Abandoning Green Card Application
#1

I’ve applied for permanent residency for my daughter who’s 12 through AOS while on ESTA. I-30 is approved but the decision to grant her LPR could take up-to 13 months according to USCIS.
Family emergency means that she’ll will have to go back to the UK for a while.
what are the ramifications of abandoning the application? Can she still visit on ESTA or strictly visa now? Will visa be granted given the fact that we applied AOS while on ESTA?
Thank you
Family emergency means that she’ll will have to go back to the UK for a while.
what are the ramifications of abandoning the application? Can she still visit on ESTA or strictly visa now? Will visa be granted given the fact that we applied AOS while on ESTA?
Thank you
#2
BE Enthusiast




Joined: Sep 2017
Location: Miami
Posts: 438












I’ve applied for permanent residency for my daughter who’s 12 through AOS while on ESTA. I-30 is approved but the decision to grant her LPR could take up-to 13 months according to USCIS.
Family emergency means that she’ll will have to go back to the UK for a while.
what are the ramifications of abandoning the application? Can she still visit on ESTA or strictly visa now? Will visa be granted given the fact that we applied AOS while on ESTA?
Thank you
Family emergency means that she’ll will have to go back to the UK for a while.
what are the ramifications of abandoning the application? Can she still visit on ESTA or strictly visa now? Will visa be granted given the fact that we applied AOS while on ESTA?
Thank you
#4
Forum Regular


Joined: Jun 2022
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 56

#5
Forum Regular


Joined: Jun 2022
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 56


Op, your best bet is to apply for emergency Advanced Parole. See here: https://www.uscis.gov/greencard/gree...mergencytravel
#7

Op, your best bet is to apply for emergency Advanced Parole. See here: https://www.uscis.gov/greencard/gree...mergencytravel
#8

I think you need to consult with a lawyer. The link given above specifically says departure from the US may trigger inadmissibility if she's accrued unlawful presence, even with AP - I don't know if filing excuses her overstaying the VWP, but there's a risk here and I'd personally be taking proper legal advise.
#9

Yes, a consultation is in order. However, can you advise why you didn't file for AOS at the same time you filed the I-130 for your daughter. If she was inside of the US and you filed the I-130 for with the full intent that she was going to remain in the US to adjust status, while you were taking a big chance on doing so, you should have filed the I-485 and accommodating forms along with the I-130. They would have been adjudicated together.
Since you haven't filed the I-485 for her, she is not abandoning her green card application because one has not been filed. All that has been filed as per your post is the petition for an Immediate Relative Visa which if she returns to her own country she can finish there. The issue is that yes, she has been in overstay since her 90 day VWP expired.
An attorney can help her with filing for a waiver of inadmissibility when her visa is denied due to overstay.
You disregarded rules and regulations so far why are you willing to now abandon the still ongoing process for an immediate relative visa and adjustment of status?
Since you haven't filed the I-485 for her, she is not abandoning her green card application because one has not been filed. All that has been filed as per your post is the petition for an Immediate Relative Visa which if she returns to her own country she can finish there. The issue is that yes, she has been in overstay since her 90 day VWP expired.
An attorney can help her with filing for a waiver of inadmissibility when her visa is denied due to overstay.
You disregarded rules and regulations so far why are you willing to now abandon the still ongoing process for an immediate relative visa and adjustment of status?
Last edited by Rete; May 23rd 2023 at 4:11 pm.
#10

Technically you are correct because she applied before the end of the ESTA/VWP 90 days, however if she abandons her PR application then that will sink the AOS raft that she jumped onto from her ESTA status. In other words, abandoning her AOS/PR application will retrospectively put her into an "overstayed" status. .... Hence the advice to consult urgently with an experienced immigration attorney.
#11

I think you need to consult with a lawyer. The link given above specifically says departure from the US may trigger inadmissibility if she's accrued unlawful presence, even with AP - I don't know if filing excuses her overstaying the VWP, but there's a risk here and I'd personally be taking proper legal advise.
I find it curious that OP states that the young person has been in the US five months but less than 90 days.
The main case on advanced parole and adjustment is Arrabally. Yes, the opinion is confusing. It notes the disagreement by the administrative authorities. Despite the decision favorable to non-citizens (which is wonderful), I personally agree with the dissent. I can easily see Arrabally go by the wayside.
#12
#13
Forum Regular



Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 208












I think you need to consult with a lawyer. The link given above specifically says departure from the US may trigger inadmissibility if she's accrued unlawful presence, even with AP - I don't know if filing excuses her overstaying the VWP, but there's a risk here and I'd personally be taking proper legal advise.
- people never accrue unlawful presence for the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans while under 18, and
- people do not accrue unlawful presence while an Adjustment of Status application (I-485) is pending, even if it is ultimately denied or abandoned. So even if she were an adult, she would not have accrued unlawful presence
Last edited by newacct; May 23rd 2023 at 6:18 pm.
#14
Forum Regular



Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 208












- people never accrue unlawful presence for the 3-year/10-year unlawful presence bans while under 18, and
- people do not accrue unlawful presence while an Adjustment of Status application (I-485) is pending, even if it is ultimately denied or abandoned. So even if she were an adult, she would not have accrued unlawful presence
Last edited by newacct; May 23rd 2023 at 6:20 pm.
#15
Forum Regular



Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 208












Did she apply for regular Advance Parole with her Adjustment of Status application? (I-765 for EAD and I-131 for Advance Parole is free for I-485 applicants.)