How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
#1
How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Interesting not only for the historical moment, but also the choice of words...
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
#2
Account Closed
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 2,502
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
I can't open the link. My office firewall doesn't allow the Guardian.
Interesting not only for the historical moment, but also the choice of words...
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
#4
Hit 16's
Joined: Mar 2010
Location: Of all the gin joints, in all the towns, in all the world, she walks into mine
Posts: 13,112
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
The article's pretty lean, actually, and I echo what someone else commented: What does the author want us to take away from the article?
You'd have thought that, considering the article acknowledges that the Gulf states sit on half the world's proven oil reserves and that Iran invaded despite promising stability, they'd have extrapolated some scenarios. Instead, it ends with a very lame, "The vacuum left by the British withdrawal will be filled successfully by the local powers only if tensions are kept to a minimum." And if not...?
You'd have thought that, considering the article acknowledges that the Gulf states sit on half the world's proven oil reserves and that Iran invaded despite promising stability, they'd have extrapolated some scenarios. Instead, it ends with a very lame, "The vacuum left by the British withdrawal will be filled successfully by the local powers only if tensions are kept to a minimum." And if not...?
#5
Dunroaming back in UK
Joined: Mar 2012
Location: Expat in Yorkshire now
Posts: 11,294
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Interesting not only for the historical moment, but also the choice of words...
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
http://www.theguardian.com/theguardi...tes-sheikhdoms
#6
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
The article's pretty lean, actually, and I echo what someone else commented: What does the author want us to take away from the article?
You'd have thought that, considering the article acknowledges that the Gulf states sit on half the world's proven oil reserves and that Iran invaded despite promising stability, they'd have extrapolated some scenarios. Instead, it ends with a very lame, "The vacuum left by the British withdrawal will be filled successfully by the local powers only if tensions are kept to a minimum." And if not...?
You'd have thought that, considering the article acknowledges that the Gulf states sit on half the world's proven oil reserves and that Iran invaded despite promising stability, they'd have extrapolated some scenarios. Instead, it ends with a very lame, "The vacuum left by the British withdrawal will be filled successfully by the local powers only if tensions are kept to a minimum." And if not...?
#7
Account Closed
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 2,502
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
I was having a Millhouse moment.
In all honesty there's not much to be said about the article despite that they gave us a few genuine nuggets. Iran claimed RAK?
At the time 1/3 of the population were Indians/Pakistanis/other Arabs. It's probably 2/3 now.
Makes one wonder if the British hadn't left in 1971 but held political sway for another few decades, what role the expat population would have in the new nations? With South Asians being the largest bloc, indeed even the outright majority, how different would the politics of the UAE look?
In all honesty there's not much to be said about the article despite that they gave us a few genuine nuggets. Iran claimed RAK?
At the time 1/3 of the population were Indians/Pakistanis/other Arabs. It's probably 2/3 now.
Makes one wonder if the British hadn't left in 1971 but held political sway for another few decades, what role the expat population would have in the new nations? With South Asians being the largest bloc, indeed even the outright majority, how different would the politics of the UAE look?
#8
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 13,553
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Indeed - and I spotted this further down the page:
http://www.theguardian.com/media/201...lan-rusbridger
http://www.theguardian.com/media/201...lan-rusbridger
#9
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
I was having a Millhouse moment.
In all honesty there's not much to be said about the article despite that they gave us a few genuine nuggets. Iran claimed RAK?
At the time 1/3 of the population were Indians/Pakistanis/other Arabs. It's probably 2/3 now.
Makes one wonder if the British hadn't left in 1971 but held political sway for another few decades, what role the expat population would have in the new nations? With South Asians being the largest bloc, indeed even the outright majority, how different would the politics of the UAE look?
In all honesty there's not much to be said about the article despite that they gave us a few genuine nuggets. Iran claimed RAK?
At the time 1/3 of the population were Indians/Pakistanis/other Arabs. It's probably 2/3 now.
Makes one wonder if the British hadn't left in 1971 but held political sway for another few decades, what role the expat population would have in the new nations? With South Asians being the largest bloc, indeed even the outright majority, how different would the politics of the UAE look?
The trucial states were a protectorate not a colony, we genuinely didn't interfere too much in local politics. Sheikh shakbut was deposed with our assistance but at the request of sheikh Zayed but apart from that we acted as a neutral moderator and not overlord with the agreement of all parties. The trucial states were abandoned in 1968 when the labour government decided we couldn't afford to keep troops and the navy in the area. Sheikh Zayed then offered to pay all of the UK costs but we still decided to shut it all down. The formation of the UAE was a direct result of British abandonment so any delay in our disbandment of the 1800's agreement would have made little difference to the now Uae and it's political makeup save perhaps the uk may have had a greater influence in today's politics.
#10
Account Closed
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 0
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Short but still interesting.
#11
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
"the West was looking to Iran...to ensure regional stability"
How times change.
How times change.
#12
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Should we mourn the departure of that great democrat the Shah ?
#14
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Bear in mind what happened to the South Arabian Federation, ie Aden and the former Protectorates. Looking at that set-up no one expected the UAE to last.
#15
Re: How The Guardian reported the formation of the UAE
Bahrain and Qatar both declined to join, albeit rather late in the day, due to squabbling about who would be top dog, as it were.