For The Agents Using The Forum
#16
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by badri
I see your point. We can wait till mid novmeber.
My concern is there are lots of people who are not in the MODL. What's gonna happen to them.
They made some statement and informed people that if you don't hear anything by 1 week november give us a shout. But nothing on the non modl applications.
Since I am on that boat I am concerned.
What I am still not able to understand is the following: The have a new system to address the incoming applications. This is working fine.
Since pre july applications are not yet looked at it means that they are still lying in the pile
What's stopping them in moivng the not opend applications into the new system .... hmm I can't see any reason.
Remember eventhough we are immigrants we will be the future taxing people of australia. We pay both the Agent and DIMIA to processes our applications atleast they could be honest.
Well I am not going to whine but I would like to hear some honest answers
That's not too much to ask for ????
Badri
My concern is there are lots of people who are not in the MODL. What's gonna happen to them.
They made some statement and informed people that if you don't hear anything by 1 week november give us a shout. But nothing on the non modl applications.
Since I am on that boat I am concerned.
What I am still not able to understand is the following: The have a new system to address the incoming applications. This is working fine.
Since pre july applications are not yet looked at it means that they are still lying in the pile
What's stopping them in moivng the not opend applications into the new system .... hmm I can't see any reason.
Remember eventhough we are immigrants we will be the future taxing people of australia. We pay both the Agent and DIMIA to processes our applications atleast they could be honest.
Well I am not going to whine but I would like to hear some honest answers
That's not too much to ask for ????
Badri
#17
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by badri
I see your point. We can wait till mid novmeber.
My concern is there are lots of people who are not in the MODL. What's gonna happen to them.
They made some statement and informed people that if you don't hear anything by 1 week november give us a shout. But nothing on the non modl applications.
Since I am on that boat I am concerned.
What I am still not able to understand is the following: The have a new system to address the incoming applications. This is working fine.
Since pre july applications are not yet looked at it means that they are still lying in the pile
What's stopping them in moivng the not opend applications into the new system .... hmm I can't see any reason.
Remember eventhough we are immigrants we will be the future taxing people of australia. We pay both the Agent and DIMIA to processes our applications atleast they could be honest.
Well I am not going to whine but I would like to hear some honest answers
That's not too much to ask for ????
Badri
My concern is there are lots of people who are not in the MODL. What's gonna happen to them.
They made some statement and informed people that if you don't hear anything by 1 week november give us a shout. But nothing on the non modl applications.
Since I am on that boat I am concerned.
What I am still not able to understand is the following: The have a new system to address the incoming applications. This is working fine.
Since pre july applications are not yet looked at it means that they are still lying in the pile
What's stopping them in moivng the not opend applications into the new system .... hmm I can't see any reason.
Remember eventhough we are immigrants we will be the future taxing people of australia. We pay both the Agent and DIMIA to processes our applications atleast they could be honest.
Well I am not going to whine but I would like to hear some honest answers
That's not too much to ask for ????
Badri
The only possible reasons I can suppose are
1) the cost of resource allocation.
2) the bottleneck of April applications
Really, who knows even the rough ratio of pre-July to post-July figures in both criteria?
But anyway, we have right to ask for explanations. Maybe for non-MODL cases it would be a good way to collect people, who already are out of 50 weeks timeframe and ask ASPC if they are a statistic splash or whole system works wrong. And if the latter, we should require the true terms and realistic obligations.
As for MODL, I still think we should abide by terms of they letter. We'll wait and we'll see, how people in Russia often say Possibly, I'm more patient than others, but this doesn't mean my position is right under the circumstances.
Anyway, I'll be glad if both the streams MODL and non-MODL will move faster and successfully due to our efforts. Cheer up!
#18
Migration Agent
Joined: May 2002
Location: Offices in Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Geelong (Australia), and Southampton (UK)
Posts: 6,459
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
I understand your frustration (I've been through the process myself), but if I may say so the Department of Immigration will decide when it wants to grant your visa, which applications it decides to process as a priority, etc.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
Originally Posted by TOADFISH
I write this message because the frustration waiting for something to happen with DIMIA is now becoming unbearable.
My personal opinion (if it is shared by others the support would be appreciated) is that all Migration agents should be asking DIMIA what the hell is happening, there seems to be little or no issuing of visa's and for the migrants waiting this is now becoming unbearable.
DIMIA will not talk to anyone and refuse to tell Joe Public whats happening so is it time for the agents to start putting some pressure on.
I am well aware that this is your livelihood but i cannot think of another industry/business in the world where this poor level of service/standard of work would be tolerated.
DIMIA are not untouchable, and i feel it is about time we the migrants were given some accurate timescales.
My personal opinion (if it is shared by others the support would be appreciated) is that all Migration agents should be asking DIMIA what the hell is happening, there seems to be little or no issuing of visa's and for the migrants waiting this is now becoming unbearable.
DIMIA will not talk to anyone and refuse to tell Joe Public whats happening so is it time for the agents to start putting some pressure on.
