British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   The Maple Leaf (https://britishexpats.com/forum/maple-leaf-98/)
-   -   Canada - What has happened? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/maple-leaf-98/canada-what-has-happened-798400/)

JonboyE May 29th 2013 6:34 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 
QED

Steve_ May 29th 2013 6:34 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10731120)
There's no BBC and no Radio 4. No Broadsheets. If you grew up with CNN/Fox and to a lesser extent CBC, then your knowledge of the world is restricted to soundbites. The news here makes me vomit with it's lack of information.

I don't agree with that one either, CBC Radio 1 is pretty informative imx. And if you have cable or satellite there is BBC World News on there.

stuabroad May 29th 2013 6:47 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by Steve_ (Post 10731133)
I don't agree with that one either, CBC Radio 1 is pretty informative imx. And if you have cable or satellite there is BBC World News on there.

I access BBC World News, it's on right now in front of me. It's a repeat cycle with HardTalk thrown in every 3 hours or so. I NEED it, but it's not the full BBC nor do i expect it.

As for CBC Radio1, never listened to it as i'm not much interested in anything they've said the few times i've listened, for the reasons already stated. May have been bad timing.

Point is you can get anything you want from the UK if you want it:

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/fir...on/media-hint/

But that wasn't the point of the thread, which was querying why people here can't hold a conversation. They simply haven't had the diversity we're used to. From sectarianism (from early school years), to football, to politics etc etc ...the UK is a mismash of thousands of years worth of history which Canadians or Americans will never be educated or understand on unless they have parents from Europe.

JonboyE May 29th 2013 7:04 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10731166)
As for CBC Radio1, never listened to it ...

Which, according to the mores of British Expats, makes you ideally qualified to pontificate about its content.

stuabroad May 29th 2013 7:14 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by JonboyE (Post 10731199)
Which, according to the mores of British Expats, makes you ideally qualified to pontificate about its content.

...not sure of the relevance of your comment. The answers i've given here and elsewhere are always based on only my experience and are backed up with objective commentary. This means you should try the same - i.e. watch your mouth - and provide something useful for the other person to learn from, which you haven't as yet. I've also been a member of this forum since 2007 and comment only where I might have something interesting to say - as opposed to spending my day on here bating other people with thousands of posts.

Oink May 29th 2013 7:25 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by Steve_ (Post 10731133)
I don't agree with that one either, CBC Radio 1 is pretty informative imx. And if you have cable or satellite there is BBC World News on there.

I don't agree. The topics are usually inane and then their accents gets so on your tits that's hard to listen.

Atlantic Xpat May 29th 2013 7:34 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10731207)
...not sure of the relevance of your comment. The answers i've given here and elsewhere are always based on only my experience and are backed up with objective commentary. This means you should try the same - i.e. watch your mouth - and provide something useful for the other person to learn from, which you haven't as yet. I've also been a member of this forum since 2007 and comment only where I might have something interesting to say - as opposed to spending my day on here bating other people with thousands of posts.

Then I submit, you have missed the whole raison d'etre for BE's existence.

stuabroad May 29th 2013 7:35 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by Atlantic Xpat (Post 10731230)
Then I submit, you have missed the whole raison d'etre for BE's existence.

Indeed.

JonboyE May 29th 2013 7:50 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10731207)
...not sure of the relevance of your comment. The answers i've given here and elsewhere are always based on only my experience and are backed up with objective commentary. This means you should try the same - i.e. watch your mouth - and provide something useful for the other person to learn from, which you haven't as yet. I've also been a member of this forum since 2007 and comment only where I might have something interesting to say - as opposed to spending my day on here bating other people with thousands of posts.

You are rather missing the point. I made the comment earlier that, as immigrants, we have a bias towards thinking what we know is more important than what we don't know. You illustrated this perfectly with your subsequent post by complaining that Canadians are "culturally lacking" because the news channels that you watch and listen to don't report the news that you want to hear.

And fine, it is your opinion from your perspective. However, the fact is that CBC radio 1 does exist and does a Radio 4 (ish) type of job of providing intelligent comment and informed insight on domestic and foreign current affairs.

Everyone has opinions, and everyone is entitled to them. That said, to be informed and objective they have to be based on all the relevant facts - not just the ones you happen to know about.

stuabroad May 29th 2013 8:10 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by JonboyE (Post 10731264)
You are rather missing the point. .

What on earth are you talking about. You're taking one single line out of my whole post about CBC radio and then insisting i'm being typically UK arrogant/ ignorant and not having done my homework.. If you actually understood my whole post, my point was that a balanced viewpoint of the offerings available is what is required to be successful in Canada (and understanding the differences). By picking me up on one line you are in fact going in completely the opposite direction. In fact your understanding of what I have said is so completely out of kilter, that i'm going to refer the OP person to my previous replies and apologize for those around me not paying attention.

