British Expats

British Expats (https://britishexpats.com/forum/)
-   Australia (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/)
-   -   Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney (https://britishexpats.com/forum/australia-54/boomeranging-how-choose-between-melbourne-sydney-905915/)

boom_meringue Nov 16th 2017 12:01 pm

Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Backstory - moved to Perth in 2005, had a baby, found it was all a bit too remote and far from elderly parents so moved back to the UK in 2015. After 10 years of being away we haven't settled well, find the whole atmosphere in the UK quite depressing and have found that we have no more family support here than we had in Perth.

However..... Perth is flaming remote and despite having loads of really great friends there, it was tough staying in work. The economy is not well diversified and the breadth of opportunities in IT are just not there. To thrive you need to be in mining and the mining industry needs to be thriving, which it simply isn't.

So all that being said, we are planning on returning to Aus when our daughter finishes primary school in 2 years or so.

Melbourne or Sydney, pros and cons....GO!

dfjordan Nov 16th 2017 6:00 pm

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by Steve&Clare (Post 12383406)
Backstory - moved to Perth in 2005, had a baby, found it was all a bit too remote and far from elderly parents so moved back to the UK in 2015. After 10 years of being away we haven't settled well, find the whole atmosphere in the UK quite depressing and have found that we have no more family support here than we had in Perth.

However..... Perth is flaming remote and despite having loads of really great friends there, it was tough staying in work. The economy is not well diversified and the breadth of opportunities in IT are just not there. To thrive you need to be in mining and the mining industry needs to be thriving, which it simply isn't.

So all that being said, we are planning on returning to Aus when our daughter finishes primary school in 2 years or so.

Melbourne or Sydney, pros and cons....GO!

I think that a week’s visit to both should indicate which has a better lifestyle. If I recall correctly, for the last 7 years, Melbourne has been voted by The Economist as being the best city in the world to live in and Sydney was number 11. After spending a week in Melbourne, I can see why.

Beoz Nov 16th 2017 6:26 pm

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
If the beach or water life doesn't do it for you Melbourne is pleasant enough, if it does then Sydney.

In my opinion, there's no point living in Australia without access to water for swimming, boating, surfing, and just general living.

rammygirl Nov 17th 2017 9:00 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Throwing a curve ball but Brissie is really developing nicely. The climate is more tropical but lovely in the winter, unlike Melbourne. Still more affordable housing too.
I visited recently for a week and was surprised how much I liked it. Small enough to be very liveable and walkable to many areas and big enough to be vibrant with a growing economy.

astera Nov 17th 2017 9:33 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by Beoz (Post 12383706)
In my opinion, there's no point living in Australia without access to water for swimming, boating, surfing, and just general living.

True, plus I'd add a good climate, which is why I have crossed off both Sydney and Melbourne from my list.


Originally Posted by rammygirl (Post 12384043)
Throwing a curve ball but Brissie is really developing nicely. The climate is more tropical but lovely in the winter, unlike Melbourne. Still more affordable housing too.
I visited recently for a week and was surprised how much I liked it. Small enough to be very liveable and walkable to many areas and big enough to be vibrant with a growing economy.

Ditto that. Of all the so-called big cities I would choose Brisbane. Of course the Gold Coast has the king-of-all-climates (less than 100km south of Brissy but the difference is discernible) but of course job-wise the big city is more of a target.

boom_meringue Nov 17th 2017 5:49 pm

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Good points about Brisbane but I suspect I would find some of the same challenges work wise as Perth- very mining dependent and a lack of the breadth of industry to support a strong IT sector. We found that thousands of IT contractors moved from Bris to Perth when the state govt killed all projects during the financial crisis.

We have spent time in both Melbourne and Sydney so have a fair idea of what to expect but I would be interested to hear how people have found the vibe in each city when they first moved there.

Beoz Nov 17th 2017 8:28 pm

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by Steve&Clare (Post 12384424)
Good points about Brisbane but I suspect I would find some of the same challenges work wise as Perth- very mining dependent and a lack of the breadth of industry to support a strong IT sector. We found that thousands of IT contractors moved from Bris to Perth when the state govt killed all projects during the financial crisis.

We have spent time in both Melbourne and Sydney so have a fair idea of what to expect but I would be interested to hear how people have found the vibe in each city when they first moved there.

When it comes to Brisbane there's one question that should always be asked. "Tell me one good thing about Brisbane?". There's generally no answer to that question and if there is, its of lesser quality than what you will find in Sydney and Melbourne. It does have the best stadium in Australia in Suncorp Stadium.

You are best to focus your efforts on Sydney and Melbourne.

Just on Sydney, I am noticing a rapid change in the dynamics and vibe right now. The city is changing. Due to massive amounts of infrastructure investment areas that were once considered no go areas are now springing to life. Its quite a transformation. And with that infrastructure boom comes jobs.

