British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   USA (https://britishexpats.com/forum/usa-57/)
-   -   Skool Daze (https://britishexpats.com/forum/usa-57/skool-daze-238143/)

rincewind Jun 23rd 2004 10:30 pm

Skool Daze
 
Skool Daze, a great Spectrum computer game when I was a kid. Anyway, this has nothing to do with that :D

My wife has been going around the local schools to register her eldest for kindergarten. For those that have read my posts before, you’ll know I’m an atheist, but I couldn’t help wanting to visit the local religious schools just to see how extreme religious education is here.

One school we went to was like walking onto the set of Deliverance minus the banjos.

Anyways, they gave my wife a form to sign if the child was going to attend. We weren’t going to send them here anyway, but if we had of thought about it, the form we were given would have put us off. The title alone says it all. I have removed the name of the school to prevent the Inquisition visiting us with the “comfy chair.� Read on.

Corporal Correction Release Form


Dear Parent,

------ ------ ------ Academy is honored that you have asked our staff to assist you in training your child for Christian leadership. Our total program is designed to develop the spiritual and academic qualities that characterize your child. We appreciate your confidence in our program. To carry out your wishes for total character development, we believe it is necessary to follow Spiritual admonation to correct a child when his behavior is in violation of proper reasonable rules and procedures. When warranted, corporal correction will be exercised under the following guidelines.

1) The offence will be clearly discussed with your child.

2) A staff member will discuss spiritual applications and will pray with your child.

3) A reasonable number of firm strokes, not to exceed five, will be administered by a staff member of the same sex as your child, using a simple, flat paddle.

4) A staff witness of the same sex as your child will be present.

5) Your child will not be physically restrained. (If he or she refuses to submit to paddling, you will be asked to come discuss the matter, and if it is believes to be in the best interest of the school, the child will be withdrawn from the church-school.)

6) After administering of the strokes, a staff member will pray with your child, assuring him of her of their love.

7) A written report will be made of the date, offence, number of strokes, and name of correcting staff member and witness. A copy of the report will be sent home to you.
This is how it appears, word for word. Any typos you see are those on the original form. My wife both looked at each other after reading this and meeting the Addams Family and said, “Screw that!�

suzieque Jun 23rd 2004 10:45 pm

OMG bit over the top isn't it!!!!!
Glad you opted out, I am not an atheist but no way would I send my daughter there, beating her then praying to show you love her..............:scared: !!!!!
Sue

BritGuyTN Jun 23rd 2004 11:16 pm

OMG

'a staff member will pray with your child, assuring him of her of their love' :scared:

no way jose

i'm not a million miles away from you so i'll be checking those types of forms when the time comes

'If he or she refuses to submit to paddling' - i mean why would you?

Lion in Winter Jun 23rd 2004 11:35 pm

And to think that we are allegedly in the 21st century.................

antjen Jun 24th 2004 12:02 am

ouch
 
the place sounds like brainwashing!! - sounds like they like there 'paddling' too much!!

Ant

rincewind Jun 24th 2004 12:26 am

I pulled the other forms out of the trash and read them for a giggle (the meeting alone was off putting so why read the crap).

Here is a quote from the application form:


"I appreciate the standards of the school and do not tolerate profanity, obscenity in word or action, dishonor to the Godhead and the Word of God, or disrespect to the personnel of the school."
My belief on religion in schools is that it shouldn't be there. Period. If your family is a religious one, then leave it to the family to teach it. But, if you don't mind some paedophile preacher paddling your kid in the name of god, then by all means, destroy any chance they have of a freethinking life by sending them to schools like this.

As a parent, I find this stuff horrible. I'm glad my daughter is safe and sound in the UK.


Glad you opted out, I am not an atheist but no way would I send my daughter there, beating
I'm glad there still some religious people out there that see this as unacceptable. Most, if not all of them, are expats :D

Ash UK/US Jun 24th 2004 3:18 am


3) A reasonable number of firm strokes, not to exceed five, will be administered by a staff member of the same sex as your child, using a simple, flat paddle.
Like hell :eek:
There is no way on earth would I give my permission for someone to do this to my child. I am not against physical punishment but I believe that is the parents place... and it should be a quick slap on the behind with a HAND.

Ash :)

sanj2010 Jun 24th 2004 10:06 am

OMG

Skool Daze, I remember that game!!

I feel so old.

FlyergirlUK Jun 24th 2004 1:18 pm


Originally posted by sanj2010
OMG

Skool Daze, I remember that game!!

