British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   The Barbie (https://britishexpats.com/forum/barbie-92/)
-   -   Is the grass greener? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/barbie-92/grass-greener-503031/)

ozzieeagle Jan 3rd 2008 6:16 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
[quote=manc1;5737022]

Originally Posted by ozzieeagle (Post 5736988)

Funny that, we've been here around the same amount of years. I've worked in the bush/mines etc. Lived in a number of states. My UK experiences are much different to yours, dont get me wrong I have a few ozzy mates but I definitely dont find Australians particularly friendlier than people from other places I've travelled. Just out of curiosity, where in England did you get the ignored experience?

Last time I went, was 2.5 years ago, I did manage to talk to some people, most notably where I was from, whilst in queues along the dockland line in London, there again I couldn't contain my amazement at Canary wharf etc, which didn't exist when I left. Found it very insular in Nth Wales (Rhyl and Prestatyn) and Warrington. Milton Keynes was a bit iffy as well, Crawley seemed a bit hectic for people to take the time.

russmcp Jan 3rd 2008 9:50 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by cavacharva (Post 5733373)
It's interesting to see the OP being shouted down for stating immigration as a reason for leaving while considering becoming one herself.

I fully intend intergrating into Australian society. Speaking the langauge etc... I have to otherwise I wouldn't be allowed in the country.

That can not be said for the millions of people who have arrived on our island the past few years.

If people all want to create a little bit of home right down to the language they speak then the UK will cease to exist.


Another I fully intend post....... I'm sure you fully intend to integrate well done you.

How many of those 'millions' who have moved here have you heard talk? While i'm sure there are some that will struggle to learn the language I'm sure many will try to learn English, Mr Cappelo being one.

Do you know, I was only sat here last night worrying about all these foreign types coming over here with their foreign food swamping our shopping aisles and then thinking, christ if this carries on the UK will cease to exist.

Welcome aboard, look forward to more of your posts which should help raise a smile.

ianandmel Jan 3rd 2008 10:07 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
I've been itching to comment on the whole thing, kept holding myself back, but i just caaaan't


Originally Posted by bella-71 (Post 5733520)
`It's interesting to see the OP being shouted down for stating immigration as a reason for leaving while considering becoming one herself.`
Thanks for that. I have tried to explain but seem to keep getting shot down.
The immigration situation in the UK I am referring to is mainly the illegal ones, as I have mentioned in a previous posts.The ones that come in and dont intend to work, bring nothing to the country and just hang about in gangs.
If I were to emigrate my husband and I would both take skills to Oz with us and intend to work hard and fit into the community.
....

If you`re just going to put me down for my original post then please dont bother posting. Negative comments about my reasons for leaving the UK in relation to my expectations in Perth fine but please dont judge me.
:(

the reason why I usually get started when the word "immigrant" comes up is because I have family who had to become illegal immigrants following a coup in their home country. it took some years before they became legal. if you consider that illegal immigrants are those who have been denied asylum but know that return would mean jail or worse (simply for being of the 'wrong' ethnicity or perceived to have the 'wrong' political opinion), i really really donot understand why there is such little empathy. why not just be happy that you were lucky to be born in a relatively safe country? as for polish people: good on them, they work hard and most people i met are superfriendly and try to learn english. for asians: they are part of the commonwealth and it were the brits who came round to their country in the first place (and i doubt they made a massive effort learning other languages), some exchange is just fair play i think.
with this, i donot mean to shout you down, just try to explain why at least in my case all these rants about immigrants bring up really negative feelings.


