British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   Perth a personal view (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/perth-personal-view-325290/)

coxfamuk Sep 11th 2005 3:12 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by Storini
As has been said, many of the people with the very positive attitudes to Oz are posting mainly on the other forum. Hence the balance point between positive and negative threads will appear to shift towards the latter on this forum.

sponge bob would be roasted alive if he posted his post on the other forum.

I think people like their own views reinforced, whichever way they incline...

Can anyone tell me (or pm me) what this other forum is.

DIMO8 Sep 11th 2005 3:34 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by coxfamuk
Can anyone tell me (or pm me) what this other forum is.

Brit Portal .....i think !

CadburysFingers Sep 11th 2005 3:51 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by sponge bob
Well, i know before i start that this will upset people but its the facts has i see them. We came here looking for a better life and found that the grass is not always greener on the other side.
We picked Perth and not Brisbane because we thought the housing would be cheaper and it would not be so humid in the summer .
Well when we first got here everything seemed to be great just what we had hoped for. The weather was great the poeple were nice and there were plenty of jobs advertised. We have been here some time now and our views have changed alot. Tere are lots of jobs , the poeple are nice and the weather can be very nice indeed.ITS NOT ENOUGH from day one we have been told you wlll get used to this and you will get used to that, well thats the way we do it out here etc etc.
What this has really meant is that we are forced to accept lower standards in almost everything from education to food. from work place safety to employment rights, the list seems almost endless.
I know by now there will alot of poeple typing away to rubbish what i am saying but there are a lot of poeple that know what i am saying is true, so please read on and at least be aware of what ( i think ) awaits the hopeful immigrant, if he hasn`t researched has much has he should.
First i have to mention housing , everybody out here seems totaly obsessed with the housing market , prices have been booming for a long time now land prices are high ( this in a country with unlimited land ) and building costs are the same. At first we rented a house very large with a lot of land and all brand new. We thought this was great and began to think it would be wise to build our own new house in Australia. But it soon began to dawn on us that we would have to compomise where we wanted to build because of land prices and while we pondered this we started to take a look at the quality of the house we were renting and the others of friends and those around and nearby.
They are very poorly finished off the work is not what you would accept back in the uk yet they still run into hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Then we come to the education of our children , IT JUST MAKES ME WANT TO CRY why o why did i ever complain about schools back in the UK.I don`t see the point of going into this any further other to say you should really look into it yourself if you think the education of your children is important.
Then there is work lots of jobs about but they are nearly all in the city area which means traveling , the road network is has busy has any major city in the world at peak times, the driving ability of most of your fellow comuters is .......... well you decide when you drive from the airport .
so why do so many people come here and why do so many people stay? ( this is going to upset a lot of people i suppose ). A lot of migrants come to perth from the Uk looking for a better life and for the most part seem to find it. They come from run down northern cities terraced housing and inner city schools , perth gives them a bit more space a newer home good weather and they accept its bad points because of this. They seem to think good food is cheap food, good houses are bigger houses etc etc.

To sum it up I would have to say that in general we have had to accept lower standards in almost everthing , if you lived in a small teerraced house in a big city in the uk then it is paradise , if you live in a detached house in the country (uk ) then it is almost the opposite, on the whole the grass is not greener on the other side . People may say well its not for everyone and this is true , but before you come over think about what you have in the uk , the truth is you may be gambleing it all onthe promise of cheaper houses and sunshine, ( Well you get what you pay for in this life and it gets very clod hear in winter and very wet . )
just think before you leap, and good look which ever way you go. :confused:

A good deal of what you say is true, especially food and education. I tell you, many times I have been shopping at Coles or Action and arrived home only to notice subsequently that 5 or 6 of the items I have bought are past their sell by date, some by months, one the other week by over a year. Something else to be aware of, is that depending on the time of year your child was born, he/she can be over six before they start school. Added to that, at that age they are learning stuff they already know, for example my next door neighbours 6 year old daughter started school recently and was taught colours, this is blue that is yellow etc. She knew her colours a couple of years ago, but because many of the Australian children didnt know their colours the whole class had to do it, the same was true of reading, writing etc etc. Other friends 7 year old daughter is doing stuff at 7 that she did two years ago in England at age 5. Almost any parent you talk to, that is heavily involved in their childs upbringing, will tell you similar stories.

Before we came we had a three week reccie trip, just to check out that Australia was all that we expected it to be, and it was..................and indeed still is. That doesnt mean that everything here is perfect though, however when I compare it to England, it is far and away better, and our lives are better to boot. We had done loads of research before we left England, and knew that Australia, wasnt perfect but we also decided that the disadvantages were far outweighed by the advantages, and I have to say we havent regretted our move at all.

