British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   USA (https://britishexpats.com/forum/usa-57/)
-   -   Can I get a court order to see my child? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/usa-57/can-i-get-court-order-see-my-child-794238/)

Ja5on Apr 17th 2013 12:10 am

Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
I moved to the USA 3 years ago on a K1. I left my daughter with my ex as there was no way in the world she was going to let me take her away from her. I've been back to the UK every 8-10 months since I left and have been able to chat to my daughter on skype or by phone a few times each month.

The last time I visited a week ago, my wife and new daughter came with me (I normally go alone). I think my ex got upset at the fact my daughter enjoyed spending with us, after the 3rd day of seeing her my ex decided that my daughter gets too upset when I leave and that it would be best if I don't see her for the rest of the trip. I figured that this was unreasonable but didn't want to get into a fight with her while I was trying to enjoy my time in the UK and see family.

When I got back to the US she sent me an email saying that she wasn't planning on letting me see my daughter anymore. I made the threat of stopping sending child support (She has no court order so I am not obliged to send it, although I have been doing as it seems like the right thing to do). I'm not sure on weather or not I will follow through with this threat or not.

I was wondering if anyone else had been in a situation like this one? or if anyone has any good advice on what to do?

Also just to mention, my daughter is only 6 years old so she doesn't really get to make any of her own decisions just yet.

sir_eccles Apr 17th 2013 12:26 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
I would get some solid legal advice from a family lawyer familiar with international issues.

Do note that failure to support dependents (i.e. not paying child support) may be taken into consideration during application for citizenship and can be grounds for denial (moral character).

markwm Apr 17th 2013 12:27 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10663270)
I moved to the USA 3 years ago on a K1. I left my daughter with my ex as there was no way in the world she was going to let me take her away from her. I've been back to the UK every 8-10 months since I left and have been able to chat to my daughter on skype or by phone a few times each month.

The last time I visited a week ago, my wife and new daughter came with me (I normally go alone). I think my ex got upset at the fact my daughter enjoyed spending with us, after the 3rd day of seeing her my ex decided that my daughter gets too upset when I leave and that it would be best if I don't see her for the rest of the trip. I figured that this was unreasonable but didn't want to get into a fight with her while I was trying to enjoy my time in the UK and see family.

When I got back to the US she sent me an email saying that she wasn't planning on letting me see my daughter anymore. I made the threat of stopping sending child support (She has no court order so I am not obliged to send it, although I have been doing as it seems like the right thing to do). I'm not sure on weather or not I will follow through with this threat or not.

I was wondering if anyone else had been in a situation like this one? or if anyone has any good advice on what to do?

Also just to mention, my daughter is only 6 years old so she doesn't really get to make any of her own decisions just yet.

Child support and visitation have nothing to do with each other. Even if you never see your child again (which I sincerely hope does not happen to you) you would still be legally obligated to pay child support should a court decide you should. As an aside, keep a very careful note of all the support you do send; dates, amounts, etc., as well as a note of all visits and conversations with your ex. You may need this.

Let her calm down a bit and, if she's even slightly reasonable she'll come round. If not, you'll need to go to court but that can be costly and time consuming with no guarantee of a result in your favor.

I wish you luck.

Bob Apr 17th 2013 3:30 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10663270)

When I got back to the US she sent me an email saying that she wasn't planning on letting me see my daughter anymore. I made the threat of stopping sending child support (She has no court order so I am not obliged to send it, although I have been doing as it seems like the right thing to do). I'm not sure on weather or not I will follow through with this threat or not.

Send her the money direct?

Edit: just read the last bit, at 6, she's too young, never mind. Good luck!

Ja5on Apr 17th 2013 9:41 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Most of the conversations between me and my ex have either been online or through text messages, so its easy to keep track of all that. I send money through xe every month, I assume I can get the full history of all my transactions if I ever need to.

I go through this pretty much every time I visit. I'm just getting tired of it. I'll see how she is in a few weeks and then I may talk to a lawyer. Thanks for the replies.

Xebedee Apr 17th 2013 12:52 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Bob (Post 10663479)
Send her the money direct?

