British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Canada (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/)
-   -   EI and going home (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/ei-going-home-624683/)

Louisecooke Aug 9th 2009 7:17 am

EI and going home
 
Hi

I am currently on EI, but may have to go back to the UK for a few weeks. Obviously I won't be 'able and ready to work' or whatever it says on the website, should I tell them I am going :confused: will they stop my payments?

triumphguy Aug 9th 2009 7:22 am

Re: EI and going home
 
Oh yeah - you'ld better tell them! You can't be drawing EI and going on holiday! Big No. No!:thumbdown:

chanceUK Aug 9th 2009 7:22 am

Re: EI and going home
 
you have to tell them.

My boyfriend ( a canadian citizen) is currently on EI and made a trip to england for 2 weeks. He told them about it and they called him in for an interview to explain it. He wont get any EI money for the time he was out of the country and unable to look for work.

Last year he didnt tell them in advance but instead called them on his return. his file ended up being audited to check that they hadnt overpaid him. everything was fine in the end but it was a lot of unnecessary hassle

Jo.Ru_onway Aug 9th 2009 7:39 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by chanceUK (Post 7827346)
you have to tell them.

My boyfriend ( a canadian citizen) is currently on EI and made a trip to england for 2 weeks. He told them about it and they called him in for an interview to explain it. He wont get any EI money for the time he was out of the country and unable to look for work.

Last year he didnt tell them in advance but instead called them on his return. his file ended up being audited to check that they hadnt overpaid him. everything was fine in the end but it was a lot of unnecessary hassle

My boyfriend is in the same position and i just asked him and he said exactly the same its so much hassle to not tell therm up front
x

Tangram Aug 9th 2009 7:40 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827334)
Hi

I am currently on EI, but may have to go back to the UK for a few weeks. Obviously I won't be 'able and ready to work' or whatever it says on the website, should I tell them I am going :confused: will they stop my payments?

This may help

http://www.servicecanada.gc.ca/eng/e....shtml#Divisor

Auld Yin Aug 9th 2009 7:52 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827334)
Hi

I am currently on EI, but may have to go back to the UK for a few weeks. Obviously I won't be 'able and ready to work' or whatever it says on the website, should I tell them I am going :confused: will they stop my payments?

Hey. where do you think you're living, the UK?

Louisecooke Aug 9th 2009 8:09 am

Re: EI and going home
 
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?

Cookie Aug 9th 2009 8:28 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827426)
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?

Everyone knows everyone in NS ;)

fledermaus Aug 9th 2009 8:34 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827426)
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?

Your passport will be checked electronically when you leave the country.

Apart from that if you want to defraud the State then carry on. You can then move on to more overt methods of stealing.

Aviator Aug 9th 2009 9:49 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827426)
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?

By not telling them you would have committed fraud, you may get cut off from EI altogether or prosecuted. When you file your claim you would be making a statement that you are not out of the country, ready and willing to work.

If someone dobbs you in, then they will know. This is how they often find out, or the claimant does something stupid. Is it worth the risk for a couple of weeks EI?

If you are not a Canadian citizen then there is always the possibility of your status in Canada being revoked for fraud. Remote perhaps, but still a possibility.

fledermaus Aug 9th 2009 10:00 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827426)
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?

Thanks for the PM Louisecooke. I reserve the sympathy and understanding you mentioned for those not asking for advice on whether or not they can get away with fooling EI.

Your circumstances may deserve sympathy, fraud doesn't.

Tangram Aug 9th 2009 10:15 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by fledermaus (Post 7827609)
Thanks for the PM Louisecooke. I reserve the sympathy and understanding you mentioned for those not asking for advice on whether or not they can get away with fooling EI.

Your circumstances may deserve sympathy, fraud doesn't.

I don't think Louise was asking how to commit fraud Fled !?!?!

I read it that it was a question as to how 'they' would know.

triumphguy Aug 9th 2009 10:17 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827426)
Thanks for that. I guess I have to tell them then. How would they know I wasn't here though?


Doesn't someone on EI have to log how many jobs thjey have applied for and the results, etc? How would you account for the missing 2 weeks.

Also, YOU would know you weren't here. Sometimes it's not about being caught - you would probably get away with it (well 75%) chance - but you would know that you essentially defrauded the state - which means all those who pay taxes!

fledermaus Aug 9th 2009 11:09 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Tangram (Post 7827622)
I don't think Louise was asking how to commit fraud Fled !?!?!

I read it that it was a question as to how 'they' would know.

Well if I am wrong then I apologise, but why ask how they would know,would they stop her payments, and then say "I guess I have to tell them" if that's what you were going to do in the first place?

Oink Aug 9th 2009 1:06 pm

Re: EI and going home
 
Chapter 8, verse 7. :p

scrubbedexpat091 Aug 9th 2009 2:37 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by triumphguy (Post 7827623)
Doesn't someone on EI have to log how many jobs thjey have applied for and the results, etc? How would you account for the missing 2 weeks.

Also, YOU would know you weren't here. Sometimes it's not about being caught - you would probably get away with it (well 75%) chance - but you would know that you essentially defrauded the state - which means all those who pay taxes!

EI in my experience does not ask for the number of places one has applied, only that you are able, and willing to work.


Technically EI isn't paid via taxes but premiums everyone who has a job pays, and is insurance program and not social assistance.

triumphguy Aug 9th 2009 3:09 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Jsmth321 (Post 7827902)
EI in my experience does not ask for the number of places one has applied, only that you are able, and willing to work.

