British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   CSA (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/csa-611796/)

Baby75 Jun 2nd 2009 1:08 am

Re: CSA
 

Originally Posted by NikiL (Post 7622836)
And considering the OP was trying to find out how it worked as he felt he had a moral obligation to pay for his kids and wondered if a one off lump sum would be a way your response seems, hmm, shall we say rather snide.

Do you know the OP's specific situation? No? Do you know if he gets to see his kids? No? Nor do I. Thats why I won't judge him. Its not a question of it being inconvenient to pay for the kids - its a matter of the ex has to go through a certain legal process in the UK to be able to do so through the CSA and maybe he's trying to work out an easier way to do it, and maybe, just maybe he's not just looking at his perspective.


well said I mean OP clearly stated that he wanted to make sure he took care of his kids not take off and pay nothing.

Loch Lomond Jun 2nd 2009 3:06 am

Re: CSA
 

Originally Posted by RenShen (Post 7626307)
I am sorry if my post has upset you and on reflection I could have worded it better. This subject really pushes my buttons but I accept that I don't know all of your circumstances. It was the limited company bit that did it for me but yes, you obviously had your reasons and they might not have been the same as those in my experience.

You're talking on behalf of a friend..FFS. You haven't been through the shit that is CSA and maintenance payments. Get a life and stop being self righteous.
I didn't see my daughter for 2 years because my ex wanted 80%, yes 80% of my nett wages as maintenance. She was also working at the time.

Baby75 Jun 2nd 2009 3:30 am

Re: CSA
 
[QUOTE=Loch Lomond;7626991]You're talking on behalf of a friend..FFS. You haven't been through the shit that is CSA and maintenance payments. Get a life and stop being self righteous.
I didn't see my daughter for 2 years because my ex wanted 80%, yes 80% of my nett wages as maintenance. She was also working at the time.[/QUOTE

Would I be right in assuming the reason you didn't see her is because you disagreed with the 80% and weren't allowed to see her.

If you don't mind me asking how did you cope that has to be so hard

Yorky1969 Jun 2nd 2009 5:44 am

Re: CSA
 
I can relate to that Loch, so I sympathise.

Dont want to know the details as I know how personal these things are. And quite frankly, its non of my business! Hope your managing ok and thanks for your support. All the best.;)

[QUOTE=Baby75;7627043]

Originally Posted by Loch Lomond (Post 7626991)
You're talking on behalf of a friend..FFS. You haven't been through the shit that is CSA and maintenance payments. Get a life and stop being self righteous.
I didn't see my daughter for 2 years because my ex wanted 80%, yes 80% of my nett wages as maintenance. She was also working at the time.[/QUOTE

Would I be right in assuming the reason you didn't see her is because you disagreed with the 80% and weren't allowed to see her.

If you don't mind me asking how did you cope that has to be so hard


Kate2112 Jun 2nd 2009 5:55 am

Re: CSA
 

Originally Posted by Yorky1969 (Post 7613342)
I am planning to emigrate in the next 12-18 months and have an existing CSA commitment until 2017 for a daughter that wont be emigtating with me. Is anyone else in the same predicament that can share there experiences? Do the Australian CSA take over my case or do I stay with the UK branch? Is the system different in Australia which can change the amounts I pay now etc?

Any input is appreciated.

Thanks! :)

With hindsight it would have been easier to ask the CSA in the UK this question - as you werent trying to shirk any responsibilities like :)

Baby75 Jun 2nd 2009 6:03 am

Re: CSA
 
[QUOTE=Baby75;7627043]

Originally Posted by Loch Lomond (Post 7626991)
You're talking on behalf of a friend..FFS. You haven't been through the shit that is CSA and maintenance payments. Get a life and stop being self righteous.
I didn't see my daughter for 2 years because my ex wanted 80%, yes 80% of my nett wages as maintenance. She was also working at the time.[/QUOTE

Would I be right in assuming the reason you didn't see her is because you disagreed with the 80% and weren't allowed to see her.

If you don't mind me asking how did you cope that has to be so hard

Ignore me if you like I wont take offence sorry if i over stepped the mark:)

RenShen Jun 2nd 2009 10:18 am

Re: CSA
 
[quote=Baby75;7627043]

Originally Posted by Loch Lomond (Post 7626991)
You're talking on behalf of a friend..FFS. You haven't been through the shit that is CSA and maintenance payments. Get a life and stop being self righteous.
I didn't see my daughter for 2 years because my ex wanted 80%, yes 80% of my nett wages as maintenance. She was also working at the time.[/QUOTE

Would I be right in assuming the reason you didn't see her is because you disagreed with the 80% and weren't allowed to see her.

If you don't mind me asking how did you cope that has to be so hard

The limited company stuff was about a friend, yes. However there are quite a few reasons why matters of absent parents and maintenance payments affect me and I have "been through the shit" because I do "have a life" and it has given me many ups and downs. As I had just apologised to the OP the aggression of your tone is really unnecessary.

Oh, and notice I say absent parent. I am not banging the feminism drum here.

Deancm Jun 2nd 2009 11:08 am

Re: CSA
 
[QUOTE=RenShen;7628043]

Originally Posted by Baby75 (Post 7627043)

The limited company stuff was about a friend, yes. However there are quite a few reasons why matters of absent parents and maintenance payments affect me and I have "been through the shit" because I do "have a life" and it has given me many ups and downs. As I had just apologised to the OP the aggression of your tone is really unnecessary.

Oh, and notice I say absent parent. I am not banging the feminism drum here.

There is more than one reason why a parent is absent. Sometimes it is out of their control.

RenShen Jun 2nd 2009 11:09 am

Re: CSA
 
Yes, there is.


All times are GMT -12. The time now is 1:19 am.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.