HIV in SA
#46
Re: HIV in SA
What about the shameful collapse of the public health system? What about the hiv specialists who, in despair, were driven out of South Africa because the government deliberately thwarted them and prevented them treating people? The damage has been done. While hundreds of thousands of South Africans were dying needlessly, ANC party members were receiving the best HIV anti-retroviral treatment money could buy. Denialism for the masses, but hey, when it comes to Top Dog, then no expense spared, and as 'Eurocentric' as you please.
You offer no evidence whatsoever.
Now why would that be?
I suspect the truth will come out about this minister's sacking.
For the rest, Mr 6000, I simply don't believe you. Oh yes, certainly I believe you are seeing hiv and TB patients treated in Nyanga, as you say. But I don't believe Mbeki has abandoned his Denialism. I don't believe the Deputy Health Minister was drummed out of her job because Mbeki has discovered a passion for clean government. I don't believe Manto has bought into a proper hiv policy. I think they are paying lip service to what is truly required - and their acquiescence is through gritted teeth, dragged to the water because they must, but refusing to drink - except for the occasional sip, just to ward off the loudest of their critics. And this is not because they genuinely believe in the nonsense of Denialism. It is because they would rather preside over the needless deaths of millions rather than admit they were wrong. Just like Mugabe.
Pablo
For the rest, Mr 6000, I simply don't believe you. Oh yes, certainly I believe you are seeing hiv and TB patients treated in Nyanga, as you say. But I don't believe Mbeki has abandoned his Denialism. I don't believe the Deputy Health Minister was drummed out of her job because Mbeki has discovered a passion for clean government. I don't believe Manto has bought into a proper hiv policy. I think they are paying lip service to what is truly required - and their acquiescence is through gritted teeth, dragged to the water because they must, but refusing to drink - except for the occasional sip, just to ward off the loudest of their critics. And this is not because they genuinely believe in the nonsense of Denialism. It is because they would rather preside over the needless deaths of millions rather than admit they were wrong. Just like Mugabe.
Pablo
Just as I suggested - you have come back and shown that you know best.
Just incidentally, once again over the weekend, I listened to Madlala-Routledge saying that she was sacked over the Frere hospital visit and the unauthorised trip to Spain with her son. Strange how you seemingly even know better than her!
Last edited by 6000; Aug 13th 2007 at 8:26 am.
#47
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,881
Re: HIV in SA
Read the thread. I know that. I said it myself. Apologist.
Just incidentally, once again over the weekend, I listened to Madlala-Routledge saying that she was sacked over the Frere hospital visit and the unauthorised trip to Spain with her son. Strange how you seemingly even know better than her!
[/QUOTE]
Strange how naive you are about Mbeki's and Manto's manoeuvres.
Just incidentally, once again over the weekend, I listened to Madlala-Routledge saying that she was sacked over the Frere hospital visit and the unauthorised trip to Spain with her son. Strange how you seemingly even know better than her!
Strange how naive you are about Mbeki's and Manto's manoeuvres.
#48
Re: HIV in SA
And yet you complain about "those that should be on ARVs but aren't"? Shurely shome mishtake, Mr KIA?
Sorry - you talking to me or Nozizwe?
#51
#53
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 6,669
Re: HIV in SA
Mbeki has long been notorious for his prickliness. And, as the 65-year-old successor to Nelson Mandela enters his final two years as president, his administration seems increasingly intolerant to criticism. His party, the African National Congress (ANC), frequently makes hysterical attacks on foreign press coverage of South Africa. In February, for example, the ANC compared the BBC to "the most die-hard racists in our country" after it aired a documentary about violent crime in the country.
Deja vue all over again. Visions of Uncle Bob.
Don't dare tell the truth, because you're a racist. God, it sickens me.
#54
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,881
Re: HIV in SA
It was reported yesterday that one of those silly human-interest TV programmes that follow the lives of children as they grow up had been made about South Africa. The kids that were followed in SA are now, apparently, seven. Trouble is, two have died of Aids, and others have been the victims of violent crime, and the programme makers, who were hoping for one of those feelgood Africa goodnews programmes, are now worried that the "wrong" impression will be created.
#55
Re: HIV in SA
Isn't that what 6000 is implying on the Sunday Times thread? Criticize the government and you are racist. Could it not possibly be because of their incompetence, corruption, abuse, etc that is under attack. We do that in this country too and our officials are white! It's called free speech and when there is enough of it going around, it forces change. Horrible thought for the apologists though.
