Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

An interesting article. I am always surprised why people considering a move back to Britain (retirement for example) think of Scotland/Wales and never really thought about Northern Ireland, so there must be some truth to it.


Many British people really don't know what they have with Northern Ireland. Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I can't relate your comment to the content of the linked article.

Whether or not Ulster leaves the UK and joins Eire, should IMO be up to the people of N.I. This has also been the view of successive British governments.

Whether or not the majority of N.I. citizens want unification depends partly on demographics, since the Catholic birthrate remains higher than the Protestant, but it also depends on political and economic factors. Brexit certainly makes unification more likely.

But, I don't understand how you think this makes N.I more attractive for migrants.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I totally agree, Editha. As one who grew up in Northern Ireland, it is hard to explain the nuances of the culture and place to those who have never lived there. The article discusses the supposed indifference of the British government towards Northern Ireland, but says little about the Irish government's attitude, which has displayed much of the same sentiment over the decades. The reality is that neither the British nor Irish governments really know what to do with NI, so it's a dozing dog best left alone and handled at arm's length. The Brexit issue is just bringing it all to the forefront again, due to the fact that it's the UK's only land border with Europe.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

The UK may be indifferent to Northern Ireland but the real block to Irish reunification is that the Republic doesn't want it either. It's simply not worth the hassle.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

So very true! Why would they?

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I'm just saying that although they are British, other British people don't really consider Northern Ireland to be part of Britain and it seems to me that people from the Republic actually now have a better relationship to the place. If you look at it today, most young people would not have a problem being one country and even the rugby team manages to be one team with different religions etc. Who would have thought that Germany would ever be one country???

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I think of N.I as part of Great Britain, and I don't know anyone who doesn't. I'm neither for nor against Irish unification. It is for the people of Ulster to decide. I think it is extremely unlikely that if there was a majority in N.I for unification that either the government of the UK or Eire would oppose them.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

Why wouldn't they? People talk about the hassle etc. Yes, buying your neighbours run down garden is also a hassle at the start but once you actually plan the garden and clean it up, the benefits can be seen.


Yes it costs money, but any investment does.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

Maybe you but many don't. It's not just for Ulster to decide, as people from Connacht, Leinster, Munster would also have to agree. Many people don't see it happening but never say never.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I don't think that polls in Eire have ever showed less than a majority in favour of unification. If Ulster voted for unification, it seems inconceivable to me that the majority of voters in Eire would leave Ulster high and dry, forced either to remain part of the UK against the people's will, or go it alone.

But then, I thought it was inconceivable that Trump would win the US election, so what do I know?

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

Exactly and polls are polls. We also voted for same-sex marriage, so people here aren't always what others try to make us;).


After talking to people from the North, they actually want to move forward and are probably more open than many English these days.

Re: Why reunified Ireland offers best outcome for North’s future
 

I completely agree that it is inconceivable hat the government let alone the majority of the people would vote against re-unification- though I could see Irish government hesitating on the timing of implementation/

I do get impression current state of affairs in NI is more or less acceptable to most, and over time-maybe a long time- the situation will sort itself out.