going back..shannon imm experiences
#17
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
I wont lie , just see what happens i guess , what a nightmare..i blame the government !!!
#18
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Eugene, OR
Posts: 1,352
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
You blame the government? Why? Getting the reentry permit was your obligation if you felt you would want to return to the US.
#19
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
Hmm, I wonder if the entitlement to a hearing applies to PFI stations?
Interesting issue.
Consult with an attorney. BTW, sad to say, most immigration attorneys are not up on the law of abandonment.
In consultation, you want to find out if the attorney has ever tried at least one abandonment case. [Not an iron clad test -- but a good indication]. Also ask about familiarity with "Kane" and "Huang."
BTW, don't blame the government -- you are the one who has stayed out of the US. You may have had damn good reasons, but your attitude may very well get you in trouble. [I want to make clear that this is not meant as criticism -- but you really don't want to irritate government officials. One particularly aggressive immigration attorney I know, who would give Nancy Grace a run for her money, often lectures on the need to "grovel."]
Good luck.
Interesting issue.
Consult with an attorney. BTW, sad to say, most immigration attorneys are not up on the law of abandonment.
In consultation, you want to find out if the attorney has ever tried at least one abandonment case. [Not an iron clad test -- but a good indication]. Also ask about familiarity with "Kane" and "Huang."
BTW, don't blame the government -- you are the one who has stayed out of the US. You may have had damn good reasons, but your attitude may very well get you in trouble. [I want to make clear that this is not meant as criticism -- but you really don't want to irritate government officials. One particularly aggressive immigration attorney I know, who would give Nancy Grace a run for her money, often lectures on the need to "grovel."]
Good luck.
Last edited by S Folinsky; Jul 22nd 2011 at 9:58 pm.
#20
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
I understand your comments..but what is one supposed to do ? let there kids starve ? sit on there arse and do **** all about it ? at least i had an option , which i took.
#21
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
You came here asking a question. That is good -- but don't alienate the people trying to help you.
#22
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
They might say something, they might say nothing, you won't know until you get to the POE. You will be let in because you have a green card, but as JEff says, you might end up with an appointment before an Immigration Judge who will make the final determination whether you've abandoned your PR status or not.
I agree with all the others, have a consultation with an attorney experienced in PR abandonment.
Rene
#23
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Eugene, OR
Posts: 1,352
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
Yes, you took a good option to support your family. As for "what is one supposed to do" - one is supposed to apply for a re-entry permit prior to leaving the US if one thinks one will be out of the country for more than 6 months and is likely to want to return there to live.
I forget how long the reentry permit is good for - either one year or two. (ETA - I see from Rene's post that it's two.) So it's not a hugely long-term solution to an absence, but it can help in some situations such as yours.
Also ETA, please try not to let your temper flare up like this at the point of entry or with the immigration judge.
I forget how long the reentry permit is good for - either one year or two. (ETA - I see from Rene's post that it's two.) So it's not a hugely long-term solution to an absence, but it can help in some situations such as yours.
Also ETA, please try not to let your temper flare up like this at the point of entry or with the immigration judge.
#25
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
It wouldn't have taken very long to apply for the re-entry permit and get the biometrics done for that. Maybe a month or two at most. The re-entry permit would have helped you stay outside the USA for up to 2 years without as many problems or questions involved as you'll probably have now.
They might say something, they might say nothing, you won't know until you get to the POE. You will be let in because you have a green card, but as JEff says, you might end up with an appointment before an Immigration Judge who will make the final determination whether you've abandoned your PR status or not.
Rene
They might say something, they might say nothing, you won't know until you get to the POE. You will be let in because you have a green card, but as JEff says, you might end up with an appointment before an Immigration Judge who will make the final determination whether you've abandoned your PR status or not.
Rene
#26
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
MrF's comment about pre-clearance stations has me wondering ...
Regards, JEff
[EDIT: Love the rapidity with which the last half dozen or so posts have come!]
Regards, JEff
[EDIT: Love the rapidity with which the last half dozen or so posts have come!]
#27
Re: going back..shannon imm experiences
And what if one is skint? has no money ? and has to beg steal and borrow ? as for the re-entry permit..it can take up to 6 mths..because the powers that be are basically swamped with applications , are totally inept at there job , and basically couldnt give a dam..this is from someone who was denied 3 times for AOS , and had to be told by an ENGLISHMAN at the U.S. Embassy in London that ..should never have been denied ! GO IMM