#56
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,881
Re: HIV in SA
Well he's a master of innuendo, or thinks he is, and he will of course deny that this is what he is implying - no doubt with reference to absurd Venn diagrams or something.
Yep. Unless you're black. Then criticising the government means you're an Uncle Tom.
I don't think we're going to see "change" in SA anytime soon. Remember, the trouble only began in Zim when "change" loomed on the horizon. Then Uncle Bob got angry and out came the war drums and Bob's buddy "Hitler".
The other day, the BBC, in one of its typically starry eyed reports, was going on about how amazingly "progressive" SA's constitution is. Yeah, sure. Well when I see a change of government in SA, then I'll be impressed. In the meantime, I just remember how amazingly "progressive" the USSR's constitution was. Remember how many apologists there used to be for the old Soviet Union? How all the criticism was just disaffected 'capitalists' and other bourgeois running dogs spreading lies in the corrupt Western media?
Criticize the government and you are racist.
Could it not possibly be because of their incompetence, corruption, abuse, etc that is under attack. We do that in this country too and our officials are white! It's called free speech and when there is enough of it going around, it forces change. Horrible thought for the apologists though.
The other day, the BBC, in one of its typically starry eyed reports, was going on about how amazingly "progressive" SA's constitution is. Yeah, sure. Well when I see a change of government in SA, then I'll be impressed. In the meantime, I just remember how amazingly "progressive" the USSR's constitution was. Remember how many apologists there used to be for the old Soviet Union? How all the criticism was just disaffected 'capitalists' and other bourgeois running dogs spreading lies in the corrupt Western media?
Last edited by Pablo; Aug 13th 2007 at 6:19 pm.
#57
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 6,669
Re: HIV in SA
I think what shocks foreigners is that not all of us were racists or had racist leanings. Most South Africans were interested in living their lives in peace, as people anywhere. They did not go around calling people kaffirs, or physically harming them. In fact, many Afrikaners actually raised black kids. I worked with one who had her maid's grandchild sleeping in their bedroom with her, and he called her mama. She put him through school, etc....
The ones who were involved in the political scene, I'm talking white folk here, were wealthy, Sandton liberals who could afford to be. The rest were working to put a roof over the heads of their kids, food on the table.
A handful of bad apples is all that the world saw. They did not see the interaction between the races at a personal level. I put my maid's kids through school, paid for their uniforms, school supplies, sent food and other stuff home with her for the six weeks she took vacation every year. As did the vast majority of folk in S.Africans. I worked with black clerical staff, in the 80's even, educated folk who were marvellous. Don't ever recall a racist remark directed against them, even then.
That is the reason I think Mbeki is the very worst president the country could have. He did not have that positive interaction with the white community in S.A.
Mandela did. Cyril did. Tokyo did (wink). They would have made great presidents due to that fact, instead of bringing the hatred/suspicion of white folk to the table as Mbeki has.
The ones who were involved in the political scene, I'm talking white folk here, were wealthy, Sandton liberals who could afford to be. The rest were working to put a roof over the heads of their kids, food on the table.
A handful of bad apples is all that the world saw. They did not see the interaction between the races at a personal level. I put my maid's kids through school, paid for their uniforms, school supplies, sent food and other stuff home with her for the six weeks she took vacation every year. As did the vast majority of folk in S.Africans. I worked with black clerical staff, in the 80's even, educated folk who were marvellous. Don't ever recall a racist remark directed against them, even then.
That is the reason I think Mbeki is the very worst president the country could have. He did not have that positive interaction with the white community in S.A.
Mandela did. Cyril did. Tokyo did (wink). They would have made great presidents due to that fact, instead of bringing the hatred/suspicion of white folk to the table as Mbeki has.
#58
Re: HIV in SA
I dont think thats what shocked foreigners .I think what shocks foreigners is how after 13 years of a new democratic government how little has changed .I'm sure you and a lot of other white folks did your best for the people you employed.That is admirable cos I still hear white folks goining around saying apartheid wasnt that bad .We cant blame it for any of what we're experiencing today.
The educated black clerical staff you were working had little to no prospects of advancement. Could any one of them ,no matter how good they were ever become your manager ? . Instead their brothers and sisters were maids and gardeners like their mothers and fathers before them and theirs before them. At least we treat them well and allow them to go and visit their families in the homelands once a year with some treats from their employers.