Originally Posted by Emmis (Post 5734045)
And the problem with immigrants... I think if you were to go to Magaluf in Spain you'd find Brits who've lived there for years and don't speak Spanish... and supermarkets with isles of British food. Australia is cosmopolitan and international. A country built on a fusion of nationalities. Everyone there's an immigrant!

thank you! that would have been the next part of my own rant.
seeing how cosmopolitan and international australia is, got me started thinking about emigrating there in the first place. i have heard how racist australians can be etc, but will assume that that's a generalisation which will apply to most countries. i am looking forward to move somewhere culturally mixed.
and non-spanish speaking english workers in european countries do get to me big time when they start mentioning that they moved to spain/france/portugal "because of all those immigrants in the UK" ( i was unlucky enough to get into conversations with some during my last 4 holidays. they always seem to work in scuba diving shops. ok and i expect to get shouted at for that generalisation now...:().


Originally Posted by Buzzy--Bee (Post 5735075)
Bella, everyone was in the same situation once (ie being a potential immigrant). The point being made is that if you are coming to Australia to get away from negatives in the UK, you will probably find your new life in Australia a lot less satisfactory than you expect it to be.
The advice given to do a reccie is good, if you haven't been to Oz before. As many posters have mentioned, you may find the negatives you mention in the UK alive and well in Oz.
Please continue to ask questions, just don't be surprised if some of the answers are not what you want to hear!

Buzzy

i too think that buzzy is right. we started our research phase having the negatives in the UK (racism, little freetime opportunities for kids) in mind, but it slowly changed and now we're concentrating not on what is better in oz (in a rose-tinted glasses way) but which aspects of our life do we think we are more able to change once we move. your outlook might change whilst you're researching, dont be put off by harsh sounding comments. i often get unfriendly replies, it puzzled me in the beginning, but just imagine that the person is saying that with a half smile and doesn't actually mean it that unfriendly. i often have to rewrite to take the edge out of my replies.
all the best anyway! mel

russmcp Jan 3rd 2008 10:16 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
Nice post ianandmel

Wilgar Jan 3rd 2008 10:23 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by bella-71 (Post 5730472)
Just wondered if the grass is actually greener on the other side?

Is it worth up rooting my family and moving to perth for a better life.

I`ve read lots of mixed messages on these boards. Our reasons for thinking we would like to leave the UK and emigrate are as follows:

1/ The UK is going downhill, I work for the civil service and it is clearly tumbling!

2/ The population! Houses being built 3 stories high in every small space around cities and towns. And right behind our house that used to be a clear open space full of trees.

3/ The amount of immigrants both legal and illegal that are getting into the UK

4/ The fact that there are knives and drugs in most schools

5/ The fact that I cant allow my children to walk to the corner shop alone as a convicted child rapist has been re housed just up the road.

6/ The fact that we went on holiday to Florida for 2 weeks and by the time we returned there had been 3 murders in our town

I am not stupid and know that day to day life is mundane where-ever you live but surely we should give it a go for the sake of our children and the next generations!

I understand that a lot of the bigger cities in OZ have similar problems but surely the suburbs are generally nice places to live.

I will be leaving a lot of close friends behind, my Mum and Dad will be the biggest wrench from the kids but its our life, not theirs and surely we should do with it as we see fit.

Any advice or comments appreciated. :unsure::unsure:

The grass is always greener where you are not! Pros and cons to both places so perhaps you could visit Oz to help make up your mind.You would of course be an immigrant here and there are certainly many other immigrants who`ve been here years and do not speak English. Crime is similar in both places.We`ve been in our new suburban house 8 weeks and already had an attempted break in.Then yesterday , a man strangled his 14 yo daughter and killed himself at the end of our road.Sadly this is all part of the world we live in.
It`s a massive decision and you need to be sure................Tough decisions ahead.Happy thinking!

Wilgar Jan 3rd 2008 10:30 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by Vim Fuego (Post 5735739)
Don't post it if you don't mean it.

Anyway, on a lighter note, life is good here because there is no imminent threat from Al Quaeda, or indeed anyone called Al, because they are booking people for jay walking.

And indeed I got done for the first time in three years today (and feel more Australian because of it!).

Normally I'd stop but it was raining and I was in a 'what the hell' mood.

