cruise ships
#1
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: May 2012
Location: Cayman Islands
Posts: 4,996
cruise ships
This report (at the link) is about Carnival pulling out of Antigua, and Nassau resenting cruise-lines' antics, and the bitter dispute here in Cayman about whether to build a $300 million four-berth dock. Our argument is over the economic sense or non-sense of paying such an enormous sum - borrowed from the lines themselves, who will withhold all the present anchorage fees for the next 25 years. Skullduggery is suspected by many members of our public - skullduggery in the form of bribes. What's going on in the rest of the region?
https://caymannewsservice.com/2019/0...port-concerns/
https://caymannewsservice.com/2019/0...port-concerns/
#2
I still dont believe it..
Joined: Oct 2013
Location: 12 degrees north
Posts: 2,777
Re: cruise ships
We have a single jetty/pier so 2 boats can dock, though there have been several days when up to 4 boats have been in the bay. There is of course a big mall for the tourists in the terminal because as we all know no cruise lemming can go far without buying a fake rolex, tee shirt [i am a tourist, take my money] or jewellery [which i really do find confusing] - grand turk - 10k inhabitants, 15 jewellery shops � ����.
The jetty was locally funded with an insurance co being a part owner but seems to be a minor thing for the millions it cost so yes its probably not entirely kosher as a project. The fees for passengers are pitiful, i wouldnt mind forgoing them if thats how its funded, its of the order of 1-2 dollars if they get their butts off the boat. There are well published stats about income, i think here the spend is about 25-35 us each passenger. I have heard the reasonable stat - a visit from a cruise ship is worth the same as 1 hotel room for the year. If you look at tripadvisor fo grenada you can link to the xls file of the arrivals, and see how many passengers boats etc, its all there. This season its 520k tourists and 220 arrivals.
There is money in it for locals running all sorts of businesses. However consider how brittle tourism can be, a plane crash or zika or hurricane can damage itfor years.
In addition the smaller cruise ships, think le ponant, silversea, the pricey ones, have several docking points at marinas and the main port.
The jetty was locally funded with an insurance co being a part owner but seems to be a minor thing for the millions it cost so yes its probably not entirely kosher as a project. The fees for passengers are pitiful, i wouldnt mind forgoing them if thats how its funded, its of the order of 1-2 dollars if they get their butts off the boat. There are well published stats about income, i think here the spend is about 25-35 us each passenger. I have heard the reasonable stat - a visit from a cruise ship is worth the same as 1 hotel room for the year. If you look at tripadvisor fo grenada you can link to the xls file of the arrivals, and see how many passengers boats etc, its all there. This season its 520k tourists and 220 arrivals.
There is money in it for locals running all sorts of businesses. However consider how brittle tourism can be, a plane crash or zika or hurricane can damage itfor years.
In addition the smaller cruise ships, think le ponant, silversea, the pricey ones, have several docking points at marinas and the main port.
#3
I still dont believe it..
Joined: Oct 2013
Location: 12 degrees north
Posts: 2,777
Re: cruise ships
Hang on 300 milliion us? Is this a jetty from your island to miami? I think ours was 10?
#4
BE Forum Addict
Thread Starter
Joined: May 2012
Location: Cayman Islands
Posts: 4,996
Re: cruise ships
#5
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: cruise ships
We have the same question in Greenock. Many cruise ships coming in but very little benefit to the town.
#7
Re: cruise ships
#8
Re: cruise ships
Same questions are raised for New Zealand. Dunedin for instance. Cruise ships dock but really there is little to no benefit to the city or the surrounding area unless the cruise ship shore trips take them to a specific spot . I am thinking of my beloved albatross colony in particular with this. Most seem to do these whistle stop tour things with perhaps a short stop thrown in. We don't get them where I live although sometime they do come in. Again , the people on them just pass quickly through really .
#9
Re: cruise ships
Nothing wrong with cruising if that is what a person enjoys. Many people love to go on cruises. Our pals do.
From the passenger end of things , why would they spend extra money ashore if they have bought and paid for all inclusive & it is easy to book excursions through the cruise line.
I think the point here is do the ports of call & the surrounding businesses and communities actually really benefit in any way.
From the passenger end of things , why would they spend extra money ashore if they have bought and paid for all inclusive & it is easy to book excursions through the cruise line.
