British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   ME Job Discussions (https://britishexpats.com/forum/me-job-discussions-136/)
-   -   UAE End of Contract Service Benefit (https://britishexpats.com/forum/me-job-discussions-136/uae-end-contract-service-benefit-718588/)

crw1979 Jun 17th 2011 11:56 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by jackthehat (Post 9439012)
Thanks CRW1979 for clearing this one up - Especially the reference to 'Discounted Gratuity' - I have added your post to my 'Human Remains' file!

Meow you are 'Spot-On' as usual. However, as we all know 'Gratuity' and the way in which it is calculated, are a 'Sojourn into Sophistry' by many employers in the UAE. I would suggest that 'can include' and 'regular' are open to interpretation.

Thanks and no problem. I hate to disagree with statements made but the provisions of the Labour Law (or at least the English translation- which is not the governing version in any event) provides as follows (under Article 134):

"The wage used as a basis for calculating severance pay shall not include whatever is given to the worker in kind, housing allowance, transport allowance, travel allowance, overtime pay, representation allowance, cashier’s allowances, children education allowance, allowances for recreational and social facilities, and any other bonuses or allowances."

Therefore with respect I do not agree (based on the provisions of the Labour Law) with the previous statement about the inclusion of bonuses for the calculation of end of service gratuity. Obviously, an employer is at liberty to offer benefits greater than those provided for under the Labour. However, as noted earlier part of the reason that many employers will still adopt the allowances/bonus structure within a salary package is so at to limit gratuity liability.

Kind regards

jackthehat Jun 17th 2011 12:00 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by crw1979 (Post 9439114)
Thanks and no problem. I hate to disagree with statements made but the provisions of the Labour Law (or at least the English translation- which is not the governing version in any event) provides as follows (under Article 134):

"The wage used as a basis for calculating severance pay shall not include whatever is given to the worker in kind, housing allowance, transport allowance, travel allowance, overtime pay, representation allowance, cashier’s allowances, children education allowance, allowances for recreational and social facilities, and any other bonuses or allowances."

Therefore with respect I do not agree (based on the provisions of the Labour Law) with the previous statement about the inclusion of bonuses for the calculation of end of service gratuity. Obviously, an employer is at liberty to offer benefits greater than those provided for under the Labour. However, as noted earlier part of the reason that many employers will still adopt the allowances/bonus structure within a salary package is so at to limit gratuity liability.

Kind regards

My point exactly! - Salary is Salary! I always try to avoid allowances (on both sides of the fence). The company I work for is quite particular in getting the calculation correct, and we do not 'Quibble' over a few hundred here or there. We also include a 'Gratuity Statement' on the monthly Pay-Slip! - Yes, we give our staff Pay-Slips!

crw1979 Jun 17th 2011 12:04 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by jackthehat (Post 9439123)
My point exactly! - Salary is Salary! I always try to avoid allowances (on both sides of the fence)

Wise choice! Anyway hope that helps for all who view.

Kind regards

jackthehat Jun 18th 2011 11:53 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 
Pensions -v- Gratuity being discussed again.
http://gulfnews.com/business/your-mo...efits-1.822898

OleJanx Jun 18th 2011 1:20 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by jackthehat (Post 9440833)
Pensions -v- Gratuity being discussed again.
http://gulfnews.com/business/your-mo...efits-1.822898

Any old-timers out there remember the Saudi's GOSI set-up? (dates me a bit...):)

jackthehat Jun 18th 2011 1:46 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by OleJanx (Post 9440953)
Any old-timers out there remember the Saudi's GOSI set-up? (dates me a bit...):)

Unfortunately, I do not remember GOSI (only got to Middle East in 1996). Although I do remember Pounds Shillings and Pence, Harold Macmillan as the Prime Minister, and Kennedy being Shot! - I feel ancient!

OleJanx Jun 18th 2011 2:03 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 
IIRC, GOSI was General Organization for Social Insurance, and was a pension, payable anywhere in the world on reaching 60, that the Saudi's forked out to expats who went to Saudi in the early Seventies until the mid eighties, albiet with with some employee contributions. In the mid-eighties, when it appeared to stop, there used to be little adverts in the UK papers advising on how to get GOSI payments back.
Different generation, I guess.

Wikipedia has a (typically unhelpful) say on it.

Meow Jun 19th 2011 8:51 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by crw1979 (Post 9439114)
Thanks and no problem. I hate to disagree with statements made but the provisions of the Labour Law (or at least the English translation- which is not the governing version in any event) provides as follows (under Article 134):

"The wage used as a basis for calculating severance pay shall not include whatever is given to the worker in kind, housing allowance, transport allowance, travel allowance, overtime pay, representation allowance, cashier’s allowances, children education allowance, allowances for recreational and social facilities, and any other bonuses or allowances."

