Retiring UK vs USA?
#1
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Retiring UK vs USA?
Hi all
So I'm a Brit in the USA (Florida) and have been for 12 years. Previous to that I spent til age 35 in the UK. I am married to a US citizen who does not have a visa to live and work in the UK.
The wife and I have an ongoing discussion about retirement and where we should line ourselves up to reside. We are still 15-20 years away from it. I miss England and we can see ourselves living in either place.
Obviously we can stay in the US and she can visit the UK on a tourist type visa but my concern is US healthcare and the costs associated with it. I know we can apply for medicare when we are 65 but we'll still be paying out $$ and say one of us gets a serious health issue and we are out of pocket lots $$.
I know how the UK operates and while I am aware that the NHS is struggling, the system itself is so much cheaper. Btw I am also aware my wife would need to go through a lengthy process to be accepted in the UK too!
So people, if you had the choice to retire in the UK or the USA which one would you chose?
Thanks in advance!
So I'm a Brit in the USA (Florida) and have been for 12 years. Previous to that I spent til age 35 in the UK. I am married to a US citizen who does not have a visa to live and work in the UK.
The wife and I have an ongoing discussion about retirement and where we should line ourselves up to reside. We are still 15-20 years away from it. I miss England and we can see ourselves living in either place.
Obviously we can stay in the US and she can visit the UK on a tourist type visa but my concern is US healthcare and the costs associated with it. I know we can apply for medicare when we are 65 but we'll still be paying out $$ and say one of us gets a serious health issue and we are out of pocket lots $$.
I know how the UK operates and while I am aware that the NHS is struggling, the system itself is so much cheaper. Btw I am also aware my wife would need to go through a lengthy process to be accepted in the UK too!
So people, if you had the choice to retire in the UK or the USA which one would you chose?
Thanks in advance!
#2
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,543
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
There are more important considerations than the healthcare comparisons. Plus, you're both pretty young so there's no knowing where NHS or Medicare will be when the two of you reach retirement age. The way it is now, yes, there can be significant out of pocket with Medicare, but you have choices that limit the out of pocket. (Medicare supplement plans etc.)
Another choice, of course, is where in the US to retire, since the US has places that are hillier and less humid than FL.
I myself spend half my time in the UK and half in the US.
Another choice, of course, is where in the US to retire, since the US has places that are hillier and less humid than FL.
I myself spend half my time in the UK and half in the US.
#3
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
We lived in the UK and made the choice to retire to the US. The factors which had the greatest influence on our decision, was where the bulk of our family lived. Where the bulk of our pensions would come from. In both cases that was the US, and the US meant the bulk of our pension was not subjected to exchange rate fluctuation.
With health care it isn't just the cost to consider it is the availability as well. Last time I needed physio in the UK I waited 12 weeks for an appointment. Here 3 months ago I got an appointment in 2 days. At the same time I needed an MRI and had it done next day at 9pm at my local hospital. I doubt I would have been seen as quickly on the NHS. When your left arm suddenly stops working after a fall, being seen promptly and treated is very reassuring. OK it was more expensive than it would have been in the UK, but I consider the $200 a month I pay for medicare part B, and medicare supplemental insurance well worth the prompt appointments and treatment I received. The lack of worry and stress made it worthwhile. My out of pocket cost for 3 months of physio, 2 MRIs, one set of x-rays and 3 specialist appointments was $500. Talking to my DIL in the UK who is a nurse at BRI I would probably still be waiting for the first visit to a specialist. Here my arm is back to normal.
With health care it isn't just the cost to consider it is the availability as well. Last time I needed physio in the UK I waited 12 weeks for an appointment. Here 3 months ago I got an appointment in 2 days. At the same time I needed an MRI and had it done next day at 9pm at my local hospital. I doubt I would have been seen as quickly on the NHS. When your left arm suddenly stops working after a fall, being seen promptly and treated is very reassuring. OK it was more expensive than it would have been in the UK, but I consider the $200 a month I pay for medicare part B, and medicare supplemental insurance well worth the prompt appointments and treatment I received. The lack of worry and stress made it worthwhile. My out of pocket cost for 3 months of physio, 2 MRIs, one set of x-rays and 3 specialist appointments was $500. Talking to my DIL in the UK who is a nurse at BRI I would probably still be waiting for the first visit to a specialist. Here my arm is back to normal.
