Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
#31
Forum Regular
Joined: Feb 2005
Location: West Midlands, UK
Posts: 60
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by deedee
i agree with all you write there, the two or three major player supermarkets are guilty of a clinical destruction of UK producers simply for profit.
Thats one of the issues i have with the UK as a whole.When does it become an acceptable profit, when is it enough to say we're making a profit so lets not screw the supplier anymore?
As a dairy farmer in NZ you will produce about 1.5% to 3% profit, in the UK because of the purchasing power(and there is no other reason for the price as compliance costs are now very similar) they are currently making running at -6%-15%!
I can speak from experience too, as someone i know invested over three million pounds into a farm to produce onions for one of the main retailers.It took over twelve months before production came on stream and after less than one month of production they decided to buy from Holland instead because it saved them 0.5 pence per kilo.Business is business but the point here is that the cost saving was not passed on to the customer, and another huge business in the UK goes bankrupt.
We all love to get things cheap, but the mentality of purchasing power in the UK has lost all its morality.
The UK market is not that big an issue for dairy farmers here, Asia and China is of far more importance.Maybe this is why its not on its knees been stabbed in the back by some smart suit in purchasing for the oh so wonderful, oh such value,we can't live without them supermarkets of Blighty.
There is a social price to pay for demanding ever cheaper goods,i can think of many,perhaps its because the f##k you all attitude is far more prevelant in the UK that this is now why big supermarket business operates that way there?
Thats one of the issues i have with the UK as a whole.When does it become an acceptable profit, when is it enough to say we're making a profit so lets not screw the supplier anymore?
As a dairy farmer in NZ you will produce about 1.5% to 3% profit, in the UK because of the purchasing power(and there is no other reason for the price as compliance costs are now very similar) they are currently making running at -6%-15%!
I can speak from experience too, as someone i know invested over three million pounds into a farm to produce onions for one of the main retailers.It took over twelve months before production came on stream and after less than one month of production they decided to buy from Holland instead because it saved them 0.5 pence per kilo.Business is business but the point here is that the cost saving was not passed on to the customer, and another huge business in the UK goes bankrupt.
We all love to get things cheap, but the mentality of purchasing power in the UK has lost all its morality.
The UK market is not that big an issue for dairy farmers here, Asia and China is of far more importance.Maybe this is why its not on its knees been stabbed in the back by some smart suit in purchasing for the oh so wonderful, oh such value,we can't live without them supermarkets of Blighty.
There is a social price to pay for demanding ever cheaper goods,i can think of many,perhaps its because the f##k you all attitude is far more prevelant in the UK that this is now why big supermarket business operates that way there?
Its the same all over the UK. Big business gets its way because they have to be 'competitive' they claim. The IT industry is awash with 'cheap' Indian labour who get fast-track visas because businesses claim there is a shortage of local talent at 'the right price'... total bollocks particularly as I know plenty of people laid off and replaced by cheap Indians.
Joe consumer is happy - after all everything is so cheap! They simply cannot see the long term effects of this. In this respect I must say I have a lot of time for the French who, amongst other things, will not allow supermarkets to dominate over local/small retailers nor allow competitive pricing measures such as 'loss leaders'.
If it is any comfort I have recently been working on a project for Waitrose and from all I've seen/heard they would appear to be the only supermarket in the UK with an ethical approach to both suppliers and customers. They get the best produce in return (and are the best supermarket by far for meat). You do pay more for your food there as a result but I'm happy to do so.
Now... I'm not sure which, if any, NZ supermarkets are as evil as their UK peers... but I do suspect some of them are making cracking profits out of the average NZ consumer.
BTW - I'm pretty sure Tesco invested in The Warehouse a few years back... could this be a sign of things to come???
Alan.
Last edited by isv; Nov 1st 2005 at 8:08 pm.
#32
Just Joined
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 24
Cost of Electrical Goods
Hi there,
I know people have posted about this on here before, but there seems to be a varying opinion. We're thinking of buying the following items to bring over with us, as we've looked on the net and they're so much more expensive:-
* Decent Double American-style fridge freezer
* Decent TV Projector & Screen
* Decent Amplifier
* Decent AAAA Washing Machine
* Decent AAAA Dishwasher
You can pick all of the above up for around £2,700 in the UK, then the shipping / insurance prices are on top of that (about another £700 maximum), and there will be no warranties if they go wrong. However...looked on an NZ site the other day and the fridge alone was like $5,000NZD, and the washing machines from $1,000+. This was supposedly a 'cheap' site. It seems to me that we're better of getting it here in the January sales and bringing it with us, what do you guys think?! Are we missing some fabulously cheap shop online that does them for the same price as the UK, or are white goods really this ridiculously priced over there?!
