What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 93
What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
I've only lived here for a couple of years but it seems that Americans have this bizarre desire to watch cheesy movies about the tough rugged teacher who sweeps into a troublesome school and turns a bunch of ethnic thugs and dropouts into a winning team. Coach Carter, Gridiron Gang, Ron Clarke Story, Dangerous Minds...and now Freedom Writers.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
#2
Forum Regular
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 63
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
I've only lived here for a couple of years but it seems that Americans have this bizarre desire to watch cheesy movies about the tough rugged teacher who sweeps into a troublesome school and turns a bunch of ethnic thugs and dropouts into a winning team. Coach Carter, Gridiron Gang, Ron Clarke Story, Dangerous Minds...and now Freedom Writers.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
#3
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
I've only lived here for a couple of years but it seems that Americans have this bizarre desire to watch cheesy movies about the tough rugged teacher who sweeps into a troublesome school and turns a bunch of ethnic thugs and dropouts into a winning team. Coach Carter, Gridiron Gang, Ron Clarke Story, Dangerous Minds...and now Freedom Writers.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
#4
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
Sally, why don't you go ahead and tell us how you really feel!
#5
Account Closed
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 15,455
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
Thought I'd comment here since I am a Yank--and a teacher (in a detention school no less). The reason Americans love these movies is that the school systems in the US have been in the toilet for about 20-30 years now. Before, when the school systems were much better, these movies did not exist. Now, Americans romanticize ANYONE who can get any kind of education across to young punk kids. The worse the school system is, the more people love these films. A fantasy substitution for a harsh reality. SOME teachers do manage, against the odds and against the craziness of current school systems, to help one or two students in those rough neighborhoods, but it is absolutely never anything like in those movies. These flicks make me want to tear my graying hair out and picket the studios.
#7
I approved this message
Joined: Dec 2004
Location: Chicago
Posts: 2,425
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
Good American high school movies:
American Grafitti
Dazed and Confused (may be my favorite movie of all time...)
Rebel without a Cause
Sixteen Candles
Brick
Clueless
10 Things I Hate About You
Ferris Beuller
Hoop Dreams
Election
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Say Anything
Rushmore
Pump up the Volume (bit of a guilty pleasure)
Forgot one:
The Last Picture Show (should be required viewing)
American Grafitti
Dazed and Confused (may be my favorite movie of all time...)
Rebel without a Cause
Sixteen Candles
Brick
Clueless
10 Things I Hate About You
Ferris Beuller
Hoop Dreams
Election
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Say Anything
Rushmore
Pump up the Volume (bit of a guilty pleasure)
Forgot one:
The Last Picture Show (should be required viewing)
Last edited by Hiro11; Jan 6th 2007 at 9:55 pm.
#8
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,220
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
Thought I'd comment here since I am a Yank--and a teacher (in a detention school no less). The reason Americans love these movies is that the school systems in the US have been in the toilet for about 20-30 years now. Before, when the school systems were much better, these movies did not exist. Now, Americans romanticize ANYONE who can get any kind of education across to young punk kids. The worse the school system is, the more people love these films. A fantasy substitution for a harsh reality. SOME teachers do manage, against the odds and against the craziness of current school systems, to help one or two students in those rough neighborhoods, but it is absolutely never anything like in those movies. These flicks make me want to tear my graying hair out and picket the studios.
#9
Account Closed
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,220
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
Good American high school movies:
American Grafitti
Dazed and Confused (may be my favorite movie of all time...)
Rebel without a Cause
Sixteen Candles
Brick
Clueless
10 Things I Hate About You
Ferris Beuller
Hoop Dreams
Election
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Say Anything
Rushmore
Pump up the Volume (bit of a guilty pleasure)
Forgot one:
The Last Picture Show (should be required viewing)
American Grafitti
Dazed and Confused (may be my favorite movie of all time...)
Rebel without a Cause
Sixteen Candles
Brick
Clueless
10 Things I Hate About You
Ferris Beuller
Hoop Dreams
Election
Fast Times at Ridgemont High
Say Anything
Rushmore
Pump up the Volume (bit of a guilty pleasure)
Forgot one:
The Last Picture Show (should be required viewing)
#12
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
I've only lived here for a couple of years but it seems that Americans have this bizarre desire to watch cheesy movies about the tough rugged teacher who sweeps into a troublesome school and turns a bunch of ethnic thugs and dropouts into a winning team. Coach Carter, Gridiron Gang, Ron Clarke Story, Dangerous Minds...and now Freedom Writers.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
They are all the same - nothing but cookie cutter, formulaic movies, yet all my American neighbors seem to adore them as "heart warming".
I mean seriously, folks. There's only so many times you can see the cornball 'serious' scene as the teacher pulls the most troublesome kid to the side and with a stern face tells him how he won't give up on him...and then later the kid passes and says "I couldntve done it without you Sir".
Bleh.
Btw, some of the ones you mentioned are based on true stories.
#13
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
so what's up with all the national lampoon movies showing up in the movie shops? haven't heard of half of them....there everywhere though...
#14
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Oct 2006
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 317
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
#15
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 6,848
Re: What is it about the yanks and these damn school movies?!
I did like 'Grease' when it came out......now have it on DVD and it seems soooo cheesy!
With yet another crossover idea from the UK (where Andrew Lloyd Webber held a theatre audition competition for the part of Maria in his stage production for "The Sound of Music".....I've seen adverts (on Fox TV, I think) for a similar competition to audition for parts in a forthcoming stage production of 'Grease'...
NB: Isn't "To Sir With Love" a British secondary school movie from the 60s with Sidney Poitier and Lulu?
Can anyone remember the comedy series "Please Sir"...with John Alderton as one of the teachers?
With yet another crossover idea from the UK (where Andrew Lloyd Webber held a theatre audition competition for the part of Maria in his stage production for "The Sound of Music".....I've seen adverts (on Fox TV, I think) for a similar competition to audition for parts in a forthcoming stage production of 'Grease'...
NB: Isn't "To Sir With Love" a British secondary school movie from the 60s with Sidney Poitier and Lulu?
Can anyone remember the comedy series "Please Sir"...with John Alderton as one of the teachers?