British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Spain (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/)
-   -   ANTI SQUATTER PETITION (https://britishexpats.com/forum/spain-75/anti-squatter-petition-940445/)

DOWNANDOUT Sep 2nd 2021 10:41 pm

ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
I've raised a petition for the UK Govt as below. I've posted it on some other forums so fingers crossed we will a lot more signatures . There may be a period where you cannot sign as per the below instruction so please try again in a few days time after its been checked and published.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Forward the email below to your potential supporters.

5 people need to click the link and confirm their support for us to check your petition.

Once you’ve gained the required number of supporters, we’ll check your petition to make sure it meets the petition standards. If it does, we’ll publish it. This usually takes a week or less.

Once your petition has 21 signatures it won’t be able to add more until it’s been checked by the petitions team. So, please wait until it’s been checked and published before sharing it more widely.

Thanks,
The Petitions team
UK Government and Parliament
I’ve made a petition – will you sign it?

Click this link to sign the petition:
https://petition.parliament.uk/petit...vDKSQFkq8hT-dS

My petition:

Demand Spain Evict Squatters Within 24 hours Of Police Being Notified

Contact the Spanish PM and Minister Of Home Affairs demanding they amend their current laws regarding squatters. Their laws are biased towards squatters taking ownership of peoples properties and belongings leaving owners homeless and bereft of all their personal possessions sometimes for years.

Demand that the Spanish Police take immediate action when squatters are reported in an owners property. Evict them immediately if they have no written permission signed by the owner. Allow owners the option of cutting off all utilities rather than legally forcing them to pay for all the squatters usage. Currently Police will do nothing unless squatters are caught 'red-handed' . Eviction then has to go through the Spanish Court System which can sometimes take 1-4 years.

Dxf Sep 3rd 2021 5:40 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Hola
My signature was accepted

Davexf

Fredbargate Sep 3rd 2021 6:04 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Signed

tebo53 Sep 3rd 2021 8:55 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Signed and accepted

Fred James Sep 3rd 2021 9:08 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Would it not be more sensible to petition the Spanish government? I cannot see the UK government getting involved in attempting to change Spanish law.

Dxf Sep 3rd 2021 9:19 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Fred James (Post 13047343)
Would it not be more sensible to petition the Spanish government? I cannot see the UK government getting involved in attempting to change Spanish law.

Hola,

It would be good for BOTH governments to change the squatters rights laws

Davexf

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 9:26 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Here is a template of a petition that can be submitted to Spanish senate but I cannot speak Spanish. Also look at all the confidential information that people will have to enter.

Even worse , look at the bolded section further below which means they won't even accept the Petition.


-------------------------------------------------

Formulario Derecho de Petición (senado.es)

Written petitions must be submitted including the name of the petitioner or petitioners, nationality and address for the purpose of notifications, the addressee of the petition as well as the subject.

A form is provided for the submission of petitions, although its use is not mandatory, with petitions accepted in any written format as long as the aforementioned details are included.



Right of petition

Last revision 01/19/2021

The right to petition is a fundamental right exercised by all natural or legal persons, regardless of their nationality, as established in article 29 of the Constitution and developed in Organic Law 4/2001. This law may be exercised both individually and collectively, and consists of the faculty to submit petitions to public authorities, either to make them aware of certain facts or to request their intervention, or both at the same time. However, this right does not apply to petitions for whose satisfaction the legal system has established specific procedures, or those that are already being addressed by a parliamentary or administrative procedure or by legal proceedings.

EU.flag Sep 3rd 2021 9:29 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Is this a joke or just taking a p*ss?

Petitioning UK gov to change ES domestic law ??!!!!!! Has world gone mad ?!
Why not petition UK gov to invade ES, while at it?

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 9:36 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
It's not a joke to people who have got squatters and where Spanish Govt has blocked the right to raise a petition on their own website against laws already in place.

Also, the more aware British people are about the terrible squatter laws in Spain , the less inclined they will become to purchase a property in Spain , which will damage their rental market.

