British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Goa (https://britishexpats.com/forum/goa-170/)
-   -   Is it worth having your deeds. (https://britishexpats.com/forum/goa-170/worth-having-your-deeds-697377/)

More Dec 17th 2010 8:09 pm

Is it worth having your deeds.
 
I wonder if you are better off if you are on a agreement of sale. Having sale deeds means they cant be transferred, so impossible to sell. A sale agreement means you just need the builder to transfer the deeds if you have a buyer. What do others think?

a_f_d Dec 18th 2010 4:08 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by More (Post 9047291)
I wonder if you are better off if you are on a agreement of sale. Having sale deeds means they cant be transferred, so impossible to sell. A sale agreement means you just need the builder to transfer the deeds if you have a buyer. What do others think?

yes, insist on doing things properly and you will almost certainly be worse off!

AndyD 8-)#

dreadsoc Dec 19th 2010 12:58 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
In the current climate More I would totally agree with you - provided your builder is a decent person.
Unfortunately for some their builders have recognised an opportunity for a quick buck and are demanding huge sums of money (15 lakh in some cases), when in fact a new agreement of sale can be drawn up for about 1000 rupees, and that includes the notary fee.

For those who do stay on agreement of sale, it is advisable to have your builder sign an agreement stating they will not take any further action until you request so. There have been some cases where deeds have been registered to other named persons, or fraudulently registered behind the buyers back.

Dread -x

dj53 Dec 23rd 2010 2:12 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by More (Post 9047291)
I wonder if you are better off if you are on a agreement of sale. Having sale deeds means they cant be transferred, so impossible to sell. A sale agreement means you just need the builder to transfer the deeds if you have a buyer. What do others think?

Well we had an agreement of sale from 2005/6 and after all the problems we encountered we sold our small 1 bed apptmnt in a week March 09. The builder was excellent and all it cost us for him to cancel our sales agreement was 10,000 rupees. New one drawn up for new owner and job done.

I think I was lucky as the builder knew the advocate and all it took was a 5 minute visit to sort. Its amazing how fast things can be done here if you have the right people in your corner and they have a vested interest in the sale. So yes an agreement of sale can be good but only if you are not held to ransom by the builder.
Regards David

noni Dec 23rd 2010 2:49 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by dj53 (Post 9057547)
Well we had an agreement of sale from 2005/6 and after all the problems we encountered we sold our small 1 bed apptmnt in a week March 09. The builder was excellent and all it cost us for him to cancel our sales agreement was 10,000 rupees. New one drawn up for new owner and job done.

I think I was lucky as the builder knew the advocate and all it took was a 5 minute visit to sort. Its amazing how fast things can be done here if you have the right people in your corner and they have a vested interest in the sale. So yes an agreement of sale can be good but only if you are not held to ransom by the builder.
Regards David

Agree with you, my heart wants to keep the apartment but my head says to get out - what to do! I know, I know, you all say GET OUT.

johnny five Dec 23rd 2010 3:36 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by noni (Post 9057601)
Agree with you, my heart wants to keep the apartment but my head says to get out - what to do! I know, I know, you all say GET OUT.

Without any shadow of a doubt.........

sandyscot Dec 23rd 2010 11:35 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by dj53 (Post 9057547)
Well we had an agreement of sale from 2005/6 and after all the problems we encountered we sold our small 1 bed apptmnt in a week March 09. The builder was excellent and all it cost us for him to cancel our sales agreement was 10,000 rupees. New one drawn up for new owner and job done.

I think I was lucky as the builder knew the advocate and all it took was a 5 minute visit to sort. Its amazing how fast things can be done here if you have the right people in your corner and they have a vested interest in the sale. So yes an agreement of sale can be good but only if you are not held to ransom by the builder.
Regards David

DJ. Did you get all of your money back then? I think that if we got back what we had spent then we would almost certainly cut our losses. If you lost money what percentage did you lose, or di you make anything? I would be interested to hear.

Interestingly we had 12 friends come out to see us while we were there last year, and this year it will be 10. If we stop going it is unlikely that any of them will go back to Goa again. Multiply this by a few hundred and that is a lot less money for the Goans.

dj53 Dec 23rd 2010 11:55 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by sandyscot (Post 9059169)
DJ. Did you get all of your money back then? I think that if we got back what we had spent then we would almost certainly cut our losses. If you lost money what percentage did you lose, or di you make anything? I would be interested to hear.

