Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
#1
Forum Regular
Thread Starter
Joined: May 2007
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 80
Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Ran into a bloke the other day who is in his early sixties been living in the USA for thirty years.
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
#2
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Sounds to me like he has become a resident of Australia.
#3
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 12,865
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Ran into a bloke the other day who is in his early sixties been living in the USA for thirty years.
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
#4
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Ran into a bloke the other day who is in his early sixties been living in the USA for thirty years.
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
#5
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Ran into a bloke the other day who is in his early sixties been living in the USA for thirty years.
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
Was boasting to me how low the taxes were in the USA.
It seems he gor fired from his job because of ill health and bang went his health care with it.
Now this bloke is an American citizen who has come to Aus for our Medicare.
Now here is the thing, while he has been living the good live we Aus residents have been paying for medicare.
Now can some Aus or Brit expat tell me why we should give him free health care which he has not paid for ?
Or is time to change the rules to make it free care for Aus residents and taxpayers only ?
2) How do you know he's not a resident in Australia and eligible for Medicare?
3) Maybe we should stop giving "free" health care to all immigrants. Including the Brit expats who arrive having not paid into the system.
#6
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
He would have had a difficult job getting into Australia in the first place if he had a previous chronic health issue. So nothing to see here. One of the major benefits of living in a civilised country is universal health care to all it's permanent residents.
If he isn't a permanent resident, then he is probably feeding you bullsheet.
If he isn't a permanent resident, then he is probably feeding you bullsheet.
Last edited by ozzieeagle; Jan 6th 2014 at 1:36 am.
#7
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Sounds like the dust of el toro as well, Canada has a free health system so far less distance to travel. I'd guess that like us they have strict rules on overseas visitors.
#8
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,814
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
So he lived in the USA for 30 years .... where was he before that? Maybe he is actually an Aussie citizen as well......
#11
Banned
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 22,348
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Is there room for a lil' un' on this bandwagon?
#13
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Which is how it should be, So no issue at all.
All Australian citizens should be able to access Medicare, wherever they've lived and paid taxes in the past.
Question: If I were to turn up as a citizen of the UK after my 33 years in Aus, would I be afforded the same... I think there was a law change on this recently.... Or what about my Australian wife, if she were a bona fide 'spouse' migrant, would she get free healthcare on the NHS from day 1 of arrival in the UK ?
Last edited by ozzieeagle; Jan 7th 2014 at 4:55 am.
#14
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Which is how it should be, So no issue at all.
All Australian citizens should be able to access Medicare, wherever they've lived and paid taxes in the past.
Question: If I were to turn up as a citizen of the UK after my 33 years in Aus, would I be afforded the same... I think there was a law change on this recently.... Or what about my Australian wife, if she were a bona fide 'spouse' migrant, would she get free healthcare on the NHS from day 1 of arrival in the UK ?
All Australian citizens should be able to access Medicare, wherever they've lived and paid taxes in the past.
Question: If I were to turn up as a citizen of the UK after my 33 years in Aus, would I be afforded the same... I think there was a law change on this recently.... Or what about my Australian wife, if she were a bona fide 'spouse' migrant, would she get free healthcare on the NHS from day 1 of arrival in the UK ?
Your wife would be eligible if you were returning to live. If she was on holiday, I'm not sure but would be covered by reciprocal arrangements
All Australian citizens are eligible for Medicare - even if they have never paid tax
#15
Re: Why should Australia give American residents Health care ?
Actually they would be entitled by reciprocal agreement. The same as tourists from the UK get it in Oz.
The issue would be taking is wife to the UK permanently now as there are rules on income and savings in order to get a visa.
The issue would be taking is wife to the UK permanently now as there are rules on income and savings in order to get a visa.