#readbeforereplying

Almost Canadian May 29th 2013 9:14 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by bats (Post 10731036)
That was worthy of Sir Humphrey.

Really? I think Mr. Ford is a fool; I also accept the electorate gets the politicians it deserves.

I do find the amount of coverage this episode is getting without any real evidence bizarre. I can't see how he can prove a negative; I can see how his accusers could prove the positive. One wonders what would happen if the shoe was on the other foot; actually, we all know the answer to that, it's just easier to ignore it.

Shard May 29th 2013 9:25 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by cyasoon (Post 10729933)
On a recent trip to Canada me and my family re-connected with old friends and family. Maybe it's just my friends who live in Canada but I noticed a definite lack of interest in world affairs, an inability to engage in political dialogue (are all Canadians so uninformed about the world around them?)

Is there too much flouride in the water? Are Canadians loathe to express their personal opinions for fear of treading on the 'opinions' of others? Has the liberalism of Canada been accompanied with the fascism of political correctness? to a point where no one actually says anything?

I was disappointed to find that very few Canadians I met were able to engage in conversations that dealt with more than their day to day lives.

obviously this is probably an unfair tarnishing with the same brush, but it was my experience. Has 'tolerance' and 'acceptance' created a population who actually say nothing for fear of offending others? Are canadians that thin skinned?

Great post, OP.

I think as JonBoy said, their is a bias going on, and that many of topics Brits may find as important or interesting are not the same as those Canadians find Interesting, and vice versa! It's a difference in cultural emphasis. Perhaps a parallel can be drawn with France, where Brits (not all of us) generally find the French to philosophical and the French find Brits not philosophical enough.

With respect to history, there's a big question about what and how much needs to be learned in a new country. History contains a lot of baggage, if you're in Europe you need to be informed on that baggage, but if you're in North America much of it is irrelevant. It may even be a hindrance (look at the recent Swedish riots issue). While plenty of people on here bang on about European history, how much do they know about Asian history which is arguably as important in this century.

However, there is something to the charge that Canadians are reluctant to debate opinions. There generally seems to be far fewer people into debate than in Europe (generally being the key word) but they do exist. Especially if the topic is of interest. IME First Nations topics usually elicit some interest!

bats May 29th 2013 9:42 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10731207)
...not sure of the relevance of your comment. The answers i've given here and elsewhere are always based on only my experience and are backed up with objective commentary. This means you should try the same - i.e. watch your mouth - and provide something useful for the other person to learn from, which you haven't as yet. I've also been a member of this forum since 2007 and comment only where I might have something interesting to say - as opposed to spending my day on here bating other people with thousands of posts.

I'm quite thrilled to see someone told to watch their mouth. It's my first time.:o

JonboyE May 29th 2013 9:45 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 
OK, let's try this another way. (And let's put the quality of the journalism aside for the moment - this is just an example.)

The newspapers in Britain report cricket results. They don't report baseball.

The newspapers in Canada report baseball results. They don't report cricket.

For a Brit who has just arrived in Canada, and who loves cricket, the English newspaper will be the best newspaper as it gives him the news he wants to read. However, being a sports fan, he will gradually start to take an interest in North American sports - if for no other reason than that is all there is to watch. After a while he will see that baseball is a bit more than grown men playing rounders. Maybe he will go and see a few games. After all, it is a great excuse to sit in the sun for a few hours drinking beer. Maybe he will start to follow some local players, even follow a team. Before long, he will need to read a Canadian paper to check on his team’s statistics and the results of rivals.

He might still enjoy reading the cricket reports in a British newspaper every now and again. He has probably never seen the current players hit a ball in anger so is less involved, but it still conjures up wistful memories of Boycott grinding out a dour century under a forbidding Headingly sky. However, he needs the baseball results so he buys a Canadian newspaper. It is the best one for him now.

To labour the point to death, the British paper was best, now the Canadian one is. The papers haven’t changed – just his perspective. stuabroad's comments seemed to me like a Canadian in Glasgow telling other Canadians that the Scots are dumb because they don’t understand baseball.

I wasn’t intending to have a go at stuabroad in particular – it was just that his post came straight after mine. He is not alone – in fact his way of thinking is very common on here. But, I think it is useful in the immigration process to understand that it is impossible to make objective value judgements. Any judgement you make will be from your own perspective, and that perspective comes with all sorts of biases based on your life experience to date (mostly in the UK.) You can’t say X or Y is good or bad in Canada (or anywhere). All you can say is that X or Y is good or bad in Canada from your perspective. And, with time and more knowledge that perspective will change.

stuabroad May 29th 2013 9:47 am

Re: Canada - What has happened?
 

Originally Posted by bats (Post 10731447)
I'm quite thrilled to see someone told to watch their mouth. It's my first time.:o

In 5 years, its the first time i felt like saying it.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 6:36 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.