Abandoning Green Card Application
#16

The original post says she applied for AOS.
There is no inadmissibility to waive. She did not accrue any "unlawful presence" for the purposes of the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans, for multiple reasons:
There is no inadmissibility to waive. She did not accrue any "unlawful presence" for the purposes of the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans, for multiple reasons:
- people never accrue unlawful presence for the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans while under 18, and
- people do not accrue unlawful presence while an Adjustment of Status application (I-485) is pending, even if it is ultimately denied or abandoned. So even if she were an adult, she would not have accrued unlawful presence
#17


#18

The actual call of OP’s inquiry strikes me as fairly narrow. It strikes me that OP may not be asking the proper question to address their concerns. Us legal types are trained in issue spotting, which can be tricky at times.
#19

OK, I was it again. Also, I read your description again. Five months is longer than 90 days.
The actual call of OP’s inquiry strikes me as fairly narrow. It strikes me that OP may not be asking the proper question to address their concerns. Us legal types are trained in issue spotting, which can be tricky at times.
The actual call of OP’s inquiry strikes me as fairly narrow. It strikes me that OP may not be asking the proper question to address their concerns. Us legal types are trained in issue spotting, which can be tricky at times.
#20

#21

She did not accrue any "unlawful presence" for the purposes of the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans, for multiple reasons:
- people never accrue unlawful presence for the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans while under 18, and
- people do not accrue unlawful presence while an Adjustment of Status application (I-485) is pending, even if it is ultimately denied or abandoned. So even if she were an adult, she would not have accrued unlawful presence
However, there is also this:
A Minor Could Be Arrested and Removed From the U.S. on the Basis of an Overstay. A minor who is in the United States beyond the expiration date of a permitted stay under a non-immigrant visa is at risk of being arrested by the immigration authorities and placed into removal proceedings.
She entered under the VWP which is 90 days. A filed I-130 is not a petition that allows her to remain in the US while the petition is being adjudicated. So while is might not accrue overstay, she is in violation of the VWP and can be removed from the US.
#22

I wonder about the nature of the “emergency.” Also, I wonder if derivative acquisition of US citizenship enters into the equation?
Hence, good idea for legal consultation.
#23

Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Last edited by red_onion; May 25th 2023 at 12:45 am.
#24

From what you’ve said, she’s overstayed the VWP. On the plus side it means there’s no AOS to abandon when she returns to the UK.
I don’t know if her overstay will be forgiven because of her age or if she can never use the VWP again.
Again, I’d strongly suggest a consultation with a good lawyer.
I don’t know if her overstay will be forgiven because of her age or if she can never use the VWP again.
Again, I’d strongly suggest a consultation with a good lawyer.
#25
Forum Regular



Joined: Jun 2022
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 103












I think we may have screwed up. I was under the impression that to get AOS approved we had to complete the form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative, which we did in order to qualify and then complete the form I-485. What we have received is an acknowledgement of the application and relative time of how long it will take to get approved, whatever that means at this point. What are our options?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Leaving the USA is going to be a problem. As you didn't submit the I-485 while she was in status, she is now a visa overstayer and will likely be subject to a re-entry bar of three or ten years depending on how long she now overstays. She will never be able to use ESTA again, and I'd recommend she must not leave the USA for any reason until she has Green Card in hand.
Key question, are you a US Citizen or a GCH? Most people can't adjust status to GC from being out of status, but assuming you are a US citizen, then your daughter is an "immediate relative" and she will be able to adjust.
If it's absolutely critical that she leaves the US, you could in theory apply for Travel Parole. But she'd also need a way of getting back into the USA which I don't think she'd have as ESTA is no longer na option, and very unlikely she'd be given a visit visa, given the pending AOS.
Also, your first post says the I-130 was approved, but this recent post says you've only received an acknowledgement of the application and a time estimation of when it'll be approved. Which is it?
In summary, this is a major mess and you need a good immigration lawyer ASAP.
#26
DE-UK-NZ-IE-US... the TYP







Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 2,756












If you read the previous posts it looks like the OP married a USC around 2017/2018 and moved here on a CR1. So he could be a USC by now in theory. Given the daughters age she must be from a previous marriage / relationship. Sounds like she came for the Xmas holidays and decided to stay?
Maybe the emergency is that mum called and said she needs to come home and go to school… or medical if she has no cover in the US…
Agree with others, OP go and pay a lawyer for good advice before doing anything else… getting this wrong could not only derail this process, but cause issues with her future ability to visit…. If it has not already…
Maybe the emergency is that mum called and said she needs to come home and go to school… or medical if she has no cover in the US…
Agree with others, OP go and pay a lawyer for good advice before doing anything else… getting this wrong could not only derail this process, but cause issues with her future ability to visit…. If it has not already…
#27

I think we may have screwed up. I was under the impression that to get AOS approved we had to complete the form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative, which we did in order to qualify and then complete the form I-485. What we have received is an acknowledgement of the application and relative time of how long it will take to get approved, whatever that means at this point. What are our options?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
If you consult with immigration counsel, it is important that you consult with counsel who is competent and experienced. Just having a bar card is insufficient to gauge competence, knowledge and skill. I am of an age where my children and those of old friends are now middle aged. Several have lived the expat life and now wish to repatriate with their foreign spouse. Not too long ago, an old neighbor asked for help for their son and daughter-in-law living in France. Given that I am retired and am inactive on my bar membership, I gave them a referral to an attorney that **I** trust. Shortly after New Year, the son called me to thank me profusely. Not only was the attorney competent, he was able to hold their hands for their specific situation.
Good luck.
#28

I think we may have screwed up. I was under the impression that to get AOS approved we had to complete the form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative, which we did in order to qualify and then complete the form I-485. What we have received is an acknowledgement of the application and relative time of how long it will take to get approved, whatever that means at this point. What are our options?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Was I wrong to complete I-30 for someone who is adjusting status while in the country? Can I now file I-485? Would she still be considered an overstayer? What will happen to the I-30 application pending?
Thank you all. sorry for the confusion?
Frankly, I would not do anything until you have take advice from a good immigration attorney. And under no circumstances allow her to leave the US until you have that consultation.
#29

In these days of interview waivers, I can see a chain of adjudications. Also, correct me if my memory is faulty, is it not uncommon for petition approval to be followed by adjustment approval within a matter of days? Those CIS time estimates are not the best indicator of how long it’s going to take.
I wonder about the nature of the “emergency.” Also, I wonder if derivative acquisition of US citizenship enters into the equation?
Hence, good idea for legal consultation.
I wonder about the nature of the “emergency.” Also, I wonder if derivative acquisition of US citizenship enters into the equation?
Hence, good idea for legal consultation.
#30
BE Forum Addict






Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 1,027












Not too long ago, an old neighbor asked for help for their son and daughter-in-law living in France. Given that I am retired and am inactive on my bar membership, I gave them a referral to an attorney that **I** trust. Shortly after New Year, the son called me to thank me profusely. Not only was the attorney competent, he was able to hold their hands for their specific situation.