#4
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 10,009
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Hi all
So I'm a Brit in the USA (Florida) and have been for 12 years. Previous to that I spent til age 35 in the UK. I am married to a US citizen who does not have a visa to live and work in the UK.
The wife and I have an ongoing discussion about retirement and where we should line ourselves up to reside. We are still 15-20 years away from it. I miss England and we can see ourselves living in either place.
Obviously we can stay in the US and she can visit the UK on a tourist type visa but my concern is US healthcare and the costs associated with it. I know we can apply for medicare when we are 65 but we'll still be paying out $$ and say one of us gets a serious health issue and we are out of pocket lots $$.
I know how the UK operates and while I am aware that the NHS is struggling, the system itself is so much cheaper. Btw I am also aware my wife would need to go through a lengthy process to be accepted in the UK too!
So people, if you had the choice to retire in the UK or the USA which one would you chose?
Thanks in advance!
So I'm a Brit in the USA (Florida) and have been for 12 years. Previous to that I spent til age 35 in the UK. I am married to a US citizen who does not have a visa to live and work in the UK.
The wife and I have an ongoing discussion about retirement and where we should line ourselves up to reside. We are still 15-20 years away from it. I miss England and we can see ourselves living in either place.
Obviously we can stay in the US and she can visit the UK on a tourist type visa but my concern is US healthcare and the costs associated with it. I know we can apply for medicare when we are 65 but we'll still be paying out $$ and say one of us gets a serious health issue and we are out of pocket lots $$.
I know how the UK operates and while I am aware that the NHS is struggling, the system itself is so much cheaper. Btw I am also aware my wife would need to go through a lengthy process to be accepted in the UK too!
So people, if you had the choice to retire in the UK or the USA which one would you chose?
Thanks in advance!
Other factors lead me to prefer the UK overall- proximity to Europe at a reasonable cost, greater public transport : most parts of America one needs to drive, which as one gets older can be a challenge. Also, I found in UK a much different attitude with government services- easier to find out what is available than in US, but in UK there is so much available sometimes one can miss benefits/services that are there.
The other issue is geographical location- what will the particular location be like in 20 or 30 years time ? There are parts of UK in the north that will probably remain somewhat similar, don't know about the south; but same goes for USA : I can think of small towns in Northwest ( northern Idaho, eastern Washington parts of Oregon) of maybe parts of New England, that probably will remain with the same attractions. But will major cities and surrounding areas be livable in 20 or 30 years ? I read that Los Angeles now has 50,000 homeless people, what happens if that ends up at 200,000 or more ? One negative in UK is definitely housing prices.
I would vote UK if one could spend portion of winter in better climates !
#5
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
There are more important considerations than the healthcare comparisons. Plus, you're both pretty young so there's no knowing where NHS or Medicare will be when the two of you reach retirement age. The way it is now, yes, there can be significant out of pocket with Medicare, but you have choices that limit the out of pocket. (Medicare supplement plans etc.)
Another choice, of course, is where in the US to retire, since the US has places that are hillier and less humid than FL.
I myself spend half my time in the UK and half in the US.
Another choice, of course, is where in the US to retire, since the US has places that are hillier and less humid than FL.
I myself spend half my time in the UK and half in the US.
Yeah I agree, I don't know exactly where the NHS / Medicare will be in the future but I guess I'm going by an 'all things being equal' scenario. We're just trying to make some sense of things that's all.
I guess what I'm concerned about is if either one of us gets a major health problem, which let's be honest is quite possible, then our out of pocket expenses will be extremely large over here in the US to the point where it could wipe us out financially. Minor issues I can see being ok with the regular coverage. I am not aware of the supplements and how well that covers major health issues.
Can I ask you... are you retired with that split? I assume you have to declare one country as your main residence right?
