Cyclone Gabrielle
#16
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
It is not the rain is it. It is the lack of timely action by the one in ultimate charge to call y'know , action.
It isn't an episode from Black Adder who had more integrity.
Would calling a state of emergency earlier have made the slightest bit if difference... No
Last edited by BEVS; Jan 30th 2023 at 7:43 am.
#17
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2016
Location: Suffolk
Posts: 744
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
Elton John concert was probably all to do with insurance.
Authorities declare an emergency and the organisers are covered.
They just make a judgement call and they could be liable for the losses.
Brinkmanship.
Authorities declare an emergency and the organisers are covered.
They just make a judgement call and they could be liable for the losses.
Brinkmanship.
#18
#19
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 162
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
#21
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: bottom of the world
Posts: 4,533
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
How would it have altered things
Rain would still be falling
Streets, houses and businesses would still be flooding.
slips would still be happening.
kayakers would still be getting sucked into Storm drains
Roads were already being closed
Rescues were already happening
Police, fire services and teams with irb's were already out.
Maybe the Elton John fans might have got home a bit earlier but I can't see what else would have changed apart from a lot people in the eoc ringing a lot of other people for updates
Rain would still be falling
Streets, houses and businesses would still be flooding.
slips would still be happening.
kayakers would still be getting sucked into Storm drains
Roads were already being closed
Rescues were already happening
Police, fire services and teams with irb's were already out.
Maybe the Elton John fans might have got home a bit earlier but I can't see what else would have changed apart from a lot people in the eoc ringing a lot of other people for updates
Last edited by Justcol; Jan 31st 2023 at 5:01 pm.
#22
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
I wrote this " The general emergency response to an event is led by first response units at the outset. The point it tips to state of emergency ( in NZ) is when all units are at saturation point ( pun not intended)"
Originally Posted by Justcol
How would it have altered things
Is there a lack of understanding over what NEMA is and does and also the role of Civil Defence maybe. What calling a State of Emergency allows. How an EOC performs . Given the climate in general is and has altered for the worst and these 'once on 100 year' events are going to become more the norm , maybe a heavy duty publicity campaign is needed to up the NEMA/CD profiles and have the nation understand better what happens and whats needed to afford the public on the sharp end the information and assistance they need in times of strife. The Nelson Mayor was sterling in this during August 2022.
Note that there is currently a national accreditation and audit happening re civil defence so all teams , paid and volunteer alike, operate from one page . Through that they will all be able to deploy out of their areas. It has been mooted that this need apply to Mayors of local authorities as well as a part of their induction into their public funded role. Looking at the past few days for Auckland I'd say that needs to become a definite , although the Nelson mayor was sterling during the August 2022 atmospheric river event here. Boots on ground. Informed . Fronting.
Last edited by BEVS; Jan 31st 2023 at 9:48 pm.
#23
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
Yes. It is a bad'un. I hope it abates soon and I also hope that you and yours, plus anyone up there in the midst of this is holding up best you can be with little to no damage.
MrBEVS and the SI teams here are still on a stand by . I believe that other NI teams are possibly already deployed.
To be honest, our own region still hasn't recovered from August. That's housing , roading , infrastructure. It takes a fair old while. Westport on the West Coat remains munted really.
Perhaps there needs be a mention of the first and second responders + co-ordinators and personnel management . Those teams work in shifts. They will do double shifts or round the clock BUT their safety needs to be addressed also. Therefore there needs to be extra responders & co-ordinators available to relieve the load. NEMA does that.
MrBEVS and the SI teams here are still on a stand by . I believe that other NI teams are possibly already deployed.
To be honest, our own region still hasn't recovered from August. That's housing , roading , infrastructure. It takes a fair old while. Westport on the West Coat remains munted really.
Perhaps there needs be a mention of the first and second responders + co-ordinators and personnel management . Those teams work in shifts. They will do double shifts or round the clock BUT their safety needs to be addressed also. Therefore there needs to be extra responders & co-ordinators available to relieve the load. NEMA does that.
#24
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,810
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
You make it sound like emergency services were sitting on their hands waiting for Wayne Brown to give them an order. Emergency services perform amazing feats in-spite of politicians, not because of them. It would have been all hands on deck before a state of emergency was called. Sometimes politicians are best to stay well out of their way.
Last edited by Pollyana; Feb 1st 2023 at 1:12 am.
#25
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
Something seems to have become a little muddled.
The EOC was already up and running . The first & second responders were already doing their work per the calls and intel. That would be both the retained and the volunteer teams. The agencies would have been liaising & pushing out info etc. The issue here is that the Mayor who is a front man was not fronting. Neither was he pro-active. What he has been, subsequently ,is critical of said EOC and the agencies. So in that respect I suppose you could say this Mayor , having done nothing whilst people suffered, is now a liability. His deputy appears a little more able.
The EOC was already up and running . The first & second responders were already doing their work per the calls and intel. That would be both the retained and the volunteer teams. The agencies would have been liaising & pushing out info etc. The issue here is that the Mayor who is a front man was not fronting. Neither was he pro-active. What he has been, subsequently ,is critical of said EOC and the agencies. So in that respect I suppose you could say this Mayor , having done nothing whilst people suffered, is now a liability. His deputy appears a little more able.
#26
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: bottom of the world
Posts: 4,533
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
Sorry, still not seeing how calling it earlier would have changed one single thing apart from making a few people in the EOC feel better because they were involved.
Floods would still have happened and I doubt a single life would have been saved. One death was a fool kayaking in the flood waters and another was an clown roaming around filming himself trying to look like a hero for his social media. I have no sympathy for people who put others at risk due to their stupidity.
Floods would still have happened and I doubt a single life would have been saved. One death was a fool kayaking in the flood waters and another was an clown roaming around filming himself trying to look like a hero for his social media. I have no sympathy for people who put others at risk due to their stupidity.
#27
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,810
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
Sorry, still not seeing how calling it earlier would have changed one single thing apart from making a few people in the EOC feel better because they were involved.
Floods would still have happened and I doubt a single life would have been saved. One death was a fool kayaking in the flood waters and another was an clown roaming around filming himself trying to look like a hero for his social media. I have no sympathy for people who put others at risk due to their stupidity.
Floods would still have happened and I doubt a single life would have been saved. One death was a fool kayaking in the flood waters and another was an clown roaming around filming himself trying to look like a hero for his social media. I have no sympathy for people who put others at risk due to their stupidity.
#30
re: Cyclone Gabrielle
With & as the State Of Emergency is still in place & because nasty , nasty cyclone Gabrielle bearing down on the NI ( and perhaps parts of upper SI) NEMA has called upon out of region Civil Defence to volunteer & deploy to work where needed. Consequently MrBEVS is on standby to fly out sometime in the next couple of days. It's a fly out - 5 days - fly back rotation schedule.
Wishing everyone in its path the best .
Wishing everyone in its path the best .