Interestingly we had 12 friends come out to see us while we were there last year, and this year it will be 10. If we stop going it is unlikely that any of them will go back to Goa again. Multiply this by a few hundred and that is a lot less money for the Goans.

Well we paid 5.2lacs in total between 05 and 06 as it was an appartment near Colva in a residential complex.No pool. Then add another 1 lac for air con,furniture etc. At the time the exchange rate was not in our favour so I think 1 lac was about £1350. So the apptmnt was a shade over £6k

Well after 3 full years with the apptmnt we sold it for 9 Lacs the exchange rate was okay at 74 and this equated to approx £12150. Basically we doubled our money. Not that we wanted to sell as it was for my retirement.
Fees for selling came to approx £1k and the bulk of this was for an estate agent type guy who found at least 5 prospective buyers within a day or so.

Very sad to sell and would still like to go back but we were badly let down by our accountant so that was it. Just couldnt risk the property being seized or whatever .

nokiauser Dec 27th 2010 7:55 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
In a word - NO

sell without the deeds and get rid and get out.

prestonjohn Dec 28th 2010 7:18 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
Spoke to a Jock on Calingute Market this morning and he here for a break from Thailand where has property and he is experiencing the same problems as most of the people on this forum.However,he said that he and his wife are looking at Vietnam, where you can buy the Freehold and its legal beyond dispute !

nokiauser Dec 30th 2010 10:48 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
Please - C a l a n g u t e - so many people spell this wrong on this forum including the mod Noni.

prestonjohn Dec 30th 2010 4:48 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
Who cares the place is a dump and nightmare.

harry1 Jan 4th 2011 5:20 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by More (Post 9047291)
I wonder if you are better off if you are on a agreement of sale. Having sale deeds means they cant be transferred, so impossible to sell. A sale agreement means you just need the builder to transfer the deeds if you have a buyer. What do others think?

in many circumstances no-onwould know what going to happen 10 years ago,when everyone of us bought proprties,i myself thought to have 5 years to compile with the rules when i will retire, by buying a property with tourist visa,by chance i never thought about to register my property,when the proprty problem occure 6 or 5 years ago i thought,the law will change one day not in our favor,i sold.moved to brasil,thank god for that.i would like to say,it was short period for deeds owners to sell ,before the government start the investigations(new rules),but,lot of you decide to hang on,to see if anything can be done,then it was too late.like i always said,from my bottom of my hearth,i wish you luck and this problem can be solved,at least if you can just sell and get your money out the country,because,most of us used pension ,or saving money to buy a propety,we don´t deserve that.we just been conned.

nokiauser Jan 4th 2011 5:33 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by prestonjohn (Post 9065082)
.However,he said that he and his wife are looking at Vietnam, where you can buy the Freehold and its legal beyond dispute !

What - like were told by lawyers here in Goa - whatever :eek::eek:

Will let you know as we are going for a holiday at the end of the season but will never buy anywhere else in Asia no matter what we are told.

iain492001 Jan 4th 2011 2:55 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by nokiauser (Post 9077147)
What - like were told by lawyers here in Goa - whatever :eek::eek:

Will let you know as we are going for a holiday at the end of the season but will never buy anywhere else in Asia no matter what we are told.



Agree with your last sentiment totally. I would extend that even further - stick to what you know. i.e. UK property laws, and just come here or elsewhere & rent. Retirement dreams have not turned out to be what we had hoped for, but we only blame ourselves for getting carried away with the thought of owning a retirement property in Goa.

johnny five Jan 4th 2011 9:25 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
The other thing that MUST be factored in, where-ever you think you can legally buy property/rent and retire, is the bl**dy visa!

Even if one didnt get carried away and buy in Goa a few years back and opted for a sustantial longer term rental, life is still a nightmare with the 180 day max/2 months out cr*p.

So even if you buy elsewhere, or more sensibly rent, and even if it isn't a Mickey-Mouse country that changes its property laws on a whim, you can still get caught up in irrational and pointless visa changes.......