I am well aware that this is your livelihood but i cannot think of another industry/business in the world where this poor level of service/standard of work would be tolerated.
DIMIA are not untouchable, and i feel it is about time we the migrants were given some accurate timescales.
#19
Migration Agent
Joined: May 2002
Location: Offices in Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Geelong (Australia), and Southampton (UK)
Posts: 6,459
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Have you read this as well?
http://www.gomatilda.com/news/article.cfm?articleid=324
Best regards.
http://www.gomatilda.com/news/article.cfm?articleid=324
Best regards.
Originally Posted by badri
Hi All,
Unfortunately I will be surprised if we see any agents putting a comment on. If I am right we haven't seen much of a reaction from the agents on the pre july and post july discussions. If I remember they haven't commented much as they are also in the dark.
On the otherhand being a MARA certified agents they have more responsibility and comunication power then us. So they do have a good chance in putting the pressure.
But the question is will they ?????? They are also elusive as DIMIA
hope to see reactions from anyone there.
As far as I am concerned I am all in for writing a petition as Galilite did one more time. But with strong pharsing to The Minister and DIMIA.
Any one in for that ?
Cheers
Badri
Unfortunately I will be surprised if we see any agents putting a comment on. If I am right we haven't seen much of a reaction from the agents on the pre july and post july discussions. If I remember they haven't commented much as they are also in the dark.
On the otherhand being a MARA certified agents they have more responsibility and comunication power then us. So they do have a good chance in putting the pressure.
But the question is will they ?????? They are also elusive as DIMIA
hope to see reactions from anyone there.
As far as I am concerned I am all in for writing a petition as Galilite did one more time. But with strong pharsing to The Minister and DIMIA.
Any one in for that ?
Cheers
Badri
#20
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by Alan Collett
Thanks I saw you message on your site.
I thought of putting that when I wrote my message.
Badri
#21
Forum Regular
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 37
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
I applied 2nd February 2004 and am just a plain old 136 no modl. I am really fustrated like the rest of you, but to be honest the most fustrating thing is my agent.
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
#22
Grateful
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 402
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by lyndab
I applied 2nd February 2004 and am just a plain old 136 no modl. I am really fustrated like the rest of you, but to be honest the most fustrating thing is my agent.
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
After joining this forum, then only I found out abt all these mess. I consoled myself "hey.. it's ok.. nobody knew abt it".. But not! I found a thread started by Alan on the 16th June and he already knew abt it before it happened! Only if I joined this forum earlier...
My stupid agent knew nothing abt it back then. Whose agent can be lousier than mine??
Now, I am at all the way back of the queue of the slowest lane! who can be slower than me?
#23
Migration Agent
Joined: May 2002
Location: Offices in Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Geelong (Australia), and Southampton (UK)
Posts: 6,459
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
It is difficult for us as agents too Lynda when we have nothing to report ... probably not as emotionally difficult as for our clients, but as a skilled migrant myself I do have sympathy for you.
Some might remember the debacle when skilled visa processing was moved from offshore posts (eg London) to the new Adelaide Skilled Processing Centre (on 1 November 2002 I recall). There was an intention for posts such as London to process all applications lodged before that date and all skilled applications lodged after that date had to be sent to the ASPC. This again created an arbitrary mismatch of skilled applications with applications sent to the ASPC being processed to visa grant months before those being processed offshore. Reason: resources weren't appropriately allocated (sound familiar?).
This was compounded when a residual London skilled visa caseload was transferred to the ASPC, and sat around for several weeks (it may have been months) before a team was assigned to the applications. Result: many who lodged skilled visa applications in London had to wait 20+ months for a visa decision.
Indeed, I also recall that the Pretoria caseload was lost in transit between South Africa and the ASPC (Jeremy - JAJ - may have a better memory than me on this one).
All of which goes to show that there is always likely to be someone who has had to wait for his or her visa longer than you ...
Best regards.
Some might remember the debacle when skilled visa processing was moved from offshore posts (eg London) to the new Adelaide Skilled Processing Centre (on 1 November 2002 I recall). There was an intention for posts such as London to process all applications lodged before that date and all skilled applications lodged after that date had to be sent to the ASPC. This again created an arbitrary mismatch of skilled applications with applications sent to the ASPC being processed to visa grant months before those being processed offshore. Reason: resources weren't appropriately allocated (sound familiar?).
This was compounded when a residual London skilled visa caseload was transferred to the ASPC, and sat around for several weeks (it may have been months) before a team was assigned to the applications. Result: many who lodged skilled visa applications in London had to wait 20+ months for a visa decision.
Indeed, I also recall that the Pretoria caseload was lost in transit between South Africa and the ASPC (Jeremy - JAJ - may have a better memory than me on this one).
All of which goes to show that there is always likely to be someone who has had to wait for his or her visa longer than you ...
Best regards.
