British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   PR - We don't Vote? (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/pr-we-dont-vote-679555/)

Red_V_Roger Aug 2nd 2010 10:07 pm

PR - We don't Vote?
 
Can I just have confirmation that as PR but not citizens we cannot vote?

I know this applied when we were temp on 457....but do only citizens vote.

Strange that we have to live by the laws and pay the taxes - but can't vote them out? When people in prison for up to 3 year sentances have to vote!

northernbird Aug 2nd 2010 10:11 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by Red_V_Roger (Post 8749199)
Can I just have confirmation that as PR but not citizens we cannot vote?

I know this applied when we were temp on 457....but do only citizens vote.

Strange that we have to live by the laws and pay the taxes - but can't vote them out? When people in prison for up to 3 year sentances have to vote!

Nope, no vote. Citizens only.

NickyC Aug 2nd 2010 10:15 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 
No, you can't vote as a PR if you're not already on an electoral roll.

PRs could vote once. I did many times when I was just a PR. Rules were changed back in the 80s so only citizens could be added to the roll, but if you were already on it at the time they didn't take you off.

lapin_windstar Aug 3rd 2010 4:55 am

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by Red_V_Roger (Post 8749199)
Strange that we have to live by the laws and pay the taxes - but can't vote them out?

Same as any student, guest worker, working holidaymaker. Taxation without representation.

Originally Posted by NickyC (Post 8749216)
No, you can't vote as a PR if you're not already on an electoral roll.

PRs could vote once. I did many times when I was just a PR. Rules were changed back in the 80s so only citizens could be added to the roll

IIRC, it was actually that PRs who were also (British) "subjects" could vote but the books were closed. There is a small and dwindling class of PR Commonwealth Citizens who are entitled to vote - there was an article in the press a few months ago about it because the Liberals (maybe?) were trying to disenfranchised, but the issue was dropped presumably because it was a statistical insignificance.

JAJ Aug 3rd 2010 1:17 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by lapin_windstar (Post 8750120)
Same as any student, guest worker, working holidaymaker. Taxation without representation.

And if that's a problem, one is free to go back to home country where one has citizenship. Or if permanently admitted to Australia, become an Australian citizen when eligible.


IIRC, it was actually that PRs who were also (British) "subjects" could vote but the books were closed. There is a small and dwindling class of PR Commonwealth Citizens who are entitled to vote
25 January 1984 was the cut-off date and and I'm not sure if even PR was required at the time.
http://www.aec.gov.au/Enrolling_to_v...h_subjects.htm

dave99 Aug 3rd 2010 2:38 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 
Your lucky, I wish I didnt have to vote, to quote south park, when the choice is between a giant douche and a turd sandwhich, thats no choice at all :rofl:

Bring the monster raving looney party to australia I say, at least they are honest that they are full of crap unlike all these other politicians who crawl out the woodwork when theres an election. Full of promises about how they will make things better in your area then they disapear again and nothing changes.

mark213 Aug 3rd 2010 2:40 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by JAJ (Post 8751042)
And if that's a problem, one is free to go back to home country where one has citizenship. Or if permanently admitted to Australia, become an Australian citizen when eligible.

Yep agree. Or if you want, be on the foreign electoral register here for your country. I am on the UK's (but only got my postal vote on the day of election for what its worth), but am also an Aus citizen. Its not hard to do, just a few months wait and a test. Worth it IMO.

Bermudashorts Aug 3rd 2010 2:49 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 
I remember years ago I asked an Australian I worked with in London if he was allowed to vote in the forthcoming elections. He was absolutely outraged that I would even ask him the question on the grounds of he had to pay tax and therefore of course he was allowed to vote. I kind of agree with him.

Having said that, I am also glad that I might as well just switch off to this election news, one general election a year is quite enough.

bcworld Aug 3rd 2010 2:58 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by Bermudashorts (Post 8751165)
I remember years ago I asked an Australian I worked with in London if he was allowed to vote in the forthcoming elections. He was absolutely outraged that I would even ask him the question on the grounds of he had to pay tax and therefore of course he was allowed to vote. I kind of agree with him.

Paying tax isn't the qualification in the UK though. EU and Commonwealth citizens who are resident in the UK are allowed to vote...so for example an American non-citizen can't. I don't think EU citizens can vote in general elections either.

Bermudashorts Aug 3rd 2010 3:26 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by bcworld (Post 8751175)
Paying tax isn't the qualification in the UK though. EU and Commonwealth citizens who are resident in the UK are allowed to vote...so for example an American non-citizen can't. I don't think EU citizens can vote in general elections either.

I know it isn't the qualification in the UK. I am saying there is some logic in the whole "no taxation without representation" statement.

Pollyana Aug 3rd 2010 5:17 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by dave99 (Post 8751149)
Your lucky, I wish I didnt have to vote, to quote south park, when the choice is between a giant douche and a turd sandwhich, thats no choice at all :rofl:

Bring the monster raving looney party to australia I say, at least they are honest that they are full of crap unlike all these other politicians who crawl out the woodwork when theres an election. Full of promises about how they will make things better in your area then they disapear again and nothing changes.

Just spoil the paper - they can fine you if you don't turn up to vote, but they have no control over what you actually put on the ballot paper :sneaky:

MartinLuther Aug 3rd 2010 8:15 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 
You can vote as a PR.

Just find a neighbour who doesn't want to vote and ask him if you can vote in his stead.

MartinLuther Aug 3rd 2010 8:19 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by Bermudashorts (Post 8751216)
I know it isn't the qualification in the UK. I am saying there is some logic in the whole "no taxation without representation" statement.

That was just a call to revolution in the American uprising. It applied to the community rather than the individual. As only land owners got to vote after the revolution I'm sure there were plenty of people paying taxes without vote. And it could be argued that representation and voting are not exactly the same thing.

dave99 Aug 3rd 2010 11:49 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by Pollyana (Post 8751330)
Just spoil the paper - they can fine you if you don't turn up to vote, but they have no control over what you actually put on the ballot paper :sneaky:

thats interesting, I think I heard someone else mention that but wasnt sure if it was right.

So if I draw a nice picture of a bunch of rabbits attacking a politican or something, instead of ticking a box then thats like me abstaining from voting?

bcworld Aug 3rd 2010 11:52 pm

Re: PR - We don't Vote?
 

Originally Posted by dave99 (Post 8751973)
So if I draw a nice picture of a bunch of rabbits attacking a politican or something, instead of ticking a box then thats like me abstaining from voting?

...or put a '1' against every candidate and your paper will be binned.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 2:09 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.