Annetje Sep 3rd 2021 9:55 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by EU.flag (Post 13047351)
Is this a joke or just taking a p*ss?

Petitioning UK gov to change ES domestic law ??!!!!!! Has world gone mad ?!
Why not petition UK gov to invade ES, while at it?

They could "deal" with France at the same time.
#NoMoreMacron :thumbup:

growinspain Sep 3rd 2021 9:55 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
They cannot even agree on a license exchange pact and from past examples - the British government does not provide much support to people who leave the island.

This is just a waste of my taxes that could be going to a better cause.

Fredbargate Sep 3rd 2021 9:57 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by EU.flag (Post 13047351)
Is this a joke or just taking a p*ss?

Petitioning UK gov to change ES domestic law ??!!!!!! Has world gone mad ?!
Why not petition UK gov to invade ES, while at it?

The British people could possibly change Spanish law by refusing to holiday in Spain.

But I doubt many of them have any idea of this problem and most want the cheapest they can get.

scrubbedexpat142 Sep 3rd 2021 9:58 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Fredbargate (Post 13047312)
Signed

Priceless! Ever heard of brexit Fred?

OP - read some of your horrendous story and understand your motivation. But...

mikelincs Sep 3rd 2021 10:12 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
As the UK has LEFT the EU, I very much doubt that the Spanish Government will take any notice of what is, in effect, an internal Spanish problem, perhaps the law in Spain does need to be changed, but petitioning the UK government will do no good whatsoever, even if it did receive the required number of signatures the petitions committee will, no doubt, dismiss is as not something the UK government can interfere with.

Annetje Sep 3rd 2021 10:28 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by mikelincs (Post 13047371)
As the UK has LEFT the EU, I very much doubt that the Spanish Government will take any notice of what is, in effect, an internal Spanish problem, perhaps the law in Spain does need to be changed, but petitioning the UK government will do no good whatsoever, even if it did receive the required number of signatures the petitions committee will, no doubt, dismiss is as not something the UK government can interfere with.

Even being in the EU, a country can not interfere in the domestic law of another country.

Fredbargate Sep 3rd 2021 10:48 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Expatrick (Post 13047366)
Priceless! Ever heard of brexit Fred?

Yes I voted for it and would do so again.

Also since selling my last Spanish property in 2011 I have done my best to avoid spending money in Spain or on Spanish productds

amideislas Sep 3rd 2021 1:36 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Fredbargate (Post 13047384)
Yes I voted for it and would do so again.

Also since selling my last Spanish property in 2011 I have done my best to avoid spending money in Spain or on Spanish productds

are you now living in the UK? Then your job is made easier since it's now more difficult to get Spanish products. Really, you don't even have to work at it.

Not that Spain is all that concerned. It has free access to a 19T$ consumer market.

scrubbedexpat142 Sep 3rd 2021 1:39 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Fredbargate (Post 13047384)
Yes I voted for it and would do so again.

So the mantras "take back control" & "make our own laws" only work one way - fair enough.

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 2:04 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by mikelincs (Post 13047371)
As the UK has LEFT the EU, I very much doubt that the Spanish Government will take any notice of what is, in effect, an internal Spanish problem, perhaps the law in Spain does need to be changed, but petitioning the UK government will do no good whatsoever, even if it did receive the required number of signatures the petitions committee will, no doubt, dismiss is as not something the UK government can interfere with.

Obviously I know the UK cannot force or influence Spain to do anything but the petition is to make 100's of thousands of British people aware of the perils that await them if they buy a property in Spain . I'm on another forum and none of them knew about squatters rights until they experienced first hand.

a. This will make British people more aware.
b. If the petition gets more publicity , it could damage the purchasing of property in Spain and indirectly affect the rental market.

The Scandinavians are already pulling out of buying properties in Spain , and if the UK follows it might make the 'Spanish Ministry Of Interior' think twice about ignoring the plight of property owners whose lives have been damaged by squatters.

amideislas Sep 3rd 2021 2:15 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
This sounds like Daily Mail stuff. "Perils"? I own property in Spain, and not only is it not in any kind of "peril", but has more than doubled in value in just 5 years. And continues to do so.