I think the point here is do the ports of call & the surrounding businesses and communities actually really benefit in any way.
#10
Re: cruise ships
Nothing wrong with cruising if that is what a person enjoys. Many people love to go on cruises. Our pals do.
From the passenger end of things , why would they spend extra money ashore if they have bought and paid for all inclusive & it is easy to book excursions through the cruise line.
I think the point here is do the ports of call & the surrounding businesses and communities actually really benefit in any way.
From the passenger end of things , why would they spend extra money ashore if they have bought and paid for all inclusive & it is easy to book excursions through the cruise line.
I think the point here is do the ports of call & the surrounding businesses and communities actually really benefit in any way.
#11
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Nov 2012
Location: bute
Posts: 9,740
Re: cruise ships
In Greenock the main beneficiaries are the taxis who pick people up and drive them off to more salubrious parts of Bonnie Scotland. Brigadoon awaits, and the imaginary destinations described in "Outllander" or JK Rowling
#12
Re: cruise ships
We went on a cruise round the Med in 2013. Visited some lovely places but the most we ever did was buy a beer or two and a piece of tat. When you have an 'eat your own weight and more' service on the boat, you really aren't up to eating in restaurants at your destination. I certainly DIDN'T buy a Tag Heuer or similar! And to be honest, watching the tourists in George Town when several boats are in has put me off ever going on a cruise again. Snobbery I know. Herder around like sheep. No thanks.
#13
Account Closed
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 0
Re: cruise ships
We have a problem here with the river cruise boats - packs roaming the city, either on foot, on bikes or in coaches - spending next to nothing.
#14
Re: cruise ships
We went on a cruise round the Med in 2013. Visited some lovely places but the most we ever did was buy a beer or two and a piece of tat. When you have an 'eat your own weight and more' service on the boat, you really aren't up to eating in restaurants at your destination. I certainly DIDN'T buy a Tag Heuer or similar! And to be honest, watching the tourists in George Town when several boats are in has put me off ever going on a cruise again. Snobbery I know. Herder around like sheep. No thanks.
We have never bought jewellery either. Always worried that it may be fake. I do buy the odd gift/clothes etc, depending what the shops are like.
Last edited by Jerseygirl; Jun 8th 2019 at 2:38 pm. Reason: Typo
#15
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Jan 2011
Location: Tunbridge Wells KENT
Posts: 2,914
Re: cruise ships
Having had the opportunity to view first-hand, cruise ship traffic in three different locations (Bermuda, St Lucia and here in Dorset (ten visits scheduled here for July)) I would say a lot depends upon how an individual destination is set-up to accommodate cruise ships.
In Bermuda we have a pretty-much ideal cruise-ship destination, the way it is 'worked' in that passengers typically spend three nights there on cruises ex NY and New Jersey, so passengers and crew have plenty of time to spend money locally and crew typically spend more time there than anywhere else, so use banks, shops, phones and bought accessories, hairdressers and Bermuda has Harbour Nights geared to attracting passenger spend on food, drink, what have you. As well as all this, the cruise lines and therefore pax spend substantial port fees, which Bermuda can command because Bermuda is an exclusive-sell destination ex the NY and Boston areas.
In the Caribbean, unless an island singles itself out as being somewhat unique, there is not that much to entice a cruise line apart from convenient logistics and possibly provisioning, though of course cruise passenger feedback will have some bearing. This means that big operators like Carnival will pick port fees down to the bone or they simply won't come. So it is up to islands to gear up, with purpose-built cruise passenger 'terminals' a la Philipsburg, St Kitts, St Lucia, Antigua..... to draw passenger expenditure and hopefully taxi drivers make something over and above what the local agents and their bus operators make on pre-booked tours. Other than that, there is just the odd ice cream, roti, drink and t-shirt perhaps. HOWEVER, typically, island tourism departments play the numbers game and try to convince the locals that they are doing a good job by enticing vast numbers (based on individual cruise-ship full capacity) when in fact many stay on-board and therefore spend ZERO locally apart from those port fees. A big issue is whether the ease of cruise tourism detracts from stay-over visitors, but then even the latter can be marginal, aside from employment, when all-inclusive Sandals-type holidays keep guests IN their compound for the most part and typically negotiate near ZERO taxes on profits and ship these out to the owners. What is more, such hotel groups pretty much buy-in everything DIRECT so local wholesalers struggle to get in on the action. So in such circumstances islands are pretty much left only with low wages and airport departure taxes.
