View Poll Results: Should the New Zealand Government do more to support Ukraine?
No, we should not provide more support.
0
0%
Yes, but only humanitarian aid.
3
27.27%
Yes, any material assistance required (humanitarian, weapons etc.)
8
72.73%
Voters: 11. You may not vote on this poll
Providing aid to Ukraine
#1
Providing aid to Ukraine
As you may be aware New Zealand has started to supply aid to Ukraine to support the Russo-Ukrainian war effort.
Last edited by Charismatic; Apr 20th 2022 at 8:47 am.
#2
Re: Providing aid to Ukraine
I put in that we should provide more material support. While I would normally reserve this to humanitarian support only given New Zealands international stance it's become clear that diplomatic efforts with Russia are proving futile and evidence of war crimes are mounting. Having exhausted all other reasonable options I'm happy for New Zealand to provide whatever assistance we can (including military aid or training for Ukrainians) to expedite the end to this conflict.
If there is to be no ceasefire, either to allow talks or civilians to evacuate conflict zones, then I think we must support the swift and decisive military action required to roll-back the Russian occupation. My hope is that sufficient military pressure will bring Russia to the table. Sadly if violence is the only language Russia will respond to we have few choices in our actions.
Just to be clear though I'm not advocating sending the laser kiwi. We don't want to unleash that kind of destructive capability on Russia. Reasonable usen9f force only.
If there is to be no ceasefire, either to allow talks or civilians to evacuate conflict zones, then I think we must support the swift and decisive military action required to roll-back the Russian occupation. My hope is that sufficient military pressure will bring Russia to the table. Sadly if violence is the only language Russia will respond to we have few choices in our actions.
Just to be clear though I'm not advocating sending the laser kiwi. We don't want to unleash that kind of destructive capability on Russia. Reasonable usen9f force only.
#3
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2013
Location: Perth
Posts: 623
Re: Providing aid to Ukraine
Given that the war is now mostly confined to the Donbass region for the most part most definitely not. The west should be only helping in a humanitarian way and not trying to inflame this. Unfortunately Ukraine is stuck in between a power struggle between east and west
#4
Re: Providing aid to Ukraine
Agree.
#5
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2016
Location: Suffolk
Posts: 744
Re: Providing aid to Ukraine
If, for example, China invaded NZ South Island and occupied everything south of Christchurch would you be in favour of the rest of the world sending only humanitarian aid and encouraging NZ to negotiate a ceasefire and let China keep everything they have occupied?
#6
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2013
Location: Perth
Posts: 623
Re: Providing aid to Ukraine
Not sure what this means.
If, for example, China invaded NZ South Island and occupied everything south of Christchurch would you be in favour of the rest of the world sending only humanitarian aid and encouraging NZ to negotiate a ceasefire and let China keep everything they have occupied?
If, for example, China invaded NZ South Island and occupied everything south of Christchurch would you be in favour of the rest of the world sending only humanitarian aid and encouraging NZ to negotiate a ceasefire and let China keep everything they have occupied?
Another thing i don't like is that the West hold's itself to some higher standard when just a few years ago we had political leaders who deliberately lied in order to justify the invasions of a nation that cost the lives of hundreds of thousands of people. Where innocent people were killed without regard. Imagine if the rest of the world had of sanctioned all those nations involved, banned it's politicians, elite and even athletes from partaking in international events. Calling for these leaders to be held accountable for war crimes. This hypocrisy therefore only exposes the reasons they give for defending Ukraine are not at all genuine and that there is a greater purpose behind it, perhaps to weaken Russia and to punish it for acting out in defiance of the current order. Russia and China in particular have wanted to break off from this world order for some time in which the US holds the dominant position, what we are seeing is that these superpowers saying to the west we don't need you as much as you think and our international affairs will be dictated by our own interests and not yours. This is just the way of the world now, China and India are both increasing importing goods from Russia, it's clear whose side they are on. Look at the deal with the Solomon Islands. It's feels like the world is militarizing once more getting ready for the inevitable. Hopefully it doesn't come to that and that it merely stays as a cold war at most. One thing i know is for certain, pro-longing the war isn't going to help the Ukrainian people at all
#7
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: bottom of the world
Posts: 4,533