Edit: just read the last bit, at 6, she's too young, never mind. Good luck!


Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10663808)
Most of the conversations between me and my ex have either been online or through text messages, so its easy to keep track of all that. I send money through xe every month, I assume I can get the full history of all my transactions if I ever need to.

I go through this pretty much every time I visit. I'm just getting tired of it. I'll see how she is in a few weeks and then I may talk to a lawyer. Thanks for the replies.

Set up an account for your daughter and put the money into it as you would otherwise send it to her Mum.
Then send copies of the statements to her by registered post.

You'd be widtholding and yet not.

AmerLisa Apr 17th 2013 2:09 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Is there any way you two can go through a mediator over there to settle things? I know it may be wishing on a star, but if you two could sit down together, without the threats, and hash out what is in the best interest for your daughter, perhaps it may help. Do they have family court there?

Manc Apr 17th 2013 2:58 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
get that bitch in court. toot sweet.

you have every right to see your child.

sir_eccles Apr 17th 2013 4:15 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Xebedee (Post 10664105)
Set up an account for your daughter and put the money into it as you would otherwise send it to her Mum.
Then send copies of the statements to her by registered post.

You'd be widtholding and yet not.

Done as some sort of trust would enable you to be clear on who can access it and there may be tax advantages too.

Cardienscarf Apr 17th 2013 4:18 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Manc (Post 10664362)

you have every right to see your child.

And your child has every right to see you.

I'm sorry you're in this situation. I would advise seeking legal help immediately. Conversations/arguments between you and your ex are unlikely to solve anything. If you can go the mediation route as AmerLisa suggested, great.

Keep paying child support. Not only will it look favourably on you, it is the right thing to do for your daughter. However much it sticks in your throat to make the payment to your ex, if she is in financial difficulty, it will affect your daughter.

Please maintain contact with your daughter in any way you can. If your ex won't let her Skype or email, send postcards and letters. Let her know you love her, you miss her, you look forward to hearing from her and seeing her again. She needs to hear from you regardless of what is going on between you and her mum. Keep it to a normal father/6 yr old daughter conversation. Please do not involve her in any way in the friction between you and your ex. If she asks questions, answer them honestly but don't give her more than she asks for. Let her digest what she hears, and then she may ask another question. Rinse and repeat!

A 6 year old can be in distress one minute and playing with her toys or talking about her friend the next and then come back to the distress for 5 minutes, and then talk about her friend or go off and play with her toys again......

I'm not trying to tell you how to raise your daughter (really!!) but she is the one who will suffer most if you two adults don't get your act together and do the right thing for her. You can't sort it out between you so get help.

AmerLisa Apr 17th 2013 4:21 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Cardienscarf (Post 10664514)
And your child has every right to see you.

I'm sorry you're in this situation. I would advise seeking legal help immediately. Conversations/arguments between you and your ex are unlikely to solve anything. If you can go the mediation route as AmerLisa suggested, great.

Keep paying child support. Not only will it look favourably on you, it is the right thing to do for your daughter. However much it sticks in your throat to make the payment to your ex, if she is in financial difficulty, it will affect your daughter.

Please maintain contact with your daughter in any way you can. If your ex won't let her Skype or email, send postcards and letters. Let her know you love her, you miss her, you look forward to hearing from her and seeing her again. She needs to hear from you regardless of what is going on between you and her mum. Keep it to a normal father/6 yr old daughter conversation. Please do not involve her in any way in the friction between you and your ex. If she asks questions, answer them honestly but don't give her more than she asks for. Let her digest what she hears, and then she may ask another question. Rinse and repeat!

A 6 year old can be in distress one minute and playing with her toys or talking about her friend the next and then come back to the distress for 5 minutes, and then talk about her friend or go off and play with her toys again......

I'm not trying to tell you how to raise your daughter (really!!) but she is the one who will suffer most if you two adults don't get your act together and do the right thing for her. You can't sort it out between you so get help.

Absolutely!