As far as "squatter" law is concerned, I'm not clear on the details, but I've heard it's quite difficult to get them out once they've installed themselves. And I'd applaud any reasonable changes to that.

The UK however, isn't an appropriate jurisdiction to lobby for this. It has zero influence over these matters.

Assanah Sep 3rd 2021 2:32 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by DOWNANDOUT (Post 13047462)
Obviously I know the UK cannot force or influence Spain to do anything but the petition is to make 100's of thousands of British people aware of the perils that await them if they buy a property in Spain . I'm on another forum and none of them knew about squatters rights until they experienced first hand.

a. This will make British people more aware.
b. If the petition gets more publicity , it could damage the purchasing of property in Spain and indirectly affect the rental market.

The Scandinavians are already pulling out of buying properties in Spain , and if the UK follows it might make the 'Spanish Ministry Of Interior' think twice about ignoring the plight of property owners whose lives have been damaged by squatters.

Maybe people that own second homes should be punished. They push up prices, make housing unaffordable for the people living there, make most communities deserted shitholes for most of the year. I see no value in foreigners buying up houses on a big scale. Maybe the Spanish should hold a referendum about British buying houses in Spanish soil.

bobd22 Sep 3rd 2021 3:07 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Even should this get sufficient signatures to warrant a response from the UK government they will simply say its not something we can change and we can't change the laws of foreign countries. Imagine the outcry if Spain interfered with UK law in this way? Petition the Spanish Government not the British. This is the sort of thing you could have written to an MEP about but we don't have such representation after Brexit.

agree_to_disagree Sep 3rd 2021 3:17 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
I think this thread is a bit ridiculous.

With the backdrop of Brexit and Gibraltar relations are well strained already.

UK government have enough to worry about without sticking their nose in Spanish internal affairs...

With regard to house buyers who were unaware of squatters rigts in Spain, ignorance of law excuses no one...

SanNico Sep 3rd 2021 3:19 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by DOWNANDOUT (Post 13047462)
a. This will make British people more aware.
b. If the petition gets more publicity , it could damage the purchasing of property in Spain and indirectly affect the rental market.

Including the property you need to sell.

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 3:48 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Assanah (Post 13047472)
Maybe people that own second homes should be punished. They push up prices, make housing unaffordable for the people living there, make most communities deserted shitholes for most of the year. I see no value in foreigners buying up houses on a big scale. Maybe the Spanish should hold a referendum about British buying houses in Spanish soil.

People are already being punished by the biased pro-squatter laws and its not just about second homes. A squatter can wait for you to leave your permanent residence (even Spanish domiciles) and then just break in , change the locks and you've got the owners house and his possessions for at least 1-2 years. The electricity and water cannot be cut off otherwise the owner can be prosecuted for coercion and the added bonus is that the owner must pay the utility bills too until the day of eviction. If you've caught the squatter red-handed breaking in then you may have a chance for the police to arrest/evict them but it depends on how the police feel on the day (too much paperwork) and they'll just say 'go through the courts'.

Reasons not to buy a property in Spain? Quite a few come to mind, and someone needs to write about them, so I'll make a start here (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 4:09 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by agree_to_disagree (Post 13047489)
I think this thread is a bit ridiculous.

With the backdrop of Brexit and Gibraltar relations are well strained already.

UK government have enough to worry about without sticking their nose in Spanish internal affairs...

With regard to house buyers who were unaware of squatters rigts in Spain, ignorance of law excuses no one...

Even if you aren't ignorant of the laws, it doesn't matter how many locks and alarms you've installed , if a squatter wishes to get in he will and then your life will become a nightmare.

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 4:14 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by SanNico (Post 13047490)
Including the property you need to sell.

Yes , it will affect sales prices too but why take the risk of spending 1000's of euros through the courts and then reclaiming a house that has been trashed, your possessions sold off or thieved ( building insurance will not cover any damage/loss except the breaking and entering aspect).

