Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
#1
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
Whut?
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-46288510
Note: it's BBC, not Daily Mail.
There must be more to the story.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-46288510
Note: it's BBC, not Daily Mail.
There must be more to the story.
#2
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
That link is saying he was caught spying for the UK government, but the translated text of the verdict (The National), just states third parties.
So the BBC is saying he was a spy working for the UK? Hmmmm I'm not buying that one. I do know he'd published documents/thesis that were critical towards the UAE and supportive of the muslim brotherhood - a bit weird to come here at all I'd suggest.
"The Federal Appeals Court of Abu Dhabi sentenced Matthew Hedges, 31, to life imprisonment after being convicted of spying on the UAE and providing sensitive security and intelligence information to third parties. The court also ruled that he would be deported from the country after the execution of the sentence and would be charged the costs of the legal case. The court ordered the confiscation of all his equipment, devices, research and studies. The convicted person has the right to challenge the ruling with the State Security Department of the Federal Supreme Court within a maximum period of 30 days."
#3
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
That link is saying he was caught spying for the UK government, but the translated text of the verdict (The National), just states third parties.
So the BBC is saying he was a spy working for the UK? Hmmmm I'm not buying that one. I do know he'd published documents/thesis that were critical towards the UAE and supportive of the muslim brotherhood - a bit weird to come here at all I'd suggest.
So the BBC is saying he was a spy working for the UK? Hmmmm I'm not buying that one. I do know he'd published documents/thesis that were critical towards the UAE and supportive of the muslim brotherhood - a bit weird to come here at all I'd suggest.
What are the odds he serves a token few months and is quickly deported? That this is mainly a warning to other interested parties not to stick their noses where it doesn't belong?
#4
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
Of course we all know this cannot be true. Spying is the preserve of dastardly Russians and Orientals. Clearly Putin has a hand in all of this.
#6
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
Well to be given a life sentence suggests he was caught with his pants down, ie there was clear evidence he was involved in nefarious activities on behalf of the British state. I wonder if MI6 will compensate his family? They've probably told his family to do one
To any future MI6 agents reading this, I suggest you stay out of the GCC countries. Their security services are a LOT better than you might think....
To any future MI6 agents reading this, I suggest you stay out of the GCC countries. Their security services are a LOT better than you might think....
#7
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
My guess is pardoned for either Martyr's/anniversary day holiday or next Eid. I'd guess before Christmas.
Especially with the BBC airing this on Dec 6th.
Especially with the BBC airing this on Dec 6th.
#8
Account Closed
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 0
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
All very strange, the BBC article reads that they were expecting a very different verdict / sentence.
IKnowNothing - if I produced and/or published written words (let's not call it information or evidence or opinion because I just don't know what it may have been) that was very critical of a place I would be very, very hesitant about going to that place. Even if it means your credibility is questioned, it's got a perfect excuse built in that it's so bad you can't go there safely.....mental if what you say is true / correct.
#9
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
You also have to think, if it's all untrue and he really was just doing work on a thesis for his doctorate, why would the Foreign Secretary threaten repercussions? They've never done that before - think of the guys arrested for spying when they were taking pictures, and a whole lot more.
I have a feeling that, because the UK is making such a thing of it, then there's something in it.
I have a feeling that, because the UK is making such a thing of it, then there's something in it.
#10
Forum Regular
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 198
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
I'm not the only one noticing the discrepancy between a life imprisonment and an order to be deported afterwards....
What are the odds he serves a token few months and is quickly deported? That this is mainly a warning to other interested parties not to stick their noses where it doesn't belong?
What are the odds he serves a token few months and is quickly deported? That this is mainly a warning to other interested parties not to stick their noses where it doesn't belong?
#11
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
Let’s put the boot on the other foot and believe all the media BS about him being just a student researching uae security. What would happen if an Emirati PhD student went sniffing around security sensitive sites in Blighty such as army barracks, MI5 headquarters etc and was caught red handed and admitted to it? Would our police/security services simply say “don’t do it again mate” and deport him? Far from it, he would be tried under the Terrorist/Secrets/whatever Act and given a lengthy jail sentence. No sane person on this earth would simply go to another country and research their secret security protocols. Like I said earlier, he was on MI6’s payroll and got caught with his pants down. I guess MI6 underestimated the uae’s capability of catching foreign spies lol
#12
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
Let’s put the boot on the other foot and believe all the media BS about him being just a student researching uae security. What would happen if an Emirati PhD student went sniffing around security sensitive sites in Blighty such as army barracks, MI5 headquarters etc and was caught red handed and admitted to it? Would our police/security services simply say “don’t do it again mate” and deport him? Far from it, he would be tried under the Terrorist/Secrets/whatever Act and given a lengthy jail sentence. No sane person on this earth would simply go to another country and research their secret security protocols. Like I said earlier, he was on MI6’s payroll and got caught with his pants down. I guess MI6 underestimated the uae’s capability of catching foreign spies lol
Methinks he was just a dim chap who asked the wrong questions of the wrong people in his research.
#13
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
MI6 doesn’t hire random PhD students to go spy for them. He’s political leverage for something else.
#14
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
The UAE - for all its draconian laws - doesn't just jail people for life willy nilly despite what you may have read in the Daily Mail. He appears to have been caught red handed with all the evidence on him when stopped at the airport. He definitely wasn't caught with just a few photos of sensitive sites, that is 100% certain.
Gulf News is usually fairly accurate in its reporting and I've no reason to doubt they're telling porkies in this case:
https://gulfnews.com/uae/briton-31-g....1542799607314
*obviously this chap wasn't intelligent enough to NOT get caught in his nefarious activities. Perhaps University standards are slipping these days? lol
Last edited by psychopomp1; Nov 22nd 2018 at 11:28 am.
#15
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2015
Posts: 3,520
Re: Briton jailed for spying in the UAE
I would say those are exactly the type of people our security services would hire: intelligent*, behind a respectable profession and above all, which no-one would ever suspect of being a spy. Remember, the likes of M16 work behind extreme secrecy and there's not a cat in hell's chance, MI6 (or our Gov't) would ever come out and say "yes, he was working as a spy, now pls free him" as that would go against the grain in one of their main aims: keeping their operations secret (even failed operations).
The UAE - for all its draconian laws - doesn't just jail people for life willy nilly despite what you may have read in the Daily Mail. He appears to have been caught red handed with all the evidence on him when stopped at the airport. He deinitely wasn't caught with just a few photos of sensitive sites, that is 100% certain.
Gulf News is usually fairly accurate in its reporting and I've no reason to doubt they're telling porkies in this case:
https://gulfnews.com/uae/briton-31-g....1542799607314
*obviously this chap wasn't intelligent enough to NOT get caught in his nefarious activities. Perhaps University standards are slipping these days? lol
The UAE - for all its draconian laws - doesn't just jail people for life willy nilly despite what you may have read in the Daily Mail. He appears to have been caught red handed with all the evidence on him when stopped at the airport. He deinitely wasn't caught with just a few photos of sensitive sites, that is 100% certain.
Gulf News is usually fairly accurate in its reporting and I've no reason to doubt they're telling porkies in this case:
https://gulfnews.com/uae/briton-31-g....1542799607314
*obviously this chap wasn't intelligent enough to NOT get caught in his nefarious activities. Perhaps University standards are slipping these days? lol
I don't think it's anything more than some Muslim Brotherhood sympathising man asking the wrong questions of the wrong people. There are highly sensitive parties and figures in the UAE that the government keeps a very close watch on and this is their way of sending out warning signals to others.