Ja5on Apr 17th 2013 10:59 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
She said she doesn't care if I give her money or not. She just wants our daughter to grow up with her and her boyfriend and to pretty much just cut me out of her life. I am planning on giving her a couple of weeks to calm down, then I will see weather or not she will allow me any contact. If she is still being difficult then I will try to find a lawyer who can help me with this. Does anybody know if it would be better getting a US lawyer or a UK one? Obviously I can't fly back for multiple court dates.

I also don't know how much a lawyer would cost. I would say as of now I could put up about $2,000. I don't want to spend all that money just for a judge in the UK to tell me that my daughter is doing just fine with her mother and that I'm not allowed any access.

Thanks for all the replies, I'm still praying that my ex will calm down and let me see her again. But it does go back and forth.....I'm hoping that it can stay somewhat ok until my daughter is a little older and can make her own mind up!

lizzyq Apr 17th 2013 11:03 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Ex-girlfriend or ex-wife? I ask because when I got divorced I had to (and did) allow "reasonable access" to my daughter's father and that was legally binding.

yellowroom Apr 17th 2013 11:50 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
I'm sorry you are going through this. A friend went through something similar with his son, and for five years the only news he got was through his son's understanding teachers. He rang up every couple of weeks and they would discuss is progress in school. He still sent letters and postcards and gifts etc.

His son got in touch in his teenage years thanks to Facebook, and during one of his visits my friend showed him copies of the letters that he had written over the years - his son had not received a single one, his mum had told him his dad didn't want to know him. Long story short, son rejected his mother and went to live with my friend instead.

My friend and his son will never get back those lost 5 years, but they are looking forwards not back. So hang on in there Ja5on, it will work out eventually.

It's terrible how badly people can behave when it comes to their children - for every story you hear of father's running away from their responsibilities, there is a story of a mother refusing the father access for no good reason (the only acceptable ones being abuse or violence).

Lion in Winter Apr 18th 2013 12:04 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10665164)
She said she doesn't care if I give her money or not. She just wants our daughter to grow up with her and her boyfriend and to pretty much just cut me out of her life. I am planning on giving her a couple of weeks to calm down, then I will see weather or not she will allow me any contact. If she is still being difficult then I will try to find a lawyer who can help me with this. Does anybody know if it would be better getting a US lawyer or a UK one? Obviously I can't fly back for multiple court dates.

I also don't know how much a lawyer would cost. I would say as of now I could put up about $2,000. I don't want to spend all that money just for a judge in the UK to tell me that my daughter is doing just fine with her mother and that I'm not allowed any access.

Thanks for all the replies, I'm still praying that my ex will calm down and let me see her again. But it does go back and forth.....I'm hoping that it can stay somewhat ok until my daughter is a little older and can make her own mind up!


I would really try and find some legal help. Perhaps the British Embassy can give you some guidance as to whether to consult a lawyer here or there. Equally, there are several fathers' rights groups in the UK and I expect they would respond to an email from you and give you an idea of what you can do. A parent's right and need to see his or her child, and vice versa, should certainly not depend only on the goodwill of the other parent. The only time a parent should not see a child is if that puts the child at risk of immediate harm. Please get some help - you can't really wing it with legal issues.

Cardienscarf Apr 18th 2013 12:10 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Lion in Winter (Post 10665255)
I would really try and find some legal help. Perhaps the British Embassy can give you some guidance as to whether to consult a lawyer here or there. Equally, there are several fathers' rights groups in the UK and I expect they would respond to an email from you and give you an idea of what you can do. A parent's right and need to see his or her child, and vice versa, should certainly not depend only on the goodwill of the other parent. The only time a parent should not see a child is if that puts the child at risk of immediate harm. Please get some help - you can't really wing it with legal issues.

I absolutely agree with this. I wouldn't wait to see if she calms down. Even if she does this time, there will be a next time. Start the process to get it sorted and then everyone knows where they stand and can move on accordingly.

Your daughter is under the jurisdiction of England and Wales so I would suggest starting there with a Skype consultation with a solicitor. You really can't afford not to.

Ja5on Apr 18th 2013 12:10 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Ex girlfriend.