Here is an excerpt from my conversation with the ever-entertaining Plod:

Plod: "Do you have any identification?'
Me: "Here's my driving licence'
Plod: "Thank you Sir"
Me: (jokingly) "You're not going to take that as well are you?"
Plod: <tells me in monotone that this is not a traffic violation and does not carry any demit points>

Ah it brightened my day so it did, well worth $30.

Good luck with your plans :)

I was done for jay walking at Venice Beach,California a few years ago. I thought the police officer was joking , until I was informed I must turn up at local police station with my passport. Ironically, as he was telling me off he had his back to a couple of guys beating up another man!

Hutch Jan 3rd 2008 10:31 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by bella-71 (Post 5730472)
Just wondered if the grass is actually greener on the other side? Any advice or comments appreciated. :unsure::unsure:

I've said it before and I'll say it again - there's no right or wrong reason for emigrating - it's just whatever works for you.

Check this out. It was my first ever blog post (well, my first blog on *this* site anyway) and it summed up the way I'd come to feel about England.

Looking back on that post two years down the line ... I don't regret a single word of it. Was all of England that like - of course not - but most of the important bits that made up my day-to-day life were. I didn't commute along a canal to work in a stately home manually weighing women's breasts. Of course over here I don't have an office overlooking the Sydney Opera House and arrive at work by Sunseeker Portofino 53 manually weighing women's breasts either - but the day-to-day stuff, the grind, for me it's vastly better here.

I wouldn't say I emigrated because I hated England, but I certainly didn't move to Australia just for the pull of this place. I tried living elsewhere in England and it didn't work out - the grind was the same. The grind here is different - partly because I made it that way and partly because Australia enabled me to. You've got to meet the place half way.

:)

BadgeIsBack Jan 3rd 2008 10:42 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
I'd go with Buzzy and Hutch.

For me, there was a *big* pull over here, and a little push from the UK - namely housing stock and overcrowding and a wish for a change of tempo.

Some people do come over to get a ''better'' life - but also some of the ones who do nothing but moan or are ill-equipped can expect to get out of their depth.

There was a woman on this site about 3 years ago who was out of her depth big time yet noone had the guts to say it - she displayed all the characteristics of a migrant who should never have bothered. Her identity will remain a secret....(:p)

KLF Jan 3rd 2008 11:03 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by BadgeIsBack (Post 5738069)
I'd go with Buzzy and Hutch.
Some people do come over to get a ''better'' life - but also some of the ones who do nothing but moan or are ill-equipped can expect to get out of their depth.

There was a woman on this site about 3 years ago who was out of her depth big time yet noone had the guts to say it - she displayed all the characteristics of a migrant who should never have bothered. Her identity will remain a secret....(:p)

Define ill-equipped in the context of emigrating to Australia.

This woman...your missus?

cavacharva Jan 4th 2008 1:51 am

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by russmcp (Post 5737891)
Another I fully intend post....... I'm sure you fully intend to integrate well done you.

How many of those 'millions' who have moved here have you heard talk? While i'm sure there are some that will struggle to learn the language I'm sure many will try to learn English, Mr Cappelo being one.

Do you know, I was only sat here last night worrying about all these foreign types coming over here with their foreign food swamping our shopping aisles and then thinking, christ if this carries on the UK will cease to exist.

Welcome aboard, look forward to more of your posts which should help raise a smile.

Thanks for that, always pleased to amuse ;)

But I really think your the one out of touch, not me. Try this from the bbc for the current opinion on this.

http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/thre...410&#paginator

Personally I don't give a toss how many foreigners come to the UK so long as they can speak English and don't go round in a world cocooned by translators paid for by British tax payers.