Cheers
I know people have posted about this on here before, but there seems to be a varying opinion. We're thinking of buying the following items to bring over with us, as we've looked on the net and they're so much more expensive:-
* Decent Double American-style fridge freezer
* Decent TV Projector & Screen
* Decent Amplifier
* Decent AAAA Washing Machine
* Decent AAAA Dishwasher
You can pick all of the above up for around £2,700 in the UK, then the shipping / insurance prices are on top of that (about another £700 maximum), and there will be no warranties if they go wrong. However...looked on an NZ site the other day and the fridge alone was like $5,000NZD, and the washing machines from $1,000+. This was supposedly a 'cheap' site. It seems to me that we're better of getting it here in the January sales and bringing it with us, what do you guys think?! Are we missing some fabulously cheap shop online that does them for the same price as the UK, or are white goods really this ridiculously priced over there?!
Cheers
#33
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by chez
farmers in the uk getting poorer , food in the supermarkets (uk) is getting more expensive , and tesco's (example) making profits in the billions at the expense of the farmers and the goverment lets them do it!
le
le
I have to say at this time i trust terry Leahy more than Tony Blair.
My answer........pull out of Europe / Abolish CAP and free the markets.....
#34
Just Joined
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 5
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Of course its not cheaper to live her in NZ what else is it linked to than wages the bottom line is that wages in NZ are terrible compared to equivalents around the world. As a plumber/heating engineer I am seriously struggling to keep my head above water - and thats after 4 months. - I think its inevitable that we will end up back in the UK. what shocks me most about NZ is that my quality of life has dropped drasticly when we thought it would improve. The way i see it his country(nz) is in serious trouble - there are 600 people leaving a WEEK, its obvious why- no money here. I can fully understand the comment from the person who said they left due to no money no job and no future, i can really see why that would be true. my personal opinion is that this is one of the most expensive places ive ever been in comparison to wages, my friends inbali indonesia have a better quality of life compared to what they earn.........
#35
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by expomm
Of course its not cheaper to live her in NZ what else is it linked to than wages the bottom line is that wages in NZ are terrible compared to equivalents around the world. As a plumber/heating engineer I am seriously struggling to keep my head above water - and thats after 4 months. - I think its inevitable that we will end up back in the UK. what shocks me most about NZ is that my quality of life has dropped drasticly when we thought it would improve. The way i see it his country(nz) is in serious trouble - there are 600 people leaving a WEEK, its obvious why- no money here. I can fully understand the comment from the person who said they left due to no money no job and no future, i can really see why that would be true. my personal opinion is that this is one of the most expensive places ive ever been in comparison to wages, my friends inbali indonesia have a better quality of life compared to what they earn.........
Some people i'm sure are doing very well but chances are if you want decent cash....you'll be looking outside NZ - just like most kiwi's themselves (myself included) have.
#36
Just Joined
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 5
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
you hit the nail on the head - sad thing is i really like this country it is soo beautifull and coould be an epic place to live if a few problems are addressed.
The fact that people leaving was a topic on campbell live last night is not a good sign though the way i see it the future is pretty bleak here at the mo but i really hope i'm wrong.
The fact that people leaving was a topic on campbell live last night is not a good sign though the way i see it the future is pretty bleak here at the mo but i really hope i'm wrong.
#37
Re: Cost of Electrical Goods
Originally Posted by PRinAuckland
Hi there,
I know people have posted about this on here before, but there seems to be a varying opinion. We're thinking of buying the following items to bring over with us, as we've looked on the net and they're so much more expensive:-
* Decent Double American-style fridge freezer
* Decent TV Projector & Screen
* Decent Amplifier
* Decent AAAA Washing Machine
* Decent AAAA Dishwasher
You can pick all of the above up for around £2,700 in the UK, then the shipping / insurance prices are on top of that (about another £700 maximum), and there will be no warranties if they go wrong. However...looked on an NZ site the other day and the fridge alone was like $5,000NZD, and the washing machines from $1,000+. This was supposedly a 'cheap' site. It seems to me that we're better of getting it here in the January sales and bringing it with us, what do you guys think?! Are we missing some fabulously cheap shop online that does them for the same price as the UK, or are white goods really this ridiculously priced over there?!
