British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/using-s1-certificiate-non-lucrative-visa-application-947699/)

Algorfa1950 Mar 15th 2024 9:10 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Fred James (Post 13244823)
I thought the language requirement was for UK citizenship, not residency. Its the same in Spain. For citizenship you have to pass a language exam and a test of your knowledge of Spanish history, culture etc.

This is true, PLUS in the UK free interpreters are provided at every opportunity when they need English in any Public Service office, I know because I used to work for the local council and it cost us a fortune every month in interpreter costs, some immigrants didn't even bother to turn up and couldn't even be bothered to ring and cancel the appointment ! I am all for learning the language of the country you are going to live, but to get there to start learning surely it makes sense to help people in the process with forms that you can interpret into English. Forms and official letters in the UK from hospitals and councils etc. are written in at least a dozen languages on the attached pages!! You don't get that in any other EU country that I know of. Britain is too soft in the use of taxpayer money to everyone that arrives on its shores and is one of the reasons I am leaving the UK ! Some of the differences between the Spanish and British process for gaining residency are staggering. Not that I disagree with the Spanish process, I don't, I fully agree with it, they ensure they don't get people who are going to rely on the state for their living, pity they don't employ the same rules in the UK!

DLC Mar 15th 2024 9:13 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Fred James (Post 13244823)
I thought the language requirement was for UK citizenship, not residency. Its the same in Spain. For citizenship you have to pass a language exam and a test of your knowledge of Spanish history, culture etc.

For ILR in the UK you need a language test. Imagine the uproar if Spain tried that with permanent residency...

1sexsmith Mar 15th 2024 10:05 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by DLC (Post 13244830)
For ILR in the UK you need a language test. Imagine the uproar if Spain tried that with permanent residency...

Yep that is my point. Anyway you do need English language for permanent residence in UK not just citizenship. Not going to get drawn into too much of an argument about it but one of the other problems with putting public documents and forms in English is that in alot of cases there are words, categories, documents, processes that do not easily align with Spanish ones and so this invariably leads to confusion. I am at the moment trying to wade my way through declaring UK probate in Spain and there are lots of issues pertaining to various things that don't exactly equate to Spanish things.
Classifying things like premium bonds is a tiny example: Spain does not count them as savings but investments and then want expiry dates and purchase prices etc. Names also involve problems. My son's 720 was put in such a way by the gestor that his official surname uses his middle name and family name!! Anyway we live in Spain and until the costa blanca declares itself an independent state we are probably going to come up against Spanish every now and then!

bobd22 Mar 15th 2024 10:11 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Algorfa1950 (Post 13244828)
This is true, PLUS in the UK free interpreters are provided at every opportunity when they need English in any Public Service office, I know because I used to work for the local council and it cost us a fortune every month in interpreter costs, some immigrants didn't even bother to turn up and couldn't even be bothered to ring and cancel the appointment ! I am all for learning the language of the country you are going to live, but to get there to start learning surely it makes sense to help people in the process with forms that you can interpret into English. Forms and official letters in the UK from hospitals and councils etc. are written in at least a dozen languages on the attached pages!! You don't get that in any other EU country that I know of. Britain is too soft in the use of taxpayer money to everyone that arrives on its shores and is one of the reasons I am leaving the UK ! Some of the differences between the Spanish and British process for gaining residency are staggering. Not that I disagree with the Spanish process, I don't, I fully agree with it, they ensure they don't get people who are going to rely on the state for their living, pity they don't employ the same rules in the UK!

A lot of the official main Spanish government sites do allow you to select English and certain other languages online. I have used that when doing non resident tax returns and residency applications etc. Often though when you bring up a help screen that does often revert to Spanish only. So it's not that they don't do anything to help . At our local hospital there are volunteer translators. They help if for instance in a consultation they are available either in person or via telephone to assist. I'm sure that depends very much on location in Spain and number of foreign residents in the area. I find the hospital very helpful re language difficulties. Medical language can be confusing even in one's own language so isn't really the easiest.
​​​

Fred James Mar 16th 2024 12:01 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 
For online stuff, Google translates very well. Even the tax declaration forms come up in English.

