Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
#1
Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
We are looking at suitcases and have a total allowance of 90kg (3x20kg +10kg).
Anyway, what do you think would be best ? Softcase or Holdall ?
Anyway, what do you think would be best ? Softcase or Holdall ?
#3
Just Joined
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: Heathfield
Posts: 8
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
http://www.matalan.co.uk/fcp/product...ist=Dept,brand
These ones are very lightweight and have plenty of room inside altough at first glance it doesn't appear so - I lent my nana's for a trip to Ibiza and will be purchasing one to send over to Oz for when I arrive.
These ones are very lightweight and have plenty of room inside altough at first glance it doesn't appear so - I lent my nana's for a trip to Ibiza and will be purchasing one to send over to Oz for when I arrive.
#4
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
Depends on how much you value the contents, if youve ever seen the way the baggage handlers throw the luggage around. We wouldn't use anything else other than hard cases.
#5
Auntie Fa
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Seattle
Posts: 7,344
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
We've had this discussion once or twice before so have a search.
Hard cases for me, wherever I go. The 4 Samsonites we bought in 2001 for our first trip to Oz earned their pay despite doing what's probably a few hundred thousand miles. When they crack, they've gone, but one's still going strong - the others replaced by today's models.
Hard cases for me, wherever I go. The 4 Samsonites we bought in 2001 for our first trip to Oz earned their pay despite doing what's probably a few hundred thousand miles. When they crack, they've gone, but one's still going strong - the others replaced by today's models.
#6
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Apr 2009
Location: Burns Beach and loving it!
Posts: 830
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
And the opposite for me!
I buy the lightest (strong) nylon bags I can find, which weigh around 0.5kg each rather than 5+ kg for solid suitcases. Never had any damage.
(N.B. Even using light nylon bags, 3 of us had 130kg of luggage on the move across. Hard suitcases would have cost us even more in excess baggage charges.)
I buy the lightest (strong) nylon bags I can find, which weigh around 0.5kg each rather than 5+ kg for solid suitcases. Never had any damage.
(N.B. Even using light nylon bags, 3 of us had 130kg of luggage on the move across. Hard suitcases would have cost us even more in excess baggage charges.)
#8
Auntie Fa
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Seattle
Posts: 7,344
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
And the opposite for me!
I buy the lightest (strong) nylon bags I can find, which weigh around 0.5kg each rather than 5+ kg for solid suitcases. Never had any damage.
(N.B. Even using light nylon bags, 3 of us had 130kg of luggage on the move across. Hard suitcases would have cost us even more in excess baggage charges.)
I buy the lightest (strong) nylon bags I can find, which weigh around 0.5kg each rather than 5+ kg for solid suitcases. Never had any damage.
(N.B. Even using light nylon bags, 3 of us had 130kg of luggage on the move across. Hard suitcases would have cost us even more in excess baggage charges.)
#9
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Apr 2009
Location: Burns Beach and loving it!
Posts: 830
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
LOL, I do have SOME standards.
I got some brilliant lightweight bags in Tanglin Mall though
I got some brilliant lightweight bags in Tanglin Mall though
#10
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
We used a mixture of both. We bought a couple of cheap, large, lightweight suitcases from Tescos. Hubby was a bit unsure about the quality but they survived completely unscathed as did my freebie holdall. I must admit I did pack bedding in the holdall rather than clothes as I wasn't quite so bothered about that if it did split or the zip went.
Alison x
Alison x
#11
Just Joined
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 2
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
Just to muddy the waters. Combo. Hard case for things
needing protection, lightest holdall for clothes etc. Depends on what you are carrying, we'll be using one of each.
needing protection, lightest holdall for clothes etc. Depends on what you are carrying, we'll be using one of each.
#12
Auntie Fa
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Seattle
Posts: 7,344
Re: Suitcases - Soft or Holdall ?
Just make sure it has wheels. Having spent a week last April travelling to the UK, wandering round airports and train stations galore, I'm a huge fan of 4-wheel cases - can push them with a finger.