High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2018
Posts: 22
High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
We're starting to make some concrete plans for our move from Canada to England, and we're having second thoughts about bringing our cats. We have 2 cats, both less than 3 years old - one of them is very outgoing and adaptable and would most likely have no issues at all with the move. The other one is a different story - he is very easily stressed and very skittish with strangers (sometimes even with us). It had always been part of the plan to bring them with us, but lately we've been reconsidering as we see how stressed out he's been getting just with the upset to his routine with people in and out of our house for viewings while we've had our house up for sale.
Has anyone else had experience with a super-anxious cat making the long-haul flight? We just don't know how he would handle it with all the strange sounds and surroundings, and we're wondering if it would be kinder to him to try and find him a new home for both of them (we think it would be cruel to split them up). I know he would still have anxiety issues adjusting to his new family, but it would likely be a lot easier on him than making a 8 hour flight.
So conflicted...any advice from those with similar situations would be appreciated!
Has anyone else had experience with a super-anxious cat making the long-haul flight? We just don't know how he would handle it with all the strange sounds and surroundings, and we're wondering if it would be kinder to him to try and find him a new home for both of them (we think it would be cruel to split them up). I know he would still have anxiety issues adjusting to his new family, but it would likely be a lot easier on him than making a 8 hour flight.
So conflicted...any advice from those with similar situations would be appreciated!
#2
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
My Tyler was a one person cat. He would skedaddle when other people were around. Any sign of anything different or unusual and he was off . Putting him in a cat carrier was a mission. We were both often stressed out by the time this was achieved and he often disgraced himself on his way to a vet visit. He would cling to me.
Tyler made the trip from the UK to NZ back in 2004. That is two long haul flights. He breezed the trip with no ill effects & then had to put up with a good couple of weeks of a cattery. He was just so pleased to see me when I followed him a few weeks later. I will never forget those purrs or shake tail welcome before he launched himself into my arms.
I cannot say what you should do for your pusscat. I can only say how it was for Ty.
Tyler made the trip from the UK to NZ back in 2004. That is two long haul flights. He breezed the trip with no ill effects & then had to put up with a good couple of weeks of a cattery. He was just so pleased to see me when I followed him a few weeks later. I will never forget those purrs or shake tail welcome before he launched himself into my arms.
I cannot say what you should do for your pusscat. I can only say how it was for Ty.
#3
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Cats aren't humans, so while it is tempting to try to apply what makes you anxious to your cat, or even try to apply what you see makes your cat anxious to your expectation of how you think your cat might react to flying, that may not be a good predictor of how your cat actually reacts to being in the hold of a plane. Cat's generally like, and seek out dark hidey-holes so while your cat might not like being carried in a box in a car in the day time, being in the hold of a plane might be seen totally differently if you were a cat - most of us would hate being crated and put in a dark place, but we aren't cats.
#4
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jun 2015
Location: France
Posts: 861
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Don’t forget you can get tranquilisers from the vet so even though the full effects will wear off at some point he’ll still be pleasantly doped up.
#5
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Hi Nate: I'm an animal lover and rescuer. The only thing you may not have contemplated is the length of time your kitty will have to stay in quarantine at home. That long time may fray his nerves far more than a long plane ride. Good luck with your move.
#6
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
It isn't recommended to sedate a pet for flying. They prefer that this is not done.
#9
Auntie Fa
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Seattle
Posts: 7,344
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
I'm with BEVS, please ignore advice to drug your cats. You have no idea what reaction they may have when nobody is watching them. We did put Rescue Remedy in their water for a few days prior to moving ours but I'm never convinced about that stuff (for animals or humans).
Two of our three were hand-reared, all three neurotic. I won't lie and say the move (Singapore to Sydney so a similar flight to yours) and a month in quarantine was a breeze, they were definitely affected by it, but 11 years on they seem to have forgiven us.
I know nothing about quarantine for the UK, sorry.
(We did say we'd never move them again but here we find ourselves, planning to move two of them to the US - a much longer journey - when the third's cancer gets the better of him.)
Two of our three were hand-reared, all three neurotic. I won't lie and say the move (Singapore to Sydney so a similar flight to yours) and a month in quarantine was a breeze, they were definitely affected by it, but 11 years on they seem to have forgiven us.