Cost wise Sydney has more expensive housing than Melbourne but everything else is the same if not cheaper. But that is generally reflected in the higher salaries in Sydney. 5 Million wouldn't live there if they couldn't afford it. You pay for what you get.

In my opinion if you want the best of everything, head to Sydney, if you are happy with no 2, go Melbourne. Melbourne is certainly a nice place and its the only other place I would live in Australia if I had to move from Sydney.

quoll Nov 18th 2017 9:39 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Go where you get the best job offer. Not much to choose between them really, both expensive, both Australian.

Kim67 Nov 18th 2017 11:10 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Brisbane

carcajou Nov 19th 2017 7:35 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by quoll (Post 12384738)
Go where you get the best job offer. Not much to choose between them really, both expensive, both Australian.

I pretty much agree with this. 10-15 years ago I would have chosen Sydney but would go with Melbourne now.

If the job offers are the same - flip a coin.

sr71 Nov 20th 2017 12:00 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 
Melbourne is a large Australian city, Sydney is a large international city.

I find Melbourne too parochial, it's best attributes are events, bars, restaurants and it's still reasonably priced. Otherwise it's a dreary, ugly place.

Sydney on the other hand is one of the most geographically blessed cities on earth. And personally I think that seeing hills and the harbour, beaches etc is good for the soul. Downsides are that it's undeniably expensive, nightlife potentially not as good, restaurants better than Melbourne, cafes not as good.

Sydney's ease of access to some of the worlds best coastline, plus other places like the Blue Mountains, Hunter Valley etc make it a very attractive place to live too.

IT jobs would be Sydney, then Melbourne. Much harder in Brisbane and Perth - again Brisbane jobs can be mining driven.

GarryP Nov 20th 2017 7:06 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by sr71 (Post 12385634)
Melbourne is a large Australian city, Sydney is a large international city.


Originally Posted by carcajou (Post 12385155)
I pretty much agree with this. 10-15 years ago I would have chosen Sydney but would go with Melbourne now.

I think this is the point. 15-20 years ago Sydney was the preeminent Australian city (it was never a global city). However mismanagement, lack of investment, and massively overpriced real estate has taken most of the shine off the place - something that the lockout laws really put the coup de gras on.

Melbourne and Sydney are now much more equally balanced. Sydney looks prettier (for the tourists) but Melbourne is the better place to live. You can see that balance in international air transport - where the arrivals are about the same between the two cities.

What that practically means is there's likely to be more growth in Melbourne going forward (meaning jobs is likely to look better).

And in the end, that's probably the point - follow the best job offer.

sr71 Nov 20th 2017 7:22 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by GarryP (Post 12385717)
I think this is the point. 15-20 years ago Sydney was the preeminent Australian city (it was never a global city). However mismanagement, lack of investment, and massively overpriced real estate has taken most of the shine off the place - something that the lockout laws really put the coup de gras on.

Melbourne and Sydney are now much more equally balanced. Sydney looks prettier (for the tourists) but Melbourne is the better place to live. You can see that balance in international air transport - where the arrivals are about the same between the two cities.

Bit the thing is all those problems exist in Melbourne too, it's just lagging. Around 15+ years ago Melbourne was brilliant, it really was the most liveable city, by far. But basically since the Kennett government leadership has been lacking, infrastructure is a decade behind the population growth, any development has been short-sighted and poorly designed (Docklands)

My view is you get 90% of the problems of Sydney, but without the nice location. And if you like beaches and the ocean it's a no brainer.

Beoz Nov 20th 2017 9:44 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by GarryP (Post 12385717)
However mismanagement, lack of investment,

Yes Bob Carr, Christina Kenneally and Co. Talk about resting on your laurels.

Thankfully since then things have changed and things are soooo much better, and still on the improve.




Originally Posted by GarryP (Post 12385717)
and massively overpriced real estate has taken most of the shine off the place

I wonder if the shine was taken of London, New York and Hong Kong with their property prices.

Demand must be high. I guess location means you pay for what you get. (Awaiting the 6 bedroom McMansion picture somewhere near Werribee)


Originally Posted by GarryP (Post 12385717)
Something that the lockout laws really put the coup de gras on.

The square mile lock out law area is for tourists and bogans. Do keep up.

Beoz Nov 20th 2017 9:47 am

Re: Boomeranging - how to choose between Melbourne and Sydney
 

Originally Posted by sr71 (Post 12385634)
Sydney on the other hand is one of the most geographically blessed cities on earth.

Thats a good way of putting it. Vancouver is another but unfortunately gets a truck load of rain.


All times are GMT. The time now is 1:48 pm.

Powered by vBulletin: ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.