My wife had to show evidence in writing of actual job positions, applications and interviews each ei payment period.

Technically if you have a job and are paying EI, then you are 99% likely to be paying taxes - but I quibble.

The point I was making was that the individual is aware when they are being dishonest and in the end it comes down to their own conscience, whether or not they get caught.

Simon Legree Aug 9th 2009 4:14 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Tangram (Post 7827622)
I don't think Louise was asking how to commit fraud Fled !?!?!

I read it that it was a question as to how 'they' would know.

Why would you want to know that if you weren't trying to "pull a fast one". Rest assured, "they" do know. Others have already said that. As a tax payer I'm glad that "they" do know !

scrubbedexpat091 Aug 9th 2009 5:05 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by triumphguy (Post 7827941)
My wife had to show evidence in writing of actual job positions, applications and interviews each ei payment period.

Technically if you have a job and are paying EI, then you are 99% likely to be paying taxes - but I quibble.

The point I was making was that the individual is aware when they are being dishonest and in the end it comes down to their own conscience, whether or not they get caught.



Must vary by location, all my wife had to was answer a couple questions online every 2 weeks, and that was it. Never had to show anything, but maybe it varies based on unemployment rate.

brizzle Aug 9th 2009 6:36 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827334)
Hi

I am currently on EI, but may have to go back to the UK for a few weeks. Obviously I won't be 'able and ready to work' or whatever it says on the website, should I tell them I am going :confused: will they stop my payments?

I personally think that if you're just going to visit the UK for 10-14 days then don't tell them. I don't think the different departments talk to each other as much as you think, and I've never had any checks upon leaving Canada. It's probably more hassle to tell them.

However if you intend to go away for 3-6 + weeks. Then you are obligated to tell them I reckon. Just my opinion.

Tangram Aug 9th 2009 10:43 pm

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Simon Legree (Post 7828033)
Why would you want to know that if you weren't trying to "pull a fast one". Rest assured, "they" do know. Others have already said that. As a tax payer I'm glad that "they" do know !

I give up. That's it from me for a while.

normanstrongbow Aug 10th 2009 1:23 am

Re: EI and going home
 
FYI:

www.servicecanada.gc.ca/eng/ei/publications/fraud.pdf

Aviator Aug 10th 2009 1:46 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by brizzle (Post 7828247)
I personally think that if you're just going to visit the UK for 10-14 days then don't tell them. I don't think the different departments talk to each other as much as you think, and I've never had any checks upon leaving Canada. It's probably more hassle to tell them.

However if you intend to go away for 3-6 + weeks. Then you are obligated to tell them I reckon. Just my opinion.

You are obligated to tell them if you are out of the country for a day. What you are suggesting is breaking the law and fraud.

http://www.servicecanada.gc.ca/eng/e...ml#individuals

Jingle Aug 10th 2009 1:56 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7827334)
Hi

I am currently on EI, but may have to go back to the UK for a few weeks. Obviously I won't be 'able and ready to work' or whatever it says on the website, should I tell them I am going :confused: will they stop my payments?

Hi Louise - my OH was on EI during which time we went to the States for 10 days (holiday booked before he got made redundant). We ticked the box that he was not able to work that period of time and they stopped the payment for a couple of weeks and resumed it when we returned.

I try and be as honest as possible when dealing with government folk ... but that's me. You have to do what you feel comfortable with but you must realise that EI is paid out, generally in good faith, by the government to assist people whilst they are looking for work - not taking a holiday. After all some people don't even get holiday pay from their employers!

J :)

Louisecooke Aug 10th 2009 2:27 am

Re: EI and going home
 
Thank you for all those that have given helpful replies and for clarifying the position which is all I asked. I wish it was a holiday that is making me go back :( if I do go back that is. However, rest assured if I do I will be declaring that fact :)

Aviator Aug 10th 2009 2:30 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7829391)
Thank you for all those that have given helpful replies and for clarifying the position which is all I asked. I wish it was a holiday that is making me go back :( if I do go back that is. However, rest assured if I do I will be declaring that fact :)

If you advise them of the reason, usually they stop your EI payments for that period and add it on to the end, so you don't lose out in the long run if you are on EI for your full entitlement.

chanceUK Aug 10th 2009 3:39 am

Re: EI and going home
 
there is something called medical leave where your EI payments continue but i dont know much about it.

Aviator Aug 10th 2009 3:43 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by chanceUK (Post 7829537)
there is something called medical leave where your EI payments continue but i dont know much about it.

You have to be sick for that and have a doctor sign off on it.

Jingle Aug 10th 2009 3:48 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Louisecooke (Post 7829391)
I wish it was a holiday that is making me go back :( if I do go back that is. However, rest assured if I do I will be declaring that fact :)

Apologies Louise - I should not have assumed .... hope things work out for you ... not least that you find a job sometime soon :) OH has been out of work since May and it's quite scary the amount of jobs he's applied for.

If it isn't a holiday then maybe a quick chat with the EI people will help sort out any confusion you may have. We had to call to clarify something with them and spoke of a v helpful person.

Take care, J :)

bodgerx Aug 10th 2009 7:44 am

Re: EI and going home
 

Originally Posted by Tangram (Post 7828758)
I give up. That's it from me for a while.

Flouncing?

Greenhill Aug 12th 2009 9:36 am

Re: EI and going home
 
Can I have all your stuff?


Originally Posted by Tangram (Post 7828758)
I give up. That's it from me for a while.


MrBeaver Aug 14th 2009 12:29 pm

Re: EI and going home
 
paper rock sissors!


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 10:18 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.