jothefw

A thread actually searching out glass bottles reminded me of this terrible story I'd read in the UK press.

Basically a young man lost his life due to an accident. He was in the wrong place at the wrong time. His amazing wife is trying to have the UK government stop glass bottles being sold in nightclubs, pubs etc.

She only needs 9000 more signatures to make it to 100,000 - she's awaiting the trial of the guilty persons as I type. Her courage and the way she's tackled this campaign are inspiring. She has two young children and I don't know if I were in her situation that I'd have coped as well as she has.

http://www.pop-campaign.co.uk/

I really don't know how she'll get on banning glass bottles but it's got to be worth 5 minutes of looking at her site and perhaps signing

DadAgain

At risk of sounding like one of those "guns don't kill people - people kill people" nutter I would be mildly miffed if this got up.

Whilst I have a great deal of sympathy for anyone who ends up on the receiving end of a drunken violent thug, I'm not convinced that widespread bans are the right solution.

I think we have to consider that glass bottles do provide significant value when used properly over the usual alternatives. If you're drinking sensibly, glass bottles are perfectly safe and either decanting to plastic glasses or being served plastic bottles would simply be horrible - (It'd save me a fortune though and a lot of people would go home sober a lot more often!)

With guns of course its difficult to make ANY legitimate argument for how they improve anyones life - but glass? glass is GREAT... it can be cleaned and reused, it feels nice, it retains temperature better than plastic etc etc etc


DONT SIGN!!!! Keep the glass!!!

Tramps_mate

To a point.. But in night clubs they should use plastic cups and supply beer in plastic bottles too. BWS or supermarket can sell glass.

moneypenny20

I don't understand the bit in bold. I also don't understand the need for glass bottles or glasses in a pub setting but that's me. Anyway, the significant value???

Bibbs

The flavour.

And I don't agree with it. Typical nanny state, lets ban everything.

How about having proper punishments for crime and letting the people who like a beer out of a bottle carry on?

moneypenny20

Apparently the beer in this country is so piss poor, I can't see what damage a plastic cup could do to it. People don't go to the type of pubs and clubs were most of these fights break out for the quality of the alcohol. They go to get wasted for some unknown reason.

Amazulu

They give you an advantage if you get into a bar fight though

Bibbs

Is it wrong I laughed?

jothefw

I like my beer in a bottle, I understand.

However flick knives are banned for a reason, a broken bottle does more damage. My brother got caught in a club years ago, the guy attacked lost his eye. They were just minding their own business, having a quiet drink after work.

Did you read the story?

DadAgain

...and people are killed each year by cars but we don't ban them do we?

Some things are capable of causing horrible injuries when not used properly. trying to ban everything is not the solution.

if a pub serves beer in a plastic, I'll have one drink and leave - never to darken its halls again. it's a travesty - beer in plastic should be illegal for crimes against taste (Perhaps I'll start a petition)?

roaringmouse

Polycarbonate beer mugs can be cleaned and reused as well. I don't see an issue in pubs & clubs having to use this kind of alternative to glass - if you want to drink from a glass mug, then drink at home. If you want the social aspect of a pub then accept the need to drink from a polycarbonate mug or similar. Makes sense to me. No, but we ban drunk people from driving cars - and if someone is caught driving over the limit then they face the consequence. Likewise, a glass mug shouldn't be an issue, however add alcohol to the equation (just like with cars) then it can become a problem.

chris955

The think is glass has been used forever by morons in fights, my brother had a huge scar literally the length of his cheek from being glassed in a fight in Geelong back in the very early 70's. Harsher penalties would help stop it but even that is debatable.

DadAgain

I'm pretty sure you could do some severe damage with a broken dinner plate if you were so inclined. Should we force all restaurants that open to the public to use paper plates? After all if you WANT to eat of china you can do that at home!

Drinking out of a cold glass, or a chilled bottle in a pub is one of the few luxuries some of us have in life. Force the pubs to serve in plastic and the quality of the experience is badly diminished and I'd bet most pubs would see a dramatic drop in patronage.

Banning something enjoyed by millions simply because a pitifull few idiots misuse is simply not a solution to the worlds woes.

Pollyana

The Nanny State Culture....what happened to making people take responsibility for their actions instead of trying to legislate against every little possible thing?

asprilla

Next thing you know, even the plastic beer glasses will be banned.

We'll all have to drink from the taps!!!