Originally Posted by lyndab
I applied 2nd February 2004 and am just a plain old 136 no modl. I am really fustrated like the rest of you, but to be honest the most fustrating thing is my agent.
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
They just keep on saying that there is no pre-july/post-july issue at all, and that DIMIA are just busy.
ARGGHHHHHH
its hard to have patience but I know once my visa is granted I will laugh at how stressed I was
#24
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Alan - it was Nov 2001 when DIMIA centralised the applications processing at ASPC. My 2 cents worth about the processing at Adelaide - I really don't think the delays have been intended and since ASPC has started functioning the processing times have been considerably reduced. There were times when the processing had been a couple of years and more and my own application took nearly 3+ years when the changes were introduced in 1989/90. The reason why they had to introduce the changes in processing arrangements and priorities is a valid one and if some have to wait a bit longer and others get it quickly, it is only in the short term and everyone will benefit in the long run. So hang in there and it will be well worth the wait. As many of you think that the RMAs are not posting a reply, it has necessitated for me to post one and it is not to get any browny points with DIMIA. Cheers
#25
Migration Agent
Joined: May 2002
Location: Offices in Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, Geelong (Australia), and Southampton (UK)
Posts: 6,459
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Thanks ... I posted from memory - clearly the years are passing more quickly than I realise!
Best regards.
Best regards.
Originally Posted by K S Adityan
Alan - it was Nov 2001 when DIMIA centralised the applications processing at ASPC. My 2 cents worth about the processing at Adelaide - I really don't think the delays have been intended and since ASPC has started functioning the processing times have been considerably reduced. There were times when the processing had been a couple of years and more and my own application took nearly 3+ years when the changes were introduced in 1989/90. The reason why they had to introduce the changes in processing arrangements and priorities is a valid one and if some have to wait a bit longer and others get it quickly, it is only in the short term and everyone will benefit in the long run. So hang in there and it will be well worth the wait. As many of you think that the RMAs are not posting a reply, it has necessitated for me to post one and it is not to get any browny points with DIMIA. Cheers
#26
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by K S Adityan
Alan - it was Nov 2001 when DIMIA centralised the applications processing at ASPC. My 2 cents worth about the processing at Adelaide - I really don't think the delays have been intended and since ASPC has started functioning the processing times have been considerably reduced. There were times when the processing had been a couple of years and more and my own application took nearly 3+ years when the changes were introduced in 1989/90. The reason why they had to introduce the changes in processing arrangements and priorities is a valid one and if some have to wait a bit longer and others get it quickly, it is only in the short term and everyone will benefit in the long run. So hang in there and it will be well worth the wait. As many of you think that the RMAs are not posting a reply, it has necessitated for me to post one and it is not to get any browny points with DIMIA. Cheers
fine, DIMIA used to take 3 years prior.. but does that there should be no improvements..
now, since DIMIA have improved, why lose the foothold...
regards,
raj
#27
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by Alan Collett
I understand your frustration (I've been through the process myself), but if I may say so the Department of Immigration will decide when it wants to grant your visa, which applications it decides to process as a priority, etc.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
Again thanks for the replys Alan. Your above perfectly sums up the traffic warden mentality of DIMIA. The worry from my part is that with applications piling in day after day, when will the situation ever improve?
#28
Grateful
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 402
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
If you ask me, the only way to solve this is to move everybody to the new system. As I am typing here, I have to admit that I have zero knowledge of what's happening within DIMIA. But as for any system, common sense tells us that running two different sets of procedures concurrently is normally highly expensive and inefficient.
Well oh well, what can we do besides whining...
Well oh well, what can we do besides whining...
#29
KRSC Member
Thread Starter
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 30
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by Alan Collett
I understand your frustration (I've been through the process myself), but if I may say so the Department of Immigration will decide when it wants to grant your visa, which applications it decides to process as a priority, etc.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
Indeed, DIMIAs reaction to your comment about the waiting being unbearable is likely to be that you are always at liberty to withdraw your application if you want certainty as to outcome.
My understanding is that there are an increasing number of people wanting to move to Australia (witness the increase in the Skilled Independent visa passmark - it was 110 points only 3 years ago). I have a view on decisions taken that have meant skilled visa applicants lodging post 1 July 2004 are receiving visas months before those who lodged prior to that date, the introduction of Centrelink into the Assurance of Support process, TRAs processing times and the withdrawal of deeming dates on their classification letters, etc - and I express them to the professional body of which I am a member (the Migration Institute of Australia), which has regular meetings with the DIMIA. Out of those meetings positive things do happen ...
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
#30
Re: For The Agents Using The Forum
Originally Posted by Alan Collett
The bottom line is that fairness and equity are often of no consequence to the DIMIA - intending migrants don't have a vote. You have to be patient, accept the reality of the situation, and (if it helps) sound off on this forum.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
I fear little of the above will be of comfort to previous posters on this thread, but that's the situation as I see it.
Best wishes to all.
have already recieved the visas. You see it's just frustrating, as you know when this happens.