Storini Sep 11th 2005 4:17 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 
The "other board" I referred to is this one: http://s3.invisionfree.com/ABCDiamond/index.php?act=idx , registration required.

It was set up after the last major flame war here claimed several casualties.

Lewis Lapthorn Sep 11th 2005 6:09 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by sponge bob
Well, i know before i start that this will upset people but its the facts has i see them. We came here looking for a better life and found that the grass is not always greener on the other side.
We picked Perth and not Brisbane because we thought the housing would be cheaper and it would not be so humid in the summer .
Well when we first got here everything seemed to be great just what we had hoped for. The weather was great the poeple were nice and there were plenty of jobs advertised. We have been here some time now and our views have changed alot. Tere are lots of jobs , the poeple are nice and the weather can be very nice indeed.ITS NOT ENOUGH from day one we have been told you wlll get used to this and you will get used to that, well thats the way we do it out here etc etc.
What this has really meant is that we are forced to accept lower standards in almost everything from education to food. from work place safety to employment rights, the list seems almost endless.
I know by now there will alot of poeple typing away to rubbish what i am saying but there are a lot of poeple that know what i am saying is true, so please read on and at least be aware of what ( i think ) awaits the hopeful immigrant, if he hasn`t researched has much has he should.
First i have to mention housing , everybody out here seems totaly obsessed with the housing market , prices have been booming for a long time now land prices are high ( this in a country with unlimited land ) and building costs are the same. At first we rented a house very large with a lot of land and all brand new. We thought this was great and began to think it would be wise to build our own new house in Australia. But it soon began to dawn on us that we would have to compomise where we wanted to build because of land prices and while we pondered this we started to take a look at the quality of the house we were renting and the others of friends and those around and nearby.
They are very poorly finished off the work is not what you would accept back in the uk yet they still run into hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Then we come to the education of our children , IT JUST MAKES ME WANT TO CRY why o why did i ever complain about schools back in the UK.I don`t see the point of going into this any further other to say you should really look into it yourself if you think the education of your children is important.
Then there is work lots of jobs about but they are nearly all in the city area which means traveling , the road network is has busy has any major city in the world at peak times, the driving ability of most of your fellow comuters is .......... well you decide when you drive from the airport .
so why do so many people come here and why do so many people stay? ( this is going to upset a lot of people i suppose ). A lot of migrants come to perth from the Uk looking for a better life and for the most part seem to find it. They come from run down northern cities terraced housing and inner city schools , perth gives them a bit more space a newer home good weather and they accept its bad points because of this. They seem to think good food is cheap food, good houses are bigger houses etc etc.

To sum it up I would have to say that in general we have had to accept lower standards in almost everthing , if you lived in a small teerraced house in a big city in the uk then it is paradise , if you live in a detached house in the country (uk ) then it is almost the opposite, on the whole the grass is not greener on the other side . People may say well its not for everyone and this is true , but before you come over think about what you have in the uk , the truth is you may be gambleing it all onthe promise of cheaper houses and sunshine, ( Well you get what you pay for in this life and it gets very clod hear in winter and very wet . )
just think before you leap, and good look which ever way you go. :confused:

If you decide to pick your family up and move to the other side of the world, then yes you're right, of course you should think long and hard, and do your homework. This is why I visited and worked through 6 months of a Perth Autumn/Winter for a trial period. We hope to emigrate there next year, and no, I'm not from the North of England. I live in a rural area in the south, and drive a BMW. However, I know what you're trying to say, all be it a little tactless.

The main points on this thread that I want to respond to is about the weather. How on earth can anybody refer to a Perth winter as wet and cold. We are talking about an Australian city that has more hours of sunshine than any other, and an average high in the middle of winter of 19C. On the occasions the temperature does dip into single figures, most people are tucked up in bed.

Of course Perth has more rain in the winter than summer, but the dams are still frightfully low, and without rain there would not be the lovely greenery and vegetation. On my way to the bus stop every morning in the middle of August, I would pick an orange off a tree for my lunch. What fruit lives and grows through an English winter?

As for the cold, I didn't once need a coat. Can you imagine not owning a warm coat in England for 7 months of the year? :eek: The most my wife and I ever needed was a jumper/cardigan/light jacket. I could show you photos of family on City Beach jumping the waves in July, and having a picnic in shorts and t-shirts at Kings Park in early September.

Another factor about a Perth winter over other Australian cities - they don't move their clocks in Autumn or Spring. So on winter solstice at the end of June, the earliest it ever gets dark is around 5.30pm. Compare that to 21st December in Blighty.

So whatever detriment visitors to this forum wish to post about Perth, please don't mislead viewers by bringing weather into the equation. There are very few cities in the world that come close.

