Departing Malaga passport control
#2
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 871
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
The sooner they introduce the EES system for third country nationals, the better.
#4
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 871
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
That is a bit of a grey area. The EU have stated that stamps on the passports of EU residents are null and void but they leave it to the discretion of each individual EU state and don't put themselves out to stop them from doing it. It's not really their problem is it?
#5
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2020
Location: Nerja
Posts: 600
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
My experience at Malaga is provided you show both your Spanish TIE and passport, they won't stamp your passport, either on leaving or entering. I don't know what happens if you are resident elsewhere in EU and show your local residence document, even in theory they shouldn't stamp
#6
BE Enthusiast
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 640
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I have travelled 6 times since I got my TIE. You wont get your passport stamped if you tell the guard in Spanish you are a uk national with Spanish residence. You show your TIE not your passport unless asked. If you hand passport and talk in English they will ignore( or maybe not understand you/ accents etc) they do not need to engage in a lengthy conversation in broken English if they dont want to. The emphasis is for you to speak Spanish andake it clear you are a resident and you dont want your passport stamped. I came back to Spain last week and simply showed my TIE and said I was a resident and he waved me through. Others appeared to trying to hand over passports being asked something without understanding anything and clearly getting stamped ( they didn't seem bothered though- presumably because they dont know what it all means)
#7
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Mar 2019
Posts: 871
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I have travelled 6 times since I got my TIE. You wont get your passport stamped if you tell the guard in Spanish you are a uk national with Spanish residence. You show your TIE not your passport unless asked. If you hand passport and talk in English they will ignore( or maybe not understand you/ accents etc) they do not need to engage in a lengthy conversation in broken English if they dont want to. The emphasis is for you to speak Spanish andake it clear you are a resident and you dont want your passport stamped. I came back to Spain last week and simply showed my TIE and said I was a resident and he waved me through. Others appeared to trying to hand over passports being asked something without understanding anything and clearly getting stamped ( they didn't seem bothered though- presumably because they dont know what it all means)
UK residents in Portugal are also having their passports stamped sometimes but like I said, nobody in the EU is going to spend any of their valuable time on this self inflicted, British problem.
#8
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
On one occasion I showed my card first before my passport, I said I was a resident, I got stamped. It's not even clear if the law in Spain is that non-EU residents get stamped or not... Either way it doesn't matter as you always show your residency card with your passport, at least until you stop being an EU resident, and I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.
#9
BE Enthusiast
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 640
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I dont understand why people are getting their passports stamped if they are clearly showing their TIE cards. As I have said I have done it 6 times and never been stamped. My teenage son also has done it and he just shows his green card- however he speaks perfect Spanish and always says he is a British national but with permanent residence. They then either just wave him through or once they asked for his NIE and checked on computer. I do think that the problem is that you need to be able to converse with them in Spanish clearly and fluently so that they understand that you dont want them to stamp your passport. Normally your TIE will suffice as Spanish usually just show their identity cards not passports. If they open your passport and are about to stamp just tell them it is not required. I think the problem is often English pronunciation of Spanish is difficult for them to understand and they simply assume your are a visitor or they expect you to more clear about your status.
#10
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I speak Spanish fine, it's the telling a policeman how to do his job bit that is the tricky part.
You are supposed to show both TIE and passport when crossing a border.
But in the end they have discretion to stamp, the law says they can, and when you show your card with your passport the stamps mean nothing anyway.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
You are supposed to show both TIE and passport when crossing a border.
But in the end they have discretion to stamp, the law says they can, and when you show your card with your passport the stamps mean nothing anyway.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
#11
BE Enthusiast
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 640
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I can speak Spanish fine, it's the telling a policeman how to do his job bit that is the tricky part. But in the end they have discretion to stamp, the law says they can, and when you show your card with your passport the stamps mean nothing anyway.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
#12
BE Enthusiast
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 640
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I can speak Spanish fine, it's the telling a policeman how to do his job bit that is the tricky part. But in the end they have discretion to stamp, the law says they can, and when you show your card with your passport the stamps mean nothing anyway.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
However if you aren't a resident and you don't get a stamp then absolutely insist on one, at least until electronic stamping is officially rolled out.
#13
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 1,153
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
He said everyone apart from those carrying an EU family member card gets a stamp. Which if you read the original 2004 directive seems to be true.
I have no idea if any later recommendations on passport stamping by the EU commission have any legal backing in Spain.
I have no idea if any later recommendations on passport stamping by the EU commission have any legal backing in Spain.
#14
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 1,013
Re: Departing Malaga passport control
I dont understand why people are getting their passports stamped if they are clearly showing their TIE cards. As I have said I have done it 6 times and never been stamped. My teenage son also has done it and he just shows his green card- however he speaks perfect Spanish and always says he is a British national but with permanent residence. They then either just wave him through or once they asked for his NIE and checked on computer. I do think that the problem is that you need to be able to converse with them in Spanish clearly and fluently so that they understand that you dont want them to stamp your passport. Normally your TIE will suffice as Spanish usually just show their identity cards not passports. If they open your passport and are about to stamp just tell them it is not required. I think the problem is often English pronunciation of Spanish is difficult for them to understand and they simply assume your are a visitor or they expect you to more clear about your status.
To be honest with you, thats rubbish. The border force guards should know their job.
Its not mine or others place to tell them that they are wrong.
Besides its a stamp, its not the end of the world.
Not that we plan to travel anytime soon but when it happens I will hand over my TIE and hold my passport open ready to be asked for it. If it gets stamped then great, thats what the thing is for. If it don't then oh well..