Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
#1
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Location: parkdale, melbourne
Posts: 553
Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
I am living in Melbourne but looking into moving to Perth in the next 18 months. I was disturbed to see an article on the news last night (not sure which channel it was on). That claimed that more than 85 percent of people living in Perth felt unsafe and they had put police officers on the trains to provide security. :scared:
Having visited Perth 4 years ago I felt quite safe then.
Does anyone have an opinion on the safety/ crime? I have children that will be eventually going into the city alone. Is this just ' certain' areas of Perth? If so which should we avoid.
I know that it is wise to be cautious wherever. Is it more so in Perth??
Louise
Having visited Perth 4 years ago I felt quite safe then.
Does anyone have an opinion on the safety/ crime? I have children that will be eventually going into the city alone. Is this just ' certain' areas of Perth? If so which should we avoid.
I know that it is wise to be cautious wherever. Is it more so in Perth??
Louise
#2
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
I take the train into the city whenever i need to go and feel quite safe, never give it a second thought, but that is only one line from Clarkson to the City. Even at night i've never come across any problems. Maybe someone who uses the other lines can advise you about those.
Lynn
Lynn
#3
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
I regularly take the train into the city as well, and until recently took it daily home from work. My 14yo daughter often goes to the city with her friends too.
Aside from the occasional drunk (or wierdo) at city station which is quickly nipped in the bud by security, I've only had one occasion that made me a little uneasy.
Apparently in the next car (not mine thank goodness) there was a disgruntled gentleman yelling and screaming. Someone said they believed he had a knife up his sleeve so the train made an unscheduled stop to allow security to escort him off.
I still can't say I've ever felt "unsafe" on the trains.
There are wierdos all over the world. You may run into one occasionaly but not necessarily on the train!
Siren
Aside from the occasional drunk (or wierdo) at city station which is quickly nipped in the bud by security, I've only had one occasion that made me a little uneasy.
Apparently in the next car (not mine thank goodness) there was a disgruntled gentleman yelling and screaming. Someone said they believed he had a knife up his sleeve so the train made an unscheduled stop to allow security to escort him off.
I still can't say I've ever felt "unsafe" on the trains.
There are wierdos all over the world. You may run into one occasionaly but not necessarily on the train!
Siren
#4
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Originally Posted by Siren & Brian
Aside from the occasional drunk (or wierdo) at city station which is quickly nipped in the bud by security,
Siren
Siren
#5
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Originally Posted by Bordy
That Scossie gets around Siren.
Revenge will be sweet on the 15th for that comment!!
#6
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Originally Posted by Bordy
That Scossie gets around Siren.
I KNEW I recognized that giggle!! :
You know I luvs ya Scos...
Siren
#7
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
I use the train almost every day travelling to and from work, often travelling late on a Frday night due to the city's late night shopping. Apart from the fact that they only ever put 2 carriages on the Clarkson line and I have to bloody stand all the way home from work, I always feel very safe on the train.
#8
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
During the day is fine. But when I'm on the train(not very often at all), it's often quite late at night(coming back from a festival or night out), and I don't feel that safe(oh, and someone threw up once, ewwwwww). A part of it is that 'apparently' there is a need for video security and guards everywhere. Everywhere there's talk about 'all stations have video security', there's going to be more guards(and now police), there's locked and secure parking at a lot of the stations, etc.
And of course there's been a few attacks at trainstations lately.
Secondly is the train station itself(Glendalough) and the walk home in the dark.(in Holland I would bike home by myself at 12 at night no problem, wouldn't here).
Btw, most people on here will say they feel save, because they hardly only use the northern(to Clarkson) and western line(to Freo).
I am sure they'd feel less safe on the lines going to Midland and Armadale.
Pascal felt quite uneasy on a train ride from Maddington(where I work), back into the city, and that was during the day.
Anyway, generally speaking, I'm sure you'll have more chance to have a car accident than to experience violence on the trains.
And of course there's been a few attacks at trainstations lately.
Secondly is the train station itself(Glendalough) and the walk home in the dark.(in Holland I would bike home by myself at 12 at night no problem, wouldn't here).
Btw, most people on here will say they feel save, because they hardly only use the northern(to Clarkson) and western line(to Freo).
I am sure they'd feel less safe on the lines going to Midland and Armadale.
Pascal felt quite uneasy on a train ride from Maddington(where I work), back into the city, and that was during the day.
Anyway, generally speaking, I'm sure you'll have more chance to have a car accident than to experience violence on the trains.
#9
Home and Happy
Joined: Dec 2002
Location: Keep true friends and puppets close, trust no-one else...
Posts: 93,810
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Originally Posted by Simone
Anyway, generally speaking, I'm sure you'll have more chance to have a car accident than to experience violence on the trains.
Has anyone on here experienced violence on the Aus trains in that time?
#10
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Oct 2002
Location: Yallingup
Posts: 343
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
If anyone's got the West Australian today there is an article about replacing Transit Guards with Police officers on the trains. I think you'll find that more problems occur at the Stations than on the train. Having said that all of the stations that I work out of have on-site Security.
The Buses are a different kettle of fish...... especially at night and depending on the area of course.
The Buses are a different kettle of fish...... especially at night and depending on the area of course.
#11
BE Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Joined: Nov 2004
Location: parkdale, melbourne
Posts: 553
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Thanks for that,
It's pretty much what I was hoping. Wherever you are you get the occasional weirdo. I didn't want to move with my family from a place we all feel secure if it was going to be a regular occurrence. As it's the Northern Sub's I'm looking at moving to everyone seems to feel happy there.
I'm sure I will have a few more questions on Perth as it gets closer to us moving there.
Hoping to visit again around October time but taking off my "tourist" glasses and really looking into the suburbs and schools.
Thanks again,
Louise
It's pretty much what I was hoping. Wherever you are you get the occasional weirdo. I didn't want to move with my family from a place we all feel secure if it was going to be a regular occurrence. As it's the Northern Sub's I'm looking at moving to everyone seems to feel happy there.
I'm sure I will have a few more questions on Perth as it gets closer to us moving there.
Hoping to visit again around October time but taking off my "tourist" glasses and really looking into the suburbs and schools.
Thanks again,
Louise
#12
Guest
Posts: n/a
Re: Feel unsafe on Perth's Trains?
Our line is a bit dodgy along it's middle segment. Funny I get on along with the respected commuters and hobby farmers, within 5 stops its all the weirdos and rif-raf, then once you get to the inner city all the good sorts start getting on again
Reminds me of London - my line was great - loads of display of affluence all over the line (quite scary actually - house prices were silly) , I'd get off at Waterloo, cross to another - Waterloo East and the line onwards to SE London was like being in another world. I daren't speak to anyone in case it came out "I say, old man, frightfully sorry to speak but one doesn't know if this is one's station. Do you want my wallet and watch?".
Badge
Reminds me of London - my line was great - loads of display of affluence all over the line (quite scary actually - house prices were silly) , I'd get off at Waterloo, cross to another - Waterloo East and the line onwards to SE London was like being in another world. I daren't speak to anyone in case it came out "I say, old man, frightfully sorry to speak but one doesn't know if this is one's station. Do you want my wallet and watch?".
Badge