MrsDagboy Sep 11th 2005 9:45 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by CadburysFingers
A good deal of what you say is true, especially food and education. I tell you, many times I have been shopping at Coles or Action and arrived home only to notice subsequently that 5 or 6 of the items I have bought are past their sell by date, some by months, one the other week by over a year. Something else to be aware of, is that depending on the time of year your child was born, he/she can be over six before they start school. Added to that, at that age they are learning stuff they already know, for example my next door neighbours 6 year old daughter started school recently and was taught colours, this is blue that is yellow etc. She knew her colours a couple of years ago, but because many of the Australian children didnt know their colours the whole class had to do it, the same was true of reading, writing etc etc. Other friends 7 year old daughter is doing stuff at 7 that she did two years ago in England at age 5. Almost any parent you talk to, that is heavily involved in their childs upbringing, will tell you similar stories.

The problem is that, firstly, Perth education doesn't necessarily equate to education everywhere in Australia & secondly, you are comparing it to UK because a child has previously started school in the UK. Since they start school what seems to be almost 2 years earlier in the UK, it's almost impossible for them NOT to do over here something that they have already done. But why does that make the education system some how bad or wrong? :confused: If they taught the colours & told them that blue was red & red was green I could understand people jumping up & down & saying that the education system was rubbish, but they are just taught things at a different time & stage - but that doesn't mean it's inferior does it? :confused:

I've never had a child in the UK education system, but I'm very happy with the education standard where our boys go to school in Brisbane, but then I'm not comparing it to the UK, only judging it as I see it. Seems that alot of people in Perth aren't happy with the education, but it's hard to work out whether it's because the standard really is lower or simply that more people compare it with the UK - usually unfavourably.

As for the grocery things, what you described happens very rarely here where I live (although it did happen quite a bit when we were in the UK, strangely enough :scared: ), perhaps it's just a Perth thing? :p :D

My main problem with the OP is their comment in the first couple of lines that "these are the facts". Sorry, but they aren't facts, they are opinions, which of course everyone is entitled to, but don't be surprised when people disgree.


PS. BTW, love your signature - no more soup for you ....NEXT!!!! :D

Vash the Stampede Sep 11th 2005 10:12 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by MrsDagboy
Hey Vash, how's your head mate? :D :D

LOL... How many times must I remind myself to take your advice before I post...!? :rolleyes:

:D

aussie73 Sep 11th 2005 10:14 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by CadburysFingers
A good deal of what you say is true, especially food and education. I tell you, many times I have been shopping at Coles or Action and arrived home only to notice subsequently that 5 or 6 of the items I have bought are past their sell by date, some by months, one the other week by over a year. Something else to be aware of, is that depending on the time of year your child was born, he/she can be over six before they start school. Added to that, at that age they are learning stuff they already know, for example my next door neighbours 6 year old daughter started school recently and was taught colours, this is blue that is yellow etc. She knew her colours a couple of years ago, but because many of the Australian children didnt know their colours the whole class had to do it,

If the kids are being taught colours in year 10 when they are 15 years old then its time to panic. :D

Amazulu Sep 11th 2005 10:32 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by aussie73
If the kids are being taught colours in year 10 when they are 15 years old then its time to panic. :D

:eek: My 2.5 yo son knows some of his colours already!.

Vash the Stampede Sep 11th 2005 10:57 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by MrsDagboy
The problem is that firstly Perth education doesnt necessarily equate to education everywhere in Australia & secondly, you are comparing it to UK because a child has previously started school in the UK. Since they start school what seems to be almost 2 years earlier in the UK, its almost impossible for them NOT to do over here something that they have already done. But why does that make the education system some how bad or wrong? :confused: If they taught the colours & told them that blue was red & red was green I could understand people jumping up & down & saying that the education system was rubbish, but they are just taught things at a different time & stage - but that doesnt mean its inferior does it? :confused:

I've never had a child in the UK education system, but Im very happy with the education standard where our boys go to school in Brisbane, but then Im not comparing it to the UK, only judging it as I see it. Seems that alot of people in Perth arent happy with the education, but its hard to work out whether its because the standard really is lower or simply that more people compare it with the UK - usually unfavourably.

Exactly. Well said. :)

The other thing to remember is that experience of one single school in Perth is not necessarily representative of the school system throughout the whole of Western Australia.

If people don't think the state schools are good enough, they are more than welcome to try the private schools - which IMHO are easily posh enough to satisfy the inherent British desire for snobbery, class distinction, and generally making oneself feel better at the expense of others. :rolleyes:

For example...


Guildford Grammar (est. 1896.)

St Bridgid's (est. 1929.)

St Mary's (est. 1921.)

Scotch College (est. 1897.)

Santa Maria (est. 1938.)

Christ Church Grammar (est. 1910.)

Aquinas College (est. 1894.)