I am lucky that my dad has my daughter 3 afternoons a week and she spends some days with my mum as well, so I always get updates...she has had issues with my patents speaking to my daughter about me in the past though. I think I will seek legal help on the matter. As far as my ex is concerned I abandoned my daughter and gave up all rights when I moved to the USA. Before I moved my daughter would stay with me 3 nights a week and full day at the weekend. All this was arranged between us.

penguinsix Apr 18th 2013 2:21 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10665270)
Ex girlfriend.

I am lucky that my dad has my daughter 3 afternoons a week and she spends some days with my mum as well, so I always get updates...she has had issues with my patents speaking to my daughter about me in the past though. I think I will seek legal help on the matter. As far as my ex is concerned I abandoned my daughter and gave up all rights when I moved to the USA. Before I moved my daughter would stay with me 3 nights a week and full day at the weekend. All this was arranged between us.

Legal advice, and quite possibly a formal custody arrangement is something you should be considering. Your ex- seems to be toying with ideas of cutting you out of the child's life for good, and you really want to move quickly to get 'informal understandings' and 'handshake agreements' etched into something more formal and legal. You'd hate to have her run to a court one day and bend the truth saying "I want full legal custody--I've tried to reach the father but he ran off to America and we don't know where he is".

http://reunite.org is an international child abduction organization, which you are not in need of, but they do have several links and resources that might help you better understand your rights and what you can expect from the process.

ian-mstm Apr 18th 2013 1:40 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10665270)
As far as my ex is concerned I abandoned my daughter and gave up all rights when I moved to the USA.

What your ex thinks... is irrelevant. As the biological father, you can assert your parental rights at any time - and the law is on your side.

Ian

Ja5on Apr 18th 2013 3:28 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Will I have to physically go to court in the UK? I'm going to try to find a lawyer this weekend and work out my best course of action. I emailed her today asking how long she was planning on not letting me have contact. She said that she doesn't want me to see our daughter ever again as I don
't deserve to....
Thanks again to everyone for the replies. I will keep this thread updated with how everything works out.

scrubbedexpat097 Apr 18th 2013 4:09 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10666395)
Will I have to physically go to court in the UK? I'm going to try to find a lawyer this weekend and work out my best course of action. I emailed her today asking how long she was planning on not letting me have contact. She said that she doesn't want me to see our daughter ever again as I don
't deserve to....
Thanks again to everyone for the replies. I will keep this thread updated with how everything works out.

Unless there is any kind of court order refusing you access then you have every right to see your daughter, also your daughter now has a sister that she needs to see and bond with, your ex is being very very selfish denying the visits.


Good luck honey:fingerscrossed:

ian-mstm Apr 18th 2013 5:57 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10666395)
Will I have to physically go to court in the UK?

Yes, you might have to... and there's no way around it. Indeed, you might need to make several trips. While it might be a financial hardship, you want to be the one who makes the accommodation for your daughter - since it appears the mother doesn't care to accommodate anyone but herself.

I'll repeat what others have said before - set up a trust account for your daughter and put any support money in there. You are not obligated to send money to the mother... support is the right of the child, not the parent. The court can appoint someone to manage the trust... because you don't want the mother getting her hands on it.

Ian

Manc Apr 18th 2013 8:39 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10666395)
She said that she doesn't want me to see our daughter ever again as I don't deserve to....

she doesn't have the legal right to make that decision.

I stand by my earlier comment.

Lion in Winter Apr 19th 2013 1:47 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10666395)
Will I have to physically go to court in the UK? I'm going to try to find a lawyer this weekend and work out my best course of action. I emailed her today asking how long she was planning on not letting me have contact. She said that she doesn't want me to see our daughter ever again as I don
't deserve to....
Thanks again to everyone for the replies. I will keep this thread updated with how everything works out.


You are probably going to need a court order that mandates your contact with your child - where, when, and how and need legal help to do so. I would contact a solicitor or parents' rights group in the UK and get advice sooner rather than later, so that you can prove that you want to maintain contact with your child. Don't hang about and fuel her claim that you abandoned your child.

