The Green family
#16
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2013
Location: Perth
Posts: 623
Re: The Green family
As far as I'm aware he is applying for PR through a sponsorship from an employer which is a 186 visa. He tried this with previous employers but was let down. Who knows why he didn't go the 189/190 route but based on the fact they have used immigration lawyers on this I assume they gave them the best advice on which route to go.
#17
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2013
Location: Perth
Posts: 623
Re: The Green family
Probably better those that take that option accept it is a temporally stay and not have in mind that is will be a stepping stone to PR. Far better to come out on a permanent visa from the beginning. (on all fronts) I'm not sure just why the Australian workplace is too often a place of bullying or under mining but it sadly is. In most countries expertise is welcomed and those importing highly qualified labour from overseas sources will allow that individual to pursue what would be fair to assume the reason they were recruited in the first place. (to bring their form of expertise to the employer and Australian work place) Sadly, too often management is of a very poor standard. Ineffective and feels threatened by those from a work place (overseas) that promoted, let alone allowed, the freedom to complete task without undue interference, instead of judging on finished result . It too often appears the employer wants the knowledge from overseas employee but take the credit then rid themselves of that employee once knowledge gained. (depends on position obviously)
But simply, very hard to understand how Green family did not take matters into hand and seek a change of status. Unless of course, for whatever reason was unable to qualify under existing rules. Something is suggestive that this is more likely the case. There was an English couple in Perth with a similar ordeal last year. Never heard the outcome to that. But I thought at the time 'they were trying it on' by going to the media , with a rather flimsy arguement for reasons to stay.
But simply, very hard to understand how Green family did not take matters into hand and seek a change of status. Unless of course, for whatever reason was unable to qualify under existing rules. Something is suggestive that this is more likely the case. There was an English couple in Perth with a similar ordeal last year. Never heard the outcome to that. But I thought at the time 'they were trying it on' by going to the media , with a rather flimsy arguement for reasons to stay.
I do agree that yes it would have been better that the Greens took matters into their own hands but given that they have been using immigration agent's throughout this process and have spent ALOT of money there must have been a reason they have went the route they have advised to them by immigration agent's.
#18
Re: The Green family
"six businesses the 44-year-old has worked for have since gone bust, leaving the family without any way of obtaining a sponsor."
Sounds like he's cursed!!
Sounds like he's cursed!!
#19
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Oct 2008
Location: Perth
Posts: 6,775
Re: The Green family
Yes hindsight is a wonderful thing but the reality is many come here on a sponsorship from an employer which leads to PR. I know if I was headhunted by a company on the other side of the world and offered relocations costs and a route to PR I would accept it aswell rather than going the route I did. In most cases it does work out. We only hear of the bad cases because they are highlighted.
I do agree that yes it would have been better that the Greens took matters into their own hands but given that they have been using immigration agent's throughout this process and have spent ALOT of money there must have been a reason they have went the route they have advised to them by immigration agent's.
I do agree that yes it would have been better that the Greens took matters into their own hands but given that they have been using immigration agent's throughout this process and have spent ALOT of money there must have been a reason they have went the route they have advised to them by immigration agent's.
It appears they have an omen of sorts around their necks, being connected with so many business's going bust? Of course we don't know the entire story and usually there is more under the surface that remain submerged in media reports.