British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   Why so much negativity about Perth??? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/why-so-much-negativity-about-perth-720502/)

fish.01 Jun 11th 2011 11:50 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by Amazulu (Post 9427374)
This classic song popped into my head when I started reading this thread:

http://youtu.be/wzNjmIWbns4

I think it describes it brilliantly

:thumbsup: should be the BE official song !!

GreenMan72 Jun 11th 2011 11:53 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by fish.01 (Post 9427347)
You might be interested in this research I did a while back which includes Sydney and Perth weather:

Annual Dry days Per Year (>= 1mm)

288 Brisbane - Annual Rainfall 1149
270 Adelaide - Annual Rainfall 622.1
265 Perth - Annual Rainfall 867.6
260 Sydney - Annual Rainfall 1084.4
255 Melbourne - Annual Rainfall 648.5

Summer Dry Days Per Month (Avg Min/Max Temps Celsius)

30 Perth (17.9 - 29.7) <---- Very dry summer
28 Adelaide (16.7 - 28.6) <---- Very dry summer
26 Melbourne (14.3 - 25.9) <---- Medium dry summer
23 Brisbane (20.7-29.4) <---- Humid with afternoon storms
23 Sydney (18.7-25.9) <---- Somewhat humid with afternoon storms

Winter Dry Days Per Month (Avg Min/Max Temps Celsius)

27 Brisbane (9.5-20.4) <---- Very dry, very warm winter
25 Sydney (8.0-16.3) <---- Very dry, warmish winter
21 Melbourne (6.0-13.4) <---- Wet, very cold winter
19 Adelaide (7.7 - 14.8) <---- Wet, cold winter
16 Perth (9.0-17.4) <---- Very wet, warmish winter

Note: Based on 100 yr averages at city centre reading stations (where available). Source: Australian Bureau of Meteorology
Note: Comments on right of temps mine so just best guesses based on the numbers

Thanks for the stats - I bought 55 years worth of Sydney Observatory Hill data from BOM and have been crunching a few numbers (just a small hobby of mine :)). My biggest climatic driver is sunshine hours. I would prefer a sunny cooler day over a cloudier, warmer day anytime.

I like Perth's stable summers - those summer months with 10+ avg hours of sun per day look flipping brilliant.

In all fairness to Sydney, our late winters and springs are very nice so perhaps I am at the grumpy end of a long cloudy and wet cycle :p

Disturbingly, Sydney is becoming cloudier although it is possibly correcting a high sunny spell from 2000-2005 (total sunshine hours have been trending downwards since 2005 - am hoping the decline will reverse or stabilise!)

fish.01 Jun 12th 2011 12:02 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by GreenMan72 (Post 9427399)
Thanks for the stats - I bought 55 years worth of Sydney Observatory Hill data from BOM and have been crunching a few numbers (just a small hobby of mine :)). My biggest climatic driver is sunshine hours. I would prefer a sunny cooler day over a cloudier, warmer day anytime.

I like Perth's stable summers - those summer months with 10+ avg hours of sun per day look flipping brilliant.

In all fairness to Sydney, our late winters and springs are very nice so perhaps I am at the grumpy end of a long cloudy and wet cycle :p

Disturbingly, Sydney is becoming cloudier although it is possibly correcting a high sunny spell from 2000-2005 (total sunshine hours have been trending downwards since 2005 - am hoping the decline will reverse or stabilise!)

How long have you lived in Sydney?

GreenMan72 Jun 12th 2011 12:23 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by fish.01 (Post 9427420)
How long have you lived in Sydney?

Almost 3 years

fish.01 Jun 12th 2011 12:46 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by GreenMan72 (Post 9427456)
Almost 3 years

Yes, you've seen it at it's worst...been extra wet last few years on east coast.

GreenMan72 Jun 12th 2011 12:50 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by fish.01 (Post 9427505)
Yes, you've seen it at it's worst...been extra wet last few years on east coast.