I feel so old.
LOL Me too!! I loved it!!! How sad! :D

yorkshirelass Jun 24th 2004 2:04 pm

And these schools actually have pupils there?

rincewind Jun 24th 2004 4:10 pm

1 Attachment(s)

Originally posted by FlyergirlUK
LOL Me too!! I loved it!!! How sad! :D
:D :D

Duncs Jun 24th 2004 4:18 pm

If thats how schools behave it explains a lot about local culture round here. Do they have special uniforms made from only one kind of cloth to keep with Leviticus 19:19.

God its barbaric. In europe you would be breaching the European Convention on Human Rights with that behaviour. The USA supposedly values individual freedoms but has this in the schools? The longer I am living here, the more the word theocracy seems appropriate.

TexasPenguin Jun 24th 2004 4:26 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 
Ermmm....
Isn't that document just an over the top American style too many words etc. waiver for us as parents to allow a "slap 'side the ear" when the kid skips school, runs in the corridor, makes innapropriate comments etc. etc. etc.

Anything wrong with that?

Got exactly the same treatment when I was at school - before the UK got all 'enlightened' and preferred to let kids 'express' themselves by disrupting class for everyone else in the UK.

Sorry guys, can't see the problem - 'barbaric', I think not!!!

(And yes, I DO have kids in school in Texas!).

Andy.

kellwie Jun 24th 2004 4:33 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 
Please, everyone keep in mind that these are private, religious schools we are talking about, not state/public schools!

Ray Jun 24th 2004 4:49 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by AndySmithers
Ermmm....
Isn't that document just an over the top American style too many words etc. waiver for us as parents to allow a "slap 'side the ear" when the kid skips school, runs in the corridor, makes innapropriate comments etc. etc. etc.
Anything wrong with that?
Got exactly the same treatment when I was at school - before the UK got all 'enlightened' and preferred to let kids 'express' themselves by disrupting class for everyone else in the UK.
Sorry guys, can't see the problem - 'barbaric', I think not!!!
(And yes, I DO have kids in school in Texas!).
Andy.
Have to go along with you their Andy...take out the religious crap and it sounds just like my old school...Got caned/slippered fairly regularly and my mum supported the school no end ...As an oldie it just seems we had more respect for everything and everybody
perhaps instilled by that punishment..

Duncs Jun 24th 2004 4:50 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by AndySmithers
Ermmm....
Isn't that document just an over the top American style too many words etc. waiver for us as parents to allow a "slap 'side the ear" when the kid skips school, runs in the corridor, makes innapropriate comments etc. etc. etc.

Anything wrong with that?

Got exactly the same treatment when I was at school - before the UK got all 'enlightened' and preferred to let kids 'express' themselves by disrupting class for everyone else in the UK.

Sorry guys, can't see the problem - 'barbaric', I think not!!!

(And yes, I DO have kids in school in Texas!).

Andy.
Oh yes your so right. as a child I never felt so loved as when I was being beaten.

No its not a slap side the ear its what it says, a paddling. Every school district in Mississippi with the exception of Oxford allows the beating of children public and private. Its a disgrace. Every problem solved with violence from school behaviour to popular culture and we wonder why 11,000 people a year get shot to death! I am no pacifist but what children dont need is a paddling maybe some of that misbehaviour is actually a cry for help from a distressed child and a bit of love and understanding is needed. But hey a slap up the ear is so much easier than doing some work trying to understand whats wrong isnt it?

yorkshirelass Jun 24th 2004 4:56 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by kellwie
Please, everyone keep in mind that these are private, religious schools we are talking about, not state/public schools!
Actually, there are some states that do allow corporal punishment in their schools, but they leave it up to the inidvidual school district to decide whether it will be enforced. There is a listing of each state at this link:

http://www.familyeducation.com/artic...1-3980,00.html

I looked into this when one of the local school districts in the Tampa Bay area near where I live agreed to bring paddling back to its school.

jjmb Jun 24th 2004 4:56 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by AndySmithers
Ermmm....
Isn't that document just an over the top American style too many words etc. waiver for us as parents to allow a "slap 'side the ear" when the kid skips school, runs in the corridor, makes innapropriate comments etc. etc. etc.

Anything wrong with that?

Got exactly the same treatment when I was at school - before the UK got all 'enlightened' and preferred to let kids 'express' themselves by disrupting class for everyone else in the UK.

Sorry guys, can't see the problem - 'barbaric', I think not!!!

(And yes, I DO have kids in school in Texas!).

Andy.
Remember as the writer after you said this is for private and religious school not public schools. Only last year in Austin there was a case of child endangerment when a boy was taken to hospital by his parents to Hospital after a whipping by his church teachers. 2 brothers, teachers at the school and in their early 20's, believed in taking in turns 'whipping" the badness out of the boy with sticks. He was so badly injured that he was in hospital for several days. Despite this, parents of other pupils of the school, fully supported the brothers. The brothers were jailed but the school is still open.

