My brother who’s a German citizen applied for an eea permit for me and my two sisters We have been refused twice on the ground of not providing relationship evidence with my brother as We are non Eu from Afghanistan , me, my sisters and my brother dont have a birth certificate cuz we belong to a backwarded country which didn’t have a system for registering birth, but we have our ID cards, passport and letters from our embassy confirming our relationship with our parents and we have our parents marriage certificate as well,
We have been refused twice, once We got a refusal after two weeks and the second time after 5 days, but the third time we decided to do undergo a dna test from DDC we all got our results which is 99,999999997% , 99,999999996% , 99,999999995%, We applied again three months ago we got a not straight forward email and since then i haven’t heard anything from them,
I emailed them twice using my brothers credit card I got a reply that my application is being considered and currently awaiting a decision and they escalated twice but I didn’t get a reply from HO, we are praying so much can someone experience plz help and give me some hope and tell me if a dna test is sufficient for proving a relationship and what are our chances for getting an fp? We are fully and wholly dependent upon our brother he sends us money and we have all the proof my brother has it’s own house in UK he’s a self employed, we don’t live in
our own country cuz we don’t have any family member in our country we have no home nothing we are living as a refugee in Pakistan , plz someone experience help plzz I’ll be very grateful

I got this email twice 3 months ago after that nothing, should we be hopeful that we I’ll be given our visa’s my heart never stops saying that we I’ll be given our visa’s this time � ����� ����
We spent our whole life living in a country where we couldn’t study properly couldn’t build a good future for our selves this is the saddest part of my life � ����

Thank you for applying for a UK visa. Your visa application has been received and is under consideration. We aim to process non settlement applications within 15 working days (unless you have opted for the Priority Visa service), and settlement applications within 60 working days.

Unfortunately, the processing of your application has not been straightforward and we will be unable to decide your application within our customer service targets. We are continuing to work on your application and aim to make a decision as soon as possible.

We will write to you again if there is any change to this. Please do not attend the Visa Application Centre until you have been advised that your application has been decided and that your passport is ready for collection.

Thanks for reply pollyana so kind of you we didn’t hire an immigration lawyer this third time he prepared all documents he advised us to undergo a dna test because we didn’t have any birth certificates, let me write u the actual wording of the entry clearance officer when we were rejected for the second time.

"You have failed to provide any evidence of your relationship to your sponsor. On the evidence submitted in support of your application and on the balance of probability I am not satisfied that you are related to your sponsor. I’m therefore not satisfied that you are an extended family member in accordance no with regulation 8(2) of the immigration European economic area regulations 2016"

These are the wordings and we were also given right of appeal that’s it

Thank you , god bless u pollyana

Thanks for the reply we did what the lawyer advised us to do cuz to prove a relationship u have to have a Birth certificate which we don’t have so dna was the only proof, we did have other proofs but the officer had a doubt on our relationship which is genuine and we proved it with the dna test, so let’s hope for the best im
always hopeful ✌🏻

Pollyana what ever religion u have I respect it , I know it very well that god doesn’t issue visa’s but nothing happens unless decreed by allah I believe in my allah he’s the most merciful, I don’t care if u r a pagan or an infedel it’s ur belief and I respect it , don’t bring religion on ur forum as I’m not interested , bye have a good day

I respect all the religions in this world that’s how I’m even the pagans 😀😃

Which visa are you attempting to apply for? You should be looking at an EEA Family Permit.

Yes I applied for EEA family permit .. may be this option is for those if the spouse is in UK but we are living together in Germany and will go together to UK after getting the visa so I assume that option is for such case if the spouse is in UK

Have you been living in Germany? If so have you considered naturalising as a German citizen?
No I have not actually from the last 7 years our stay is not consistent in Germany ..