That's good to hear (in a weird sort of way). Hopefully some normality will return!

the troubadour Jun 12th 2011 2:25 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by Amazulu (Post 9427374)
This classic song popped into my head when I started reading this thread:

http://youtu.be/wzNjmIWbns4

I think it describes it brilliantly

Public Enemy....great stuff and old Johnny Rotton not bad either.

fitz Jun 12th 2011 4:24 am

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 
Perth is bigger than any city in the UK bar london. :eek:

you've obviously not been to many city's in the UK.:thumbup:

the troubadour Jun 12th 2011 12:22 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by fitz (Post 9427856)
Perth is bigger than any city in the UK bar london. :eek:

you've obviously not been to many city's in the UK.:thumbup:

Does being bigger than any other British city have a lot of significance?
Besides in sprawl it is barely noticable Perth being a city at all.

Deancm_MKII Jun 12th 2011 1:29 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by aussietobe (Post 9426985)
From Birmingham's wiki site:

"Birmingham is the most populous British city outside London, with 1,028,700 inhabitants according to 2009 estimates."

Manchester:

In 2009, its population was estimated to be 483,800,[3] making it the seventh-most populous local authority district in England.

You obviously have no idea what the difference is between the inner urban population versus greater metropolitan area population.

Those figures are for the inner urban area and not the greater metropolitan area. Comparing a city such as Perth you need to compare the greater metropolitan area otherwise you are comparing apples and oranges.

Following on from Birminghams wiki:

"Birmingham's metropolitan area, which includes surrounding towns to which it is closely tied through commuting, is also the United Kingdom's second most populous with a population of 3,683,000"

I could do the same for Manchester. Geography not your strong point?

If you are a teacher, God help the kids.

Deancm_MKII Jun 12th 2011 1:40 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by GreenMan72 (Post 9427293)
I am very curious about Perth. The huge drawcard for me is its climate (which I've thoroughly researched). I have most of what I need in life, am not bothered by it's isolation, and love the outdoors. But then again it can be hard to know what it is really like until you live there so reading other people's feedback is good.

I am tired of the changeable climate here in Sydney - it is driving me up the wall. We've had over 160 rain days for the 12 months ended May. Granted the La Nina has been bad but I long to live somewhere where there is good chance a weekend summer BBQ will not be ruined by rain. I actually prefer a boring, predictable climate.

Also Sydney can be too much of a rat race for me and I prefer things a bit quieter.

I have three cousins now who live there and they all love it.

I've been for a couple of visits and it resonated with me a lot. My challenge is going to be convincing my wife to move :(

If Perth was more established it would be the best place to live in Australia. As it stands right now, visiting Perth is like visiting Melbourne in the early eighties.

In 20 - 30 years, Perth will be the place to be in Australia.

HelenTD Jun 12th 2011 2:05 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by Deancm_MKII (Post 9428460)
If Perth was more established it would be the best place to live in Australia. As it stands right now, visiting Perth is like visiting Melbourne in the early eighties.

I don't think that Perth is as advanced as that:sneaky:.

chris955 Jun 12th 2011 2:58 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 
The main problem with Perth is, as has been said, the isolation and the wild west feel that does absolutely nothing for me. I couldnt stand living so far from civilisation but it appeals to some.

the troubadour Jun 12th 2011 4:13 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by HelenTD (Post 9428492)
I don't think that Perth is as advanced as that:sneaky:.

Tend to agree there. Time frame far too short. Things move slowly Out West. Besides that why would Perth become the number one city?

Besides being a head office for various resource companies that perfom the task up north there is little to suggest any real valid reason for Perth to be more than that.

Water looks to be a very big factor as well into the feasabilty of future greatness.

the troubadour Jun 12th 2011 4:17 pm

Re: Why so much negativity about Perth???
 

Originally Posted by chris955 (Post 9428576)
The main problem with Perth is, as has been said, the isolation and the wild west feel that does absolutely nothing for me. I couldnt stand living so far from civilisation but it appeals to some.

Indeed. Not a lot here for those liking a metro,cosmopolitan lifestyle,but the isolation is an attraction for some which in turn perhaps reconfirms the nature of the place and how little some things are likely to change for those wanting so change.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 7:16 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.