#6
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Several points that you haven't mentioned that would factor into a decision is whether you have children. Do you have US Citizenship. Does your wife truly want to live her senior years away from family and friends and would you be financially able to sponsor her for a spousal visa when the time comes.
#7
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
We lived in the UK and made the choice to retire to the US. The factors which had the greatest influence on our decision, was where the bulk of our family lived. Where the bulk of our pensions would come from. In both cases that was the US, and the US meant the bulk of our pension was not subjected to exchange rate fluctuation.
With health care it isn't just the cost to consider it is the availability as well. Last time I needed physio in the UK I waited 12 weeks for an appointment. Here 3 months ago I got an appointment in 2 days. At the same time I needed an MRI and had it done next day at 9pm at my local hospital. I doubt I would have been seen as quickly on the NHS. When your left arm suddenly stops working after a fall, being seen promptly and treated is very reassuring. OK it was more expensive than it would have been in the UK, but I consider the $200 a month I pay for medicare part B, and medicare supplemental insurance well worth the prompt appointments and treatment I received. The lack of worry and stress made it worthwhile. My out of pocket cost for 3 months of physio, 2 MRIs, one set of x-rays and 3 specialist appointments was $500. Talking to my DIL in the UK who is a nurse at BRI I would probably still be waiting for the first visit to a specialist. Here my arm is back to normal.
With health care it isn't just the cost to consider it is the availability as well. Last time I needed physio in the UK I waited 12 weeks for an appointment. Here 3 months ago I got an appointment in 2 days. At the same time I needed an MRI and had it done next day at 9pm at my local hospital. I doubt I would have been seen as quickly on the NHS. When your left arm suddenly stops working after a fall, being seen promptly and treated is very reassuring. OK it was more expensive than it would have been in the UK, but I consider the $200 a month I pay for medicare part B, and medicare supplemental insurance well worth the prompt appointments and treatment I received. The lack of worry and stress made it worthwhile. My out of pocket cost for 3 months of physio, 2 MRIs, one set of x-rays and 3 specialist appointments was $500. Talking to my DIL in the UK who is a nurse at BRI I would probably still be waiting for the first visit to a specialist. Here my arm is back to normal.
Thanks Lansbury for your reply.
I think my concern is major health problems. My mother had kidney cancer and it was diagnosed and treated fantastically in the UK. She's also had both hips done too and all went great. I know it's not the same everywhere in the UK, nor is it getting better.
My worry is major health issues in the US. How well does Medicare + Supplementary payments cover you? What cost are they and how much can you potentially pay out of pocket for a major health issue?
#8
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Several points that you haven't mentioned that would factor into a decision is whether you have children. Do you have US Citizenship. Does your wife truly want to live her senior years away from family and friends and would you be financially able to sponsor her for a spousal visa when the time comes.
#9
BE Forum Addict
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 1,114
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Another thing you may wish to think about is how up-to-date your own NI contributions are? Your UK state pension depended on your NI contributions. You may want to pay voluntary NI contributions to keep up your UK state pension entitlement.
https://www.gov.uk/pay-voluntary-cla...onal-insurance
#10
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
We're retired and our supplemental is fantastic and if we ever see a bill it for something under $20 and that appears to be only for husband who has had laser surgery on his eye. When I had laser surgery on my eye (with the same medicare and supplemental insurance btw just different doctors and different states) there was only the $30 co-pay.
But then our supplemental is excellent coverage and our premiums are only $1500 a year for both of us but it is through a union.
Medical coverage will change in this country and it can and does change rapidly. What is norm today can be non-existent tomorrow and that includes our excellent supplemental.
Great to have a handle on the medical insurance aspects in the US but as another poster pointed out, 10 to 12 years from now it isn't going to be the same here or there.
But then our supplemental is excellent coverage and our premiums are only $1500 a year for both of us but it is through a union.
Medical coverage will change in this country and it can and does change rapidly. What is norm today can be non-existent tomorrow and that includes our excellent supplemental.
Great to have a handle on the medical insurance aspects in the US but as another poster pointed out, 10 to 12 years from now it isn't going to be the same here or there.
