Exchange Rates Question?
#1
Exchange Rates Question?
I have seen a few posts on here recently regarding the exchange rate being really good, however there is a difference between tourists rates today $2.20 and commercial rates $2.46. Anyone enlighten me as to why there are 2 rates and in what circumstances the commercial rates are used.
Cheers
Cheers
#2
Forum Regular
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 39
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by teejay66
I have seen a few posts on here recently regarding the exchange rate being really good, however there is a difference between tourists rates today $2.20 and commercial rates $2.46. Anyone enlighten me as to why there are 2 rates and in what circumstances the commercial rates are used.
Cheers
Cheers
www.tranzfers.com
or
www.ozforex.com
for better rates. You should be looking to get a rate not too far of the interbank rate, as the exchanger will want to obviously make a margin off of your transfer and the more money you are transferring the closer to the interbank rate you can get
Lloyd
#3
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Hi all.
Got our holiday money today.
M & S yesterday was $ 2,389 so ordered from first choice as they are local,fixed rate at same as M&s,today m&s was 2,370! Good thinks I,go to the bank to get the cash to pay first choice and lady in bank says "your drawing a lot out,anything nice your buying??" so tell her and she says bank are selling at $2.42 !!!
Go to first choice and tell them with a slip stamped by the bank stating their rate and guess what....they matched it!!
just goes to show..shop around even if it's relativly small amounts compared to those on their way for good.
$70 + dollars in our back pockets for doing nothing more than playing one off against the other really....hope this helps
Got our holiday money today.
M & S yesterday was $ 2,389 so ordered from first choice as they are local,fixed rate at same as M&s,today m&s was 2,370! Good thinks I,go to the bank to get the cash to pay first choice and lady in bank says "your drawing a lot out,anything nice your buying??" so tell her and she says bank are selling at $2.42 !!!
Go to first choice and tell them with a slip stamped by the bank stating their rate and guess what....they matched it!!
just goes to show..shop around even if it's relativly small amounts compared to those on their way for good.
$70 + dollars in our back pockets for doing nothing more than playing one off against the other really....hope this helps
#4
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by rugbymad
Hi all.
Got our holiday money today.
M & S yesterday was $ 2,389 so ordered from first choice as they are local,fixed rate at same as M&s,today m&s was 2,370! Good thinks I,go to the bank to get the cash to pay first choice and lady in bank says "your drawing a lot out,anything nice your buying??" so tell her and she says bank are selling at $2.42 !!!
Go to first choice and tell them with a slip stamped by the bank stating their rate and guess what....they matched it!!
just goes to show..shop around even if it's relativly small amounts compared to those on their way for good.
$70 + dollars in our back pockets for doing nothing more than playing one off against the other really....hope this helps
Got our holiday money today.
M & S yesterday was $ 2,389 so ordered from first choice as they are local,fixed rate at same as M&s,today m&s was 2,370! Good thinks I,go to the bank to get the cash to pay first choice and lady in bank says "your drawing a lot out,anything nice your buying??" so tell her and she says bank are selling at $2.42 !!!
Go to first choice and tell them with a slip stamped by the bank stating their rate and guess what....they matched it!!
just goes to show..shop around even if it's relativly small amounts compared to those on their way for good.
$70 + dollars in our back pockets for doing nothing more than playing one off against the other really....hope this helps
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
#5
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by teejay66
I am confused, don't take much.lol
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
#6
An Australian Citizen !!
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Terrigal - NSW Central Coast since June 2005
Posts: 1,237
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by Suni&Jay
See two post above. You need to have trading accounts with people like ozforx to get anywhere near interbank rates.
Hi
Yes.......... forget tourist rates through the bank/post office etc...... use them only for your 2 weeks in Spain on hols.
Talk with the dealers - HIFX, Ozforex etc - there are many links on here - and some very recently. They will put you straight but you will need to open an account with one (or more) of them in order to deal.
The interbank rate at the moment is $2.465 and you should be able to get within, say, 3 cents of that depending on the amount you have to trade.
Good luck
Jim
#7
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 68
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by teejay66
I am confused, don't take much.lol
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
We didn't really give it much thought and paid by credit card.
Ozforex and Hifx will charge transfer fees for such a small sum. I also can't remember the payment methods that DIMA accepts?
Darren
#8
Forum Regular
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 68
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by demigrate
Check with your credit card company what commission they charge and look at the current rate. Compare this with what the bank will charge in commission and fees for a bankers draft. Remember the rate could even improve in the weeks before the card is charged. It could as you rightly said go down as well.
We didn't really give it much thought and paid by credit card.
Ozforex and Hifx will charge transfer fees for such a small sum. I also can't remember the payment methods that DIMA accepts?
Darren
We didn't really give it much thought and paid by credit card.
Ozforex and Hifx will charge transfer fees for such a small sum. I also can't remember the payment methods that DIMA accepts?
Darren
#9
An Australian Citizen !!
