British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Canada (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/)
-   -   calgary or edmonton (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/calgary-edmonton-798999/)

malcuk Jun 3rd 2013 9:15 am

calgary or edmonton
 
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton

JonboyE Jun 3rd 2013 9:17 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by malcuk (Post 10739292)
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton

It might help if you can expand on what you are looking for.

cjones Jun 3rd 2013 9:28 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by malcuk (Post 10739292)
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton


Edmonton has a big shopping centre with mini golf. They both have a rodeo, but Calgary's is a bit more well known. Hope that helps.

Novocastrian Jun 3rd 2013 9:36 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by malcuk (Post 10739292)
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton

edmonton has more letters than calgary

haggis88 Jun 3rd 2013 10:13 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
neither, they're both shiteholes :)

Former Lancastrian Jun 3rd 2013 3:45 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
Both have a shit NHL team. Edmonton is further north. Both have an airport although Calgary is busier. Edmonton is closet to Jasper national park whereas Calgary is closer to Banff national park.
Both employ welders, carpenters, teachers etc etc. Both pay the same sales tax and GST.
Both have British style pubs which serve Guinness and fish and chips.
Both are a long way from Toronto.
The #1 Trans Canada highway doesn't go through Edmonton but goes through Calgary.

ann m Jun 3rd 2013 4:05 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
Calgary. It's nearer to other stuff. Edmonton is 3 hours to Calgary before you get to other stuff. You're welcome. ;)

Piff Poff Jun 3rd 2013 5:17 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
How about stopping halfway in red deer...

haggis88 Jun 3rd 2013 5:23 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by Piff Poff (Post 10739749)
How about stopping halfway in red deer...


Piff Poff Jun 3rd 2013 5:26 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
No that would be Drumheller lol. Too many out of towners in the mix in dead rear:rofl:

cheeky_monkey Jun 4th 2013 12:23 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by Former Lancastrian (Post 10739679)
Both have a shit NHL team. Edmonton is further north. Both have an airport although Calgary is busier. Edmonton is closet to Jasper national park whereas Calgary is closer to Banff national park.
Both employ welders, carpenters, teachers etc etc. Both pay the same sales tax and GST.
Both have British style pubs which serve Guinness and fish and chips.
Both are a long way from Toronto.
The #1 Trans Canada highway doesn't go through Edmonton but goes through Calgary.

All the above except the #16 Trans Canada highway doesn't go through Calgary but goes through Edmonton:p

rwin Jun 4th 2013 2:57 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
They are rivals. Pick one and like everyone else there, you'll hate the other for no other reason than it's not where you live.

ExKiwilass Jun 4th 2013 3:21 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
edmonton is called Deadmonton by trolls in the Comments section of the Globe and Mail. And by people in vancouver.

Calgary is called Cowtown even though they don't have cows there anymore.

HTH.

Steve_ Jun 4th 2013 6:43 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by malcuk (Post 10739292)
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton

Depends...

Edmonton is more of a blue collar town than Calgary and it is colder, plus it's a much longer drive to get anywhere. However, because the govt. is there and also geography, it is a nicer town, imo. Much nicer along the Saskatchewan River plus it is a more normal sort of city, i.e. a conurbation, whereas Calgary is a monolithic block and 80% of the residential areas look identical.

I think because of the transport links and a slightly better job market, Calgary wins. Calgary also has a lower crime rate.

stuabroad Jun 8th 2013 1:24 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by malcuk (Post 10739292)
can anyone tell me whats the better place calgary or edmonton

The snow seems to clear a month or so earlier in Calgary, give or take the odd 1-foot dump every now and then. If you suffer from Migraines you do not want to stay in Calgary due to the rapid pressure changes associated with chinook winds - there's nothing quite as painful as a "chinook headache" - http://www.migraines.org/about_media/helthsct.htm

Edmonton is closer to Jasper... which is good...but also further away from Kelowna etc which is not so good.

Edmonton is a shithole from a cultural perspective...but so is Calgary, where the increased size does not provide any additional attraction as far as i can see. I've lived in Edmonton for 5 years now and have worked for a couple of months at a time in Calgary every now and then. I thought i always wanted to move to Calgary to be nearer the Rockies, but to be honest the smaller town feel of YEG is a plus. Perhaps when they build the new downtown arena by 2016 the downtown will actually start to resemble a downtown with some spark to it. Otherwise it's just urban sprawl with a Starbucks every now and then...same as Calgary.