Algorfa1950 Mar 16th 2024 12:55 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by bobd22 (Post 13244837)
A lot of the official main Spanish government sites do allow you to select English and certain other languages online. I have used that when doing non resident tax returns and residency applications etc. Often though when you bring up a help screen that does often revert to Spanish only. So it's not that they don't do anything to help . At our local hospital there are volunteer translators. They help if for instance in a consultation they are available either in person or via telephone to assist. I'm sure that depends very much on location in Spain and number of foreign residents in the area. I find the hospital very helpful re language difficulties. Medical language can be confusing even in one's own language so isn't really the easiest.
​​​

I agree, not even in a British hospital is it easy to understand some medical conditions LOL !

Algorfa1950 Mar 16th 2024 12:56 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Fred James (Post 13244867)
For online stuff, Google translates very well. Even the tax declaration forms come up in English.

Yes I have found that too.

Gt321 Mar 16th 2024 3:09 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 
Of course Brits shiukd make an effort to learn Spanish, but a high degree of Spanish language would be needed to fill in some of the forms. I don't know if English is taught in all Spanish schools, but many Spaniarda seem to speak English to a high standard. Plus I think the older you are, the harder it is to learn languages.

Algorfa1950 Mar 16th 2024 3:11 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Gt321 (Post 13244899)
Of course Brits shiukd make an effort to learn Spanish, but a high degree of Spanish language would be needed to fill in some of the forms. I don't know if English is taught in all Spanish schools, but many Spaniarda seem to speak English to a high standard. Plus I think the older you are, the harder it is to learn languages.

Yes I agree, I am 73 and struggle a bit but I know the Spanish love you to attempt the right words and only laugh when you get them wrong which I have done many times, but they appreciate you trying.

bobd22 Mar 16th 2024 5:14 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Algorfa1950 (Post 13244900)
Yes I agree, I am 73 and struggle a bit but I know the Spanish love you to attempt the right words and only laugh when you get them wrong which I have done many times, but they appreciate you trying.

I agree thing is if you try rather than just assume they speak English it is very much appreciated. I was at the hospital recently and the young female doctor only spoke Spanish. I had to say in Spanish that I didn't speak a lot of Spanish and could you speak slower for me. I understood enough to know that she said to her colleague "at least he tries " that's for me is the main thing try your best and most Spaniards will appreciate that and do their best to help. Age is definitely a factor re learning a new language I'm 70 and struggle but do try, that trying is the main thing we are incomers to their country and should rightly try our best.

Algorfa1950 Mar 16th 2024 5:38 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by bobd22 (Post 13244919)
I agree thing is if you try rather than just assume they speak English it is very much appreciated. I was at the hospital recently and the young female doctor only spoke Spanish. I had to say in Spanish that I didn't speak a lot of Spanish and could you speak slower for me. I understood enough to know that she said to her colleague "at least he tries " that's for me is the main thing try your best and most Spaniards will appreciate that and do their best to help. Age is definitely a factor re learning a new language I'm 70 and struggle but do try, that trying is the main thing we are incomers to their country and should rightly try our best.

I agree, pity that don't think like that in the UK when they come here in their thousands.😒

Thairetired2016 Mar 16th 2024 11:39 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Fred James (Post 13244823)
I thought the language requirement was for UK citizenship, not residency. Its the same in Spain. For citizenship you have to pass a language exam and a test of your knowledge of Spanish history, culture etc.

In Germany it is also for residency since Brexit. Same in Austria.
If you entered the country before the cut off date you don't need it.

1sexsmith Mar 16th 2024 11:57 pm

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Algorfa1950 (Post 13244922)
I agree, pity that don't think like that in the UK when they come here in their thousands.😒

​​​​In Spain they will call you Guiri or Chan.

Algorfa1950 Mar 17th 2024 12:54 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by 1sexsmith (Post 13244994)
​​​​In Spain they will call you Guiri or Chan.

What does that mean and what's with the "​​​â� ��‹" symbols ?

Just put those words in Google Translate and it doesn't even recognise them ?

tebo53 Mar 17th 2024 1:01 am

Re: Using S1 Certificiate for Non Lucrative Visa Application
 

Originally Posted by Algorfa1950 (Post 13245005)
What does that mean and what's with the "​​​â� ��‹" symbols ?

Just put those words in Google Translate and it doesn't even recognise them ?

Didn't get those symbols on my phone....

Steve


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 7:05 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.