Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
#61
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
Every state is different. Here in California, we have proposition 13 which was passed in 1978. Property tax is based upon assessed valuation which is market value. However, property tax is capped at 1% [plus bonded indebtedness] and assessed value cannot increase more than 2% per year. The Prop 13 rate will be the base for allowing reductions of tax when market value goes down. The baseline is reset upon sale
So, let say you have two houses in LA [3 bedroom, 2 bath, 3000 sq ft] in a nice neighborhood next to each other -- both are worth $2 million. House A was purchased in 1994 for $300K. So the property taxes started at $3000 per year and with the 2% annual increase are now at about $6000 per year. House B was purchased in 2009 for $2 million -- the tax will be about $20,000 per year.
Lets say House B was purchased before the recent market crash in 2006 for $2,750,000. House B can obtain temporary reductions in assessed valuation, but house A cannot. This is true even though both houses lost $750,000. So House A would have to decrease a lot [and I think there is a "recapture" of past Prop 13 benefits, but I'm not sure].
So, if the home owner has owned a house for 25 years, raised a family, and the kids have moved out, it can be an expensive proposition to move to a smaller house. [There are some situations based upon age and geography where one carry over the Prop 13 valuation to the new home].
On top of that -- the Federal personal residence basis carry over was eliminated a few years back. So let's say the owner of House A above purchased their first house for $46,000, sold it for $103,000, bought a house for $140,000 which sold for $200,000 and bought current house for $300,000, the taxable basis for current home will be $183,000. There will be a fairly hefty capital gains tax due upon sale of that house.
[If homeowner A dies before the end of 2010, the basis will adjust with no taxes, the prop 13 will carry over to a descendant who takes possession, and there will be no Federal Estate Tax. California has a "pick-up" tax for when there is a Federal Estate Tax -- not applicable this year].
So, let say you have two houses in LA [3 bedroom, 2 bath, 3000 sq ft] in a nice neighborhood next to each other -- both are worth $2 million. House A was purchased in 1994 for $300K. So the property taxes started at $3000 per year and with the 2% annual increase are now at about $6000 per year. House B was purchased in 2009 for $2 million -- the tax will be about $20,000 per year.
Lets say House B was purchased before the recent market crash in 2006 for $2,750,000. House B can obtain temporary reductions in assessed valuation, but house A cannot. This is true even though both houses lost $750,000. So House A would have to decrease a lot [and I think there is a "recapture" of past Prop 13 benefits, but I'm not sure].
So, if the home owner has owned a house for 25 years, raised a family, and the kids have moved out, it can be an expensive proposition to move to a smaller house. [There are some situations based upon age and geography where one carry over the Prop 13 valuation to the new home].
On top of that -- the Federal personal residence basis carry over was eliminated a few years back. So let's say the owner of House A above purchased their first house for $46,000, sold it for $103,000, bought a house for $140,000 which sold for $200,000 and bought current house for $300,000, the taxable basis for current home will be $183,000. There will be a fairly hefty capital gains tax due upon sale of that house.
[If homeowner A dies before the end of 2010, the basis will adjust with no taxes, the prop 13 will carry over to a descendant who takes possession, and there will be no Federal Estate Tax. California has a "pick-up" tax for when there is a Federal Estate Tax -- not applicable this year].
#62
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Feb 2009
Location: North Charleston,SC. born in Stockport,UK.
Posts: 10,109
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
That's the one nice thing about where we live, they pick up recycling every fortnight but you don't have to sort it out, just stick it in a box or bag and it'll get picked up.
Also nice the town actually picks the rubbish up. A lot of the towns we've been checking out don't do rubbish collection, so it's either the town dump or have private collection at around $30-40 a month.
Also nice the town actually picks the rubbish up. A lot of the towns we've been checking out don't do rubbish collection, so it's either the town dump or have private collection at around $30-40 a month.