Cheers
I know people have posted about this on here before, but there seems to be a varying opinion. We're thinking of buying the following items to bring over with us, as we've looked on the net and they're so much more expensive:-
* Decent Double American-style fridge freezer
* Decent TV Projector & Screen
* Decent Amplifier
* Decent AAAA Washing Machine
* Decent AAAA Dishwasher
You can pick all of the above up for around £2,700 in the UK, then the shipping / insurance prices are on top of that (about another £700 maximum), and there will be no warranties if they go wrong. However...looked on an NZ site the other day and the fridge alone was like $5,000NZD, and the washing machines from $1,000+. This was supposedly a 'cheap' site. It seems to me that we're better of getting it here in the January sales and bringing it with us, what do you guys think?! Are we missing some fabulously cheap shop online that does them for the same price as the UK, or are white goods really this ridiculously priced over there?!
Cheers
Robert
#38
Forum Regular
Joined: Nov 2005
Location: london-temp
Posts: 31
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by expomm
you hit the nail on the head - sad thing is i really like this country it is soo beautifull and coould be an epic place to live if a few problems are addressed.
The fact that people leaving was a topic on campbell live last night is not a good sign though the way i see it the future is pretty bleak here at the mo but i really hope i'm wrong.
The fact that people leaving was a topic on campbell live last night is not a good sign though the way i see it the future is pretty bleak here at the mo but i really hope i'm wrong.
#39
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by Buzzy--Bee
I mentioned to my Kiwi Mother in Law that many people on this website were struggling financially, including a family of 4 I had read about who were living in Auckland on $65000.
Her response was "well they must be living very extravagantly then".
Im ny experience Kiwis cannot believe anything could be more expensive in NZ than in the UK.
Would anyone like to comment on this?
Her response was "well they must be living very extravagantly then".
Im ny experience Kiwis cannot believe anything could be more expensive in NZ than in the UK.
Would anyone like to comment on this?
New Zealand is a very expensive country, wages are very poor. Lived in CHCH for a year and it sucked us dry. Best scenery i have every seen, BUT YOU CAN'T EAT IT CAN YA! and that is the problem. House prices are just daft (as anyplace) and as long as you like chopping wood and trying to light it when wet.....freez due to poor house constuction when it snows. Yes it snows! Just check out my old posts. Still we all miss it to be honest. The UK is over crowded and nasty. If i had plenty of money we would go back, but not otherwise.
#40
Victorian Evangelist
Thread Starter
Joined: Sep 2005
Location: Melbourne, by the beach, living the dream.
Posts: 7,704
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by Lenmil
New Zealand is a very expensive country, wages are very poor. Lived in CHCH for a year and it sucked us dry. Best scenery i have every seen, BUT YOU CAN'T EAT IT CAN YA! and that is the problem. House prices are just daft (as anyplace) and as long as you like chopping wood and trying to light it when wet.....freez due to poor house constuction when it snows. Yes it snows! Just check out my old posts. Still we all miss it to be honest. The UK is over crowded and nasty. If i had plenty of money we would go back, but not otherwise.
#41
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by isv
It is this way in the UK because the government are happy for it to be so. Ditto the shear numbers of illegal/off-the-books employees - the gangmasters provide dirt-cheap labour for the farmers so that they may stand some chance of deliverying on just-in-time supermarket contracts. The government turn a blind eye because if they didn't the supermarkets would claim that prices would have to increase.
Its the same all over the UK. Big business gets its way because they have to be 'competitive' they claim. The IT industry is awash with 'cheap' Indian labour who get fast-track visas because businesses claim there is a shortage of local talent at 'the right price'... total bollocks particularly as I know plenty of people laid off and replaced by cheap Indians.
Joe consumer is happy - after all everything is so cheap! They simply cannot see the long term effects of this. In this respect I must say I have a lot of time for the French who, amongst other things, will not allow supermarkets to dominate over local/small retailers nor allow competitive pricing measures such as 'loss leaders'.
If it is any comfort I have recently been working on a project for Waitrose and from all I've seen/heard they would appear to be the only supermarket in the UK with an ethical approach to both suppliers and customers. They get the best produce in return (and are the best supermarket by far for meat). You do pay more for your food there as a result but I'm happy to do so.
Now... I'm not sure which, if any, NZ supermarkets are as evil as their UK peers... but I do suspect some of them are making cracking profits out of the average NZ consumer.
BTW - I'm pretty sure Tesco invested in The Warehouse a few years back... could this be a sign of things to come???
Alan.
Its the same all over the UK. Big business gets its way because they have to be 'competitive' they claim. The IT industry is awash with 'cheap' Indian labour who get fast-track visas because businesses claim there is a shortage of local talent at 'the right price'... total bollocks particularly as I know plenty of people laid off and replaced by cheap Indians.
Joe consumer is happy - after all everything is so cheap! They simply cannot see the long term effects of this. In this respect I must say I have a lot of time for the French who, amongst other things, will not allow supermarkets to dominate over local/small retailers nor allow competitive pricing measures such as 'loss leaders'.