Yosser Jun 24th 2004 4:57 pm


Originally posted by rincewind
:D :D
one of the best games ever.:D

Me and my best mate would have endless fits of laughter, when you could actually type in a different name so of course "Mr wacker, became Mr wanker".

TexasPenguin Jun 24th 2004 5:16 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by Duncs
Oh yes your so right. as a child I never felt so loved as when I was being beaten.
What's that got to do with it?
If some other kid messes around in my child's class, disrupting the lesson (or worse), then what has 'loved' got to do with it?
Oh yes, much more important the the misbehaver 'learns' that bad behaviour=kind words and special attention rather than punishment!


No its not a slap side the ear its what it says, a paddling. Every school district in Mississippi with the exception of Oxford allows the beating of children public and private. Its a disgrace. Every problem solved with violence from school behaviour to popular culture and we wonder why 11,000 people a year get shot to death! I am no pacifist but what children dont need is a paddling maybe some of that misbehaviour is actually a cry for help from a distressed child and a bit of love and understanding is needed. But hey a slap up the ear is so much easier than doing some work trying to understand whats wrong isnt it?
Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!
Listen, I lived in a good middle class area of the UK (Dorset). Yet every damn night we were victimized by these little 'distressed children' that no-one, NO-ONE had ever instilled any discipline, respect for society etc. in!
Round here you do that kind of thing - you go to jail. Crime > Punishment, real simple really and it's instilled into kids from day 1 in kindergaten.
I say again, I have grown up to be a non-violent pretty non-confrontational kind of guy, pay my taxes, respect authority etc. At school I did plenty wrong and had the crap beaten out of me by the head. That cane hurt, really hurt! And, I don't personally give a crap if the head got some kind of sexual gratification for using the cane - that's his funeral, not mine!

Don't get me wrong, as a parent I think I've physically smacked each of my two kids once only in their entire lives. The tongue is generally MUCH worse than the hand if you apply it for the right reasons.

And, my kids ARE in a private church school, corporal punishment IS allowed, as is physical contact with the teachers (first thing I saw at the school was a male teacher put his arm around a 14 year old girl upset about some failed work assignment - I suddenly realized how far from common sense we had strayed in the UK!).

Andy.

TexasPenguin Jun 24th 2004 5:20 pm

Re: Skool Daze
 

Originally posted by jjmb
Remember as the writer after you said this is for private and religious school not public schools. Only last year in Austin there was a case of child endangerment when a boy was taken to hospital by his parents to Hospital after a whipping by his church teachers. 2 brothers, teachers at the school and in their early 20's, believed in taking in turns 'whipping" the badness out of the boy with sticks. He was so badly injured that he was in hospital for several days. Despite this, parents of other pupils of the school, fully supported the brothers. The brothers were jailed but the school is still open.
Sorry, don't see the distinction between private and state schools that's being painted here.

Don't understand the point of your post either. 2 teachers at a school broke the law and were jailed. Yes, poor kid to be subjected to that (and I'd be the first to throw away the keys for the 2 brothers) but how does criminal action of this type in a school have relevance to the general corporal punishment in schools argument?

jjmb Jun 24th 2004 6:29 pm

As far as I know corporal punishment isn't practised in public schools in Texas. As to the point of the 2 brothers, yes, they were rightly jailed but they would have got away with it if the parents hadn't of taken the child to hospital and from all accounts its was a regular feature of the school. Also, all the other parents supported the brothers because it was done in '"God's name".

TexasPenguin Jun 24th 2004 7:25 pm

Yes,
I'll grant you that religious extremism, rather like any kind of extremism, has no real place in the civilised world.
And, I'll also grant you that a lot of un-civilised behaviour hides behind a "God's name" shield.

But I think that point got slightly off-topic here.

The fact is that most good private schools in the South are church schools. Some are waayyy over the top in their religious zeal, others not so.

But, correct me if I'm wrong, I don't think there's any connection per se, between religion and corporal punishment in schools.

My point is simply that this "we musn't smack our kids" and "corporal punishment is barbarism" nonsense swallowed by the UK in the name of following the EU is plain wrong - wrong for the kids, for the parents and, most importantly, for the country.

Andy.

rincewind Jun 24th 2004 10:35 pm

Personally, the only person I believe who has a right to smack my daughter is myself or her mother.

I remember being at school in England and the fear that they would call my parents if I did anything wrong was enough to keep me inline. My mother was heavy handed, but only when necessary. I soon learnt that lesson.