DOWNANDOUT Sep 3rd 2021 4:25 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by amideislas (Post 13047466)
This sounds like Daily Mail stuff. "Perils"? I own property in Spain, and not only is it not in any kind of "peril", but has more than doubled in value in just 5 years. And continues to do so.

As far as "squatter" law is concerned, I'm not clear on the details, but I've heard it's quite difficult to get them out once they've installed themselves. And I'd applaud any reasonable changes to that.

The UK however, isn't an appropriate jurisdiction to lobby for this. It has zero influence over these matters.

"I've heard it's quite difficult to get them out once they've installed themselves" - gulp!

Squatters - General La Siesta discussion - La Siesta forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - General Playa Flamenca discussion - Playa Flamenca forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Safety and security information in Pedreguer - Pedreguer forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Legal procedure to deal with SQUATTERS - General La Siesta discussion - La Siesta forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - Safety and security information in Torrevieja - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

SQUATTERS - General property discussion in Monte Azul - Monte Azul forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Here to stay, Javea squatters claim - News in Javea / Xàbia - Javea / Xàbia forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - General Torrevieja discussion - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters hurl rocks at holiday homeowner and TV crew after being filmed breaking into house in Spain’s Seville - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Squatters on Spain’s Costa Blanca took over TWO houses – one to live in, the other to store stolen loot - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Spain’s Costa Blanca Sees Squatters Extorting Money from Holiday and Rental Home Owners - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Spanish Police Evict Gypsy Squatters from Expats home on the Costa del Sol stuck in the UK under lockdown - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

The City Council of Alicante urges the Government to fight against squatters - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Squatters - General property discussion in Torrevieja - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters in Spain, and how to avoid adverse possession (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatters in Spain, and how to evict them from a Spanish property (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatter horror stories in Spain - extortion in Sitges (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

The cost of dealing with squatters in Spain (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatters in Spain: The good, the bad, and the ugly (spanishpropertyinsight.com)


Notdunroamin Sep 3rd 2021 4:59 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by DOWNANDOUT (Post 13047355)
It's not a joke to people who have got squatters

Who, in terms of Brits, probably don't amount to double digits!

I know that personally you've had an horrendous experience but you need to keep it in perspective.




agree_to_disagree Sep 3rd 2021 5:02 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by DOWNANDOUT (Post 13047504)
Its not just about second homes. A squatter can wait for you to leave your permanent residence (even Spanish domiciles) and then just break in

You need to think like a burglar here…

They want a soft-touches, not ones that could see and charged with ´allanamiento de morada´ or breaking and entering.

Any burglar worth his salt will stake out a place and work out the routine when the place is empty. They do their homework and then move in when the occupant is on holidays or away long term like holiday homes. Why run the risks of entering the home of someone who is a permanent resident and has just gone to work. Makes no sense! Lots of properties to target so a smart thief will go for the soft touches not the riskier ones… No data to support that but it is just my instinct on the topic…

amideislas Sep 3rd 2021 5:03 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by DOWNANDOUT (Post 13047526)
"I've heard it's quite difficult to get them out once they've installed themselves" - gulp!

Squatters - General La Siesta discussion - La Siesta forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - General Playa Flamenca discussion - Playa Flamenca forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Safety and security information in Pedreguer - Pedreguer forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Legal procedure to deal with SQUATTERS - General La Siesta discussion - La Siesta forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - Safety and security information in Torrevieja - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

SQUATTERS - General property discussion in Monte Azul - Monte Azul forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Here to stay, Javea squatters claim - News in Javea / Xàbia - Javea / Xàbia forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters - General Torrevieja discussion - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters hurl rocks at holiday homeowner and TV crew after being filmed breaking into house in Spain’s Seville - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Squatters on Spain’s Costa Blanca took over TWO houses – one to live in, the other to store stolen loot - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Spain’s Costa Blanca Sees Squatters Extorting Money from Holiday and Rental Home Owners - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Spanish Police Evict Gypsy Squatters from Expats home on the Costa del Sol stuck in the UK under lockdown - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