If it is any comfort I have recently been working on a project for Waitrose and from all I've seen/heard they would appear to be the only supermarket in the UK with an ethical approach to both suppliers and customers. They get the best produce in return (and are the best supermarket by far for meat). You do pay more for your food there as a result but I'm happy to do so.
Now... I'm not sure which, if any, NZ supermarkets are as evil as their UK peers... but I do suspect some of them are making cracking profits out of the average NZ consumer.
BTW - I'm pretty sure Tesco invested in The Warehouse a few years back... could this be a sign of things to come???
Alan.
being a partnership (are they still??) i guess means they have less profit motive?
#42
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by deedee
There is a social price to pay for demanding ever cheaper goods,i can think of many,perhaps its because the f##k you all attitude is far more prevelant in the UK that this is now why big supermarket business operates that way there?
there is also an element of misrepresentation - kiwi's do tend to overstate the cost of living argument.... granted people should do their homework but the proof of the pudding is often in the eating (yum).
Last edited by turkeytickler; Nov 4th 2005 at 9:57 am. Reason: Wanted to add to it
#43
farmer nr Queenstown NZ
Joined: Jul 2003
Location: doing stuff, lots of stuff
Posts: 367
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by kelvynd
I'm not sure anyone will argue with you over the fact wages are cr.ap in NZ.
Some people i'm sure are doing very well but chances are if you want decent cash....you'll be looking outside NZ - just like most kiwi's themselves (myself included) have.
Some people i'm sure are doing very well but chances are if you want decent cash....you'll be looking outside NZ - just like most kiwi's themselves (myself included) have.
I Will.Farming employs over 10% of NZ's population.The farmers in NZ for the last five years have earned more money from farming than any other place in the world, like for like.The same set up in the UK would earn us about 170% less for about 500-900% the cost!One case of the wages are greener on the other side of the ditch.
Turkeytickler, great name by the way , i do agree with you in that people are the same the world over.The me me thing is here, its only that as a proportion its tiny compared to the UK with its millions of people.
The conclution i've reached is the problems are the same where ever you are, only these increase with the rate of people and are more noticable,or not as noticable in small town NZ.As pressure rises due to the cost of living increases the f##k you attitude gets more popular, and i think many migrants on here forget there are a lot of very poor people in the UK.
Its not all doom and gloom in NZ, many people like it here, it wouldn't be what it is if everyone and his dog came to live here.
#44
Just Joined
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 12
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by deedee
I Will.Farming employs over 10% of NZ's population.The farmers in NZ for the last five years have earned more money from farming than any other place in the world, like for like.The same set up in the UK would earn us about 170% less for about 500-900% the cost!One case of the wages are greener on the other side of the ditch.
Turkeytickler, great name by the way , i do agree with you in that people are the same the world over.The me me thing is here, its only that as a proportion its tiny compared to the UK with its millions of people.
The conclution i've reached is the problems are the same where ever you are, only these increase with the rate of people and are more noticable,or not as noticable in small town NZ.As pressure rises due to the cost of living increases the f##k you attitude gets more popular, and i think many migrants on here forget there are a lot of very poor people in the UK.
Its not all doom and gloom in NZ, many people like it here, it wouldn't be what it is if everyone and his dog came to live here.
Turkeytickler, great name by the way , i do agree with you in that people are the same the world over.The me me thing is here, its only that as a proportion its tiny compared to the UK with its millions of people.
The conclution i've reached is the problems are the same where ever you are, only these increase with the rate of people and are more noticable,or not as noticable in small town NZ.As pressure rises due to the cost of living increases the f##k you attitude gets more popular, and i think many migrants on here forget there are a lot of very poor people in the UK.
Its not all doom and gloom in NZ, many people like it here, it wouldn't be what it is if everyone and his dog came to live here.
#45
By name and by nature
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 1,852
Re: Kiwis can't believe we have a problem with cost of living
Originally Posted by chez
deedee spot on!
Benultimate - there's LOADS of Kiwis I've spoken to who are struggling. I don't hold it up as an example of how bad New Zealand is in this regard. It's just the way things are here. I don't have bad wages and I live in Auckland, married to my Kiwi husband and I love it here. But, a colleague of mine told me the other day that he'd been under a lot of pressure with bills mounting up and he'd cashed in somes investments (he didn't say but I took it to mean an insurance policy) to take the heat off. And, he's not badly paid either but he's got four kids and his wife doesn't work. I don't whinge - I have nothing to whinge about thankfully, but scenery doesn't pay the bills and you can't go skiing if you can't afford it, so a little tolerance for something that hasn't affected you personally can go a long way.