I have met so many people that complain about how bad their own kids are and say “hopefully the school will sort them out.� Why? Can’t do it yourself?

Removing corporal punishment from schools is not the reason for today’s youth. It’s the parents. We’re all so quick to blame other reasons for our child’s behavior, but what it boils down to is lack of interest at home. We’re too quick to shove them in front of a TV or games machine to keep them quiet instead of being a family.

Just my opinion.

Duncs Jun 24th 2004 11:32 pm


Originally posted by rincewind
Personally, the only person I believe who has a right to smack my daughter is myself or her mother.

I remember being at school in England and the fear that they would call my parents if I did anything wrong was enough to keep me inline. My mother was heavy handed, but only when necessary. I soon learnt that lesson.

I have met so many people that complain about how bad their own kids are and say “hopefully the school will sort them out.� Why? Can’t do it yourself?

Removing corporal punishment from schools is not the reason for today’s youth. It’s the parents. We’re all so quick to blame other reasons for our child’s behavior, but what it boils down to is lack of interest at home. We’re too quick to shove them in front of a TV or games machine to keep them quiet instead of being a family.

Just my opinion.
Have to agree with you on this one. Personally i think sending children to a church based school counts as abuse anyway. The last thing any kid needs is a good brainwashing.

I misbehaved a lot at school myself and got caned on a regular basis for it. Maybe however if someone had bothered to take the time to find out why i behaved like that it wouldnt have taken an abortive suicide attempt and a psychotherapist to realise i was somewhat upset about being sexually abused by my neighbour. But hey all those beatings made me the man i am today i suppose.

Sometimes its a neccessary form of discipline but sometimes the effort needs to be made to find out whats wrong first?

TexasPenguin Jun 25th 2004 12:59 am


Originally posted by rincewind
Personally, the only person I believe who has a right to smack my daughter is myself or her mother.
So, where does that thought end then? If your daughter breaks the law, are you the only one allowed to deal with that? What's the difference between that and breaking the discipline code at school?

Agreed absolutely that the problem with kids today (some kids today, in fact a tiny minority of kids today) is lack of parental control. If my kids misbehaved badly enough at school to warrant corporal punishment then the school punishment would fad into insignificance compared to what they would get when they got home!
But the fact is that my kids go to school where there are other children whose parents don't have the same values.

And Duncs. - not sure if you have any children but, I was very happy for my kids to go to a church school BECAUSE I am an atheist - I considered MY lack of belief to be as much brainwashing to them as a christian education. Have you thought of that? Are you SO sure that YOUR beliefs are the right ones to follow that you have no room for other beliefs? Now THAT smacks of religious extremism in itself!

Andy.

Ash UK/US Jun 25th 2004 1:59 am


Originally posted by rincewind
Personally, the only person I believe who has a right to smack my daughter is myself or her mother.

I remember being at school in England and the fear that they would call my parents if I did anything wrong was enough to keep me inline. My mother was heavy handed, but only when necessary. I soon learnt that lesson.

I have met so many people that complain about how bad their own kids are and say “hopefully the school will sort them out.� Why? Can’t do it yourself?

Removing corporal punishment from schools is not the reason for today’s youth. It’s the parents. We’re all so quick to blame other reasons for our child’s behavior, but what it boils down to is lack of interest at home. We’re too quick to shove them in front of a TV or games machine to keep them quiet instead of being a family.

Just my opinion.
I couldn't agree more... expecting schools to sort your kids out is just plain lazy.

ash :)

rincewind Jun 25th 2004 2:31 pm


So, where does that thought end then? If your daughter breaks the law, are you the only one allowed to deal with that? What's the difference between that and breaking the discipline code at school?
Misbehaving at school and committing criminal law are sort of different don't you think?

Talking in class is not the same as robbing someone’s home.


I was very happy for my kids to go to a church school BECAUSE I am an atheist
I would struggle with that. Being an atheist myself and seeing the damage religion can do, I would not want my daughter to have anything to do with it. She is in a non-religious school in England. She learns about religions from her mother and I in a non-biased format. Although my beliefs are somewhat extreme, I can teach her about the many religions of the world without that bias. She knows that daddy doesn't believe along with many other people, but knows about the various religions people choose to follow.

As an atheist, how can I decide what religious school is best for my child? How can I decide which version to have installed in her? How do I know that version is correct? I can't and won't do it. I would rather she was raised with that open mindedness to allow her to investigate all the possibilities herself and not be a recovering catholic like her father.

But then we are all different and there is no rule book for raising kids. Lucky too, as most parents would be getting paddlings themselves ;)


All times are GMT. The time now is 7:09 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.