Reclaim tax on 186 visa
#1
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 127
Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Hi,
Is it possible to claim visa costs at tax return time ?
As a family of 5 it is a considerable cost. Can anyone shed some light on this please ?
Thanks in advance
Ric
Is it possible to claim visa costs at tax return time ?
As a family of 5 it is a considerable cost. Can anyone shed some light on this please ?
Thanks in advance
Ric
#2
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,815
#3
Aussie Finn Mixture!
Joined: May 2005
Location: Leschenault WA (after few locations around WA and Around Europe!)
Posts: 1,151
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Why should Oz tax payers give you a refund for wanting to move to Australia? Not a chance.
#4
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 127
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
I'm actually in Australia and have been for a number of years, paying very high tax however I'm never asked if they would pay the visa, only if it was tax deductible.
#5
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,815
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Its not. No offence meant personally, but why should it be?
#6
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 127
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
I don't think it should be. If it was tax decuctable though I would claim it. I think Teza Mis understood me though. I am paying for the full visa myself and glad to do so but if it can't be tax deductible then that's cool. No harm in looking into these things. Thanks Pollyana � ����
#7
Aussie Finn Mixture!
Joined: May 2005
Location: Leschenault WA (after few locations around WA and Around Europe!)
Posts: 1,151
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
I didn't misunderstand, I was stating the fact that you paid to be processed to get a visa to a country you want to live in, onshore or offshore application is regardless. Why should there be a taxpayer funded break for that? Regardless of your own situation that would mean refunds to nearly 100 000 people a year....
#8
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,815
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
I didn't misunderstand, I was stating the fact that you paid to be processed to get a visa to a country you want to live in, onshore or offshore application is regardless. Why should there be a taxpayer funded break for that? Regardless of your own situation that would mean refunds to nearly 100 000 people a year....
#9
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Except that as far as I know, if an employer pays visa costs then that may be tax deductible to the employer for corporate tax purposes. Would employer then have to pay Fringe Benefits Tax, or treat it as imputed income to the employee? Good questions for a tax accountant.
#10
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 127
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Again guys I agree that it shouldn't be tax deductable but my question isn't should it be, it was simply is it tax deductable.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
#11
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Again guys I agree that it shouldn't be tax deductable but my question isn't should it be, it was simply is it tax deductable.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
A company paying the fees in behalf of an applicant would charge visa fees simply as a necessary business expense in finding a suitable employee, it would be like charging a recruitment agent fee or advertising fee.
As I read it JAJ is actually contemplating whether an employee who has their visa fees paid by the company should incur more tax (FBT). He is not suggesting that your question is a good one to put to an accountant. It isn't.
#12
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 127
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Thank you for that Bermuda shorts, I appreciate that.
No big tax return for me then haha.
No big tax return for me then haha.
#13
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Again guys I agree that it shouldn't be tax deductable but my question isn't should it be, it was simply is it tax deductable.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
#14
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,815
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Again guys I agree that it shouldn't be tax deductable but my question isn't should it be, it was simply is it tax deductable.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
If the answer is no then fine, I'm looking for a factual answer not a moral discussion.
I thought that's what the forum was for, to be given info and without sounding arrogant, I have not asked if you think this should be the case.
The above poster says it would be an interesting question for an accountant to which I agree.
I use BE forums when I am in need of info not to be shot down by users who think I am asking for a personal opinion on a subject that I didn't ask about. If you did not know the answer then don't answer my question.
Discussion is what the forum is for. The FBT angle is an interesting one, I must admit, hadn't thought of it from that side - and that is why discussion is useful. You just have to be prepared to take the rough with the smooth.
#15
Just Joined
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 7
Re: Reclaim tax on 186 visa
Hi there,
Actually, you shoot him down, come on ;-)
Sorry to reply to this old post, but after reading it, I felt the need to respond !
I agree with you, why Au tax payers would pay for one who wants to migrate to Australia ?
But you may agree that Australia is looking for skilled people. This is a need. So, why Au tax payers would not pay for hiring skilled people that will create and make Australia a more competitive place ?
That said. I actually claimed my VISA cost. Three times, so the question may have a little bit of sense. It was temporary VISAs so it may not be the same procedure for a permanent one. But I got back full tax on each claim (around 35% of each VISA cost then). It was claimed as relocation expanse even if the two renew were made in the country -I mean without real relocation cost-.
Cheers
@J
Actually, you shoot him down, come on ;-)
Sorry to reply to this old post, but after reading it, I felt the need to respond !
I agree with you, why Au tax payers would pay for one who wants to migrate to Australia ?
But you may agree that Australia is looking for skilled people. This is a need. So, why Au tax payers would not pay for hiring skilled people that will create and make Australia a more competitive place ?
That said. I actually claimed my VISA cost. Three times, so the question may have a little bit of sense. It was temporary VISAs so it may not be the same procedure for a permanent one. But I got back full tax on each claim (around 35% of each VISA cost then). It was claimed as relocation expanse even if the two renew were made in the country -I mean without real relocation cost-.
Cheers
@J
Last edited by Juanito69; Dec 2nd 2014 at 8:50 am.