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Terrigal - NSW Central Coast since June 2005
Posts: 1,237
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by teejay66
I am confused, don't take much.lol
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
Tough call. Most CC companies charge around 2.75% for a "cash" transfer which is what they class this type of transaction and, yes, the rate might well fall by the time the visa fee is taken by DIMIA - a double whammy against you perhaps..
You could talk to some of the exchange dealers recommended on here to see if they offer their services for this sort of transaction - they will, of course, also charge a percentage, and they usuallly have a minimum amount you can trade (possibly around £5000) but you should get a much better initial rate from them than you would from either your CC company or the High Street banks.
Then all you should have to do is weigh up the best option (finanacially) for you
Regards
Jim
#10
An Australian Citizen !!
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Terrigal - NSW Central Coast since June 2005
Posts: 1,237
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by Jimclevs
Hi Tracey
Tough call. Most CC companies charge around 2.75% for a "cash" transfer which is what they class this type of transaction and, yes, the rate might well fall by the time the visa fee is taken by DIMIA - a double whammy against you perhaps..
You could talk to some of the exchange dealers recommended on here to see if they offer their services for this sort of transaction - they will, of course, also charge a percentage, and they usuallly have a minimum amount you can trade (possibly around £5000) but you should get a much better initial rate from them than you would from either your CC company or the High Street banks.
Then all you should have to do is weigh up the best option (finanacially) for you
Regards
Jim
Tough call. Most CC companies charge around 2.75% for a "cash" transfer which is what they class this type of transaction and, yes, the rate might well fall by the time the visa fee is taken by DIMIA - a double whammy against you perhaps..
You could talk to some of the exchange dealers recommended on here to see if they offer their services for this sort of transaction - they will, of course, also charge a percentage, and they usuallly have a minimum amount you can trade (possibly around £5000) but you should get a much better initial rate from them than you would from either your CC company or the High Street banks.
Then all you should have to do is weigh up the best option (finanacially) for you
Regards
Jim
Jim
#11
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
I got $2.43 from Tranzfers on the 22nd March, plus 7 pounds transfer fee. This was for an amount under 1000 quid
#12
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: Sydney
Posts: 47
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by renth
I got $2.43 from Tranzfers on the 22nd March, plus 7 pounds transfer fee. This was for an amount under 1000 quid
On Tranzfers.com the lowest you can do is GBP 50.00 and the fee is 7 pounds. The bigger the amount the better the rate as you can see below.
The difference between wholesale and what you get on Tranzfers.com is as follows:
- Wholesale rate now 2.4741 (also called the spot or interbank rate)
- Tranzfers rate now for GBP 50.00 = 2.4382
- Tranzfers rate now for GBP 50,000.00 = 2.4646
Credit card companies usually state in their terms that they charge 2% exchange rate commission. They can be more efficient for small amounts because you don't pay a 7 pound fee. Hope that helps.
Regards,
Matt Gilmour
#13
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by renth
I got $2.43 from Tranzfers on the 22nd March, plus 7 pounds transfer fee. This was for an amount under 1000 quid
I've not been charged more than .01(eg. interbank rate $236.96 transfer £2.3611) for my transactions, and there's so many people on here saying the difference has been .04/.05 or more. Or am I missing something?
Ignore, should have read the tread above
#14
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Originally Posted by teejay66
I am confused, don't take much.lol
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
I have to pay the visa application fee and thought by sending the fee by bankers draft I would take advantage of the good exchange rate. I called Thomas cook today and asked them what the rate was and she quoted $2.20, so I queried it with her and she said the $2.46 was the commercial rate, and if I went through the bank the rate would be relatively the same.
So please someone tell me how I can get a bankers draft and take advantage of the good exchange rate, or otherwise would it be better to pay by credit card and risk by the time they take the fee the exchange rate would have gone down.
Your opinions please.
Tracey
If I was to go into a UK bank, travel agent, foreign currency dealer etc with £stg to change into A$'s they would give me the Buy rate i.e. I'd only get $2.20 for each £. However, if I was doing the reverse and wishing to change my $'s into £'s they would give me the Sell rate i.e. I'd have to hand over $2.46 or whatever for each £ (I'm selling $'s see). The bank makes a profit on these dealings through the difference in the rates.
If you were doing a transfer through HIFX or whoever from one account to another they don't use these tourist rates but what is based on the interbank rate. Invariably the rate you get will be almost the same as the mid-point between the above rates - $2.33 in this example. If you see an interbank rate you won't get quite as good a rate as this (because you arent' a wholesaler or bank) and how close you are to this rate depends on the amount you have to exchange. Obviously the closer you get to the sort of amount banks deal in the better the rate you will get.
Hope that clears that up!
OzTennis
This is why you'll see different rates quoted
#15
Re: Exchange Rates Question?
Lloyds TSB are offering 2.4596 on their travellers cheques. We always find they give the best rate and they are American Express travellers cheques.