To name only a handful.

jensteve Sep 11th 2005 11:42 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 
Hi all
I apologise now for any slip ups with my English language skills, I forever seem to put my foot in it.

I agree somewhat with what sponge bob has said, although he was rather tactless at the north/south divide coment. I have said many times to friends here it all depends on what you had in the UK as to what and how you find Perth and Australia.
I have lived on council estates and never would have been classed as well off in the UK so I find living in Perth a breath of fresh air. I can understand how an afluent person living in the UK whether it be North or South would have a bit of a culture shock coming over here.
As for schooling I can understand where he is coming from, I think he should ahve asked the reasons behind the seemingly falling behind the UK children seem to be over here.
I asked and was told they like to have a good base on maths and English before they are allowed to do other things, the fact that they ripped apart my sons English skills and said they would have never let a child come out of primary school lacking some of the basic skills required for high school cheered me up somewhat. What they explained made simple sense and I am now happy with my sons schooling. This may be why some people find their children seem held back, its not because they can't be bothered teaching other things which they may have done in the UK, its because from the schools point of view they are not upto scratch with their English language skills, and they won't start them doing other enjoyable subjects until they have a good firm grounding to build upon.

Perth is a strange place and I guess it all depends on the person if they fit in, or find it an enjoyable place to live, but yes it does depend on your previous life in the UK as to exactly how you fit in over here, if you came with nothing here would be paradise, if you came having done everything possible, this place maybe rather dull and its housing low quality.

Hope I didn't offend

jenny

Vash the Stampede Sep 11th 2005 11:44 am

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by jensteve
Hi all

I apologise now for any slip ups with my English language skills, I forever seem to put my foot in it.

I agree somewhat with what sponge bob has said, although he was rather tactless at the north/south divide coment. I have said many times to friends here it all depends on what you had in the UK as to what and how you find Perth and Australia.

I have lived on council estates and never would have been classed as well off in the UK so I find living in Perth a breath of fresh air. I can understand how an afluent person living in the UK whether it be North or South would have a bit of a culture shock coming over here.
As for schooling I can understand where he is coming from, I think he should ahve asked the reasons behind the seemingly falling behind the UK children seem to be over here.

I asked and was told they like to have a good base on maths and English before they are allowed to do other things, the fact that they ripped apart my sons English skills and said they would have never let a child come out of primary school lacking some of the basic skills required for high school cheered me up somewhat. What they explained made simple sense and I am now happy with my sons schooling. This may be why some people find their children seem held back, its not because they can't be bothered teaching other things which they may have done in the UK, its because from the schools point of view they are not upto scratch with their English language skills, and they won't start them doing other enjoyable subjects until they have a good firm grounding to build upon.

Perth is a strange place and I guess it all depends on the person if they fit in, or find it an enjoyable place to live, but yes it does depend on your previous life in the UK as to exactly how you fit in over here, if you came with nothing here would be paradise, if you came having done everything possible, this place maybe rather dull and its housing low quality.

Hope I didn't offend

jenny

Excellent post; very well said. :)

aussie73 Sep 11th 2005 12:03 pm

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by CadburysFingers
A good deal of what you say is true, especially food and education. I tell you, many times I have been shopping at Coles or Action and arrived home only to notice subsequently that 5 or 6 of the items I have bought are past their sell by date, some by months, one the other week by over a year.

Keep the receipts from shopping and if any items are past the used by date take them back to the supermarket and they will refund or exchange it.

Scorpio1 Sep 11th 2005 12:18 pm

Re: Perth a personal view
 
I agree with Sponge Bob Squarepants in many respects. There is definitely a lowering of many standards to be had when living in Perth. On the plus side you've got the sunshine, bigger houses & beaches but you've got to weigh all this up against the bad things. And even the good things have their downside - the weather gets too hot, damn flies & wind, house build quality not great & you'll hear all the dogs (and hoons) around for miles, beaches - the novelty soon wears off & it's usualy too windy to sunbathe (or 'sunbake' as they hilariously call it) :scared: .

Where Sponge Bob did go wrong was the 'northerner' bit. It's not just northerners from council estates who would really like Perth - it's anyone who's common from anywhere in the UK. It's a fact - your standards are lower therefore you see only the good things in Perth & that's fair enough. Even the awful Aussie accent may seem bearable if you've got an awful one yourself ;) !

webgum Sep 11th 2005 12:29 pm

Re: Perth a personal view
 

Originally Posted by Scorpio1

Where Sponge Bob did go wrong was the 'northerner' bit. It's not just northerners from council estates who would really like Perth - it's anyone who's common from anywhere in the UK. It's a fact - your standards are lower therefore you see only the good things in Perth & that's fair enough. Even the awful Aussie accent may seem bearable if you've got an awful one yourself ;) !

oh dear someone else looking to start a fight.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 5:10 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.