#63
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
We are paying a relatively high property tax compared to others in our street because we bought when the market was high. However we did recently receive a reduction based on the assessed market value having dropped by over $100,000. As you say, the system throws up alot of anomalies eg. people wanting to downsize.
Another high housing cost area is Boston. One of my daughters went to school in that area -- two of her classmates married after graduation and moved to Michigan where the started good high paying jobs. Remember that together, they graduated with a substantial load of student debt. They bought a large house for $160,000 -- in the words of their class cohorts -- "free housing!"
Many people complain about the unfairness of Prop. 13 in the differential of taxes. Of course, it pays to remember that the people who bought 15 years ago and now paying a mortgage equivalent to the going rate for a one-bedroom apartment. [Prior to Prop 13 -- there were people who had burned the mortgage but found that their housing costs had skyrocketed due to taxes]. For people who bought recently, they were able to qualify for the loans and knew the tax payments in advance.
What I do think is unfair is that commercial real estate is paying a much lower percentage of the tax load. First, commercial property changes hands much less than residential property -- and there are ways to avoid prop 13 reassessment even though there is a virtual sale.
BTW, in the early 80's I shared office space with my brother. The building was sold. Due to the fact that Prop 13 caused the property tax to instantly triple, we got a fairly steep operating expense assessment. We informed the new landlord that "assignee steps into the shoes of the assignor" and that the tax increase would not have been made against the old landlord who assigned the lease to the new landlord. After consultation with their lawyer, new landlord accepted our argument on condition we do not tell any other tenant in the building. We ended up paying about 65% of total rent compared to other tenants for the remainder of the lease. Did not renew and moved out when the lease ended.
#64
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
Have to say I am pleasantly surprised about the pick-ups we get here, Monday is recycling day, no sorting, just stick it out front. Wednesday is yard waste pick up, you should see some of the piles around here on a tuesday night Sometimes it's hard to drive through the streets because opposite neighbors will put out huge loads of palmetto leaves, bushes, grass cuttings all sorts of crap! Then Thursday is household trash day. No idea how much it all costs, cause we rent, we just pay for the thursday pick up.
It has been a misdemeanor to collect from the City containers, but LAPD has always had better things to do. The scavengers no longer bring big trucks with large crews. The only scavenging that goes on is by quite poor people and the consensus is to look the other way -- the cost to the City is quite minimal.
BTW, L.A. Dodgers have a set time limit for people to leave the stadium after a game. A largish number of people actually attend games in the $5.00 bleachers and there are informal clean up territories and places to stash the plastic bags in advance. This underground economy is well known to exist and is tolerated -- the Dodgers get that extra $5.00 plus parking and save on clean up costs! [Speaking of the Dodgers, trial in The Divorce has now started.]
#65
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
Haven't a clue what any of it costs or even how much a pint of milk is.
#66
Lost in BE Cyberspace
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 41,518
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
Some good stories there, Folinsky. We do get some scavengers. I wish the system for recycling yourself was easier, but I suspect the City wouldn't want that I tried it a few times but it took so long in the heat. Then my neighbour and I were giving our bottles/cans to a homeless person for a while, but recently he said he didn't need them any more.
Regarding the house prices, when we first came, the received wisdom was that you paid a fortune for a house here and then cashed in your chips by moving out of state on retirement. Hmm.
Regarding the house prices, when we first came, the received wisdom was that you paid a fortune for a house here and then cashed in your chips by moving out of state on retirement. Hmm.
#67
Re: Bills- Sewer/Water/Gas/Electric/Garbage...how much do you pay?
Have to say I am pleasantly surprised about the pick-ups we get here, Monday is recycling day, no sorting, just stick it out front. Wednesday is yard waste pick up, you should see some of the piles around here on a tuesday night Sometimes it's hard to drive through the streets because opposite neighbors will put out huge loads of palmetto leaves, bushes, grass cuttings all sorts of crap! Then Thursday is household trash day. No idea how much it all costs, cause we rent, we just pay for the thursday pick up.