The City Council of Alicante urges the Government to fight against squatters - News in Costa Blanca - Costa Blanca forum, Spain

Squatters - General property discussion in Torrevieja - Torrevieja forum - Costa Blanca forum in the Alicante province of Spain

Squatters in Spain, and how to avoid adverse possession (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatters in Spain, and how to evict them from a Spanish property (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatter horror stories in Spain - extortion in Sitges (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

The cost of dealing with squatters in Spain (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

Squatters in Spain: The good, the bad, and the ugly (spanishpropertyinsight.com)

It sounds serious. And in need of serious reevaluation. Luckily our properties aren't in "peril" of this. And neither should yours be.

Still, the UK has zero influence. Might as well petition Madagascar.

agree_to_disagree Sep 3rd 2021 5:24 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Is there a dustbin or filter feature you can use on here to remove a ridiculous thread from the Spain home page?

Rosemary Sep 3rd 2021 5:42 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by agree_to_disagree (Post 13047542)
Is there a dustbin or filter feature you can use on here to remove a ridiculous thread from the Spain home page?

Members are free to ignore any threads that they are not interested in so that is the filter method.

Rosemary

mikelincs Sep 3rd 2021 7:49 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by amideislas (Post 13047535)
It sounds serious. And in need of serious reevaluation. Luckily our properties aren't in "peril" of this. And neither should yours be.

Still, the UK has zero influence. Might as well petition Madagascar.

Almost all of those are Costa Blanca, and most will be holiday homes left unoccupied for months at a time, this was bad in terms of homes left unoccupied, and not only British ones, but where we lived there were Spanish, German, Norwegian etc. all there only for a few months a year. I went to a meeting of the place we lived in and was given 2 votes, I had been given voting rights by my neighbour, German, and never knew, apparently they were given to the previous occupants of our house, and the votes were allocated to the house. There was never any problem with squatters there, mind you it was a gated community eventually.

Fredbargate Sep 4th 2021 7:05 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by amideislas (Post 13047449)
are you now living in the UK?

No

Dxf Sep 4th 2021 9:15 am

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by mikelincs (Post 13047595)
Almost all of those are Costa Blanca, and most will be holiday homes left unoccupied for months at a time, this was bad in terms of homes left unoccupied, and not only British ones, but where we lived there were Spanish, German, Norwegian etc. all there only for a few months a year. I went to a meeting of the place we lived in and was given 2 votes, I had been given voting rights by my neighbour, German, and never knew, apparently they were given to the previous occupants of our house, and the votes were allocated to the house. There was never any problem with squatters there, mind you it was a gated community eventually.

Hola,

Sorry NO, it happens here also. On Police advice, since the squatters weren't actually in the property, we broke in and changed the locks from the ones they had put in. The property was then reoccupied by us, and fortunately, the sale that had been agreed went through a few days later without problem.

Davexf

DOWNANDOUT Sep 4th 2021 1:47 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
ref: amideislas post 31

What do you mean 'neither should yours be' . It has for 3-4 years, read my thread ' Tenant Eviction Nightmare Part 1' and 'Tenant Eviction Nightmare Part2 '.

Guess what? The tenant we evicted via the courts has broken back in again and claiming 'adverse possession'.

DOWNANDOUT Sep 4th 2021 1:49 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
Ref : agree_to_disagree post 32

This thread is being is being removed anyhow . I am raising a new petition that can actually be a UK responsibility , not a request to Spain.

growinspain Sep 4th 2021 2:35 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 

Originally Posted by Fredbargate (Post 13047717)
No

He still bows down and pays for the Queen though.

Rosemary Sep 4th 2021 3:24 pm

Re: ANTI SQUATTER PETITION
 
I am closing this thread at the request of DOWNANDOUT as he is preparing an alternative petitiion.

Rosemary


All times are GMT. The time now is 4:51 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.