British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Canada (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/)
-   -   Brits leaving in record numbers (https://britishexpats.com/forum/canada-56/brits-leaving-record-numbers-465711/)

Vim Fuego Jul 12th 2007 10:20 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 
45 in 2004, 66 in 2005 and 78 in 2006 ... who knows where it will lead?

flipflop Jul 12th 2007 10:27 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by Vim Fuego (Post 5047275)
45 in 2004, 66 in 2005 and 78 in 2006 ... who knows where it will lead?

hey!

Rob4BC Jul 12th 2007 11:12 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by landhouse (Post 5046956)
Hi Paul, this goes no way to answer your question but Britain has always been such a transient nation. How many British are indeed truly British anymore? There are probably only a handful who can trace their Anglo Saxon roots.

With such an historical influx of immigrants from places such as Scandanavia, Rome, the Caribbean, Pakistan, India and now eastern Europe it is a very diverse little island.

Families are drowning themselves in the straits between Tangier and Gibraltar to get here. Men are strapping themselves to the undercarriages of lorries and people are risking their lives to work illegally in places like Morecambe Bay in order to pay the passages of their families to come here.

There are no elysian fields.

Many are choosing to emigrate from here because they feel they are becoming marginalised in what they view as their own country. In some places road signs are in Urdu, Punjabi, Hebrew, Polish and finally in English. This makes people angry and to escape the immigrants they become one themselves. It's very ironic.

I live near Blackpool and last year the majority (75%) of seasonal workers were Polish. This year the locals have 'fought back' and taken the jobs for themselves bringing this total down to 25%.

A comparisan can be made to the British moving to Canada. Yes, I'm finding it hard to get a job and so is my OH but we are aware that we are immigrants and that there is a hierarchy to employment. Many complain but if this country did the same they wouldn't be moaning then because it would be happening to others rather than themselves.

I don't think that we are moving out in such vast numbers but I think that the housing market has played such a great part in it though.

Oh, I've digressed so far from your original question but coming from a country where political correctness had gone too far its nice to be heading to a country where they can advertise a job and ask exactly for the type of person they want. re an ad I saw where only black women aged between 18 and 35 need apply!

Sorry!:o

Read a book called "Bloody Foreigners" to know how the UK has always had immigrants going back to the very beginning - it's what makes this country so interesting, and frustrating at the same time.

Rob.

Biiiiink Jul 12th 2007 11:18 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 
Where do they get the figures from?

No-one asked us where we going, for what purpose, and if we'd be coming back. We had the accountant do the necessary leaving the country tax paperwork but the child benefit continued to be paid (despite repeated requests to stop) for a year and a half after we'd left, so I don't believe they can draw any kind of reliable data from other government depts.


Edit: ahh, p33-p40 of dbd's link. a 0.3% sample of travellers is interviewed at entry/exit ports - "The resulting estimates of migration are not sufficiently robust for all the uses to which they are put."

dbd33 Jul 12th 2007 12:42 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 
Something else not considered so far is the number of emigrants from the UK who were recent immigrants. Someone who came from Poland worked for a few years and went home would count as an immigrant and, five years later, as an emigrant.

Mr Lee Jul 12th 2007 3:39 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by landhouse (Post 5046956)
How many British are indeed truly British anymore? There are probably only a handful who can trace their Anglo Saxon roots.

I think you'll find that the true "British" were there long before the Anglo-Saxons and still are.

Imagine if there was a forum like this in days gone by?


Originally Posted by YeOldeDailyMailReader
I've had enough of these bloody Romans/Angles/Saxons/Vikings/Normans/Flemish coming in and taking our jobs and claiming sovereignty over our land. And the crime rate's gone up! It's not safe to walk the dirt tracks any more without some plague-ridden Vandal peasant threatening me with a dagger. This country's gone to the dogs. No wonder me and thousands like me are off to Ireland!


rae Jul 12th 2007 3:45 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by NSpaul (Post 5046785)
As you read through this forum you get the impression literally huge numbers of people are leaving or planning to leave the UK. Every day there are dozens of new members enquiring about moving to Canada (and presumably its the same situations in the other country forums). Given that only a small minority of emigrants are probably forum members it kind of leaves you with the impression everyone is literally fleeing! In fact when I spoke to a friend in the UK she said she had heard there were now more people emigrating than there were immigrants coming in. Does anyone have any real data on this? Are Brits actually leaving in record numbers?

there is another documentary ongoing, though not sure when it will air, if it will air at all, the bbc panaroma are following the stories of uk cops leaving to join forces around the world, this may have some interesting general data. i may even be on it, they are following some officers over to edmonton.

boxerdog03 Jul 12th 2007 7:06 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by Southcote (Post 5047014)
However, alot of the people coming in are plugging vital skills gaps, such as in nursing, so its not all bad

The NHS are cutting back on staff, closing hospital beds and moving inpatient staff into vacant posts which have been frozen for the last 18 months so the NHS can cook their books and claw back some of their overspends.

