British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/melbourne-adelaide-527188/)

The Crow Apr 8th 2008 9:58 am

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by mr mover (Post 6179523)
Its simple if you, Work to live ,or Live for work go to Melbourne, if you want a life then Adelaide has a lot more to offer...........mm;)

That's not always true - my OH works far less hours here, we have beautiful surroundings with an abundance of facilities, events, sporting options etc close by and 45 mins from the city with an artrs, events, sports and festivals programme to die for :)

pompeyblonde Apr 8th 2008 2:29 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 
mmm...... and depends on the kind of life you are after!

Potato_potato Apr 8th 2008 3:02 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 
I can understand the Sydney V Melbourne rivalry as both these cities have just as much going for them as each other, however I find it amazing that some Adelaide people actually believe Adelaide with a population of only 1 million can compare to a world class city such as Melb with 4 million people.

Adelaide is nothing more than a very large regional town, with a couple of nice beaches. You never hear of anyone in AUS, for good reason, upping sticks and relocating to Adelaide of all places.

Melbourne, however is a world class city with excellent work prospects, culture, arts, sport etc. Melb is full of people from Adelaide who have moved looking for better opportunities and a real city vibe.

Adelaide and Melbourne should never be used in the same sentence. They're chalk and cheese. They may have the same weather and both idolise AFL but that's about where the comparisons end.

I also think it's debatable whether Adelaide has a better lifestyle. The lifestyle may be quiter (due to the smaller population and being a regional town) however that doesn't necessarily make it better as such.

Once again, bring on the SYDNEY V MELB debates. It's like stepping out of a Ferrari in to another Ferrari. However, comparing Melb to Adelaide is like stepping out of a Ferrari in to a Toyota Camry with the grandpas hat on the rear shelf.

Buzzy--Bee Apr 8th 2008 3:08 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Potato_potato (Post 6180883)
Once again, bring on the SYDNEY V MELB debates. It's like stepping out of a Ferrari in to another Ferrari. However, comparing Melb to Adelaide is like stepping out of a Ferrari in to a Toyota Camry with the grandpas hat on the rear shelf.

Actually Melbourne is more like a Bentley than a Ferrari. Classy, comfortable, refined. Sydney as a Ferrari is right. Flashy, expensive, show-off.

:D

Buzzy

Potato_potato Apr 8th 2008 3:17 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Buzzy--Bee (Post 6180896)
Actually Melbourne is more like a Bentley than a Ferrari. Classy, comfortable, refined. Sydney as a Ferrari is right. Flashy, expensive, show-off.

:D

Buzzy

Just don't throw me in a Camry :thumbup: The repayments may be less but it's cheap, boring, slow and predictable - much like Adelaide.

pompeyblonde Apr 8th 2008 4:33 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 
Surely Adelaide is an old Holden ute with a cattle dog barking in the back???:rofl:

Wendy Apr 8th 2008 4:41 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Potato_potato (Post 6180883)
You never hear of anyone in AUS, for good reason, upping sticks and relocating to Adelaide of all places.

Shouldn't you be busy looking for a QLD versus Perth thread to stir up instead? :sneaky::p:D

I know lots of people that have relocated from other parts of Australia to SA. My driving instructor has lived in every city and says that Adelaide is the best city in Australia. He's a true blue born and bred Queenslander (he's actually originally from the Gold Coast ;)) - it's all about personal choice at the end of the day.

I think it says a lot for BOTH places that the people who actually live in them are so passionate about the place they choose live in that they are arguing about which is better.

Geelong Gent Apr 8th 2008 5:00 pm

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Wendy (Post 6181062)
Shouldn't you be busy looking for a QLD versus Perth thread to stir up instead? :sneaky::p:D

I know lots of people that have relocated from other parts of Australia to SA. My driving instructor has lived in every city and says that Adelaide is the best city in Australia. He's a true blue born and bred Queenslander (he's actually originally from the Gold Coast ;)) - it's all about personal choice at the end of the day.

I think it says a lot for BOTH places that the people who actually live in them are so passionate about the place they choose live in that they are arguing about which is better.

Melbourne and Adelaide tend to attract similar minded people:thumbsup:

Quite happy too promote both .... at the end, its the individuals choice and good luck what ever they choose.

Kristo Apr 9th 2008 7:19 am

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Potato_potato (Post 6180883)
I can understand the Sydney V Melbourne rivalry as both these cities have just as much going for them as each other, however I find it amazing that some Adelaide people actually believe Adelaide with a population of only 1 million can compare to a world class city such as Melb with 4 million people.

Adelaide is nothing more than a very large regional town, with a couple of nice beaches. You never hear of anyone in AUS, for good reason, upping sticks and relocating to Adelaide of all places.

Melbourne, however is a world class city with excellent work prospects, culture, arts, sport etc. Melb is full of people from Adelaide who have moved looking for better opportunities and a real city vibe.

Adelaide and Melbourne should never be used in the same sentence. They're chalk and cheese. They may have the same weather and both idolise AFL but that's about where the comparisons end.

I also think it's debatable whether Adelaide has a better lifestyle. The lifestyle may be quiter (due to the smaller population and being a regional town) however that doesn't necessarily make it better as such.

Once again, bring on the SYDNEY V MELB debates. It's like stepping out of a Ferrari in to another Ferrari. However, comparing Melb to Adelaide is like stepping out of a Ferrari in to a Toyota Camry with the grandpas hat on the rear shelf.


I am still waiting with bated breath for your explanation as to exactly why Melbourne is so much more cultured than Adelaide.

I ask this in no way to disrespect Melbourne's achievements, but you choose to criticise Adelaide, without quailifying your statements regarding culture. Please Potato_Potato, in exactly what ways is Melbourne *more* cultured than Adelaide?

mr mover Apr 9th 2008 8:33 am

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 
[QUOTE=Potato_potato;6180883]I can understand the Sydney V Melbourne rivalry as both these cities have just as much going for them as each other, however I find it amazing that some Adelaide people actually believe Adelaide with a population of only 1 million can compare to a world class city such as Melb with 4 million people.

Adelaide is nothing more than a very large regional town, with a couple of nice beaches. You never hear of anyone in AUS, for good reason, upping sticks and relocating to Adelaide of all places.

What do you think keeps me in a job?..............mm;)

stuckinblighty Apr 9th 2008 8:45 am

Re: MELBOURNE OR ADELAIDE
 

Originally Posted by Potato_potato (Post 6180883)
I can understand the Sydney V Melbourne rivalry as both these cities have just as much going for them as each other, however I find it amazing that some Adelaide people actually believe Adelaide with a population of only 1 million can compare to a world class city such as Melb with 4 million people.

Adelaide is nothing more than a very large regional town, with a couple of nice beaches. You never hear of anyone in AUS, for good reason, upping sticks and relocating to Adelaide of all places.

Melbourne, however is a world class city with excellent work prospects, culture, arts, sport etc. Melb is full of people from Adelaide who have moved looking for better opportunities and a real city vibe.

Adelaide and Melbourne should never be used in the same sentence. They're chalk and cheese. They may have the same weather and both idolise AFL but that's about where the comparisons end.

I also think it's debatable whether Adelaide has a better lifestyle. The lifestyle may be quiter (due to the smaller population and being a regional town) however that doesn't necessarily make it better as such.

Once again, bring on the SYDNEY V MELB debates. It's like stepping out of a Ferrari in to another Ferrari. However, comparing Melb to Adelaide is like stepping out of a Ferrari in to a Toyota Camry with the grandpas hat on the rear shelf.

You're still sticking with Adelaide then ????


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 11:35 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.