'IMHO' or the Bishop of Norwich?
A 'thanks' at the right time might not have gone out of style in a hundred years, but you try holding a door open for a colleague of the female persuasion today, and in a reasonable percentage of cases you'll get an earful.
#29
Thread Starter
Home and Happy










Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 94,305
From: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...











Not a mum, but a very involved Aunty to three who are growing up fast - middle one just reached 18
She's the most technology addicted, but still loves board games and books; her sister is a more voracious reader at 13, I got her a kindle 2 years ago but she still buys books as well, and she adores family board games -especially scrabble at which she shines!
The whole politeness and thank you thing is well drilled into all of them, even my student nephew, though its a text or facebook with him rather than a letter!
We also are a real family of card senders, always have been, and even though we now send facebook pics the cards still fly back and forth, seems a bit more personal somehow.
She's the most technology addicted, but still loves board games and books; her sister is a more voracious reader at 13, I got her a kindle 2 years ago but she still buys books as well, and she adores family board games -especially scrabble at which she shines!The whole politeness and thank you thing is well drilled into all of them, even my student nephew, though its a text or facebook with him rather than a letter!
We also are a real family of card senders, always have been, and even though we now send facebook pics the cards still fly back and forth, seems a bit more personal somehow.
#30
Theoretically I know how to pass the port, but since the ladies have to leave the room before the gentlemen drink it and smoke their cigars, it is not something I have had to put into practice myself.
Small drop of madeira anyone??
Small drop of madeira anyone??