Student nurses who have spent 3 years training (on a pittance) can't get jobs.

Sharon

newshoney Jul 12th 2007 8:36 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by Mr Lee (Post 5048137)
I think you'll find that the true "British" were there long before the Anglo-Saxons and still are.

Imagine if there was a forum like this in days gone by?

True Brits? Do you mean the Celts? Are those blood lines any "purer" than any others. As my elderly father (part Scots, part "English" in whatever combination of Angle, Saxon, Norman, Dane etc.) maintains: even the white Brits are all "mongrels". Anyhow it's not only white-skinned Brits who leave (and frequently return). I guess people will always seek "greener pastures"... only to realise that living anywhere brings its own share of problems vs loveliness.

And while I'm on the subject of race... hasn't genetic analysis "proved" we're all descended from the same African Eve anyhow? I guess those ancient nomads (early emigrants/immigrants) have a lot to answer for.

PPS: I also note that Canadians treasure their immigrants and seem to despise the aboriginal population, while in Britain it's the reverse. Go figure.

Tableland Jul 12th 2007 9:56 pm

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by hudd (Post 5047273)
What I notices is that living in the SE (I live in Oxfordshire) is that the immigrants now are those that can afford to buy the housing in the half a miilion quid brackets. 10 years ago when I lived in Kent they were immigrants with no skills or funding that were trying to get into the UK.

I assume its like Brits and others moving to Canada with $500K+ worth of real estate assests and buying up housing. The immigrants I recently come across seem not to be short of money i.e driving BMW/Merc etc and well qualified and educated. So being an ex immigrant(8 years in Canada) I have no problems with skilled persons wanting to work and live in the UK.

I agree with your final point. Many of Britain's skilled workers are now paying tax to Canberra and Ottawa, so the more skilled workers entering Britain, the better. The trouble is, many of those entering are not skilled, as the UK has only just woken up to the existence of the points-based immigration system.

Can't say I have any experience of your first paragraph. I live in the SE and most Polish can usually be found stuffed into rapidly-converted-to-rental semis.

Perhaps what is disconcerting many people is the scale of the migration today. I'm certain that up to 1997, Britain took 50,000 immigrants a year (at least through the 1980s and 1990s), but after 1997 this jumped to what many have claimed is now 500,000 a year. Quickly people have linked this to the increase in house prices, and so on, and a new anti-immigrant culture is born. Rightly or wrongly, this leads to a displacement where many British shift over to Canada or Australia, and take their skills with them, many of which were gained at considerable expense to the British tax payer.

Where does it all end? Can the economies sustain permanent shifting of people, or will this be seen as a golden age of immigration, soon to come to an end because of increased "international security" concerns and economic problems?

Iain Mc Jul 13th 2007 12:37 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

However go to the ‘returning to the UK’ forum and the impression would be rather different
I think the amount of traffic on that forum is more of an indicator.

Whilst very vocal, the amount of threads and active users on a daily basis is far lower than the outbound forums(fora?); especially when you consider that's a single forum catering for everybody heading back, whereas the outbound are divided amongst scores of others by region.

dbd33 Jul 13th 2007 12:41 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by Iain Mc (Post 5049634)
I think the amount of traffic on that forum is more of an indicator.

Whilst very vocal, the amount of threads and active users on a daily basis is far lower than the outbound forums(fora?); especially when you consider that's a single forum catering for everybody heading back, whereas the outbound are divided amongst scores of others by region.

But people emigrating need their dreams bolstered and their fears calmed by strangers. People going home can phone their mothers for that reassurance.

Also, people going home already know the routine stuff; how to work the banks, how to get a driving license, yadda yadda.

Howard1944 Jul 13th 2007 12:43 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 
I think most Britains are leaving because the UK doesn't have a Dental Plan.:D

Iain Mc Jul 13th 2007 1:11 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

People going home can phone their mothers for that reassurance....
Ho ho, yes, true enough.

And I guess there's also a lot more speculative posting on the outbound ones.

Paul Wildy Jul 13th 2007 5:06 am

Re: Brits leaving in record numbers
 

Originally Posted by Biiiiink (Post 5047478)
...the child benefit continued to be paid (despite repeated requests to stop) for a year and a half after we'd left...

we have had that problem too. did you have to repay it? Just curious;)


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 5:23 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.