The pothole's in Edmonton this year are a f***ing disgrace.

cjones Jun 8th 2013 6:23 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by stuabroad (Post 10747714)

Edmonton is a shithole from a cultural perspective...but so is Calgary, where the increased size does not provide any additional attraction as far as i can see. I've lived in Edmonton for 5 years now and have worked for a couple of months at a time in Calgary every now and then. I thought i always wanted to move to Calgary to be nearer the Rockies, but to be honest the smaller town feel of YEG is a plus. Perhaps when they build the new downtown arena by 2016 the downtown will actually start to resemble a downtown with some spark to it. Otherwise it's just urban sprawl with a Starbucks every now and then...same as Calgary.

The pothole's in Edmonton this year are a f***ing disgrace.

Get used to it... How do you think they're financing the arena?

scootb Jun 9th 2013 4:07 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by haggis88 (Post 10739392)
neither, they're both shiteholes :)

I actually like Edmonton,way better than Glasgow or Paisley back home(I hated city life in Scotland),haven't been to Calgary yet,so no comments on that one.

cheeky_monkey Jun 10th 2013 12:27 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
I have lived in both cities..but nobody is interested in my opinion just of those who have flown over both cities once a few years ago on their way to Toronto or Vancouver.:thumbup:

ExKiwilass Jun 10th 2013 2:17 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
I like Edmonton people, too bad the city is ugly.

haggis88 Jun 10th 2013 3:19 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by scootb (Post 10749074)
I actually like Edmonton,way better than Glasgow or Paisley back home(I hated city life in Scotland),haven't been to Calgary yet,so no comments on that one.

Everything's better than Glasgow or Paisley :P

i actually don't really mind Calgary, but OP was asking a stupid question, so i replied with a stupid answer :)

scootb Jun 10th 2013 4:21 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by haggis88 (Post 10749961)
Everything's better than Glasgow or Paisley :P

i actually don't really mind Calgary, but OP was asking a stupid question, so i replied with a stupid answer :)

Dunno mate,London,and Manchester are bigger sheetholes than Glasgow and Paisley lol.
I like the way that Edmonton is spread out,and theres no dog crap all over the pavements,the playparks aren't littered with smashed buckie bottles,and miss spelt graffiti etc..
Even the drunken native's sleeping next to bushes aren't as bad as the drunks back home.

haggis88 Jun 10th 2013 7:01 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by scootb (Post 10750907)
Dunno mate,London,and Manchester are bigger sheetholes than Glasgow and Paisley lol.
I like the way that Edmonton is spread out,and theres no dog crap all over the pavements,the playparks aren't littered with smashed buckie bottles,and miss spelt graffiti etc..
Even the drunken native's sleeping next to bushes aren't as bad as the drunks back home.

yeah i suppose it's subjective though isn't it?

Calgary is very similar, infact am i right in thinking it's been voted Reuters cleanest city in the world on more than one occasion?

That said, i do notice a fair bit of grafitti in Calgary, mostly on the newsstands at bus-stops etc...

don't tend to see as many teenage drunks roaming the streets either, but i'm lead to believe they all sit in someones basement and get stoned instead! :lol:

Novocastrian Jun 11th 2013 8:25 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by scootb (Post 10750907)
Dunno mate,London,and Manchester are bigger sheetholes than Glasgow and Paisley lol.
I like the way that Edmonton is spread out,and theres no dog crap all over the pavements,the playparks aren't littered with smashed buckie bottles,and miss spelt graffiti etc..
Even the drunken native's sleeping next to bushes aren't as bad as the drunks back home.

Irony overload warning light has come on.

banjaboy Jun 12th 2013 11:28 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
Edmonton, nice people, older city, Calgary...........not my cup of tea.

Edo Jun 12th 2013 11:53 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 
Edmonton. Cuz it is cheaper, especially the rents.

adele Jun 12th 2013 4:16 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by ExKiwilass (Post 10749865)
I like Edmonton people

My OH is from Edmonton :)


Originally Posted by ExKiwilass (Post 10749865)
too bad the city is ugly.

Yeah, the city's all same, same, same...and so spread out! The river valley and Strathcona were alright, but for the most part it was generic and I was so happy to get home to Vancouver. :wub:

Steve_ Jun 13th 2013 5:04 am

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by adele (Post 10754413)
Yeah, the city's all same, same, same...and so spread out!

Well I find I don't have time to admire it while I'm driving around Edmonton, because the traffic actually moves. :p North Vancouver, especially around the bridges, is very pretty. :lol:

adele Jun 13th 2013 2:21 pm

Re: calgary or edmonton
 

Originally Posted by Steve_ (Post 10755523)
Well I find I don't have time to admire it while I'm driving around Edmonton, because the traffic actually moves. :p North Vancouver, especially around the bridges, is very pretty. :lol:

I don't need to drive in Vancouver, so I don't own a car - I walk or take the bus, so I have plenty of opportunity to soak up and appreciate my surroundings :p


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 8:34 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.