.

a_f_d Jan 4th 2011 9:58 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by johnny five (Post 9078715)
The other thing that MUST be factored in, where-ever you think you can legally buy property/rent and retire, is the bl**dy visa!

Even if one didnt get carried away and buy in Goa a few years back and opted for a sustantial longer term rental, life is still a nightmare with the 180 day max/2 months out cr*p.

So even if you buy elsewhere, or more sensibly rent, and even if it isn't a Mickey-Mouse country that changes its property laws on a whim, you can still get caught up in irrational and pointless visa changes.......


.

... and then there's the finance rules - I always thought that the Baht 65,000 a month for long term Thai visas covered a couple, but I happened to check something yesterday and now it clearly says 65,000 for spouse as well or 180 (?) day visa trips.

AndyD 8-)#

johnny five Jan 4th 2011 10:55 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by a_f_d (Post 9078789)
... and then there's the finance rules - I always thought that the Baht 65,000 a month for long term Thai visas covered a couple, but I happened to check something yesterday and now it clearly says 65,000 for spouse as well or 180 (?) day visa trips.

AndyD 8-)#

Andy, are you saying a long term Thai visa costs £1382 per month.........EACH?

a_f_d Jan 5th 2011 3:54 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by johnny five (Post 9078919)
Andy, are you saying a long term Thai visa costs £1382 per month.........EACH?

No - to get a long term visa (pensioners' visas) without the need for regular 'visas trips' you need (amingst other things) to show a regular monthly amount (currently 65,000 Baht) paid into a Thai bank, or a fixed deposit (currently 800,000 Baht). I think this used to cover a couple, but I just read it is each.
There are probably others on BE who know more.

AndyD 8-)#

Remy-Ireland Jan 8th 2011 10:08 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by johnny five (Post 9078715)
The other thing that MUST be factored in, where-ever you think you can legally buy property/rent and retire, is the bl**dy visa!

Even if one didnt get carried away and buy in Goa a few years back and opted for a sustantial longer term rental, life is still a nightmare with the 180 day max/2 months out cr*p.

So even if you buy elsewhere, or more sensibly rent, and even if it isn't a Mickey-Mouse country that changes its property laws on a whim, you can still get caught up in irrational and pointless visa changes.......


.

In hindsight its just far too risky to set up home and/or buy property in any country which you require a visa for.

nokiauser Jan 15th 2011 10:48 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by prestonjohn (Post 9065082)
Spoke to a Jock on Calangute Market this morning and he here for a break from Thailand where has property and he is experiencing the same problems as most of the people on this forum."However,he said that he and his wife are looking at Vietnam, where you can buy the Freehold and its legal beyond dispute !

Spoke to our friend in Vietnam last night and he said that the above quote was very wrong - as a foreigner he is having nearly as many problems in Vietnam as in other parts of Asia. His Vietnam wife owns the property and it has legally nothing to do with him but it was his money that bought it and they run the guest house together (it was not a marriage of convenience).
They are advertising Condos for on the seafront by Crowne Plaza (world wide company) but he told us not to touch them due to the visa situation which could change at any time.

The answer all over the world.

msj5 Jan 19th 2011 1:53 am

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 

Originally Posted by nokiauser (Post 9105205)
Spoke to our friend in Vietnam last night and he said that the above quote was very wrong - as a foreigner he is having nearly as many problems in Vietnam as in other parts of Asia. His Vietnam wife owns the property and it has legally nothing to do with him but it was his money that bought it and they run the guest house together (it was not a marriage of convenience).
They are advertising Condos for on the seafront by Crowne Plaza (world wide company) but he told us not to touch them due to the visa situation which could change at any time.

The answer all over the world.

So exactly what problems is your friend in Vietnam having?
i`d have thought being married to a Vietnamese national his problems should be very minimal!

nokiauser Jan 19th 2011 2:17 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
When we go to see him in April I will question him in depth and let you know. His property was not our main topic of conversation yesterday. It was a question I asked and he said what I quoted earlier knowing what problems are happening in Goa.

nokiauser Jan 19th 2011 6:16 pm

Re: Is it worth having your deeds.
 
When we meet in April I will discuss it further with him and let you know. Are you thinking of buying there?
His property was not our main topic of conversation yesterday but I quoted what I read here and he just said what I have already reported, it is basically to do with foreigners owning land.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 4:41 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.