Pablo would be impressed to see a change in government in S.A. If the interaction with whites was really as positive for the majority of south africans then maybe we would see a change in government .I'm sure if you ask your maid and her kids that you put through school who they voted for they would say A.N.C.
Mandela played his role and so do Mbeki .My personal opinion is that although he is a hard worker it is hard to see the good he has done because of his huge failings in certain areas.
The educated black clerical staff you were working had little to no prospects of advancement. Could any one of them ,no matter how good they were ever become your manager ? . Instead their brothers and sisters were maids and gardeners like their mothers and fathers before them and theirs before them. At least we treat them well and allow them to go and visit their families in the homelands once a year with some treats from their employers.
Pablo would be impressed to see a change in government in S.A. If the interaction with whites was really as positive for the majority of south africans then maybe we would see a change in government .I'm sure if you ask your maid and her kids that you put through school who they voted for they would say A.N.C.
Mandela played his role and so do Mbeki .My personal opinion is that although he is a hard worker it is hard to see the good he has done because of his huge failings in certain areas.
#59
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 6,669
Re: HIV in SA
I dont think thats what shocked foreigners .I think what shocks foreigners is how after 13 years of a new democratic government how little has changed
Yes. We swapped a white racist government, for a black racist government.
.I'm sure you and a lot of other white folks did your best for the people you employed.That is admirable cos I still hear white folks goining around saying apartheid wasnt that bad .We cant blame it for any of what we're experiencing today.
They're morons then.
The educated black clerical staff you were working had little to no prospects of advancement. Could any one of them ,no matter how good they were ever become your manager ? . Instead their brothers and sisters were maids and gardeners like their mothers and fathers before them and theirs before them. At least we treat them well and allow them to go and visit their families in the homelands once a year with some treats from their employers.
At least they were employed, as opposed to being one of the 40 percent unemployed that are currently wondering where their next meal is from. NELSON MANDELA is a lawyer - there were bunches of black professionals/businessmen around. It is a pity that there are so many South American women and men who are maids and gardeners, or in India and China, who are maids and gardeners. They should all have been doctors, attorneys or space shuttle pilots.
As to the last sentence, HOW DARE you make a mockery of people we cared for deeply, who helped raise our children. I guess it is better for them to have been living in the same homelands, without work, clothing, uneducated kids, etc.....pathetic. There are millions of uneducated people in South and Central America, India, etc..who work as maids and gardeners and would be more than happy to have the sort of life that most of the S.A. maids and gardeners had.
You have blinkers on.
Mandela played his role and so do Mbeki .My personal opinion is that although he is a hard worker it is hard to see the good he has done because of his huge failings in certain areas.
Yes. We swapped a white racist government, for a black racist government.
.I'm sure you and a lot of other white folks did your best for the people you employed.That is admirable cos I still hear white folks goining around saying apartheid wasnt that bad .We cant blame it for any of what we're experiencing today.
They're morons then.
The educated black clerical staff you were working had little to no prospects of advancement. Could any one of them ,no matter how good they were ever become your manager ? . Instead their brothers and sisters were maids and gardeners like their mothers and fathers before them and theirs before them. At least we treat them well and allow them to go and visit their families in the homelands once a year with some treats from their employers.
At least they were employed, as opposed to being one of the 40 percent unemployed that are currently wondering where their next meal is from. NELSON MANDELA is a lawyer - there were bunches of black professionals/businessmen around. It is a pity that there are so many South American women and men who are maids and gardeners, or in India and China, who are maids and gardeners. They should all have been doctors, attorneys or space shuttle pilots.
As to the last sentence, HOW DARE you make a mockery of people we cared for deeply, who helped raise our children. I guess it is better for them to have been living in the same homelands, without work, clothing, uneducated kids, etc.....pathetic. There are millions of uneducated people in South and Central America, India, etc..who work as maids and gardeners and would be more than happy to have the sort of life that most of the S.A. maids and gardeners had.
You have blinkers on.
Mandela played his role and so do Mbeki .My personal opinion is that although he is a hard worker it is hard to see the good he has done because of his huge failings in certain areas.
#60
Re: HIV in SA
Yep every office had a least one black face in it, they were called the teaboy/ girl, nothing racist in that.
Tokyo Sexwale's positive interaction - 13 years on Robben Island
Govan Mebeki's positive interaction - 23 years on Robben Island.
I get it, it was Thabo's old man who got the positive interaction, and Thabo is cheesed off because he missed out.