Trixie_b Apr 19th 2013 5:01 am

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10666395)
Will I have to physically go to court in the UK? I'm going to try to find a lawyer this weekend and work out my best course of action. I emailed her today asking how long she was planning on not letting me have contact. She said that she doesn't want me to see our daughter ever again as I don
't deserve to....
Thanks again to everyone for the replies. I will keep this thread updated with how everything works out.

Best of luck.

slummymummy Apr 19th 2013 9:53 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
Oh dear...

So, Ja5on, do you think that your ex is angry because you left the country and she thinks it's upsetting for your daughter when you leave after a visit?

I find that it helps when you acknowledge how someone else feels. How about another try at an email. I would write something like this:

Dear ex,

I know that you are angry about me moving to the USA, away from (daughter). It wasn't an easy decision, but in the end I decided that I would be happier here and I felt like it's also better for (daughter) to have a happy daddy that she sees sometimes, rather than a miserable one that she sees more often. Anyway, this is how things are now and I would really like for us to make the best of the situation. I love and miss (daughter) and I want to see her as much as I can. It's important for a girl to have a good relationship with her dad, and although she also has (new boyfriend) in her life, I'm still her real dad and will always be. I feel that you refusing for her to see me is a really bad decision that is definitely not good for (daughter) and also might backfire against you in the future when she finds out what you did. Please let me carry on seeing her as often as I can. She might get upset when I leave but I think she would be much more upset if she never gets to see me.

Edit: And maybe add something about her sister too!

-----------

Good luck!

kins Apr 20th 2013 1:58 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 
My dad lived in a different country to me for most of my childhood. That made it even more important to get a court order for him to see us. We did 2 weeks at Easter, 6 weeks at summer, and 2 weeks every other Christmas with him. It was set up through a UK lawyer and in court before he left the country. It meant I got to see the world but on the other hand it meant I did a lot of unaccompanied minor travelling.

My uncle's ex tried to stop him seeing their daughter. They went to court, set up visitation, but she consistently refused to abide by the court's order. In the end on the judge's advice he instead filed for custody and won. The alternative would have been for the judge to send the mother to prison, and no one wanted that.

Good luck...

Cardienscarf Apr 20th 2013 2:00 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by kins (Post 10669422)
My dad lived in a different country to me for most of my childhood. That made it even more important to get a court order for him to see us. We did 2 weeks at Easter, 6 weeks at summer, and 2 weeks every other Christmas with him. It was set up through a UK lawyer and in court before he left the country. It meant I got to see the world but on the other hand it meant I did a lot of unaccompanied minor travelling.

My uncle's ex tried to stop him seeing their daughter. They went to court, set up visitation, but she consistently refused to abide by the court's order. In the end on the judge's advice he instead filed for custody and won. The alternative would have been for the judge to send the mother to prison, and no one wanted that.

Good luck...

Great to hear it from your perspective as the child. :)

Ja5on Apr 20th 2013 2:31 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by kins (Post 10669422)
My dad lived in a different country to me for most of my childhood. That made it even more important to get a court order for him to see us. We did 2 weeks at Easter, 6 weeks at summer, and 2 weeks every other Christmas with him. It was set up through a UK lawyer and in court before he left the country. It meant I got to see the world but on the other hand it meant I did a lot of unaccompanied minor travelling.

My uncle's ex tried to stop him seeing their daughter. They went to court, set up visitation, but she consistently refused to abide by the court's order. In the end on the judge's advice he instead filed for custody and won. The alternative would have been for the judge to send the mother to prison, and no one wanted that.

Good luck...

Thanks, I'm a little worried that she will ignore court orders. I don't know weather or not a judge would grant me custody when it would mean moving my daughter to another country. I am hoping it all goes well. I guess we will see.

Manc Apr 20th 2013 7:33 pm

Re: Can I get a court order to see my child?
 

Originally Posted by Ja5on (Post 10669458)
Thanks, I'm a little worried that she will ignore court orders.

either that or she goes to jail.


All times are GMT. The time now is 8:54 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.