You certainly wouldn't get that in France, Germany or Spain.

ianandmel Jan 4th 2008 2:33 am

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by cavacharva (Post 5738738)

You certainly wouldn't get that in France, Germany or Spain.

i have not followed the previous argument between the two of you, but as for Germany:
i was listening to the radio in germany (where i spent christmas) a couple of days before christmas eve and was astonished to hear about an initiative which was running alongside some kind of german version of "help a local child" which focussed on how to reach out to and help illegal immigrants (exact german translation used there) to celebrate christmas with some dignity.
now that is something you would not find over here.

have to mention though that hamburg is always priding itself for its diversity, cannot speak for other cities.

russmcp Jan 4th 2008 2:45 am

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
[QUOTE=cavacharva;5738738]Thanks for that, always pleased to amuse ;)

But I really think your the one out of touch, not me. Try this from the bbc for the current opinion on this.

http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/thre...410&#paginator

Personally I don't give a toss how many foreigners come to the UK so long as they can speak English and don't go round in a world cocooned by translators paid for by British tax payers.

You certainly wouldn't get that in France, Germany or S






thanks for the link, out of touch I don't think I am more the type to make my own mind up. Its a quiet news day here in the UK (I used to work In the media) and the BBC asking for peoples opinions suggest that.

No link to a forum will alter my stance. I want to move to oz cos I love it not get away but have a new adventure in what is in fact an irrelevant short time on this planet.

cavacharva Jan 4th 2008 2:50 am

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by ianandmel (Post 5738928)
i have not followed the previous argument between the two of you, but as for Germany:
i was listening to the radio in germany (where i spent christmas) a couple of days before christmas eve and was astonished to hear about an initiative which was running alongside some kind of german version of "help a local child" which focussed on how to reach out to and help illegal immigrants (exact german translation used there) to celebrate christmas with some dignity.
now that is something you would not find over here.

have to mention though that hamburg is always priding itself for its diversity, cannot speak for other cities.


If Germany can afford to do that. Good for them, very commendable. With people being refused life saving cancer drugs on the NHS I'd say we are not quite there yet in this country.

The argument Im putting is would you expect immigrants to the UK to learn English themselves at their own cost or have it provided by the tax payer?

Would you expect a German-English translator in a German hospital? Would you expect a translator for your court appearance or quit smoking session all paid for by the German tax payer?

Have we got our priorities right in this country? I dont think we do.

manc1 Jan 4th 2008 1:04 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 
[QUOTE=ozzieeagle;5737258]

Originally Posted by manc1 (Post 5737022)

Last time I went, was 2.5 years ago, I did manage to talk to some people, most notably where I was from, whilst in queues along the dockland line in London, there again I couldn't contain my amazement at Canary wharf etc, which didn't exist when I left. Found it very insular in Nth Wales (Rhyl and Prestatyn) and Warrington. Milton Keynes was a bit iffy as well, Crawley seemed a bit hectic for people to take the time.


Have you heard the old saying they use in England. The further north you go the friendlier the people. :thumbsup:

chris and farideh Jan 4th 2008 1:39 pm

Re: Is the grass greener?
 

Originally Posted by cavacharva (Post 5738738)
Thanks for that, always pleased to amuse ;)

But I really think your the one out of touch, not me. Try this from the bbc for the current opinion on this.

http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/thre...410&#paginator

Personally I don't give a toss how many foreigners come to the UK so long as they can speak English and don't go round in a world cocooned by translators paid for by British tax payers.

You certainly wouldn't get that in France, Germany or Spain.


Personally I think you do give toss about how many legal/illegal migrants are moving to UK, otherwise you wouldnt mention it, & look for website to tell us about it.
You would get it in Germany, I use to live in Germany 14 years ago, & they had organization which use to help immigrants of non speaking Germans countries, I use to work for them on voluntary basis, they use to get them translators, then they use to help them to learn the langauge.
You seem to hate legal/illegal migrant in UK so much, why not go & get job with those organizations who works with some of these illegal migrant, & find out for yourself why they had to leave their country in the first place than you might just have a little more sympathy towards them.
Just remember when you come here, you are just as equal to all Aisan/African/Chinese & loads other nationality, because you are migrating like them, & would get treated the same. :D
I love Australia.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 6:24 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.