Therefore with respect I do not agree (based on the provisions of the Labour Law) with the previous statement about the inclusion of bonuses for the calculation of end of service gratuity. Obviously, an employer is at liberty to offer benefits greater than those provided for under the Labour. However, as noted earlier part of the reason that many employers will still adopt the allowances/bonus structure within a salary package is so at to limit gratuity liability.

Kind regards

I'm afraid you are incorrect when it comes to gratuity and REGULAR commissions. My comments are based on rather more than just having read an interpretation of the labour law.

crw1979 Jun 19th 2011 5:10 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 
[QUOTE=Meow;9442166]I'm afraid you are incorrect when it comes to gratuity and REGULAR commissions. My comments are based on rather more than just having read an interpretation of the labour law.[/Q

I think earlier you noted "bonuses" which is where I took issue with what you said. I presume that you are basing the point on "commissions" on the paragraph in a prominent local law firm's Labour Law publication which states that a UAE court judged that regular commissions would be taken into account or alternatively in relation to discussions that you have had with the Ministry of Labour which you noted in an article in the National in February. It would be interesting to see the circumstances of the judgment, particularly given that as a civil law jurisidciton there is no binding precedent as there would be in a common law jurisdiction and as such courts are free to interpret the law as they see fit in the circumstances. I would certainly be interested in you sharing any further information on this point, in particular any written advice that the Ministry of Labour have provided on this point and legal opinion you have received in support of the same. Thanks.

mentalist Mar 21st 2012 7:50 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 
OK so, according to the UAE Labour Laws, I should get 21 days for each of the first 5 years as gratuity, but how is the daily rate calculated? If I work 20 days a month, would it be my monthly salary divided by 20 or my monthly salary divided by the actual number of days in a month? It may sound trivial but it makes a difference of nearly AED50,000 in my case. Does anybody know?

weasel decentral Mar 21st 2012 8:12 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by mentalist (Post 9964316)
OK so, according to the UAE Labour Laws, I should get 21 days for each of the first 5 years as gratuity, but how is the daily rate calculated? If I work 20 days a month, would it be my monthly salary divided by 20 or my monthly salary divided by the actual number of days in a month? It may sound trivial but it makes a difference of nearly AED50,000 in my case. Does anybody know?

I am sure one of the resident experts will answer better, but I'd imagine going to be your monthly salary divided by 30 and then multiplied by 21. Otherwise if you took it as 20 working days they would essentially say one months salary?

that's how its been worked for me so far (or some variation of it).

As a maths exercise :nod:

so 21/21- 21/30 = 50,000

3/10 = 50,000

payout (max)= 166,000 / divided by years worked over 5 (taking 5) = 33,000aed

salary approximately 9,000 USD per month?

Millhouse Mar 21st 2012 9:32 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by mentalist (Post 9964316)
OK so, according to the UAE Labour Laws, I should get 21 days for each of the first 5 years as gratuity, but how is the daily rate calculated? If I work 20 days a month, would it be my monthly salary divided by 20 or my monthly salary divided by the actual number of days in a month? It may sound trivial but it makes a difference of nearly AED50,000 in my case. Does anybody know?

Use 21 days. The accrual works out to be roughly 5.5% of your salary each month.

Weasel, I made it 8k USD...

mentalist Mar 21st 2012 3:03 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by Millhouse (Post 9964426)
Use 21 days. The accrual works out to be roughly 5.5% of your salary each month. Weasel, I made it 8k USD...

Why use 21 days? It should be 30 or 31 days surely assuming that it's not working days.:confused:and my salary is much less than US$9K.

Millhouse Mar 21st 2012 5:13 pm

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by mentalist (Post 9965039)
Why use 21 days? It should be 30 or 31 days surely assuming that it's not working days.:confused:and my salary is much less than US$9K.

I don't make up the rules :) All I know is, when I left my last place it was 21 days. They were very open about it and showed it as a monthly accrual on my payslip (5.5ish%). The law says 21 days per year, 21/365.25 = 5.7%. I think it's much easier to think of it as a %.

Anyway, I rounded up - I calculated it at 7.5k USD...:rofl:

mentalist Mar 22nd 2012 6:04 am

Re: UAE End of Contract Service Benefit
 

Originally Posted by Millhouse (Post 9965344)
I don't make up the rules :) All I know is, when I left my last place it was 21 days. They were very open about it and showed it as a monthly accrual on my payslip (5.5ish%). The law says 21 days per year, 21/365.25 = 5.7%. I think it's much easier to think of it as a %.
Anyway, I rounded up - I calculated it at 7.5k USD...:rofl:

I obviously haven't made myself very clear. I know you get 21 days pay. What I was querying is how you calculate the daily amount payable. If it's indeed 21/365.25 then fair enough, but we don't work 365.25 days a year...do we?


All times are GMT. The time now is 1:52 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.