Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
#16
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
Certainly is a huge difference.
I am very sure. The audience were all Brits who gasped and asked questions and the conclusion was that its best not to disclose the "I wont be back part", although the CPA and Attorney would not accept that as an option (but they did smile...)
I am very sure. The audience were all Brits who gasped and asked questions and the conclusion was that its best not to disclose the "I wont be back part", although the CPA and Attorney would not accept that as an option (but they did smile...)
#18
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,852
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
#19
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
Indeed, as I said the seminar speakers were very clear that it covered giving up residency regardless of citizenship.
Anyway, all it means is that if anyone is thinking about doing it they may want to consult a CPA with experience in the expat arena.
Anyway, all it means is that if anyone is thinking about doing it they may want to consult a CPA with experience in the expat arena.
#20
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2009
Location: Norfolk UK
Posts: 447
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
If you surrender your residency then your 401K/IRA is taxed at an additional 30%, plus 10% early withdrawal as well as income tax.
I only learned this at a seminar a few weeks ago hosted by the British American Business Council in SF, who had tax and legal professionals give the talk.
It does assume one makes full disclosure when liquidating.........
I only learned this at a seminar a few weeks ago hosted by the British American Business Council in SF, who had tax and legal professionals give the talk.
It does assume one makes full disclosure when liquidating.........
So now I'm fixin' to pull out of the Roth before I leave these fine US shores. How would I ever get this refunded from IRS ?
I need to understand more though because if I pull my Traditional it will be classed as income in one shot and put me in a high tax bracket, not at all the intent of having a IRA.
From what I find searching the web the 30% withholding is for non-resident ALIENS, not non-resident US Citizens but I can't yet find confirmation.
Last edited by J.J; Dec 18th 2009 at 4:38 am. Reason: clarity of message
#21
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
Fatbrit mentioned it and its a biggie - you have to vest first.
Some companies are two years, others 3 or 5. If you aren't vested, that 'free' money (employer contributions) is zilch.
Still, if you don't vest, the exercise should be a decent way to earn as opposed to a savings account, and you can't know your tax burden/base when you withdraw it. You can roll it over or wait until a low tax year.
Some companies are two years, others 3 or 5. If you aren't vested, that 'free' money (employer contributions) is zilch.
Still, if you don't vest, the exercise should be a decent way to earn as opposed to a savings account, and you can't know your tax burden/base when you withdraw it. You can roll it over or wait until a low tax year.
#23
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,852
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
What's more she is a US citizen so has to file a yearly US tax return on her worldwide income anyway. I'm really not sure why she thinks she has an issue, other than it being a pain in the ass to get money withheld on a Roth withdrawal and then having to get it refunded the next time she files a return.
Last edited by Giantaxe; Dec 18th 2009 at 4:31 pm.
#24
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,852
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
#25
Forum Regular
Joined: Nov 2007
Location: South Staffs UK & Gulf Coast Florida
Posts: 137
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
So, my thinking is that if I'm only planning to be in the US for a limited period (say a couple of years before returning back to UK), then it's not worth it from a hassle perspective because you'll only have put away a small amount which will be inaccessible for 30 years (and knowing me I'll forget about it).
Sound about right? Much appreciated.
#26
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Dec 2009
Location: Norfolk UK
Posts: 447
Re: Is a 401k worthwhile if you're only staying a couple of years?
@ OP, IMO, I wouldn't invest in a 401k if I was planning to leave the US after a short time., and if I did invest in one it would be only up to the amount that would get a matching contribution from my employer and only then if the match amount exceeds the penalty payable for early withdrawal if you liquidate it while still resident in US.
But if you leave it in place when you leave the US then the custodian is obligated to withhold an amount of 30% as tax to be passed to the IRS if you have a non-USA address when you eventually withdraw the monies. The way to avoid this withholding is to file a IRS Form W-9 confirming you are a US Citizen or legal Permanent Resident - and it is unlikely you would be either after a short stay in USA. Even if you did get a PR Green Card and you move out the US then the Green Card defaults to invalid after a period of (1 year??) and you suffer the 30% tax.
But if you leave it in place when you leave the US then the custodian is obligated to withhold an amount of 30% as tax to be passed to the IRS if you have a non-USA address when you eventually withdraw the monies. The way to avoid this withholding is to file a IRS Form W-9 confirming you are a US Citizen or legal Permanent Resident - and it is unlikely you would be either after a short stay in USA. Even if you did get a PR Green Card and you move out the US then the Green Card defaults to invalid after a period of (1 year??) and you suffer the 30% tax.