![]() |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by roaringmouse
(Post 11211841)
If the question is very relevant to you, and for 18 years the answer has been to return "home", then why haven't you already returned?That was kind of my point in questioning the relevancy.
It seems for the OP the answer to the question is leading them to move back to the UK (presuming it happens this time). For someone else the answer for 18 years has been to return if their partner died, but it hasn't resulted them in returning at any time before now. So I don't get the point of using the answer to the question what would you do if your partner died in order to make a decision on moving now while both are still alive. If you really felt like you couldn't live alone where you migrated together in the first place, then why did you migrate? Was it the dream of other person and you tagged along or something? I can understand it when people are in an inter-national marriage - you live in the US because your spouse is from there and because they live there. If they die, your main reason for being there is gone. Analogous (but different) situation would be living in a place because "the job is there" -if you lose your job, or retire, the reason for being there is gone (I don't plan on staying here when I retire, for example). I can also understand it if spouse A wants to live in the US and spouse B doesn't - if spouse A dies, the reason for spouse B living in the US is gone. But when both parties say they'd go home if the other died, I find it a bit harder to understand, except maybe if you didn't have any/many friends or family in the US, then you'd be lonely and would go home to be back with your old friends and family. Interesting topic, but still seems a bit of a morbid topic for a "dinner party" conversation. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
I can understand it when people are in an inter-national marriage - you live in the US because your spouse is from there and because they live there. If they die, your main reason for being there is gone.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
I can also understand it if spouse A wants to live in the US and spouse B doesn't - if spouse A dies, the reason for spouse B living in the US is gone.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
But when both parties say they'd go home if the other died, I find it a bit harder to understand
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
Interesting topic, but still seems a bit of a morbid topic for a "dinner party" conversation.
|
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
Interesting topic, but still seems a bit of a morbid topic for a "dinner party" conversation. It's one of the few subjects that is relevant to every single person in the world - we're all going to drop off the perch eventually. Far from being 'morbid', it's realistic and healthy to talk about it. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by spouse of scouse
(Post 11211931)
Why? Is there a particular setting that you think the topic of death should be confined to?
It's one of the few subjects that is relevant to every single person in the world - we're all going to drop off the perch eventually. Far from being 'morbid', it's realistic and healthy to talk about it. I'm perfectly happy (? maybe not the right word!) to discuss these topics, but if someone asked me at a dinner party what I'd do if my (insert name of favourite person) died, I'd probably suggest they lighten up and don't spoil the mood. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by spouse of scouse
(Post 11211931)
Why? Is there a particular setting that you think the topic of death should be confined to?
It's one of the few subjects that is relevant to every single person in the world - we're all going to drop off the perch eventually. Far from being 'morbid', it's realistic and healthy to talk about it. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by Stormer999
(Post 11211977)
Being British we are too busy talking about the rain........;)
Only three certainties in life - death, taxes and rain. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
I think so many couples cannot bear to talk about death as if it might hasten it! But it is important to discuss what each wants to happen. A close friend of ours died last year and in the months preceding his death, he wrote down all his "instructions", shredded papers he did not need etc. When he became very ill and subsequently died, there were no doubts as to what his wishes were. It made it so much easier for his wife and family.
|
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by roaringmouse
(Post 11211841)
If the question is very relevant to you, and for 18 years the answer has been to return "home", then why haven't you already returned?That was kind of my point in questioning the relevancy.
It seems for the OP the answer to the question is leading them to move back to the UK (presuming it happens this time). For someone else the answer for 18 years has been to return if their partner died, but it hasn't resulted them in returning at any time before now. So I don't get the point of using the answer to the question what would you do if your partner died in order to make a decision on moving now while both are still alive. If you really felt like you couldn't live alone where you migrated together in the first place, then why did you migrate? Was it the dream of other person and you tagged along or something? If you do not see the point of the OP's question...then don't click on the thread. So far no one has agreed with you...but they have answered the OP and agree with her. Please do not take the thread off topic...open a new thread. Thanks. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
I have moved The off topic posts into a new thread....
http://britishexpats.com/forum/showthread.php?t=830917 |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by spouse of scouse
(Post 11211931)
Why? Is there a particular setting that you think the topic of death should be confined to?
It's one of the few subjects that is relevant to every single person in the world - we're all going to drop off the perch eventually. Far from being 'morbid', it's realistic and healthy to talk about it. Dad's. But if its never talked about people will not know what personal wishes are involved. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Interesting related question would be, "If you and your spouse got divorced, would you stay in the country?" I wonder for how many people the answer would be different than for the original question (the death one).
We have a lot of people on BE who moved overseas with spouses, or to marry spouses, and got divorced. IIRC, most of them didn't return to the UK at the time (except for those who divorced because the other spouse wouldn't leave the country, so the two things were wrapped up). The whole issue of what you would do differently if you were suddenly widowed, divorced, etc. is an interesting one (except for my "death conversation during dinner" misgivings, of course ;)). I suppose if you'd change anything major it maybe tells you something about your current life. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11211900)
But when both parties say they'd go home if the other died, I find it a bit harder to understand, except maybe if you didn't have any/many friends or family in the US, then you'd be lonely and would go home to be back with your old friends and family. Interesting topic, but still seems a bit of a morbid topic for a "dinner party" conversation. I because I am only here because my DW wanted a bit of an adventure after bringing up children and always doing the "safe" thing. I am just as happy anywhere, have lived and worked in quite a few different countries in my time, but simply love England. She because she has NO linguistic ability. When we first tried Spain, she trotted out little bits of French. Now we are in France, all she can remember is the odd bit of Spanish. (I would suggest Italy, but think she might forget how to make lasagne;)) There are a lot of people out here where only one half speaks the language, and if they pass on, the other is left absolutely stranded. European countries are VERY bureaucratic, (and I am not blind to the UKs move in that direction), so if you do not speak the language you can wind up in real trouble. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by michali
(Post 11212025)
I think so many couples cannot bear to talk about death as if it might hasten it! But it is important to discuss what each wants to happen. A close friend of ours died last year and in the months preceding his death, he wrote down all his "instructions", shredded papers he did not need etc. When he became very ill and subsequently died, there were no doubts as to what his wishes were. It made it so much easier for his wife and family.
This could have been me or any one of my housemates on three separate occasions. Death certainly has the effect of helping you to focus on what is important in your life (including where you want to live - or don't, as the case may be). |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11212708)
I suppose if you'd change anything major it maybe tells you something about your current life.
Yes. |
Re: Thee Question to ask about returning to the UK.
Originally Posted by dunroving
(Post 11212708)
Interesting related question would be, "If you and your spouse got divorced, would you stay in the country?" I wonder for how many people the answer would be different than for the original question (the death one).
Cheers Nigel |
| All times are GMT -12. The time now is 2:32 am. |
Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.