457/175 LAFHA eligibility
#1
457/175 LAFHA eligibility
Hi,
I think this has been covered before, but I've not seen what looks like a consensus on what the situation is, so here goes:
I've got an application lodged for a 175 PR visa. Its CSL, so lets make an assumption it will be granted sometime late next year.
I now have an employer willing to sponsor me on a 457 visa, and is talking about LAFHA allowances and fixed term agreements to take advantage of this. The employer is talking about a fixed-term contractual obligation as an employee/employer rather than taking me on as an independent contractor, if that makes sense. I presume this will be granted before the 175 visa, so I would be 'using' it.
The 2 questions that come to mind therefore are:
What would the ATO's take on me having applied for, then holding a 175 visa be and applying for LAFHA? I presume they would take this as an indication you were looking to 'set up shop' rather than return 'home'.
Would holding a fixed-term agreement with an employer negate this to an extent and allow LAFHA, regardless of the visa type held?
Are there any restrictions/caveats on employment rights if holding a fixed-term contract compared to a permanent employee?
My gut instinct is that I would probably be ok until the 175 was granted, at which point I might have trouble convincing the ATO that I was intending to return home, regardless of the wording of any contract.
Thanks,
Rob
I think this has been covered before, but I've not seen what looks like a consensus on what the situation is, so here goes:
I've got an application lodged for a 175 PR visa. Its CSL, so lets make an assumption it will be granted sometime late next year.
I now have an employer willing to sponsor me on a 457 visa, and is talking about LAFHA allowances and fixed term agreements to take advantage of this. The employer is talking about a fixed-term contractual obligation as an employee/employer rather than taking me on as an independent contractor, if that makes sense. I presume this will be granted before the 175 visa, so I would be 'using' it.
The 2 questions that come to mind therefore are:
What would the ATO's take on me having applied for, then holding a 175 visa be and applying for LAFHA? I presume they would take this as an indication you were looking to 'set up shop' rather than return 'home'.
Would holding a fixed-term agreement with an employer negate this to an extent and allow LAFHA, regardless of the visa type held?
Are there any restrictions/caveats on employment rights if holding a fixed-term contract compared to a permanent employee?
My gut instinct is that I would probably be ok until the 175 was granted, at which point I might have trouble convincing the ATO that I was intending to return home, regardless of the wording of any contract.
Thanks,
Rob
#2
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 823
Re: 457/175 LAFHA eligibility
Yep you have to prove that your home is not Australia, so by applying for a permanent Australian residents' visa the ATO aren't going to believe you if you and your company make a claim for LAFHA i'm afraid.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
#3
Re: 457/175 LAFHA eligibility
Yep you have to prove that your home is not Australia, so by applying for a permanent Australian residents' visa the ATO aren't going to believe you if you and your company make a claim for LAFHA i'm afraid.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
(The old man looked into it when he was transferred from SA to WA)
#4
Re: 457/175 LAFHA eligibility
Yep you have to prove that your home is not Australia, so by applying for a permanent Australian residents' visa the ATO aren't going to believe you if you and your company make a claim for LAFHA i'm afraid.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
Seek professional advice, and most large companies have a department dealing with visas so they should know whether or not your elligible.
I've asked their legal/hr dept. to look at this so I'll see what they say. It's primarily Sydney-based with some travel, so perhaps there might be some eligibility not related to immigration/relocation.
Thanks for the input,
Rob
#7
BE Enthusiast
Joined: Feb 2007
Location: Sydney
Posts: 924
Re: 457/175 LAFHA eligibility
If you have school age kids the big one on a 457 is having to pay school fees (for public schools) of approx $5,000 per child in NSW. Depending on the number of kids it can totally wipe out any advantages of LAFHA.