I know nothing about quarantine for the UK, sorry.
(We did say we'd never move them again but here we find ourselves, planning to move two of them to the US - a much longer journey - when the third's cancer gets the better of him.)
#10
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Indeed. Australian vets refuse point blank to provide pet sedatives for flights. If the pet has an adverse reaction to the sedative there is no one there to help them in-flight.
#11
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2018
Posts: 22
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Thanks to everyone for the input. I know there's no right answer to this - we're just going to have to weigh everything out and make what will be the best decision for us and our little fluffball.
#12
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Our cat would never tolerate an overseas flight, especially now that they go into the plane's cargo hold. We also think it's somewhat cruel to the animal. Dogs are much more outgoing and do better in such travel. I've never seen a cat hang its head out of a speeding car window enjoying the wind like dogs. Maybe we just have a very sensitive cat.
#13
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Our cat would never tolerate an overseas flight, especially now that they go into the plane's cargo hold. We also think it's somewhat cruel to the animal. Dogs are much more outgoing and do better in such travel. I've never seen a cat hang its head out of a speeding car window enjoying the wind like dogs. Maybe we just have a very sensitive cat.
It isn't cruel at all. It is practical all round if you wish to remain with your cat. What can be a little difficult for a cat or dog I feel is taking them into a passenger cabin with all the noise and smells + confinement.
I am not sure why or how you know that dogs fare better than cats or perhaps also horses during flights . In my experience and that of others that we know who flew their cats UK to New Zealand , that is not the case. I have however heard of a dog that passed away not long after arriving in NZ. Whether that was the flughts, age or health was not determined . It was sad.
Originally Posted by NateWagner
Thanks to everyone for the input. I know there's no right answer to this - we're just going to have to weigh everything out and make what will be the best decision for us and our little fluffball.
As I wrote, I brought out my cats, one of which was a very angsty puss , maybe down to the fact he was part burmese. He breezed it and he had many more happy years with us even though he remained wary of other people, the vet building and the dreaded pet carrier.
#14
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2013
Location: Chicago
Posts: 470
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Has your cat ever done one? My cats have. Back to back long haul + internal.
It isn't cruel at all. It is practical all round if you wish to remain with your cat. What can be a little difficult for a cat or dog I feel is taking them into a passenger cabin with all the noise and smells + confinement.
I am not sure why or how you know that dogs fare better than cats or perhaps also horses during flights . In my experience and that of others that we know who flew their cats UK to New Zealand , that is not the case. I have however heard of a dog that passed away not long after arriving in NZ. Whether that was the flughts, age or health was not determined . It was sad.
It isn't cruel at all. It is practical all round if you wish to remain with your cat. What can be a little difficult for a cat or dog I feel is taking them into a passenger cabin with all the noise and smells + confinement.
I am not sure why or how you know that dogs fare better than cats or perhaps also horses during flights . In my experience and that of others that we know who flew their cats UK to New Zealand , that is not the case. I have however heard of a dog that passed away not long after arriving in NZ. Whether that was the flughts, age or health was not determined . It was sad.
In my city, there are occasional episodes of pet deaths in cargo holds, mostly due to inadequate temperature or pressurization. Despite cabin noises and people, pets are much safer and more comfortable with and near their owner in the cabin. It's much more rare that a pet death occurs in the cabin next to the owner than separated in the cargo hold.
As I said, we each have our own opinions on this. We can't ask the pets obviously, but for cats I still think in general it's very unnatural and causes quite a bit of discomfort. To me, this is cruel. But I don't disagree that sometimes it's a necessity and better than having the pet abandoned or given up to a pet shelter.
Last edited by Richard8655; Mar 14th 2019 at 2:07 am.
#15
Auntie Fa
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: Seattle
Posts: 7,344
Re: High Anxiety Cat - should he fly?
Many thousands of us have moved our cats. In Singapore the alternative is often to chuck them back on the street - and yes I have seen it done by so-called animal-loving expats. Which is the more cruel?
I would have stayed put rather than leave mine on the streets.
I would have stayed put rather than leave mine on the streets.