I recall a debate on the merits of sinking money into improved infrastructure coming up in San Juan PR some years back when it was established that overall it made no economic sense there to be sinking money into a new cruise ship terminal to take the larger ships. However, they still built it.
100% focus on tourism in any fashion is not a happy arrangement for most island economies, particularly when slow season can be long.
Here in Weymouth/Portland, where cruise tourism is on the up and up now with the attraction of provincial English destinations such as Bath, Stonehenge, Salisbury & Jurassic Coast being easily accessible, the bus/tour operators are clearly doing well but the local merchants haven't worked out how to capture cruise passenger spend (crew load up at Tesco Metro on essentials). It's ironic that George III and large entourage traveled all the way from Windsor by coach to get here and turned it into a trendy seaside vacation spot (actually the Romans vacationed here first) which then lasted centuries and much of the attraction is still here, and yet the locals can't YET sell it to separate cruise ship passengers from their money. Fortunately, Portland had to do next to nothing to enable its port to accommodate these ships, even the large ones, like Crown Princess.
In Bermuda we have a pretty-much ideal cruise-ship destination, the way it is 'worked' in that passengers typically spend three nights there on cruises ex NY and New Jersey, so passengers and crew have plenty of time to spend money locally and crew typically spend more time there than anywhere else, so use banks, shops, phones and bought accessories, hairdressers and Bermuda has Harbour Nights geared to attracting passenger spend on food, drink, what have you. As well as all this, the cruise lines and therefore pax spend substantial port fees, which Bermuda can command because Bermuda is an exclusive-sell destination ex the NY and Boston areas.
In the Caribbean, unless an island singles itself out as being somewhat unique, there is not that much to entice a cruise line apart from convenient logistics and possibly provisioning, though of course cruise passenger feedback will have some bearing. This means that big operators like Carnival will pick port fees down to the bone or they simply won't come. So it is up to islands to gear up, with purpose-built cruise passenger 'terminals' a la Philipsburg, St Kitts, St Lucia, Antigua..... to draw passenger expenditure and hopefully taxi drivers make something over and above what the local agents and their bus operators make on pre-booked tours. Other than that, there is just the odd ice cream, roti, drink and t-shirt perhaps. HOWEVER, typically, island tourism departments play the numbers game and try to convince the locals that they are doing a good job by enticing vast numbers (based on individual cruise-ship full capacity) when in fact many stay on-board and therefore spend ZERO locally apart from those port fees. A big issue is whether the ease of cruise tourism detracts from stay-over visitors, but then even the latter can be marginal, aside from employment, when all-inclusive Sandals-type holidays keep guests IN their compound for the most part and typically negotiate near ZERO taxes on profits and ship these out to the owners. What is more, such hotel groups pretty much buy-in everything DIRECT so local wholesalers struggle to get in on the action. So in such circumstances islands are pretty much left only with low wages and airport departure taxes.
I recall a debate on the merits of sinking money into improved infrastructure coming up in San Juan PR some years back when it was established that overall it made no economic sense there to be sinking money into a new cruise ship terminal to take the larger ships. However, they still built it.
100% focus on tourism in any fashion is not a happy arrangement for most island economies, particularly when slow season can be long.
Here in Weymouth/Portland, where cruise tourism is on the up and up now with the attraction of provincial English destinations such as Bath, Stonehenge, Salisbury & Jurassic Coast being easily accessible, the bus/tour operators are clearly doing well but the local merchants haven't worked out how to capture cruise passenger spend (crew load up at Tesco Metro on essentials). It's ironic that George III and large entourage traveled all the way from Windsor by coach to get here and turned it into a trendy seaside vacation spot (actually the Romans vacationed here first) which then lasted centuries and much of the attraction is still here, and yet the locals can't YET sell it to separate cruise ship passengers from their money. Fortunately, Portland had to do next to nothing to enable its port to accommodate these ships, even the large ones, like Crown Princess.
Last edited by Pistolpete2; Jun 9th 2019 at 7:47 am.