#11
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
We're retired and our supplemental is fantastic and if we ever see a bill it for something under $20 and that appears to be only for husband who has had laser surgery on his eye. When I had laser surgery on my eye (with the same medicare and supplemental insurance btw just different doctors and different states) there was only the $30 co-pay.
But then our supplemental is excellent coverage and our premiums are only $1500 a year for both of us but it is through a union.
Medical coverage will change in this country and it can and does change rapidly. What is norm today can be non-existent tomorrow and that includes our excellent supplemental.
Great to have a handle on the medical insurance aspects in the US but as another poster pointed out, 10 to 12 years from now it isn't going to be the same here or there.
But then our supplemental is excellent coverage and our premiums are only $1500 a year for both of us but it is through a union.
Medical coverage will change in this country and it can and does change rapidly. What is norm today can be non-existent tomorrow and that includes our excellent supplemental.
Great to have a handle on the medical insurance aspects in the US but as another poster pointed out, 10 to 12 years from now it isn't going to be the same here or there.
#12
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 10,009
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Thanks Lansbury for your reply.
I think my concern is major health problems. My mother had kidney cancer and it was diagnosed and treated fantastically in the UK. She's also had both hips done too and all went great. I know it's not the same everywhere in the UK, nor is it getting better.
My worry is major health issues in the US. How well does Medicare + Supplementary payments cover you? What cost are they and how much can you potentially pay out of pocket for a major health issue?
I think my concern is major health problems. My mother had kidney cancer and it was diagnosed and treated fantastically in the UK. She's also had both hips done too and all went great. I know it's not the same everywhere in the UK, nor is it getting better.
My worry is major health issues in the US. How well does Medicare + Supplementary payments cover you? What cost are they and how much can you potentially pay out of pocket for a major health issue?
But maybe someone could answer- as far as I know is Medicare residency-based ? I know NHS is suppose to be.
#13
Just Joined
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 7
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
You will need to think about your wife's UK visa before moving back to the UK with her.
Another thing you may wish to think about is how up-to-date your own NI contributions are? Your UK state pension depended on your NI contributions. You may want to pay voluntary NI contributions to keep up your UK state pension entitlement.
https://www.gov.uk/pay-voluntary-cla...onal-insurance
Another thing you may wish to think about is how up-to-date your own NI contributions are? Your UK state pension depended on your NI contributions. You may want to pay voluntary NI contributions to keep up your UK state pension entitlement.
https://www.gov.uk/pay-voluntary-cla...onal-insurance
#14
Heading for Poppyland
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: North Norfolk and northern New York State
Posts: 14,543
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
Thanks Robin
Yeah I agree, I don't know exactly where the NHS / Medicare will be in the future but I guess I'm going by an 'all things being equal' scenario. We're just trying to make some sense of things that's all.
I guess what I'm concerned about is if either one of us gets a major health problem, which let's be honest is quite possible, then our out of pocket expenses will be extremely large over here in the US to the point where it could wipe us out financially. Minor issues I can see being ok with the regular coverage. I am not aware of the supplements and how well that covers major health issues.
Can I ask you... are you retired with that split? I assume you have to declare one country as your main residence right?
Yeah I agree, I don't know exactly where the NHS / Medicare will be in the future but I guess I'm going by an 'all things being equal' scenario. We're just trying to make some sense of things that's all.
I guess what I'm concerned about is if either one of us gets a major health problem, which let's be honest is quite possible, then our out of pocket expenses will be extremely large over here in the US to the point where it could wipe us out financially. Minor issues I can see being ok with the regular coverage. I am not aware of the supplements and how well that covers major health issues.
Can I ask you... are you retired with that split? I assume you have to declare one country as your main residence right?
#15
Re: Retiring UK vs USA?
I pay medicare part B deducted from my social security payment. My Medicare Advantage plan is $88 per month and that includes prescriptions. Deductible is zero, with a maximum out of pocket in 2018 of $3,400 in network or $6,700 out of network. My wife has an identical plan.