Northern Ireland
#1
Account Closed










Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 8,266









Not a wind up, I would really like to know.
Why was N.I. not granted independence along with the south?
Why was N.I. not granted independence along with the south?

#2

My parents still stand for the Queen and the anthem etc


#3

#4

I know, I'm giving the simple one liner and waiting for Wellington with the long history answer, others for their side of political answers, the couple of replies who don't give a damn about NI and will let people know about it, the few 'bomb throwers' who just want to stir it up.
Am I missing anyone?
Am I missing anyone?


#5

I know, I'm giving the simple one liner and waiting for Wellington with the long history answer, others for their side of political answers, the couple of replies who don't give a damn about NI and will let people know about it, the few 'bomb throwers' who just want to stir it up.
Am I missing anyone?
Am I missing anyone?



#7

The Dail (Irish parl) wanted all 32 counties and Stormont wanted to keep Ulster (9 counties), the industrial and financial capitals. The Dail settled for 26counties therefore splitting Ulster with 3 counties in the republic and 6 still attached to U.K. The Dail accepted the deal thinking they would get the other 6 at a later date. History has told us this was not so, hence the fighting which has been going on sporadically through the generations.

#8
Straw Man.










Joined: Aug 2006
Location: That, there, that's not my post count... nothing to see here, move along.
Posts: 46,302












What Framac has neglected to mention, and its THE main reason why the partition took place is religion.
The North had a majority Protestant population and thats why they chose to opt out, they did not want to end up a a minority in a majority Catholic state.
To be honest the story is so complicated that a simple answer is very hard to give, the subsequent split in the Nationalist movement caused much of the violence, and the British were not the first targets, the RIC bore the brunt of that for a long time, and it was when the general strikes and civil disobedience took place, followed by the collapse of the Inland Revenue in ireland that the British entered in force. The rest is history!
The North had a majority Protestant population and thats why they chose to opt out, they did not want to end up a a minority in a majority Catholic state.
To be honest the story is so complicated that a simple answer is very hard to give, the subsequent split in the Nationalist movement caused much of the violence, and the British were not the first targets, the RIC bore the brunt of that for a long time, and it was when the general strikes and civil disobedience took place, followed by the collapse of the Inland Revenue in ireland that the British entered in force. The rest is history!

#9
Account Closed










Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 8,266









Anyone recommend some good books on the subject?

#11
Straw Man.










Joined: Aug 2006
Location: That, there, that's not my post count... nothing to see here, move along.
Posts: 46,302












http://www.kennysirishbookshop.ie/
http://www.amazon.com/Children-Troub.../dp/0671537385
The second is a book i have read and it was brilliant.
http://www.amazon.com/Children-Troub.../dp/0671537385
The second is a book i have read and it was brilliant.
